Big Featured Discussions | February 08, 2013 | 269 comments

What books should be required reading in schools?

The chairman of the Idaho Senate's Education Committee introduced a bill this week that would make "Atlas Shrugged" required high school reading. John Goedde says he chose the book because "it made my son a Republican." Students would be required to read the Ayn Rand tome and take a test on it in order to receive a high school diploma.

After receiving waves of criticism for the bill - namely, that a state requiring its students to read a book on the evils of statism is the height of irony - Goedde said he hadn't introduced the bill to actually change the curriculum, but to emphasize the importance of the book's message. Via Raw Story:

"When I read Atlas Shrugged, and it’s been probably 30 years since I read it, but it certainly gives one a sense of personal responsibility,” Goedde explained on Tuesday. “I don’t plan on moving this forward – it was a statement.”

The same article notes that Paul Ryan was chastised by Catholic groups because his proposed budget was based more on Ayn Rand's brand of self above all versus the more charitable teachings of Christ.

Required reading lists vary from school to school, but some names appear on almost all of them, including titles such as "To Kill A Mockingbird," "Catcher in the Rye," "The Great Gatsby," "The Scarlet Letter," "Animal Farm."

We want to hear about the books that shaped your upbringing. What books do you think should be mandatory high school literature?

What books should be required reading in schools?

  1. groups:
    Community,   Opinion,   Big Featured Discussions
  2. tags:
    Books Literature Discussion
  3. recommended by:
    unimatrix0
  4.     
    |

269 comments // What books should be required reading in schools?

  • Mishima
  • bailey78
  • Mishima
    • -2
      Mishima [removed]  
    • bailey78:

      {Just a little something to help brain wash the young minds}

      I am really glad you wrote that! It reveals your thinking.

      You consider that book "brainwashing" of young minds. OK, let's take a look at the contents; do you know ANYTHING about the book?

      It is just a collection of fables, classical stories, arranged by theme. Let's see the FIRST four themes:

      Chapter 1: Self-Discipline

      2: Compassion

      3: Responsibility

      4: Friendship

      First story in Chapter 1 is by Robert Louis Stevenson. Others by Longfellow, James Baldwin, Taylor and plenty by Aesop.

      YOU made the assertion above in quotes. Now defend it. Explain it. Tell me how these stories "brainwash" children.

      YOU MADE THE ASSERTION, DEFEND IT!

    • 3 months ago
  • bailey78
    • 0
      bailey78  
    • Mishima:

      Well lets see anything that you recommend has got to be bad for young minds I see just how twisted yours is and how you want to destroy all that you fear or are ignorant of. That is unless your not the guy that has gone to other sites and recruited others to come here and troll this site. An we both know you are. Does that make you feel like a Big Man ?

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • -1
      Mishima [removed]  
    • bailey78:

      You asserted the book would be used to "brainwash" children. You summarily declared a book was bad for children. I am asking you to explain it. Not use that request as some kind of platform to attack me, but to explain your assertion.

    • 3 months ago
  • bailey78
    • +1
      bailey78  
    • Mishima:

      as I said why do you lie as you do? what do you have to fear from telling the truth? Oh thats right they would remove you from the site and you just hate to be told your not welcome any place. We see who you are and what your motive is.

    • 3 months ago
  • bailey78
  • matka
  • bailey78
    • +2
      bailey78  
    • matka:

      I don't like it when people put on false fronts and stalk others. Thats just what some here are doing. Others just like to run around and belittle others and degrade them and say Oh no that wasn't me. People like that are of the lowest morals.

    • 3 months ago
  • matka
    • +1
      matka  
    • bailey78:

      I don't think anyone would like that. We all know there is stalkin' and false fronts,
      socks/puppets, all this here at Current. And that is depressing too.

      So okey, u can b e bitter and sharp, now I know why. Still sad though.

