Community | October 20, 2009 | 171 comments

There are 5 million children who could be potentially orphaned by ICE deportations

Image
jubal
Cristina in her show on Univision tonite featured the stories of several children who have been left orphaned in the United States due to the deportation of their parents. On Cristina's website she reports, based on ICE estimates, that 5 million children, United States citizens by birth, live with their illegal alien parents. On her show she focused on several cases of children whose parents were taken from their homes and the children were forced to be placed in the hands of family relatives or friends because ICE, according to the children, wouldn't allow the parents to take the children with them, because they were "United States Citizens".

The US Immigration newsletter says different....http://www.usimmigrationsupport.org/newsletter/2006/dec_15.html

They claim that the government does not make the decision for the parents, they claim that the decision is the parent's decision. One thing they do make clear to the parents, they say, is that if the children are left behind without being left in the care of responsible adults, they will be handed over to Child Protective Services and they will end up in the Foster Care System.

Another troubling consequence, besides the suffering of the children left behind in the United States, is the growing anger and hatred they feel towards American Authority figures for having their parents, sometimes violently, ripped away from the children's lives.

Watching the show is a very emotional experience. To look into the eyes of these children is so heartbreaking. Several parents interviewed by Cristina reported that they were not given the option of taking their children with them, while others talked about another unique situation. Families where one parent has a work visa, the other parent doesn't, and they have one child who was born outside of the country while they have two children born inside of the country.

In a case recently in Yakima, Washington, three children were orphaned by a domestic violence incident that left both their illegal alien parents dead in a murder suicide. The children were taken in by their illegal alien aunt who legally adopted them in American courts. She was being deported but the five children, two of hers, and the three of her sisters, were not named in the deportation order. According to the article in the New York times, "Here in Eastern Washington, where the number of illegal immigrants is high, Gonzalez's almost certain deportation would hardly be worthy of note. But because of the children, her case has ensnarled government agencies in ways such cases seldom do, with state and Yakima County juvenile-court officials advocating that the family be allowed to stay, while immigration authorities move toward deportation."

What do you think should happen to the children? Should they be deported with their parents? What if they are American Citizens, should the ICE be deporting American Citizens because of their parent's illegal status? Recently, a class-action lawsuit against the U.S. government was filed by 60 American children whose parents face deportation. Their argument is that such deportation violates certain amendments of the U.S. Constitution.
  1. groups:
    Community,   News and Politics,   Current Tonight,   Immigration
  2. tags:
    News and Politics Family Immigration Ice 1 more
  3. recommended by:
    Vierotchka
  4.     
    |

171 comments // There are 5 million children who could be potentially orphaned by ICE deportations

  • courage
  • jubal
    • 0
      jubal  
    • Laws have changed over the past 50 years. Many laws are stupid, ill conceived, and/or just plain unjust. People break laws all the time, especially those that diminish human rights.

      My father's side of the family came to this country when the immigration policy was very liberal. Migrant workers were common place. People migrated annually from below the US / Mexico border to work on the farms in Spring and Summer and then returned to their countries in the fall. The problems started when Nixon and Reagan started playing games with the immigration policies and did not clearly create visa statuses for the migrant farm workers. Once it started to become difficult for these workers to come and go, they decided to stay here so they could work and still support their families back south of the border.

      When people get used to a certain way of things and they suddenly change without a fair system in place to deal with the repercussions of the change, then that is unjust.

      Nixon was notorious. He saw the opportunity to help his campaign donors to raid the middle class, create HMO's to make money off denying healthcare, begin the task of dismantling entitlement programs (created by FDR) and to suck the wealth out of the middle class.

      Back in the 60's and 70's America experienced its highest standard of living for the middle class in its history. The dollar was strong and people earned living wages. It was possible for one parent to work while the other stayed home to take care of the kids.

      After Nixon and Ford came Carter. The International Cartels decided to begin their plundering of the middle class by first orchestrating the OIL Embargo and the huge increases in prices and shortages of gasoline. HMO's were given birth, deregulation of all the financial markets began. All the protections that consumers enjoyed and helped to increase the wealth of the middle class were removed. Essentially all obstacles to them being looted were removed. And the looting has continued to this day.

      The middle class is now decimated and the propaganda of the day is blame the immigrants who are here illegally. People have been mind fucked by the profiteers to blame the poor for what is happening in America, instead of blaming the real bandits. The Fascist Corporatists who rape and pillage this country.

      Now under GHW Bush, we have leveraged all of our infrastructure assets to China. America is owned by foreign countries and we are saddled with a debt that can never be repaid, but all of this is the fault of the illegal immigrants.

      I am telling you its utter bullshit and people need to wake up tot he facts of history. We have been fucked by practically every president since Nixon.

      Thankfully Obama seems to be really tough and he is cracking down on the greedy corporatist bastards. Just recently he announced that he was forcing the companies that are paying outrageous salaries and bonuses to their executives who recieved bailout funds. We need this type of tough regulations restored so that the middle class can begin recovering.

    • 2 years ago
  • mjsmith11
    • 0
      mjsmith11  
    • Having a child here is not the same as being a Citizen of the United States of America. We, as Americans, must do what is in the best interest of our Country. We have laws that must be followed. It is a shame that parents put their own children into this situation. It is the parents of the children who are to blame. The people of the United States should sue the parents who break our laws and think they can get away with it by having their children being exploited. I see that man in the picture with his head in his hand. I do not feel sorry for him one bit. He put himself and his children into this situation. My Grandparents came here in the 1950's on my Mother's side and on my Fathers side we go as far back as being here as indentured servants and I have had ancestors that had to leave New York because they were loyal to the British Government. "The World does not owe you a thing, and you owe it to the World to be a good person." "Life is not fair." If everybody would just keep the last two quotes I said in mind, they would have a clear vision on how to live on this planet. When someone in the United States commits a crime and they are here illegally, ICE should be notified and the criminal should be detained until ICE picks them up. When a Law Enforcement Agency does not turn over lawbreakers who are also here in the United States of America illegally, their blood is on their hands. Too often gang memebrs are allowed to stay in the United States when they should not even be here in the first place MS-13 specifically. I love America, America is the greatest Country on the Planet. The United States of America has fair immigration laws. The United States of America is the most welcoming Country on the Planet. The United States of America must enforce our Immigration Laws because it is the right thing to do. I do not feel sorry for anyone, and I would never ever want anyone to feel sorry for me.

