PETA dresses up in KKK robes outside the Westminster Dog Show
source: http://www.usatoday.com/sports/2009-02-09-peta-westminster-kkk-protest_N.htm
-
-
- AwesomeJosh
- added this
http://www.usatoday.com/sports/2009-02-09-peta-westminster-kkk-protes...
People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals knows how to grab attention. And show off its laundry.The animal rights group, which every year stages a protest at the Westminster Kennel Club Dog Show, had two of its members dress in Ku Klux Klan garb outside Madison Square Garden on Monday.
Their goal, according to a post on the PETA website, was to draw a parallel between the KKK and the American Kennel Club. "Obviously it's an uncomfortable comparison," PETA spokesman Michael McGraw told the Associated Press.
But the AKC is trying to create a "master race" when it comes to pure-bred dogs, he added. "It's a very apt comparison."
The group passed out brochures implying the Klan and AKC have the goal of "pure bloodlines" in common.
"I can't speak for everyone, but the vast majority of the people exhibiting and handling and showing at Westminster are more interested in the health of dogs than anything else," Westminster spokesman David Frei told the AP.
"We want to produce the next generation of healthy and happy dogs," he said, "not just for the show ring but for the couches at home."
Bystander Fatima Walden told the AP the KKK imagery was inappropriate no matter what the message.
"They could have used something else as an example," she said. "You should be considerate to everybody."
Other than a shouting match during the hour-long protest, police said the scene remained calm...
-
- groups:
- Community, Current News US, Dog Videos & Dog News
-
- tags:
- News, Current TV, Current News US, Dog Videos & Dog News, 3 more
-
-
Donovanwilliams
-
I love the effort....they diffidently get your attention!
- 4 years ago
-
Donovanwilliams
-
-
estee_arie
-
i think there are smarter ways to get points across.
- 4 years ago
-
estee_arie
-
-
morirjedi
-
what a bunch of idiots. if a ever see another peta rally i will @#$$$ their asses. i have had dogs all my life. don't you ever compare the kkk to a dog competition. that is the most offensive thing i have seen for some time. how out of touch can these people be!
- 4 years ago
-
morirjedi
-
-
mutedmajority [removed]
- This comment was removed as a violation of community guidelines.
-
mutedmajority [removed]
-
-
dariusvons
-
mutedmajority:
...where does it say anything about puppy mills? which I agree are horrible and evil, and anyone who breeds dogs only for profit are little more than slavers... or the animal equivalent. and yes the article IS about the canine equivalent to human eugenics.
also almost everyone I know or know about who does have a pure bred dog (except the local drug dealer scum, who steal pure breeds and then run mills) takes very good care of them, and don't run puppy mills. but instead may use their prize stud or bitch to breed a litter only sometimes, because breeding is a detriment to the bitches health.
- 4 years ago
-
dariusvons
-
-
dariusvons
-
so? what's the problem with breeds? or breeding making breeds? or wanting particular traits in any animal? I don't see the problem here... these guys are just nut bags who are fighting a stupid pointless fight. like creationists...
come on, I'm all for protecting any and all beings from excessive suffering. and sure I don't like factory farms and cruelty in general, but this is dumb... they take it too far. breeding is NO DIFFERENT FROM EVOLUTION... also having a pet dog it NOT slavery.
- 4 years ago
-
dariusvons
-
-
divinorum
-
"Their goal, according to a post on the PETA website, was to draw a parallel between the KKK and the American Kennel Club."
that's hilarious, because my first thought was to link PETA to the KKK.
- 4 years ago
-
divinorum
-
-
shanklinmike [removed]
-
-
Actually, we're a liberty-minded constitutional democratic-republic, NOT a mob rule democracy. Actually, that is what we are SUPPOSE to be, but as you can tell, we are actually much closer to oligarchy democracy than ever before.
- 4 years ago
-
shanklinmike [removed]
-
-
shanklinmike [removed]
-
Type in PETA on my video search! You will be amazed at the BS that goes on at PETA!!!!!
