Supreme Court rejects 9/11 detainee's lawsuit against U.S. officials
-
-
- AwesomeJosh
- added this
A sharply divided Supreme Court ruled Monday that FBI Director Robert Mueller and former Attorney General John Ashcroft can't face a lawsuit from a former Sept. 11 detainee who argued they were responsible for his restrictive confinement because of his religious beliefs.
The court on Monday overturned a lower court decision that let Javaid Iqbal's lawsuit against the high-ranking officials proceed.
Iqbal is a Pakistani Muslim who spent nearly six months in solitary confinement in New York in 2002. He had argued that while Ashcroft and Mueller did not single him out for mistreatment, they were responsible for a policy of confining detainees in highly restrictive conditions because of their religious beliefs or race.
But the government argued that there was nothing linking Mueller and Ashcroft to the abuses that happened to Iqbal at a Brooklyn, N.Y., prison's Administrative Maximum Special Housing Unit, and the court agreed.
"The complaint does not show or even intimate, that petitioners purposefully housed detainees in the ADMAX SHU due to their race, religion or national origin," said Justice Anthony Kennedy, who wrote the majority opinion. "All it plausibly suggests is that the nation's top law enforcement officers, in the aftermath of a devastating attack, sought to keep suspected terrorists in the most secure conditions available until the suspects could be cleared of terrorist activity."
Had the court ruled the other way, it would have led to hundreds of similar suits.
The New York-based 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals had said the lawsuit could proceed...
The court on Monday overturned a lower court decision that let Javaid Iqbal's lawsuit against the high-ranking officials proceed.
Iqbal is a Pakistani Muslim who spent nearly six months in solitary confinement in New York in 2002. He had argued that while Ashcroft and Mueller did not single him out for mistreatment, they were responsible for a policy of confining detainees in highly restrictive conditions because of their religious beliefs or race.
But the government argued that there was nothing linking Mueller and Ashcroft to the abuses that happened to Iqbal at a Brooklyn, N.Y., prison's Administrative Maximum Special Housing Unit, and the court agreed.
"The complaint does not show or even intimate, that petitioners purposefully housed detainees in the ADMAX SHU due to their race, religion or national origin," said Justice Anthony Kennedy, who wrote the majority opinion. "All it plausibly suggests is that the nation's top law enforcement officers, in the aftermath of a devastating attack, sought to keep suspected terrorists in the most secure conditions available until the suspects could be cleared of terrorist activity."
Had the court ruled the other way, it would have led to hundreds of similar suits.
The New York-based 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals had said the lawsuit could proceed...
-
- groups:
- Community, Politics, US Politics, 9/11
-
- tags:
- News, Politics, Current TV, US Politics, 3 more
-
-
GLiz
-
I'm undecided about this decision. I need more information on the individaul and what other pretexts he was detained. There's a large community of Pakistanis in New York. This couldn't be just random.
- 2 years ago
-
GLiz
-
-
current89
-
Not sure if I agree with the decision. Featured on the US Politics channel.
- 2 years ago
-
current89