    • 2 years ago
  • jubal
    • 0
      jubal  
    • Sorry Plusaf, I tried to post this response in the same thread three times and it wouldn't take it. So I had to post it as a new thread in this same story.

    • 2 years ago
  • jubal
    • 0
      jubal  
    • The Beautiful United States that you are remembering and thinking fondly of is gone.The American Dream has turned into a nightmare and all of us, at least the people I know and support locally and some here on this venue, just want the nightmare to end and for us to wake up and find oursleves in a safe place to exsist.

      What I do know is that in America 50 years ago, there was hope and brotherly love. In the America of today there is hate and fear and terror....and its not all caused by Muslims from the desert of Arabia. There is real terror in Washington and on Wall Street.

      All of us, the immigrants who came here 50 years ago and the immigrants who came here 100 years ago who at one time or another were hated for their ethnicity have allowed ourselves to be manipulated and beaten down so that we dont' stand up for what is right. We just ask to be left alone to live in peace in our homes. But even that is being threatened.

      This country may have started out as the Shimmering City of Hope, but it has become the Godzilla of the world. Personally I thing its too late to rescue her from those who have raped and pillaged her. That is why I have decided to support the First Nations and their movement. Once Godzilla has run out of steam, they will be there to pick up the pieces and reintroduce the survivors to the old ways of living with the land and nature in harmony.

    • 2 years ago
  • jubal
    • 0
      jubal  
    • Plusaf, I look at my grandparents who are all now dead. My grandmother from Ecuador, lived to 101, while her husband, my grandfather who died in Ecuador, was left there by my father and the rest of the family to die. He was a violent alcoholic. But he had made a big name for himself. He made it all the way to become a Supreme Court Justice. He was also a government minister prior to that and a lawyer. And yet, with all of his accomplishments, being a violent alcoholic caused his entire family of 10 children to leave Ecuador and come to America to make lives for themselves over 50 years ago.

      On the other hand, my grandparents on my mother's side. They didn't live past their 70's. They died from exposure to dozens of harmful chemicals that they were exposed to making bombs for the United States during the second world war. My grandfather worked on the Manhattan project and got injured in an explosion in a lab. He had to have steel rods grafted to both his legs because his bones were not capable of supporting his body weight. He walked with crutches. He taught me many things and told me stuff that he said was top secret. He had lost his faith in the United States because of the corruption he saw taking over the nation at all levels. He was angry at the VA because they had given him so many blood transfusions with mismatched blood that they couldn't match him correctly anymore. Both my grandparents on my mother's side gave their lives for this country and died horrible deaths.

    • 2 years ago
  • jubal
    • 0
      jubal  
    • Well if its any comfort to you who are so down on Illegal Criminal Aliens, I agree with Obama. Before we can have comprehensive immigration reform, we need to close the leaks on the borders so no more cross illegally.

      But what I am advocating is that once that closure is accomplished, then those that are here need to be treated with dignity. They aren't dogs that you can throw into a pen. They are human beings and their children who are born here deserve to have their parents in their lives.

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
  • jubal
    • 0
      jubal  
    • @Ocanada, its not the fault of the immigrants that wages have plummeted and that manufacturing jobs have gone down hill. You should direct your anger at Nixon and Reagan who saw the opportunity to manipulate things to accomplish just that.

      Republicans in general are responsible for the decimation of the middle class in this country, not the immigrants. It is more profitable for big corporations to pay lower wages. Illegal immigration is their "Ace in the Hole."

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
  • J_Jammer
    • 0
      J_Jammer [removed]  
    • jubal:

      Sometimes things need to play out by themselves without constant interference.

      Firing the police officers was just stupid. Never fire the people that go on strike they love their job they just don't love it at that moment. They love it enough to go without pay and fight for something. That's worth keeping....not getting rid of.

      Not to state that strikers are the most reasonable people, but that's just some not all.

    • 2 years ago
  • FoosMaster
    • 0
      FoosMaster  
    • I have 3 friends that have lost their "Good" businesses because of illegal immigrants!
      Note: I do kinda feel sorry for those that are taken advantage of by unscrupulous businesses, but this should not be allowed to happen. We need Far tougher laws against these types of businesses that hire and take advantage of illegal immigrants.
      1) Chris had a landscaping business for 12 years but lost it because he couldn’t compete with the Illegals. He once had 7 employees and he always paid his people a fair wage but couldn’t keep them because of the unfair competition from Illegals which caused him to loose his business. (PS - he had 2 employees from Central America that were ‘Legal’ immigrants with green cards and they eventually did get their citizenship.)
      2) Greg had a painting business and employed 11 people. He also paid his people a fair wage and lost his business because of unfair competition from Illegals.
      3) John was a private construction contractor with 4 employees. Same thing happened to him.
      These people that claim that Illegals only take the jobs that Americans don’t want are Full Of Shit!
      Yes we need better immigration laws so that it will be easier for people to come here legally, but that does not give people the right to come here illegally. It just gives unscrupulous employers an excuse to take advantage of a disadvantaged people and creates unfair competition in the markets.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
  • ocanada
    • 0
      ocanada  
    • I generally don't post multiple threads forgive me in this case.

      I want to make one point exceptionally clear. I am not racist and I have a love an affinity for Latin Culture. I can dance the salsa (well mildly) I helped to organize after school programming with a focus on education about different latin countries such as Brazil, Puerto Rico, Cuba, and Mexico. Speak basic spanish myself and am amazed by the contributions to American culture and the wider culture of the Americas that have come from the latin people. With so much to offer we need to make it easier for people from central America to get into the U.S. but illegals are an affront to those Americans who worked so hard to get here who are truly the best and brightest and have done so much to enrich this nation.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • ocanada:

      It's nice to know you care for something other than yourself. But you're way out of place on this subject!

      Just because you know the most talked about dance that we Latinos have (salsa) and know the most talked about countries that are known in America (Brazil, Puerto Rico, Cuba and Mexico) it still makes you sound out of place here.

      Again, stay out of this subject and when you know how hard it is for someone from Latin American, not just Central America, to come here with a Visa, maybe than you can talk about why and how we have enriched your society and culture. You either have to be rich in Latin America to get a Visa or know someone in Power to do so. So no, you don't know anything about Latinos...

      AND

      Every group of ethnicity in this country, has murdered, has brought gangs to this country ( Crips and bloods/Black people and Hell's Angels/White people) has stolen from others, has kidnapped and raped kids, has lie to the people in the US, (George Bush, Bill Clinton (even though i would vote for him any day of the week) Rush Limbaugh... i see a pattern of Caucasian liars with power... don't come here and single out illegals.