- 4 years ago
-
shanklinmike [removed]
-
-
dirtyemowords
-
Oh dear. That's ridiculously poor taste. I appreciate wanting to get a point across but I absolutely refuse that there can be any comparison between the KKK and the fucking kennel club.
- 4 years ago
-
dirtyemowords
-
-
cynker
-
hey let them do what they like, if they offend someone they might get punched in the face for dressing to extreme, so let it be, let them take responsibility !
- 4 years ago
-
cynker
-
-
afishlikeme
-
It does spark attention. But it is a very sore point.They should have stuck with getting naked.
- 4 years ago
-
afishlikeme
-
-
Paratus
-
People Eating Tasty Animals is just about like the KKK. Morons both. The costume is appropriate. I wonder where they were during deer season. Perhaps I should invite them over for some deer roast. The tenderloin is very good for breakfast.
- 4 years ago
-
Paratus
-
-
EricT
-
idiots.
- 4 years ago
-
EricT
-
-
barkway
-
only TWO? That pair was lucky they weren't harmed given the offensive imagery and the location.
- 4 years ago
-
barkway
-
-
TabulaRasa
-
What a way to make a fool of yourself and your organization.
- 4 years ago
-
TabulaRasa
-
-
junsumoney
-
I think people are missing the point. No matter what should you use a horrible mistake of history as a demonstration as if it was nothing.
Dressing as KKK is insulting humanity and people who had suffered the lynching. I don't care if it's for "comparison" (more of a shock value, I believe) but it's completely inhumane.
You wouldn't dress up like a KKK to protest a fucking dog show! Sooner or later, they will dress up as Nazis, and "compare" the fucking dog show with WWII. - 4 years ago
-
junsumoney
-
-
unimatrix0
-
great post awesome josh!
a clear winner by the amount of conversation generated.
It would seem the knee jerk reaction is something like "PETA sucks, blah, blah, blah". What is funny is that many seem to be under the impression that PETA made some sort of mistake; that PETA did not expect or desire the outrage and distress.
On the contrary, PETA calculated their actions precisely to generate the distress and outrage.
Judging by the outcry, the stunt was a huge success, generating a great deal of free publicity. It is no accident PETA is so successful at raising money.
I am glad PETA is around, pushing the envelope and practicing the venerable American tradition of protest. A little street theater is good for the soul.
I do regret that the issues around the genetic health of dogs was not further explored. This is an underreported and misunderstood crisis. Many breeders of pure bred dogs are guilty of perpetuating and exacerbating genetic defects in order to turn a profit.
The world of show dog breeding has been and continues to be an ugly and disheartening example of animal abuse and cruelty. Yes, the dogs in the ring are pampered and spoiled, but in creating that one show dog many other dogs are rejected. Some of these are sold as pets. Others, those deemed unfit or unsafe to be pets, are sold to bunchers for medical experiments or simply euthanized. - 4 years ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
Argon18
-
unimatrix0:
That still just assumes that just because it generates attention it does anything to help their cause when the majority of opinion is sympathy for the dog shows
How do get people to donate money when most of them are offended by the stunt? They are much more likely to donate to the Kennel Club
From the facts displayed here by the outrage it would make the dog shows more popular and not bring any attention at all to any consequences of breeding.
As was already pointed out "What a way to make a fool of yourself and your organization."
- 4 years ago
-
Argon18
-
-
unimatrix0
-
unimatrix0:
Dude,
they wanted the attention and they got it. I doubt they care much at all about your opinion one way or another. Clearly their fund raising is quite successful. They don't need or want your advice.
- 4 years ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
Argon18
-
unimatrix0:
So I guess as long as they can make money money from fund rasing that is all they care about.
That only makes them worse than the greedy breeders since that is a lot cheaper scam to pull on the bleeding hearts that do care about animal rights to get them to donate.
At least the dog shows have a lot more quality production values in their entertaiment than the low class and obnoxious stunts that PETA pulls.