    • 3 months ago
  • cw9000
  • Catmommy
    • 0
      Catmommy  
    • Speaking as a college English teacher, I can say that Rand not only extolled the joys of a totally self-centered existence at the expense of everyone else, but she isn't a particularly interesting writer. I tried reading "Atlas" once -- couldn't get through the first chapter. I found her prose uninteresting, her style self-indulgent, and her sense of her own importance truly intrusive in her work. In short, her stuff is boring and gets far more attention than it has ever deserved, but only because people use it to justify their own greed and lack of compassion for others.

      Required reading in the lower grades should not be chosen for political ends, but if we're going to go that route let's have some fair play. How about making "The Communist Manifesto" required reading? How about forcing students in fifth grade to pick up a copy of Frank Thomas's "What's the Matter with Kansas" or "Pity the Billionaire" and report on them? Let's fill middle school courses with Progressive-oriented books like "What's the Matter with White People?" by Joan Walsh and high school classes with books warning of the evils of capitalism like "Oil!" and the evils of Fascist politics in America with "It Can't Happen Here", both by Sinclair Lewis. And while we're at it, let's make this quote from Lewis part of a mandatory discussion about American literature and history in every classroom in the country:

      "in America most of us — not readers alone, but even writers — are still afraid of any literature which is not a glorification of everything American, a glorification of our faults as well as our virtues...America is the most contradictory, the most depressing, the most stirring, of any land in the world today."

      Think this right-wing politician would back a bill making books that extol the joys of a Democratic/Progressive philosophy in our schools mandatory?

      Nah, I don't either.

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
  • Mishima
    • -1
      Mishima [removed]  
    • Catmommy:

      "Think this right-wing politician would back a bill making books that extol the joys of a Democratic/Progressive philosophy in our schools mandatory?"

      Not if he is a lover of liberty and believes in our Founding principles, of course.

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • -4
      Mishima [removed]  
    • I suspect that this move by the Idaho Education Committee is in response to Obummer's "Core Curriculum" that is designed to water down reading of classics and literature, among other things, including more federal control of the departments of education across the nation. "Incentive" grants (buy-offs) are offered for this, leading to more regulations and control of education by the CENTRAL AUTHORITY.

      I do not know, but I suspect that Idaho is making the statement that they are not going to cave in to the CENTRAL AUTHORITY and let it control the education of their CHILDREN.

    • 3 months ago
  • Catmommy
  • Mishima
  • cw9000
  • truth_accessor
  • Mishima
  • Catmommy
  • Mishima
  • truth_accessor
    • +1
      truth_accessor  
    • Mishima:

      Yes it is. Harold Bloom wrote a great book called the Closing of the American Mind about the lack of uniform knowledge and common reference points of his incoming students over 40 years. Two of the things he specifically talked about were Shakespeare and the Bible. Neither is being read and referenced anymore.

    • 3 months ago
  • Varex_Sythe
  • Mishima
  • Mishima
    • 0
      Mishima [removed]  
    • truth_accessor:

      {Harold Bloom wrote a great book called the Closing of the American Mind about the lack of uniform knowledge and common reference points of his incoming students over 40 years.}

      This is refreshing to read! One of my FAVORITE books. I read it twice. I would read only a couple of pages at a time because each one had so much on which one could reflect. Brilliant man, that Bloom.

      Two things really struck me with that book. One was the absurdity of "relativity." The fact that it is logically impossible to be "morally relative," as Left-wingers sometimes claim to be. The other was how, unless one has a grounding in something, one has severe problems understanding much of anything - and that is what is happening with students today.

      But I liked Bloom's unabashed statements about Western Civilization, and his conclusions stem from the two points above. Yes, Western Civilization is the best civilization.

      I know that there is much more to his book than that, and what a masterpiece. I plan to read it yet again. I met a man whose brother said he read it 22 times!

    • 3 months ago
  • matka
  • Mishima
    • +2
      Mishima [removed]  
    • matka:

      Yes, it is. I would often stop reading after a page or two because the ideas really required some time to consider and to process. It was one of those that changed my mind about things or resulted in my seeing things from a different perspective. The one I especially liked was that "relativism" is actually an impossibility. This is important, for example, when certain types of people say that values are "relative." It is not possible, and they are mouthing platitudes, babbling bafflegab. That is part of the reason for the title: Those kinds of "ideas" were CLOSING the minds of young Americans.