      EVERYONE in this country has made a mistake in their lives, I know I have, but I don't have a criminal record, I don't have warrants or owe taxes.... but yet you want to single out every single illegal as the reason why US of A has issues... ha!

      I crossed the Mexican border and made a great life living here. In one year alone working for a bank as a VP, i made over 500k.... i'm only 33 and almost ready to retire... what are you doing for yourself? are you helping or complaining for the rest of the slackers in this country?

    • 2 years ago
  • ocanada
    • 0
      ocanada  
    • ocanada:

      I'm not pretending to understand a people that stretches over two continents and contains hundreds of millions of people just that I can share an appreciation for the accomplishments therein.

      Actually I do know what its like to get visas to come here. I've worked with representatives from the Spanish conulate in Indianapolis and have met the consular general twice. I've seen everything from religious visas, visas for students, and the art center where I worked gave out teaching visas so that people from the region could come and teach about their native cultures especially those with a history of qualifications involving low income communities and at risk youth. It took six months on our end six months on theirs just to spend one month in America to teach! It was ridiculous. Especially from Brazil whose immigration laws seem in many ways as equally restrictive as ours.

      Indianapolis latin community is very vibrant. One of our guest speakers was Marianno Pozo the grandson of Chano Pozo the famous Cuban musician. Our art exhibition showcased two Smithsonian fellows of Latin heritedge and we brought together in concert everything from folkloric dancers to a latin Super Group whose members have more than 14 grammys between them, Groupo YaYa. I do know what the best has to offer and what it is that we have gained as a result and I want to see a loosening of immigration laws because they are needlessly restrictive and promote illegal immigration.

      By the way, Marianno arived in America illegally fleeing Cuba for the most innocent of reasons, to pursue his dream of playing baseball in the major leagues he was a member of the Cuban national team and on a trip to Mexico stayed and fled to America seeking political asylum. He relayed his entire story to us and to the children in the program. And in the last year our president who is the son of an immigrant himself has his own sister denied political asylum and designated an illegal alien. The laws for asylum seekers also need to be overhauled nearly completely and I think that this is the perfect white house to accomplish it.

      But I still can not support the illegal immigration and the system it supports! With coyotes, depressed wages, so much fear and human suffering and the disproportionate economic impact it has on making Latin America reliant on remittences rather than domestic industry. It can not be allowed to continue and there must be stiff consequences for those who violate the law.

    • 2 years ago
  • Nephwrack
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • ocanada:

      We keep going around in circles with no solution here. If anyone decides to attack illegals and make unjust statements, I will continue to attack them and question their sources.

      Unless you have a solution to the problem, making clueless statements of " depressed wages, so much fear and human suffering and the disproportionate economic" I will continue to think you're uninformed and ignorant.

    • 2 years ago
  • ocanada
    • 0
      ocanada  
    • ocanada:

      Those are not clueless statements and until you work with the middle and working class of this country and understand their interests you will never get reform. What you are asking for isn't reform its a wet foot dry foot policy that will keep people pouring over the border and magically be granted legal status thats not reform. The solution is increased border security and a reform of both Asylum seekers and Visa seekers in this nation with a path to citizenship for those that are here but there still needs to be some deportations and perhaps many more than have occurred to date. Also green cards need to be issued quicker and I would even go so far as to say that naturalized U.S. citizens that have spent 35 years or more in America (the legal age to be president) should be allowed to run for president or vice president. But these are reforms that must protect and help those who did not violate U.S. laws and that is something that with your condescending attitude you will never convince enough Americans to support such proposals. Tone matters as well and the argument can not seem to be rewarding those who have violated the law.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • ocanada:

      and until i work with the middle and working class of this country? what do you think got me to the jobs I got in the past? my pretty looks? no, let me guess, my Latino looks, or maybe the accent i have when i speakit to tha white man! lol...

      Again, you start good and then end up wrong. I've been down the path of the middle and working class. Just because I made it further in life, doesn't mean I magically got there. I worked my ass off just like everyone else. I was promoted from the bottom of the pole to the highest a Latino, with my age, can make it to, at that time. I was a VP for a company at the age of 28 with 99% of the management group being white.

      Now, if you want tighter borders, sure! if you want tighter security, sure! want to deport more people because of the laws they broke? DO IT!! but to call them criminals because they are doing the same thing (again) your ancestors did? NO! you do so, or anyone else... i appear. =)

    • 2 years ago
  • ocanada
    • 0
      ocanada  
    • ocanada:

      I'm not talking about you as a person but in the approach you are projecting about reform. Which is more important the means to an end or the ends themselves? Because you will never achieve your goal of reform by telling working class Americans that the jobs being taken by illegals are jobs they wouldn't take or denying that wages have been depressed and working conditions made less safe because of unscrupulous businesses manipulating illegal workers. The working class and middle class will never side with reform and will not only be insulted but be antagonistic as I am being here in this forum and reform will not occur. Just swallow the bitter pill by admonition about the shared injustice of this system or expect nearly wholesale opposition. By doing this the other side swallows a bitter pill as well admitting the conditions that these workers come from and the danger they face getting here.

      As for doing the same thing my ancestors did? My ancestors include Native Americans and slaves just as many latin families do. Your condescension betrays your position and has you grasping at loose soil for a foundation. This countries history is as complex historically and racially as any in the Americas and it could be argued more so and again your tone hurts your argument because it derides the nation you are now a part of.

    • 2 years ago
  • ocanada
    • 0
      ocanada  
    • It isn't just Mexicans. Its many different nationalities responsible. Among them the lovely originators of MS13 a gang whose violence sent the murder rate in my home town from among the lowest to higher than washington DC in a matter of years. It has a way of making one callous when you have to suddenly fear being gunned down in your own neighborhood.

    • 2 years ago
  • ocanada
    • 0
      ocanada  
    • I'm sorry but I don't have much sympathy for them. There parents violated the law. They need to be punished. They have been a blight on American manufacturing jobs and have depressed wages across the nation and especially in rural factories which once the pillars of communities have been debased to often little more than minimum wage husks of their former selves. They can go home and work in factories shipped their by NAFTA another industrial blight for the bennefit of Mexico. I may be with the left on many issues by immigration isn't one of them. I don't believe in Amnesty. I don't beleive in loose borders, and I come from a factory family. I'm tired of excuses. This country isn't for those who violate the law and their families should not be given special privilege. I live a thousand miles away from the mexican border but an estimated sixty thousand mexican illegals live and work in my city. We only have 18,000 homeless. That number shouldn't be less than those illegally in the city and illegals have no business traveling 1,000 miles to pick grapes they are coming to pick off middle class jobs and its hurt my city greatly.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • ocanada:

      Middle class jobs? you're here crying how the illegals that pick grapes for a living and don't speak a lick of english, are taking Middle class jobs?