It's not PETA that needs the advice it's the people who are stupid enough to fall for their grandstanding and think it gives them any credibility
- 4 years ago
-
Argon18
-
-
unimatrix0
-
unimatrix0:
I understand your outrage. Do you understand that PETA is counting on your outrage, and that by expressing your outrage you are only proving their point and disproving yours?
Argon, you are the fish, and PETA just reeled you on in, laughing at your protest all the while.
If you really believe what you claim, next time don't take the bait.
- 4 years ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
Argon18
-
unimatrix0:
The fish is you because you believe those tactics work and they only serve to line PETA's pockets just as much as the dog shows
Who is being manipulated when cause for animal rights is the loser?
How am I taking the bait by exposing their scam, when it is those that donate and think that their tactics are a success that are falling for it?
There is a sucker born every minute and it is those that take what PETA does for anything other than a blatant rip off
- 4 years ago
-
Argon18
-
-
unimatrix0
-
unimatrix0:
you expose nothing, you only feed and nurture what you claim to despise.
You have swallowed the hook, you are in the boat, and you are still glad you caught the worm.
congratulations
- 4 years ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
Argon18
-
unimatrix0:
Feeding what? I don't give any credence to such outrageous antics? I don't give any money to such charlatans, I don't go to dog shows.
I only point out the hypocrisy of their position which actually DOES what they claim to despise by making the dog shows look like victims just to make money off of them.
You swallowed the hook by claiming their tactics are a success and buying into their scam by claiming that you care about the genetic health of dog that are bred make yourself the manipulated hypocrite for advocating such tactics.
Have fun in denial and enjoy the view of the pyramids.
- 4 years ago
-
Argon18
-
-
unimatrix0
-
unimatrix0:
let me make this simple - your attention, your outrage, feeds PETA.
If no one would have responded, if you would have ignored it, PETA would have failed.
The fact that they received so much attention, including yours, makes thenm a success.
For PETA, it is mission accomplished.
Your cries and protests to the contrary only reinforces this simple truth. Give it a rest. Game over.
- 4 years ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
Argon18
-
unimatrix0:
Again you mak the simple binary assumption that any attention is worth anything and confuse quantity with quality.
I suppose all the attention Micheal Phelps got did him any good either right? It's all publicity.
No wonder you're an atheist with such simplistic either/or views and can't recognize the inconsistencies and fallacies that entails
- 4 years ago
-
Argon18
-
-
unimatrix0
-
unimatrix0:
your analogy with m. phelps is fallacious. PETA is not m. phelps.
Your ad hominem reveals the poverty of your intellect and a deficit in your character.
Why don't you call PETA and advise them of your insights concerning strategy. I am sure they are eager to hear from you.
Again, give it a rest. Game over. You only embarrass yourself with your childish protests.
- 4 years ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
Argon18
-
unimatrix0:
It is embarrassing that you can't recognize anything more complex than here or not here.
Of course it is a similar situation since the publicity that PETA gets is in direct conflict than the cause they espouse just as the sponsors saw a conflict with Phelps and the causes they wanted to advocate.
The differenceis that it is Phelps personally paying the price for it and it is not PETA that pays the price but progress for animal rights.
That is where PETA is more dishonest in their tactics and proven scam artists.
You have no right to claim ad homien attacks since you started them as an attempt to distract from your weak arguments and I only responded to them to show how lame they were since your character or intellect is not sufficient to converse without them.
- 4 years ago
-
Argon18
-
-
unimatrix0
-
-
unimatrix0:
I love you argon
- 4 years ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
andeeandee
-
i mean... i didnt want them to get shot.. but there are lots of crazy people out there...
- 4 years ago
-
andeeandee
-
-
andeeandee
-
i'm surprised those people didnt get shot
- 4 years ago
-
andeeandee
-
-
TonyDukes
-
A photo is worth a thousand words............how appropriate for these native terrorist.