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • +2
      Mishima [removed]  
    • matka:

      One more thing about what I wrote. In that context, it then makes sense why these claims that we need to present young people with alternate views, or get them to "think" is nonsense. That comes later, after they get a solid grounding. This is especially true in mathematics. This "discovery" method and such are really harming our young people in schools.

    • 3 months ago
  • bailey78
  • matka
  • matka
  • Mishima
  • matka
  • Mishima
    • +1
      Mishima [removed]  
    • Image
    • matka:

      I like it because it also contains a pronounciation. Hit the little "microphone" and you will get a recording of someone pronouncing the word.

      This is another one. Sometimes I like to go to both in order to get more information about a word or some example sentences. Also, the pronounciation comes much faster on this one.

      (I had a choice of 11 pictures on this - Current allows one to pick sometimes - so I chose one I think you will like.)

      http://dictionary.reference.com/

    • 3 months ago
  • matka
    • +2
      matka  
    • Mishima:

      Totally ! U unpredictable brat..........tak, I luv it and yoo know it.
      This contraption is better than I thought. Can't thank you enough for all this info and
      helpin' me acclimate in the world of scholars !

      Now I must go explore........
      One stupid question........ what is the picture connected with a word on the dictionary, like
      "kotka' ?

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • +2
      Mishima [removed]  
    • matka:

      I do not know. I just put the www link on the post, and the series of photos came up. Thought you would like that one. We were just chatting about how much cats sleep.....

      When I was a kid, I sent away for an exercise book from a comic advertisement. They showed lions and cats, stretching. Said it was "dynamic tension" that kept them so strong, and that THEIR program (of course) incorporated this method (blah, blah, blah send us money).

    • 3 months ago
  • matka
    • +1
      matka  
    • Mishima:

      Yes, I loved that one ! Interesting about the stretching/tension info of big cats/
      feline sylvestris < haha, albeit all in all it was so nice of you to tell me all this.

    • 3 months ago
  • RaisedByWolves
    • -1
      RaisedByWolves  
    • Mishima:

      Bloom is a sexist, racist old fart who demands that the Canon of English Literature contain only the very poor writings of old white males. Even Your Goddess Rand would not fit in the Cannon nor would Bill Bennitt (sp). Until the English Canon is aggrandized to include amazing writers like Lady Mary Wroth, Toni Morrison, etc. will we have some piece of reading material that will speak to each of us instead of a bunch of old drivel from dead old white men.

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • +2
      Mishima [removed]  
    • RaisedByWolves:

      Bloom is absolutely brilliant, and actually translated Greek classics into English. Many of the universities across the country use his translations.

      You listed a couple of author: One has produced almost nothing, and the other is a political hack, a radical. The only reason you put them there is for some kind of "politically correct" mindless balance. Bloom bases his decisions upon true quality, not silly "proper repesentations" of special groups.

      "My Godess" Rand? I have not even read her. That proves how much you have been brainwashed into parroting the Left-winger radical rant.

    • 3 months ago
  • RaisedByWolves
    • +1
      RaisedByWolves  
    • Mishima:

      Because most of the English departments in the USA are populated by old white male farts. You describe nothing that is acceptable in a modern world. I'm not about to list every author who should be read, but I decry using Bloom just because he can translate Latin and Greek. I can do that, too; but I wouldn't presume to think that all of my writings are worth the solid gold of one so noble as Bloom. After all, he has a penis.

      Long live the radical left. Perhaps you would prefer the new Newsvine, Mishima, where the population is more to your taste now. This is Current. We are liberal. Deal with it.

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • +1
      Mishima [removed]  
    • RaisedByWolves:

      His translation of Greek is only one example of his superior scholarship, and it is not the sole reason that Bloom is to be respected as one of the brilliant scholars of the last few decades, of course.

      The Literature Departments of our universities are run by Left-wingers. Male or female, little difference.