      Go back into the hole you record your videos and talk about yourself more. You have to no CLUE in what you're saying and since your profile talks about how you keep writing about yourself, you should stay off topics that are beyond your intellect.

      When you know what illegals go through, know what they have suffered to get here, what they endure on a regular basis to get by, they don't stand in the corner asking for a dollar (like your homeless people do) , but for a job and the shit white people make them do, then you can come here and talk about this, until then, stay of this subject with your clueless comments.

    • 2 years ago
  • ocanada
    • 0
      ocanada  
    • ocanada:

      It is unsafe conditions. Its a hell they shouldn't be encouraged to go through for financial reasons. We need immigration reform, to make it easier for people to make it into America yes, but not doing anything about those who have come here and are continuing to come here is unacceptable because more will be killed by narco traffickers and disgusting coyotes and many more will work in unsafe conditions created by unscrupulous factory owners. When you defend illegal immigration you support the whole damned system.

      The type of jobs that go to Illegals in Indianapolis aren't all unskilled labor positions. Illegals are often normal people with skills and even college educations whose circumstances forced them to this country for whatever reason whether political, financial, or due to conflict come here illegally because either they lack the time or resources for the proper channels or simply fear refusal after all that effort. Its a legitimate fear. 1,000 miles from Mexico people here aren't working in agricultural jobs they are working for construction companies, as sanitation engineers, working in factories, working in warehousing, working in landscaping, in many diverse sectors and they aren't all bad jobs. You don't get 1,000 miles without wits or connections or at least an organized network of those willing to violate the law.

      As for my profile. Its about me. Thats the whole point of a profile. I also admit its rather dated and needs to be updated with a less self centered focus, those articles are three years old at this point as well. Current used to be much more of a social networking site than it currently is in terms of the focus being about producers and those interested in creating items for television and made for some unique storytelling that transcended just news.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • ocanada:

      Very nice... now i have some respect for you... but still, when you know how hard it is for an illegal to get here, than share your views. Complaining doesn't help and what a group of bad apples does for a living, doesn't translate to all of them, doing the same.

      Also, I'm not supporting illegal immigration, please understand that. I'm supporting a better way for illegals to become legal and to stop the hate, the BS and crying that people put on these boards because they can't find a real job.

      Every person in my family that crossed the bordered have become citizens, gone to school, have great jobs and have no criminal record. I can't speak for my cousins that were born here though... lol... but I can speak for myself and say that i don't need to be a citizen to make a change. I'm not one and won't probably one until I see a reason to be one. I've made the money only a few could make and have a great life! Why? because I worked for it...

      So, great comment but don't think treating all illegals the same is a good argument for the lack of jobs, safety issues that others don't have.

    • 2 years ago
  • ocanada
    • 0
      ocanada  
    • ocanada:

      But you are. By suborning criticism of illegal immigrants and simply resorting to insults or personal accusations of those opposed to illegal immigration you are helping that evil system. It isn't just black and white but staying with the status quo assures more human suffering than being willing to make concessions about border controls and doing something about those who have arrived here illegally or who have committed or abided crimes while here.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • ocanada:

      Your comment "But you are. By suborning criticism of illegal immigrants and simply resorting to insults or personal accusations of those opposed to illegal immigration you are helping that evil system."

      The evil system you speak of is the same system that keeps illegals out of the US. The evil system you speak of has killed millions of families because they think they are God in those borders.

      I continue to question and insult people that make unfounded statements about a group of people seeking the same thing your ancestors were looking for when they came here.

      If this does not please you, well, next time bring up a solution to the problem. Talking about MS13 or the lack of jobs middle class is loosing has nothing to do with illegals. Last time I checked, I never lost a job to an illegal and people in NY or NJ don't have issues with illegals because we work our asses off to get the best jobs!! WE don't settle for the $10 or $15 per hour jobs, we strive for the best!

      If your town or city or state can't do the same, go teach and preach down there.

    • 2 years ago
  • ocanada
    • 0
      ocanada  
    • ocanada:

      Denying that illegal immigration has something to do with those issues doens't help your cause rather it is one of the unfounded statements you are speaking of.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • ocanada:

      ocanada, so you're telling me we need to focus on the issues you speak about because illegals are the ones to blame for it. OK!

      So who do i blame for the Hells Angels? illegals?

      how about Bloods and Crips? let me guess, illegals?

      how about the lack of jobs for the middle class in NJ/NY? illegals?

      or how about the corrupt political system in NJ/NY? illegals right? because they have people running the state and the police stations.

      makes a lot of sense... i don't know why i didn't see it before...

    • 2 years ago
  • ocanada
    • 0
      ocanada  
    • ocanada:

      The solution isn't to take either no blame or all of the blame. The idea is to make reform a partnership for the reduction of poverty in the Americas. It is senseless to deny any impact on Americas working environment for the negative. The best way to achieve reform is to make it the panacea that improves working conditions and wages so that this issue is never brought about again and you aren't going to get that with this adversarial approach.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
  • jubal
    • 0
      jubal  
    • @Plusaf Perhaps you don't understand the concepts of many indigenous cultures that didn't believe that any person could OWN the earth. Those that sold the land lacked the authority to sell the land in the first place. They could not possibly speak for the over 40K indigenous tribes of North and South America. They had no right to grant title.

      Did you know that indigenous people in South America have idfferent passports and can easily get visas to come to North America? In Australia, British Columbia, and Canada at large, "First Nations" people are gaining political power. In North and South America, first nations tribes have organized and are recruiting other tribes throughout BOTH continents to "join the Americas" into a hemispherical inter-continental congress.
      .

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
  • ocanada
    • 0
      ocanada  
    • jubal:

      I'm proud of the first nation movement and have played my small part in promoting it and had the great pleasure of speaking to Native American advocates and actors like Tantoo Cardinal.