- 4 years ago
-
TonyDukes
-
-
estoppel
-
Not because now that we have an African-descendant president and all of the sudden KKK is humorous and acceptable
- 4 years ago
-
estoppel
-
-
Chuck_st_chuck
-
estoppel:
the KKK have always been humorus
Half of them are undercover fbi agents
the other half are fbi informents lolonly White surpemise group that should be feared are the lone wolves and unafiliated orginzations
like certain street gangsthe ideal of a "white terror" is sadly gone
the government considers them a more threat then radical muslims for some reason so they watch every thing on them - 4 years ago
-
Chuck_st_chuck
-
-
donkeyfly69
-
estoppel:
"KKK is humorous and acceptable"
i think they're hilarious
- 4 years ago
-
donkeyfly69
-
-
Chuck_st_chuck
-
sorry for my rant back on topic
Peta are retards
- 4 years ago
-
Chuck_st_chuck
-
-
Chuck_st_chuck
-
Nephwrack read your history the Ku Klux Klan was established after the civil war by southern democrats who refused to accept Reconstruction and to obay the new laws to allows black freedom so they Etablished the "invisable empire" and terrorized and killed free black man and woman, murdered children and white Republicans. if you were for the equalization of all men and women the Klan Saw you as a threat!.
they were nothing more but Drunk,small minded drunks and still are today.
and the Klan still votes Democratbecause republicans are still considered "nigger loving scum who ruined white society"
So you drink the kool-aid you liberal socalist jim jones lovers so much enjoy
- 4 years ago
-
Chuck_st_chuck
-
-
numinant [removed]
- This comment was removed by its owner.
-
numinant [removed]
-
-
Argon18
-
numinant:
What remains is just sympathy for the dog shows as victims of persecution.
All PETA gets out of such grandstanding is making themselves feel important and a boost to their egos
- 4 years ago
-
Argon18
-
-
srose5
-
peta folks have gone too far with this one ...
- 4 years ago
-
srose5
-
-
VitaminStolz
-
Clearly, PETA needs less flare, more brains. The KKK comparison is out of context. Better leadership is needed.
Another illogical approach to make a statement by world famous PETA. - 4 years ago
-
VitaminStolz
-
-
Chuck_st_chuck
-
plus shows how dumb peta is
First off KKK don't believe in a "Master race" they're just a bunch of Drunk Democrats running around in bed sheets.and eugenics have been around FOREVER with out it many animals might have died due to climate change, shift vegitation etc etc
Eugenics ALSO does cause problems like German sheperds with hip displacment or retrivers with bad backs because of the bottle necking that comes with it
so it has it's pros and cons
- 4 years ago
-
Chuck_st_chuck
-
-
Nephwrack
-
Chuck_st_chuck:
drunk democrats? wow. way to drink the kool aid.
- 4 years ago
-
Nephwrack
-
-
cbjones
-
I said it once, and I'll keep saying it till the people in that organization do something respectable: Fuck P.E.T.A.
- 4 years ago
-
cbjones
-
-
thewarnerla
-
pure breeds are real and true facts, and facts are stubborn things. PETA is a dysfunctional group of douche bags who don't value human life properly. PETA needs to read on how we as people got to where we are as a civilization.
- 4 years ago
-
thewarnerla
-
-
donkeyfly69
-
geez people lighten up.
it's not really a big deal
- 4 years ago
-
donkeyfly69
-
-
Found_Avenue
-
donkeyfly69:
I don't know...
If i walked out of the subway on the way to work and saw that shit smack in the middle of the Penn Station area, it would piss me off pretty bad. I would not find that to be a "cute" stunt. Their offensiveness far outweighs the point they're trying to make. I'm actually seriously shocked that no body beat any of them up... - 4 years ago
-
Found_Avenue
-
-
thewarnerla
-
PETA is a white supremacist organization. Please let some other color run it so that it doesn't give us a bad rap anymore. Animals are less than human, whats the debate about?
- 4 years ago
-
thewarnerla
-
-
unimatrix0
-
thewarnerla:
humans are animals
- 4 years ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
valiant777
-
I love my German Sheppard.