      However, you seem quite obsessed with being "inclusive." (I really get a laugh at those politically correct, mindless and meaningless words.) The overriding imperative is that a minimum % of women get included. You did not mention other special groups, however. It seem that your misandry is blinding you to the Leftist directive to be "all-inclusive." LOL

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
  • matka
    • 0
      matka  
    • Mishima:

      P.S. I'd never "hit" a little microphone; I might 'click' on it........
      just like the sweet yellow tabby kitten. I wouldn't hit it......hee-hee.

      The only way I could click on the kitten is to use a klik-a-tat toy.....one
      right by his widdo ear. click-clack, click-clack

    • 3 months ago
  • matka
    • 0
      matka  
    • THE PATRON SAINT OF DOGS, D.V.M. Paul Trout
      A wagging tale of new beginnings, healing hearts and finding your way home.

      Also: EVER BY MY SIDE: D.V.M. Paul Trout. " The best veterinary book
      that's been written since ' All Creatures Great and Small.' " - - Oregonian

    • 3 months ago
  • matka
  • Mishima
  • matka
    • +1
      matka  
    • Mishima:

      I love Mastiffs. Long ago, a friend of mine had one. She didn't need to get
      anyone to watch her kids on the front porch while she made a quick run to the
      grocery store nearby.
      She just sat her pet/friend Mastiff out on the porch with the kids..... all wuz
      well when she returned.

      I would laugh........ the dog was huge, but to people he knew, he was a
      246 pound teddy bear. LOL

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • +1
      Mishima [removed]  
    • matka:

      Yes, the Mastiff is a real wimp. But when I take him for walks, people on the street actually stop to look or even back off it I walk near. A number of times I simply said to come close, she is a "cream puff." It was obvious people wanted to get a close look and pet the monster. One guy actually stopped his truck, backed up, opened the window and said, "Now that's a dog!"

    • 3 months ago
  • matka
    • +2
      matka  
    • Mishima:

      They can look intimidating.

      And I just thought of a down-side to that size of 'Now, that's a dog'.......
      if that guy had a Mastiff, he'd have to use a front end loader to clean off his
      yard.....or take one with him down the street. HAHAHA

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
  • matka
    • +1
      matka  
    • Mishima:

      Seems the selectively bred, large breed dogs, such as St. Bernards, English
      bulldogs, Sharpei , Bloodhounds, etc., drool. yukkage The flappage in the
      jowls.
      One would assume they could selectively breed OUT that feature, but maybe
      they can't. Ya, de food bill..... whoo-ee !
      Sharpei aren't particularly huge canines, but all those wrinkles....baths all de
      time or they reek from having all the loose folds in the skin collect the odor.

      Glad tho that your cuz takes care of her Mastiff and that you enjoy it !

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
  • matka
    • +1
      matka  
    • Mishima:

      Good thinkin'........ true....'apartment living no place for dogga'.
      Shepherds be good choice.... they're wonderful canines.
      Do u plan to get this dog from a adoption place, a breeder, or what?

      I've always wanted to adopt a retired racing greyhoud....... went to a GPA exhibition at
      the Waukesha Expo once and was entranced.

      Now, I can see that possibility would've been squelched, what with a neighbor I
      nicknamed 'Shady Gestapo Lady' cuz she's always spyin' and hates animals of any
      type.

      She's killed domestic and city critters by live-trapping, poisoning and the like.
      When she 'live-trapped', she'd take the animal away herself, somewhere to dispose
      of it in her own diabolical way.
      Live-trapping is against City Ordinance. Did she get cited? Nope. She used to
      be a principal of a school in Chicago, IL. Then later,here in So. Milwaukee, I
      say, " Big deal "

      She's called the City ( and cops) on me when she noticed I live with several cats.
      She's also called for me 'feeding animals' such as birds and squirrels.

      Wot a world, eh? Now, I'm under the thumb of the City of Louse Milwaukee,
      whereas before, they didn't know I existed except at tax time. heh
      The Health Department inspects at least once a year, supposedly having to
      give the 'condemned" 24 hour notice, but in a small 'berg' like this, they don't
      follow their own regulations.