    • 2 years ago
  • jubal
    • 0
      jubal  
    • jubal:

      @Plusaf, thank you for reminding us of the law of the jungle. The strong survive and the weak get their asses kicked. But let me remind you of another interesting phenomena. Many great civilizations have come and gone. Sumeria, Persia, Egypt, Rome, Greek, Ghengis Khan, Maya, Inca, Aztec, the list goes on and on. They all had their 15 minutes so to speak. And the current civilization will also fall one day, too. It is the way of things. The current empire may be all about extreme power and might through their weapons of mass destruction, their mind control and their bilogical agents with which they can unleash a catastrophe upon the human race in their pusuit of ultimate control and domination. But one day, those who are in control now will be in the minority, and I am not talking about Obama or his administration or the last administration. The United States, The United Nations, United Europe and even China, Japan, and Russia will all come to an end some day and what will be left is perhaps peopel who will have learned from the rollercoaster of empires that what people on this thread say is a Utopian dream, is the best and only way for the world to continue. Until that time, I am not going to sit by and just take it up the ass. No Thank You.

      I am going to speak out and share my ideas. Many people are on the First Nation's train, it already left the station. It has the potential to be big.

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
  • jubal
    • 0
      jubal  
    • jubal:

      Plusaf, I look at my grandparents who are all now dead. My grandmother from Ecuador, lived to 101, while her husband, my grandfather who died in Ecuador, was left there by my father and the rest of the family to die. He was a violent alcoholic. But he had made a big name for himself. He made it all the way to become a Supreme Court Justice. He was also a government minister prior to that and a lawyer. And yet, with all of his accomplishments, being a violent alcoholic caused his entire family of 10 children to leave Ecuador and come to America to make lives for themselves over 50 years ago.

      On the other hand, my grandparents on my mother's side. They didn't live past their 70's. They died from exposure to dozens of harmful chemicals that they were exposed to making bombs for the United States during the second world war. My grandfather worked on the Manhattan project and got injured in an explosion in a lab. He had to have steel rods grafted to both his legs because his bones were not capable of supporting his body weight. He walked with crutches. He taught me many things and told me stuff that he said was top secret. He had lost his faith in the United States because of the corruption he saw taking over the nation at all levels. He was angry at the VA because they had given him so many blood transfusions with mismatched blood that they couldn't match him correctly anymore. Both my grandparents on my mother's side gave their lives for this country and died horrible deaths.

      The Beautiful United States that you are remembering and thinking fondly of is gone.The American Dream has turned into a nightmare and all of us, at least the people I know and support locally and some here on this venue, just want the nightmare to end and for us to wake up and find oursleves in a safe place to exsist.

      What I do know is that in America 50 years ago, there was hope and brotherly love. In the America of today there is hate and fear and terror....and its not all caused by Muslims from the desert of Arabia. There is real terror in Washington and on Wall Street.

      All of us, the immigrants who came here 50 years ago and the immigrants who came here 100 years ago who at one time or another were hated for their ethnicity have allowed ourselves to be manipulated and beaten down so that we dont' stand up for what is right. We just ask to be left alone to live in peace in our homes. But even that is being threatened.

      This country may have started out as the Shimmering City of Hope, but it has become the Godzilla of the world. Personally I thing its too late to rescue her from those who have raped and pillaged her. That is why I have decided to support the First Nations and their movement. Once Godzilla has run out of steam, they will be there to pick up the pieces and reintroduce the survivors to the old ways of living with the land and nature in harmony.

    • 2 years ago
  • jubal
    • 0
      jubal  
    • jubal:

      Plusaf, I look at my grandparents who are all now dead. My grandmother from Ecuador, lived to 101, while her husband, my grandfather who died in Ecuador, was left there by my father and the rest of the family to die. He was a violent alcoholic. But he had made a big name for himself. He made it all the way to become a Supreme Court Justice. He was also a government minister prior to that and a lawyer. And yet, with all of his accomplishments, being a violent alcoholic caused his entire family of 10 children to leave Ecuador and come to America to make lives for themselves over 50 years ago.

      On the other hand, my grandparents on my mother's side. They didn't live past their 70's. They died from exposure to dozens of harmful chemicals that they were exposed to making bombs for the United States during the second world war. My grandfather worked on the Manhattan project and got injured in an explosion in a lab. He had to have steel rods grafted to both his legs because his bones were not capable of supporting his body weight. He walked with crutches. He taught me many things and told me stuff that he said was top secret. He had lost his faith in the United States because of the corruption he saw taking over the nation at all levels. He was angry at the VA because they had given him so many blood transfusions with mismatched blood that they couldn't match him correctly anymore. Both my grandparents on my mother's side gave their lives for this country and died horrible deaths.

    • 2 years ago
  • jubal
    • 0
      jubal  
    • How is having a child here any different than getting married to get citizenship? I think this is a very good question to ask at this point. What, if anything, should be done about marriages for citizenship or having children with an American parent? Should the mother be deported while the father and the baby stay here?

    • 2 years ago
  • mjsmith11
    • 0
      mjsmith11  
    • We have too many people here in the USA illegally as it is. The people who commit crimes are not the victims. The people who suffer from the crimes are the victims.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
  • JohnA
    • 0
      JohnA  
    • Has anyone seen the unemployment rates lately? We don't have enough jobs for ourselves. That's not racism, that's common sense!

    • 2 years ago
  • lifestudentno83
    • 0
      lifestudentno83  
    • JohnA:

      That's more to the fault of outsourcing labor and manufacturing jobs overseas than the influx of illegal immigrants.

      Immigrants usually do the jobs that Americans do not want to do themselves.

    • 2 years ago
  • JohnA
    • 0
      JohnA  
    • JohnA:

      That is globalist, one world government, bullshit. There are no jobs Americans won't do to feed their families. My Grandfather was a migrant farmer during the Great Depression, people did whatever it took to keep their families safe and fed. Don't give me that "jobs Americans won't do" crap, it's a lie.

    • 2 years ago
  • ocanada
    • 0
      ocanada  
    • JohnA:

      That is utter bullshit. They are jobs people want a living wage for not jobs they would not do. For illeagals the job provides a living wage back home through remitences while our families starve or go on the unemployment line. Illegals depress the wages across the spectrum and damage the economy as a result while sending more than 20 billion dollars in remittences back to Mexico. Do you know what else is about 20 billion back to Mexico? Drug trafficking.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • First, your comment " In Houston (and I want justifications for these actions) there are several illegals that steal and murder. Would these people have been stolen from or murdered had these people not been here in the first place? Most likely not."

      This happens in every city, state and country. Illegals were not the first ones to steal or murder people and they were not the last... if there are some bad apples, it's because it's in our human nature and society that we have this.