- 4 years ago
-
valiant777
-
-
DRudeBoy
-
They aren't even trying to persuade people, just ridiculous publicity stunts.
- 4 years ago
-
DRudeBoy
-
-
clownpuncher
-
Wow, if the New Yorkers would have clubbed them clowns with baseball bats, they could have made it about killing the seals.
- 4 years ago
-
clownpuncher
-
-
Found_Avenue
-
That is absolutely disgusting. I'm surprised nobody beat the shit out of them. PETA, shame on you.
- 4 years ago
-
Found_Avenue
-
-
noeliasophia
-
totally inappropriate
- 4 years ago
-
noeliasophia
-
-
humanpasta
-
I wonder if they tried to hand fliers out to black people?
- 4 years ago
-
humanpasta
-
-
aquamammal
-
I love PETA. And I gladly give my money to them.
XVX for life, R.A.S.H. 'til death.
- 4 years ago
-
aquamammal
-
-
carl0s808
-
This is too much already. These dogs have a great fucking life! I didn't want to be a hater but PETA has to chill!
- 4 years ago
-
carl0s808
-
-
smallgod
-
Wow, these organizations are getting crazy. This is about as bad as forcing vegetarianism on homeless and poor people. It's sad when a life choice becomes a religion.
- 4 years ago
-
smallgod
-
-
SHAWN_RITTIMAN
-
Way to offend...eat a steak!
- 4 years ago
-
SHAWN_RITTIMAN
-
-
dbmurti
-
I'm a PETA member. You're disgust with their attention drawing ads just reveals your naivety. Please realize that their stunts are to draw your web clicks to their reasoned and effective website, www.peta.org. Why not check it out this very moment!
- 4 years ago
-
dbmurti
-
-
Argon18
-
dbmurti:
Because the well earned disgust totally disrupts any validity of whatever they're trying to convey. You can't expect anyone to believe that reason has anything to do with such outrageous behavior.
If you think that is effective to use such tactics then you have a lot to learn about what is naive and are very deluded about marketing
People are not going to be receptive at all to anything on the web site and it is unlikely they would even look with such obnoxious antics that PETA displays.
All such attention produces is a backlash of sympathy toward what is being protested
- 4 years ago
-
Argon18
-
-
fightingsioux
-
What's next for PETA's outragiousness...bombing the private homes of government funded researchers because they are using mice to discover newer antibiotics that can kill the current resistant strains of bacteria found in hospitals? They have a right to protest, but the "shock and awe" mentality of this organization has crossed the line many times in their history.
- 4 years ago
-
fightingsioux
-
-
Gargaryun
-
People Eating Tasty Animals!!!...Ever wonder WHY You never see PETA members throwing paint on those wearing LEATHER outside Biker Bars?...(self preservation)
By the way, anyone who actually WATCHED the Westminster Dog Show on Television the last 2 nights can testify that about HALF the paid sponsership advertising was for SUPPORTING Local animal shelters, by ADOPTING stray/homeless pets...& They mentioned the grateful loyalty & love of MIXED-BREED Dogs! (mutts) Most of the Dogs I've been blessed with as companions in My life have been Mixed Breeds, some with known bloodline ancestory(German Shepherd/Chow, Black Lab/Rottweiler, Chihuahua/Dascshund, etc. ), some just MUTTS without a clue to origins, & They've ALL been GREAT!
At this point in My life, I have Pure-bred Daschunds & breed them, HOME Raised, with only 3-4 Adult dogs at a time, who spend as much time indoors, loose, as they do running free in My fenced yard, depending on the weather....I daresay I probably treat My Hounds better than most of these PETA jerks do their own offspring or significant others, since the Dogs are carnivores, & I'm an Omnivore with serious carniverous leanings, so they get lots of "Dad Food" as treats...(Medium Rare Steak, cheese nibbles, scrmbled eggs), whereas the PETA freaks REQUIRE that everyone around them force themselves into biologically abnormal eating habits! Any Vegans who disagree?...I DON'T CARE!!! THHHHH(razzberry) - 4 years ago
-
Gargaryun
-
-
arcovello269
-
I'm a vegetarian, I personally hate when people automatically assume i'm a crazy PETA person. I have my own views of how I should treat animals that doesn't mean that I think everyone should believe then same things. I don't shove my views down people's throats like PETA. Blame PETA, not vegetarians and vegans.