    • 3 months ago
  • matka
    • 0
      matka  
    • THE PATRON SAINT OF LOST DOGS - D.V.M., Nick Trout
      A wagging tale of new beginnings, healing hearts and finding your way home.

      ALSO by Nick Trout: EVER BY MY SIDE - " The best veterinary book that's
      been written since 'All Creatures Great and Small.' "

    • 3 months ago
  • matka
    • +1
      matka  
    • matka:

      Sorry, all these are meant for Culdee... the two I posted that indicate I refer to myself.
      LOL

      Same for this one........ in another webpage, the subject being an animated feature about
      a dog, boy, and the Adam/Eve theory, you posted the same, "I love dogs." Maybe you weren't on this string, but look, come now and check it out. You might this book.
      Then again, reading might not be your forte'......... I'm not sure as I don't know you.

    • 3 months ago
  • matka
    • +1
      matka  
    • DEWEY The Library Cat - Vicki Myron w/ Brett Winter

      The TRUE story of a lovable library cat, whose sixth sense made him a beacon of
      hope for a small town in Iowa. Recommended for adults and/or children.

    • 3 months ago
  • RaisedByWolves
  • bulraybet
    • +4
      bulraybet  
    • Although most people will think this is dated "1984" By George Orwell. reason is show the public how much we have gotten use to big brother. and now days know one cares!!

    • 3 months ago
  • matka
  • Mishima
  • matka
  • Marc_Weeks
  • matka
    • +2
      matka  
    • War Day - Whitley Streiber

      Pride & Prejudice - Jane Austen

      Dolan's Cadillac - Stephen King - novella from Nightmares & Dreamscapes

      Knight's Acre - Norma Loft

      The Great Mysteries - Edgar Allen Poe

      CLASS - Paul Fussell

    • 3 months ago
  • matka
    • +1
      matka  
    • matka:

      Oh !- Forgot:

      LOVE SAVES THE DAY - Gwen Cooper / non-fiction

      Gwen Cooper 's 'Love Saves the Day', told with tenderness, insight, and humor. celebrates
      the ability of animals to make us all better humans.

      Another:

      (Praise for Gwen Cooper's 'Homer's Odessey', a wonderful tale for animal lovers).

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
  • matka
  • Mishima
  • matka
  • Mishima
  • Dagum
    • -1
      Dagum  
    • lol. I'm surprised "Mishima", Didn't comment on this post and create a list. That poster always seems to be recommending books to read in reply to other posters.

    • 3 months ago
  • matka
    • +2
      matka  
    • Dagum:

      He might creep over.......bot he doesn't like discussing 'books' becuz he loves
      political forums.

      Invite him personally.....we had to do dat with The Love of the Printed Word in a
      Digital Era........

    • 3 months ago
  • Vic_Romano
    • +3
      Vic_Romano  
    • Dagum:

      "NOW, concerning the characteristics of which mention is made above, I have spoken of the more important ones, the others I wish to discuss briefly under this generality, that the prince must consider, as has been in part said before, how to avoid those things which will make him hated or contemptible; and as often as he shall have succeeded he will have fulfilled his part, and he need not fear any danger in other reproaches."

      "It makes him hated above all things, as I have said, to be rapacious, and to be a violator of the property and women of his subjects, from both of which he must abstain. And when neither their property nor honour is touched, the majority of men live content, and he has only to contend with the ambition of a few, whom he can curb with ease in many ways."

      Niccolo Machiavelli, The Prince

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • -1
      Mishima [removed]  
    • matka:

      {He might creep over.......bot he doesn't like discussing 'books' becuz he loves
      political forums.}

      I saw another thread in which the posters actually claimed that they were "discussing books."

      They were not. They were just putting up titles, and the ensuing "discussion" generally consisted of:

      "I liked the book."

      "The author is awesome."

      "Great book"

      "Everyone should read this."