      I can also ask the same, why do white people rape and kidnap young girls? why do white people dress in a white robe and kill others, while hiding behind the robe? or why do blacks kill each other for a pair of sneakers? why J? could you answer me? Why does this country have the highest DUI cases in the world? and most of the people that cause these accidents are white folks? why J? or maybe you can answer this one, why did the white cop hit me in the face when I was 14, standing in front of my house because i couldn't go in, while my mom was cooking and I had friends with me... why would the cop hit me J? and then 4 hours later, because they "made a mistake" told 4 or 5 kids to go away and not be a menace. Why???

      I have reasons to hate, but I don't... i still love my Caucasians, my Latinos, Blacks and Asian people.

      So answer me those questions J, why so much hate in this country? why did a little white girl at the age of 12 get kidnapped by a white person and get molested for 8 yrs... why? I don't hear Latinos doing these type of horrific things, but i do hear about the bloods and crips, i do hear how people in the south (not all) have 3 to 4 wives... is that a family? or a man that needs to show his power over woman? I don't hear Latinos or Blacks having that many wives..

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
    • 0
      J_Jammer [removed]  
    • KSirys:

      You also don't hear serial killers that are black, asian or latino. Most are white. That is also true to who a serial killer kills. They mainly stay within their own race.

      The point isn't to blame anyone one race for a problem. The point is that they cause a problem and they aren't even citizens making it worse---because they shouldn't be here to begin with...

      Those that commit crimes that are citizens go to prison. fine. But those that are not citizens shouldn't get to go to prison. They should be deported and never allowed back if they committed something like rape or murder.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • KSirys:

      J, no one is arguing that point, that if an illegal commits a crime, they shouldn't be punish. No one here said and no one here thinks that ALL illegals are innocent. At the same time, you have stretched your comments to all illegals, that's the issue that You and I have.

      Not all illegals are the same, as well as, no all whites and blacks and every other race is or ever will be the same in their actions.

      Don't come here and say that all illegals are one thing and they all should be deported.

      Agree or Disagree?

      circle the word that reflects your best opinion!

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
  • J_Jammer
    • 0
      J_Jammer [removed]  
    • In Houston (and I want justifications for these actions) there are several illegals that steal and murder. Would these people have been stolen from or murdered had these people not been here in the first place?

      Most likely not.

      Why? Because Houston is fairly safe for many reasons. It has not been in the early 90's but that's not now.

      When Houston allowed New Orleans people to come in (illegals in a way because they don't legally belong here they just were allowed to stay out of the goodness of Houston's heart) crime skyrockted.

      When you get hit by an illegal in a car what happens? Your insurance has to pay for it because why? They don't have a DL or insurance. LUCKY day for you.

      They stand around in several areas around town waiting to be picked up. They bumrush you if you're in a van or truck because they automatically think you want their services. So you better not get gas at those stations unless you know how to say no a lot....over and over again.

      I understand that they want work. That is not the problem. The problem is that they cause unnecessary human traffic and an eyesore.

      Now this can be easily fixed by giving them specific areas they can stand to wait for an illegal job that they don't pay taxes on. That way they are not littered all around. Makes it easier for people to not feel crowed or threatened.

      There is an area called Spring Branch. It has its own School District. This District is made up of at least 90% hispanic children who have parents that are illegal. They get free food at school. They get free clothes. They get free school supplies.

      What do the kids get at the inner city schools in the poorer school district of Houston School District? NOTHING like that.

      They even have advocates and spanish speaking lines on business. They have different language forms. An entire COURT that is dedicated to them because they only speak spanish. Totally stealing from those that PAY TAXES for such services.

      Does Mexico have business that speak English as well? Do they have billboards that are only in English? Do they have court houses that are dedicated to just English speaking persons? How about forms that are only in English?

      I think that any State that borders Mexico should be taught Spanish as a second language in Elementary School. That way when one speaks to someone who is Mexican they can't avoid answering by stating they don't speak the language....because then we'd speak their language. They wouldn't like that that much. They like pretending they don't understand. It affords them a lot of ignorance.

      SOME...not all.

      I am not looking for them to be booted. I'm looking for them to pay their fair share. It's unfair that the government thinks it needs to raise taxes when it would be just fine if it got all the taxes that they asked for FROM EVERYONE.

      Respect and get respect. They do not respect enough to be afforded all what they get and take.

    • 2 years ago
  • lifestudentno83
    • 0
      lifestudentno83  
    • J_Jammer:

      Pilgrims didn't speak the native language well, but we all see how that turned out.

      Maybe Mexicans are still pissed we took Texas from then and are trying to reclaim it through massive immigration.

      Immigrants aren't the problem, true. This country flourished because of immigration. However, people are selective of the people who immigrate and how they get here. I'm sure the Pilgrims were never processed or had passports. The Spanish and African slaves did not have passports to America. They got here anyway.

      That, and human traffic wouldn't be an issue if the economy was in better shape. Mexicans and other South American residents have been immigrating here for decades, even centuries, but as soon as the economy dove south and jobs disappeared this became an issue. The immigrants did not steal jobs and do not cause a dramatic increase in crime. America has always had crime problems since the roaring 20's, but since the faces are colored it's become issues of race and immigration.

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
    • 0
      J_Jammer [removed]  
    • J_Jammer:

      I made valid points and you just gave me talking points that didn't address anything I stated.

      I am not a person that ignores anyone. So if you have something to address in my comments that's actually about my comments I'll read and reply. Right now you're just saying things a politicians says and that's not a rebuttal.

    • 2 years ago
  • eldiablo
    • 0
      eldiablo  
    • I believe it all brakes down to racism...think about how you view and consider someone you see to be an illegal resident. Some of you wouldn't really would admit it but that's why you hide behind your fancy words 'illegal' 'braking the law'. Do you really believe you want to destroy a family just because someone deiced to improve their lifes by coming to a country that would pay them 'ok' to clean or pick something up? Some of you lack morals and much as your European ancestors.Show the kindness that Native showed your ancestors.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • eldiablo:

      I didn't want to go as far as you just did, but people here don't like to talk about racism... like it doesn't exist.

      You should have read someone's comment a week ago, when we were talking about racism... thinking happy thoughts would make racism go away! lol..

    • 2 years ago
  • Mariana_GS
  • J_Jammer
    • 0
      J_Jammer [removed]  
    • eldiablo:

      I'll go further and state those that come from Mexico hate Mexico so much that they have to go to America.

      If they loved Mexico that's where they'd stay and change that country to the way they want.