- 4 years ago
-
arcovello269
-
-
tome_erau
-
There just going to keep doing ridiculous crap like this as long as they can keep people talking about them. If you want to fix the problem then just completely ignore everything PETA does from this point on and let them die off.
P.S.
Congratulations PETA on being the Ann Coulter of the vegan world - 4 years ago
-
tome_erau
-
-
jeckersly317 [removed]
- This comment was removed as a violation of community guidelines.
-
jeckersly317 [removed]
-
-
donkeyfly69
-
jeckersly317:
you're an idiot
- 4 years ago
-
donkeyfly69
-
-
unimatrix0
-
Everyone agrees they are crazy, yet they are voted up and they are on top. They are getting their message across. PETA no doubt considers this a victory.
- 4 years ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
Argon18
-
unimatrix0:
No doubt they consider it a victory for their egos but it does nothing to change the policies of the Kennel Club or even to discourage anyone from going to dog show.
In fact judging from the majority of the opinions posted on this thread it would actually encourage people to go out of spite from the insults that PETA used
"Just for this I'll be donating the Kennel club, that I don't even agree with just to make sure this event happens again next year and pisses these insensitive people off again." ...ocanada
How is it at all a victory for the animal abuses that you claim to be taking place if it has the opposite effect of making the dog shows more popular?
- 4 years ago
-
Argon18
-
-
unimatrix0
-
unimatrix0:
argon,
you are like a little lap dog, yapping at my feet, cute but annoying.
- 4 years ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
DeliaTheArtist
-
unimatrix0:
I think the victory is in awareness. Obviously there is no better way to get your point across quickly than to make a radical statement like the one they have done here. While it surely backlashed in some respects, you know what they say: No publicity is bad publicity!
- 4 years ago
-
DeliaTheArtist
-
-
Argon18
-
unimatrix0:
And you are like the videos of those promising a jihad to cleanse the infidels, deluded but dangerous.
Awareness doesn't help if the image is distorted since the perception is that they are making the dog shows more sympathetic.
How is it good pubilicity if it just shows the dog shows as the victims of persecution? That is the opposite effect than what they claim to want.
- 4 years ago
-
Argon18
-
-
DeliaTheArtist
-
unimatrix0:
"And you are like the videos of those promising a jihad to cleanse the infidels, deluded but dangerous." What? I don't understand what you are saying here.
I do not agree with their methods but I am trying to look at it from their POV- obviously to them, it was important to get the message out in the most extreme way possible- even if it was deluded and ended up with some backlash.
I'm sure however that there are a ton of radical activists who applaud this, and there are people even on this site who agree with the main idea of what they were saying even if they don't agree with how they did it. In that way, their stunt was indeed successful to some extent!
- 4 years ago
-
DeliaTheArtist
-
-
Argon18
-
unimatrix0:
Look at the "cute but annoying" bit in the reply above and it will make more sense.
You underestimate the amount of the backlash and any extent of positive sentiment was already there among the radical set.
That is evident even in the majority of replies to this post since most of them have been completely condemning the actions of PETA
The backlash among those that were even lukewarm to animal rights beforehand far outweighs any attention that the stunt has produced.
This makes the attempt not even worth the effort for all the negative effects since more people would be less inclined to support animal rights than before this happened.
- 4 years ago
-
Argon18
-
-
DeliaTheArtist
-
unimatrix0:
Oh, I didn't understand who the jihad comment was towards. Anyway, again, I understand and AGREE with your point of view- but Uni said that PETA would "consider this a victory", not that logical, rational people would! It's clear from responses here and other web sources I've read that radical activists are happy about this and may not recognize how it could hurt, not help, their cause.