      That was about it, so what is the point? At least on this thread, people are claiming that they are "discussing" books; they are just putting up titles.

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
  • matka
  • Mishima
  • matka
  • Vic_Romano
  • Mishima
  • Mishima
  • Vic_Romano
  • Mishima
    • -1
      Mishima [removed]  
    • Vic_Romano:

      No, Obummer does not like Reagan, of course. That is Left-winger deceit to claim so. Obummer knows the venerable Ronald Reagan is the most beloved president in the minds of the people, so the present con-artist president will try to associate himself with Reagan to the extent he can without enraging the Left-wingers too much.

    • 3 months ago
  • Vic_Romano
  • bailey78
  • Keyser_Soze
    • +1
      Keyser_Soze [removed]  
    • I know these titles are not what you would call literature but I do believe they would provide a significant positive outcome for society if they were required reading.

      "Blowback: The Costs and Consequences of American Empire"
      "The Sorrows of Empire: Militarism, Secrecy, and the End of the Republic"
      "Nemesis: The Last Days of the American Republic"
      "Dismantling the Empire: America's Last Best Hope"
      - by Chalmers Johnson

      Also, I would recommend that everyone who lives in a democratic nation study the keen insights found in these works. You'll never look at politics, campaigning or candidates in the same way after reading the insights contained.

      "The Dictator's Handbook: Why Bad Behavior is Almost Always Good Politics"
      "The War Trap"
      "The Logic of Political Survival"
      - by Prof. Bruce Bueno de Mesquita

    • 3 months ago
  • Vic_Romano
    • +2
      Vic_Romano  
    • Keyser_Soze:

      I wish I had discovered Chalmers Johnson about 10 years earlier than I did.

      But isn't it funny how so many books pertaining to individual freedom seem to be on the list of "required" reading?

      Something ironic about it which makes me snicker. Guess I should be happy that Guy Montag isn't being called in to burn them all.

    • 3 months ago
  • MarshainFlorida
  • Vic_Romano
  • artemis6
  • matka
  • Mishima
  • Vic_Romano
  • Mishima
  • Vic_Romano
  • truth_accessor
  • Mishima
    • +1
      Mishima [removed]  
    • Vic_Romano:

      Left-wingers operate directly in the universities, directly trying to inculcate our students into Left-wingerism myths and anti-Americanism. And indirectly at the elementary and secondary schools - Indirectly in that those who would be teachers are brainwashed into believing the revisionist texts in American history and literature, and the Left-winger nonsensical and destructive "methods" in education.

      In the latter case, if one gets students straight out of high school into the education programs, it is easier to brainwash them in colleges. But if one gets others, like ex-soldiers (look up Troops to Teachers, for example), it is harder to get them to join the Borgian "Mind-Meld" of the Left.

      This is why the unions fight for what they do, why the associations have resisted alternatives to certification (don't want people who have not been properly indoctrinated teaching), and homeschooling.

    • 3 months ago
  • Vic_Romano
  • Mishima
    • -2
      Mishima [removed]  
    • Vic_Romano:

      Interesting how you just free associate in relation to my posts.

      No conspiracy. Never said that there is one. I have told you about SIX times already: It is the Left-winger culture. It is not some kind of organized and planned-out method to which LEFT-WINGERS adhere. Rather, it is passed on in the LIBERAL culture, a kind of mindset, general belief system.

      For example, Left-wingers all know the general parameters of Political Correctness, and they know how they are SUPPOSED to think about certain things. But there is no Presidium, no troika that sends out ukases to its cells to instruct the Leftist henchmen and sycophants. There was more of that during the Progressive era when the Leftists took their marching orders directly from Moscow. But that culture has permeated into the universities today and is passed on in the Left-winger culture, just like general habits and beliefs are passed on in any culture.

      For example, Left-winger professors KNOW to give their students books by Howard Zinn to read, and they continue to do this even though Zinn has been discredited by historians and scholars.

    • 3 months ago
  • Vic_Romano
1 - 100 of 269
JessMag
from the community

top videos