      But because America is hospitable (because if it was not they wouldn't eve be allowed to stay at all....there would be sweeps and they'd be removed) they are allowed to stay.

      Good thing you ignore that factor.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • eldiablo:

      Sorry Mariana, but i have to disagree with you on this one. Whenever immigrants and other races are being contested, you can usually find a racist person behind the "reasons" why immigrants or other races shouldn't be here.

      I've met Asians, Blacks and even people from India, hating other races, but they keep that to themselves... they don't post it or comment on it.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • eldiablo:

      J, you know I love your comments and views! I also have you as a connection because i like what you put on the boards. And! because i'm part Japanese as well... but bro, how are you going to say that Mexicans hate Mexico so much that they move to this country because they hate it?? That makes no sense! I understand a few might not like the conditions of their country, but as a poor person, how do you expect them to change anything, when only the rich and the powerful are running the government?

      oh wait... the rich and the powerful running the country, that sounds like the US of A....

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
    • 0
      J_Jammer [removed]  
    • eldiablo:

      Mexico is controlled by the drug cartels is it not? That's what it seems like.

      America is ran by big business. All countries are ran by something that isn't the government in totality. It's nothing new.

      I pay my taxes....I pay a lot of taxes.

      How much do illegals pay other than sales tax? How is that fair? If they are so concerned about being part of America why do they not pay all the taxes even though they are not asked to because they really don't exist?

      Respect isn't what they have. They want it before they give it and that's not fair when they barged in here. Case by case bases is fine, but the brute and honest truth is that they pushed their way in and demanded things without giving anything.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • eldiablo:

      Again J, you're grouping all illegals as a whole, why? not all illegals are the same and I know many of them that pay their taxes to show the government one day that they did the right thing.

      I worked at a bank as a VP and noticed many illegals that wanted to buy houses, had Tax Returns... now, they didn't claim everything and let's be honest, I would have done the same!! but they paid TAXES!! because they want a house and a new life. So don't group all illegals as a whole...

      I paid 200k in taxes last year, not that my income was 200k and i paid a % of that, but $200,000 in taxes, who can say here right now, that if you were paying that much, wouldn't you find a way not to pay it all and save some???? any one?

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
  • jubal
  • J_Jammer
  • Guyatthebusstation
    • 0
      Guyatthebusstation  
    • Ok, I’ll propose a solution to our current problem.

      1.) Amnesty for all current illegal residents in the US
      1.b) for this time (5 years) get rid of ICE for the intent of finding current illegals
      1.c) Increase border security in the short term to protect against a big wave after news of amnesty leaks.

      2.) Charge a high amnesty fee of 4-7 thousand dollars per individual. (in which time they would be put on the nationalization list.)
      2.b) Allow an alternate higher tax bracket for anyone who doesn’t have the funds up front (when they have paid said fee, they to can join the nationalization list.)
      2.c) use the new funds and ear mark the higher taxes to fund the nationalization program, hopefully allowing them to handle the increased demand for nationalization.

      3.) Deport any “new” legal immigrant who commits a gross misdemeanor or felony in the first 5 years after amnesty (After they serve their sentence, which would also be paid for by the amnesty tax (ideally)

      4.) Fine any company 1 million dollars per illegal immigrant. (or at least enough to put any company who caters to illegal immigrants out of business on the first infraction)

      Now I’m going to get on by soap box,

      I hate the idea that we (as a country) should bend the rules to families that break the laws. Its BS to protect their families when they are willing to chance it themselves. I doubt these men and women don’t think about multiple outcomes when they chose to break a foreign countries law. I don’t think illegal immigrants will spend hundreds of dollars of fake documentation are naïve enough to think there are no consequences to their actions.

      I equate this to selling a sizable volume of marijuana. Most people wouldn’t say selling a qp of weed is a capitol offense. Most people won’t knock someone who is selling weed to save money for the better opportunities for them and their families. But if they were caught selling it to a federal agent, most wouldn’t give the guy a free pass, and most won’t justify them staying out of jail cause they were doing it for their family.

      Are weed laws unjust? Many would argue yes (especially on current) But the laws are on the books and everyone who sells weed knows there is a chance they could be caught and go to jail.

      If an individual finds a law to be unjust, they should break it if they want, but i don't care if you are unhappy with the consequences.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
  • FoosMaster
    • 0
      FoosMaster  
    • The problem is that they are considered citizens just because their illegal parents had them here. We are the only country in the world that allows this. Why? At the end of the Civil War the law was created as a way to make all slaves US citizens so that they could not be deported. Not sure why it is still used.
      If their illegal parents are deported they should be allowed to take their children with them unless they just don't want their children. When the kids get old enough they can leave their parents and come back to America if they wish or they can denounce their citizenship if they wish. The parents are Illegals and should be treated as such.

    • 2 years ago
  • lifestudentno83
    • 0
      lifestudentno83  
    • So? They shouldn't have came here illegally.
      They should have just came here legally, like the Pilgrims:
      En masse and slaughter the natives.
      Then they wouldn't have to worry about deportation because they would become the "natives".

      But they didn't.
      By law, those children are Americans and deserve to be orphaned because they are too lazy to work.
      Tell them to get a job and buy their parents some documentation. Lazy children.

      [Only sarcasm, I swear.]

      BTW, how does one own the land when your flesh becomes dust and dirt once buried under the earth?
      Doesn't that mean the land owns you, since you return to it?

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
  • lifestudentno83
    • 0
      lifestudentno83  
    • lifestudentno83:

      I didn't say the Native Americans DIDN'T deserve it. Because they didn't.

      I suppose I should have mention the Spanish settlers that massacred the Natives of South America as well. How careless of me.

      I suppose you supported the Americans treatment of the Asian citizens during WWII as well? At least they didn't massacre and/or genocide those people...

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
  • lifestudentno83
    • 0
      lifestudentno83  
    • lifestudentno83:

      Maybe I'll get one of those shiny "M" pins and a grant to do nothing...

      I could milk the money from a bank account, sit around and comment on current.com all day...

      You must have a MENSA membership too, since you're always here...

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
  • J_Jammer
  • Mariana_GS
  • J_Jammer
    • 0
      J_Jammer [removed]  
    • J_Jammer:

      Then you best state that some are wrong for crossing the border illegally or where is your balance that you so state is necessary?

      I don't buy you believe that.

      You are stating things that sound witty and sweet but have not backed anything with any reason.

      I await the reason.