- 4 years ago
-
DeliaTheArtist
-
-
unimatrix0
-
unimatrix0:
PETA is not interested in converting the mainstream - PETA recruits from the lunatic fringe.
This attention was predictable and is exactly what they wanted.
However, It would be nice to have a discussion around the practices of dog breeding. It is a topic close to my heart as I am active at my humane society and have a therapy dog and together we work with at risk youth.
- 4 years ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
Argon18
-
unimatrix0:
As long as they're happy stroking their own egos with the attention they can grab to make themselves feel relevant then that is all that is important to them.
But don't pretend that this has anything to do with progress for animal rights or is any effective way to get publicity for a cause.
The lunatic fringe is called that for a reason and is nothing to emulate in it's strategy or tactics
- 4 years ago
-
Argon18
-
-
unimatrix0
-
unimatrix0:
PETA is pleased with all you attention argon. You have been manipulated by PETA.
Their strategy and tactics continue to be quite successful. They count on your disdain and outrage and use it to their advantage.
PETA 1; argon 0.
- 4 years ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
Argon18
-
unimatrix0:
If the advantage they are looking for is attention to how ineffective they are then yes their selfish goal has been achieved.
But how is that worth anything?
The strategy and tactics might as well be used by any egomaniac to draw attention to their delusions whatever they might be.
Those methods are useless to accomplish anything other than derision and mocking
There are a whole lot better things to do with your time than selfishly feed your ego
- 4 years ago
-
Argon18
-
-
diode
-
crazy eh?
- 4 years ago
-
diode
-
-
DeliaTheArtist
-
-
Why is PETA full of crap? Let's let Penn and Teller explain!
- 4 years ago
-
DeliaTheArtist
-
-
pigmonkey
-
DeliaTheArtist:
LOL! Point and case!
- 4 years ago
-
pigmonkey
-
-
baby_im_bad_NEWS
-
DeliaTheArtist:
that is the most amazing thing i've ever watched.
- 4 years ago
-
baby_im_bad_NEWS
-
-
unashamed_muse
-
Im sorry, but this takes things too far. Its completely insensitive to an entire population of people. I understand their point about breeding for a superior animal, but, to be so insensitive to HUMANS goes well beyond the message they were trying to convey.
PETA is slowly losing my support and that is just sad.
- 4 years ago
-
unashamed_muse
-
-
Sexirobot
-
these motherfuckers have lost it.
- 4 years ago
-
Sexirobot
-
-
danielette
-
until the kennel club starts lynching people from trees and burning crosses in the front yards of people who don't own pure bread dogs i don't think Peta has any grounds for dressing up as the KKK. As a black woman I'm offended, there's no comparison to the two organizations PETA should be ashamed of themselves. They're just dogs.. the whole PETA organization needs to take a step back an look at how they've become a joke to most of the population
- 4 years ago
-
danielette
-
-
unimatrix0
-
The film also demonstrates how some breeders produce dogs with pronounced physical attributes – "exaggerations" – in their efforts to attract a dog show judge's eye.
The breed standards are set by the Kennel Club but are open to interpretation and the film shows how, as fashion changes, so do the dogs, leading to serious health and welfare problems in some breeds.
Bulldogs, for example, have been bred to be such an unnatural shape that most can no longer mate or give birth unassisted.
The RSPCA's Chief Vet Mark Evans says: "The show world is about an obsession, about beauty, and there is a ridiculous concept that that is how we should judge dogs…
"It takes no account of your temperament, your fitness for purpose potentially as a pet animal – and that to me just makes absolutely no sense at all."
The film also exposes famous show champions that continue to father puppies despite having serious inherited disease, and demonstrates that some breeders cull perfectly healthy puppies on purely cosmetic grounds.
As the filmmaker Jemima becomes increasingly concerned with what she uncovers, she challenges the Kennel Club.
The Kennel Club, however, robustly defends its position as the guardian of dog health, pointing out the initiatives it has taken to improve pedigree dog health – including their accredited breeder scheme which sets a code of conduct for breeders and asks them to make use of health screening schemes.
It also insists that "the vast majority of dog breeds are healthy".
Ultimately, the film concludes that far from enough is being done.
As Professor Jones says: "If the dog breeders insist on going further down that road, I can say with confidence really that there is a universe of suffering waiting for many of these breeds – and many if not most of these breeds will not survive.
"They will get so inbred that they will be unable to reproduce and their genes will come to a dead end." - 4 years ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
Argon18
-
unimatrix0:
"They will get so inbred that they will be unable to reproduce and their genes will come to a dead end."
Then that will have a lot more effect in stopping the dog shows than protests by PETA ever will but if there is so much money involved in continuing them why would they jeapordize that?
- 4 years ago
-
Argon18
-
-
unimatrix0
-
unimatrix0:
good question, but it wouldn't be the first time greedy, short sighted humans did something that was ultimately against their best interest, would it?
- 4 years ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
Argon18
-
unimatrix0:
So more than likely they would take steps to inject fresh genes into the breeding to keep themselves on the gravy train so they can continue being greedy
- 4 years ago
-
Argon18
-
-
walkthewalk
-
PETA is an embarrassment to all of us who love animals.
- 4 years ago
-
walkthewalk
-
-
pigmonkey
-
What is wrong with pure breed dogs? What is wrong with knowing a bloodline or history of a dogs family? what is wrong with NOT breeding dogs that have illness or disorder that will have to be pawned off to anyone that is stupid enough to say yes to you? People breeding dogs that no one wants is the problem, not dogs that are WELL trained, groomed and breed. I worked at the SPCA for years and let me tell you that very few 'Pure breed" dogs are apart of our adopt problem. It is stupid people like this who are the problem!
- 4 years ago
-
pigmonkey
-
-
unimatrix0
-
pigmonkey:
check the link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pedigree_Dogs_Exposed
this will explain what is wrong
- 4 years ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
nursediesel
-
abbym0308, My thoughts exactly. I've got to say they need to go after puppy mills. The people in these shows treat there dogs with utmost respect, the dogs getthe best medical and hygiene treatment and they live with the people that care for them..... If they don't treat the animals well they'll be booted out.
Puppy mills are the bad guys; and the dog fight breeders. - 4 years ago
-
nursediesel
-
-
Liquidsoul
-
LOL!!! Well those people spend millions of dollars on those dogs, only to parade them around like slaves. Submissive and trained to obey all dictates in order to be perfect to win a prize for their dominate master. Seems a little sick to me anyways, but the KKK things is a little overboard.
- 4 years ago
-
Liquidsoul
-
-
Jeffnfun631
-
Why dont they just dress up as Hospital patients. That is so stupid
- 4 years ago
-
Jeffnfun631
-
-
pddd
-
P = Pathetic
E = Evil
T = Terrorist
A = Association - 4 years ago
-
pddd
-
-
seanalyn
-
well if I had any respect left for PETA its gone now.
What hilarious is that the Westminster Dog Show and all the events surrounding it raise a ton of money for charity... most of which are animal shelter and rescue non profits. So PETA is in effect trying to take money away from animal rescue shelters. Yet again it seems like they arent looking before they leap.
Also I really doubt that dog shows are ruining the gene pool on dogs since there are far more mutts than purebreds in the world. Personally I would rather have an adorable little Corgi mutt mix than a purebred...but I have no problems with the purebreds themselves.
- 4 years ago
-
seanalyn
-
-
Raveway
-
PETA is a terrible, self-righteous (as bandit said), HYPOCRITICAL organization. They disgust me. They try to impose their radical beliefs tooooo aggressively. Watch the 'Penn & Teller: Bullshit' episode on PETA if you don't understand what I mean.
- 4 years ago
-
Raveway