    • 2 years ago
  • Mariana_GS
    • 0
      Mariana_GS  
    • J_Jammer:

      I was refering to the balance between factual coldness and compassion, because these aren't rat labs you're dealing with, they're people. Said balance is what's necessary to be objective (at least as objective as one can be).

      Again, I really wasn't suggesting what you should do with these immigrants, I was just offering advice so that people wouldn't come about the subject so heartlessly.

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
    • 0
      J_Jammer [removed]  
    • J_Jammer:

      Yes they are human. There are 7 billion of them on this planet.

      It's important to have a heart. It is also important to remember that that is what some people use to fake their problems and to make people do as they want by pulling on said strings.

      Trusting the heart on these matters isn't always wise. It's what causes more problems than heals.

    • 2 years ago
  • Katherine_Miranda
    • 0
      Katherine_Miranda  
    • You guys are ignorant. Dont Make Comments Unless You Can Personally Relate. My father got deported when I was 15 and those were some of the hardest times me & my brothers went through. So Screw ALL of You.

    • 2 years ago
  • JohnA
  • Guyatthebusstation
    • 0
      Guyatthebusstation  
    • Katherine_Miranda:

      Your comment is ignorant.

      You are pointing out the cost the family had to endure for a poor choice made by a criminal.

      I'm sure your father put some thought into his decision to enter the US illegally. He must have thought this could have been one of several outcomes. Does a bad outcome trump the laws?

      "No man is above the law and no man is below it: nor do we ask any man's permission when we ask him to obey it."

      Teddy Roosevelt

    • 2 years ago
  • jubal
    • 0
      jubal  
    • Katherine_Miranda:

      Katherine_Miranda, don't listen to these numbskulls. They have had cushy lives and don't know what suffering is.

      You have my compassion and the compassion of Millions upon Millions of the other oppressed people in this country.

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
  • samthesixth
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • I guess everyone here that's posting a comment on why Illegal immigration is wrong, must be Native American....

      Last time I checked, they are the only ones that can complain... but I guess everyone is...

    • 2 years ago
  • JohnA
  • KSirys
  • J_Jammer
    • 0
      J_Jammer [removed]  
    • KSirys:

      Native Americans are not the owners of this land. According to a well renown scholar Indians did not OWN land. They didn't OWN anything. So the land was never theirs to begin with because they didn't want to own it.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • KSirys:

      That sounds great J, so I guess he was around when the Europeans came to this country and took their land? or maybe he was around when Texas, California and New Mexico were taken from the Mexicans and now it's part of the US of A??

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
    • 0
      J_Jammer [removed]  
    • KSirys:

      Mexico was owned by Spain before they gained their what? Independence? So what they owned was not theirs...it was Spain's.

      If we are really going to do this....Mexico doesn't exist as their OWN country.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • KSirys:

      You really want to get into this? Because last time I checked, Mexico wasn't owned by anyone until it was invaded by the Spaniards... so YES, they did OWN Mexico and other parts of North America... again, do you want to start this?

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
    • 0
      J_Jammer [removed]  
    • KSirys:

      If that were true they'd have their own language. Instead they speak Spanish which is derived from the word Spain. Speaking Mexican is more like a derogatory term or a funny term depending on your context and who your friends are.

      Spain colonized Mexico therefore their people were placed there totally taking over. Just like Britain Colonized America. So Mexico was formed where natives lived and they were pushed out so the Spaniards could live.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • KSirys:

      J, sometimes you start right and then fuck it up along the way. Mexicans do speak spanish but their language was called Tetikilhati and many others but was taken away because the Spaniards and their guns, took it from them. They colonize the land and made spanish the main language Latinos speak today. That's the only reason why, we (as in Latinos) speak that language, not because it was given to us, by the holy grace of the spaniards!

      Stop trying my brother! You're not even close on this one!!

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
    • 0
      J_Jammer [removed]  
    • KSirys:

      I don't Mexico's history as well as you.

      That was not the point. No one owns the land they are on and doing this backwards in time thing isn't proving ANYTHING.

      Let the fact that Texas had their own Indians before the little river hoppers came on over? Yes or no?

      They don't own land so what does it matter?

      Shouldn't Mexico be one of the better countries since it's been around the longest? What happened there? Isn't it Mexico that totally shuts down it's souther border making it really difficult to pass through?

    • 2 years ago
  • CalPal
    • 0
      CalPal  
    • KSirys:

      J_Jammer, you're right that Native Americans believe that no one should "own" the land; they believed it should be used fairly and equally amongst everyone without anyone having special rights to the land (correct me if I'm wrong)...

      However, the Europeans had a different concept of the land, due to hundreds of years of much more intense conflict and fear of what anarchy could lead to, and when they started building their cities and establishing laws of the land, not to mention wiping them all out because they weren't loyal to their respective nation, the Natives believed that their right to the land was being taken away.

      What happened to the native americans has been unfair since the first encounter, and with issues like this news story, it's now being unfair for people who want to come into a nation taken away from the original occupiers who want to, apparently, keep others out.

      Absolute BS, IMO.

    • 2 years ago
  • Mariana_GS
    • 0
      Mariana_GS  
    • KSirys:

      "If that were true they'd have their own language. Instead they speak Spanish which is derived from the word Spain."

      We don't have our ORIGINAL languages in Latin America because Spaniards came, impaled our men, raped our women and erased all traces of original culture.

      "So Mexico was formed where natives lived and they were pushed out so the Spaniards could live."

      I understand you're trying to look at this emotionlessly, and that's generally a good thing when you study history, but now you're just separating the scientific facts from the social and cultural consequences, and there's the difference between being objective being robotically uncompasssionate. A good historian usually finds a balance, especially when they're not personally affected by the historical event and thus have no perspective (as is your case).

      In any case, this isn't what the thread is about...

    • 2 years ago
  • J_Jammer
  • Mariana_GS
    • 0
      Mariana_GS  
    • KSirys:

      "Rules change. Ownership of land change. You can't keep things the same."

      Don't you think that applies to the law as well?

      "If you can't respect the laws why should you get respect in return?"

      So African Americans in the early 20h century should've just rolled over and drooled?

      Man, you walked right into that one...

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
  • J_Jammer
    • 0
      J_Jammer [removed]  
    • KSirys:

      I know what I said and I knew you'd say something as predictable as that.

      But your last comment there....doesn't even address what I asked.

      Why should you get fair treatment when you can't respect the law?

      Bringing up black people as if Mexicans share the same plight is not only disrespectful, it's wrong.

      This time actually think before you post.

    • 2 years ago
1 - 100 of 170
more from Community:

top videos