Community | October 27, 2009 | 45 comments

"Is this haunting picture proof that chimps really DO grieve?" Incredible and so sad.

Image
lookatmypix
Look at this picture and judge for your self.



"United in what appears to be deep and profound grief, a phalanx of more than a dozen chimpanzees stood in silence watching from behind the wire of their enclosure as the body of one of their own was wheeled past.

This extraordinary scene took place recently at the Sanaga-Yong Chimpanzee Rescue Center in Cameroon, West Africa.
When a chimp called Dorothy, who was in her late 40s, died of heart failure, her fellow apes seemed to be stricken by sorrow."
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-1223227/Is-haunting-picture-proof...
  1. groups:
    Community,   Green,   Current Tonight,   Animal Rights,   2 more
  2. tags:
    News Green Current TV Journalism 6 more
  3. recommended by:
    Vierotchka
  4.     
    |

45 comments // "Is this haunting picture proof that chimps really DO grieve?" Incredible and so sad.

  • loupetho
    • 0
      loupetho  
    • We're all mammals, why wouldn't we share emotions. On my sister's farm a lone donkey has become the patriarch of half-a-dozen cows.

      I also once looked after a young tree-kangaroo (yes, a kangaroo that lives in trees) for a few months. When I took in an injured wallaby and spent less time with her, she was definitely jealous (there is video proof).

      So why not grieve as well. There's footage around of elephants regularly going back to where a friend died and gently stroking the remaining bones. It's really touching.

    • 2 years ago
  • Chique
    • 0
      Chique  
    • The animal shall not be measured by man. In a world older and more complete than ours, they move finished and complete, gifted with extension of the senses we have lost or never attained, living by voices we shall never hear. They are not brethren; they are not underlings; they are other nations, caught with ourselves in the net of life and time, fellow prisoners of the splendor and travail of the earth.- Beston

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • Dammm, i can't stop being so emotional when I see things like this happen. All of the sudden, i start tearing and my dogs come by and start licking my face... like they know i'm sad...

      Thank you for the post Pix! I'm glad this type of information is being put out there for people to see that nonhuman beings are not stupid or dumb. Most of the time, they are more intelligent then us, dumb people!!

    • 2 years ago
  • cabinettags
    • 0
      cabinettags  
    • We humans are the way we are. A lot of our behavior was originally mandated by the conditions we found ourselves in. Man was a hunter/gatherer before he learned to farm.

      As we progress, we change. But there is a lot of variety in humans. Some change slowly or not at all. So our progress isn't an even move forward; rather a constant bootstrap effort to catch the slow ones up. When you combine that with the regional differences of how folks look at things, it's hard to say we're progressing save in the most general terms.

      Animals have been a commodity that humans have used since day 1. It's only been in recent history that we've begun to view animals as living beings worthy of consideration. Previously we view them as just to be used. Hell, we spent a period of time capturing and selling humans. Humans aren't inherently bad and cruel, but that's not say we're always cool. We're not.

      There will always be those among us that take advantage of others. This is especially easy when those "others" can't defend themselves or complain about it. Doesn't do any good to complain about us. We've always been this way. But let's give credit where credit is due. ALL of us don't feel this way about animals anymore. So we're getting there. At our typical crawl.

    • 2 years ago
  • Prijedor
  • LadybugLady
  • Vierotchka
  • PajamaDan
    • 0
      PajamaDan  
    • Ummm,... of course! How self-righteous and ignorant are those who honestly believe that no OTHER animal can have the mental and emotional capabilities we have?!?!?!?! They think, they feel, they are aware, they love, they hate, they get angered, they communicate. And chimps, our closest relative, are extraordinary sentient beings with vast mental capabilities. Imagine what lies in their evolutionary future,... if they have the chance.
      It's just sad that humans haven't figured out to preserve what's left on this planet,... for the individual's sake, and for Earth's sake.

    • 2 years ago
  • idealist
    • 0
      idealist  
    • i hate it when people presume that chimps are just dumb animals.
      the book "next of kin" is all about chimps that can sign language and express how they feel.
      haunting and true these things make me despise most of the human race.

    • 2 years ago
  • michail77
    • 0
      michail77  
    • It would be silly to think that humans evolved emotions, feeling and cognitive abilities that don't exist in our animal relative. Also, chimps can do bad things, just as people do.

    • 2 years ago
  • keithponder
  • thewallisgirl
  • DougChristian
    • 0
      DougChristian  
    • keithponder:

      Stupid thought. How is this recommended? You think humans don't have sincere emotions? For Christ's sake.

      Maybe if you put "ALL" in front of that, then you'd have an interesting theory about humans being the only ones capable of deceit. But that would still be unsubstantiated.

      And someone's talking about killing people who kill animals for meat up above. Did you ever think those people are just trying to survive and don't have the luxury of thinking about animals the way you do?

      God I hate Current sometimes.

      I'm all for understanding and protecting our fellow animals, but you extremists do more harm than good to these causes.

    • 2 years ago
  • Chique
    • 0
      Chique  
    • keithponder:

      Doug, I think you're taking that comment out of context - - it's inferred that he means "unlike humans can be". And I don't see anything posted here suggesting that anyone condones or even suggested killing humans who kill animals. Maybe you misread something? If you hate Current sometimes because you don't agree with something you may be setting yourself up for a lot of disappointment since almost every thread has opposing view points. To me, that's the beauty of Current. Sometimes we even change our points of view by being open enough to look at it from a different perspective. Even if we don't, it makes us think.

    • 2 years ago
  • DougChristian
    • 0
      DougChristian  
    • keithponder:

      Read Wessagusset_Oracle's second paragraph and tell me how I misinterpreted it.

      I don't mind opposing views. I like debate. I hate Current sometimes because the views I agree with are often expressed in the extreme and often ineloquently.

      That bothers me because it feeds into liberal stereotypes, justifies the ridiculous libertarian point of view that liberals and conservatives are the same and shuts independent minds down to considering these issues.

    • 2 years ago
  • Chique
    • 0
      Chique  
    • keithponder:

      Okay, I see your point. I assumed he meant arrest them, stop them but I'll let him speak for himself. Liberals, conservatives and independents all can have different viewpoints and individuals can be viewed as ridiculous at times depending on how a topic is perceived.

    • 2 years ago
  • Wessagusset_Oracle
    • 0
      Wessagusset_Oracle  
    • keithponder:

      dougy, you have to ask, WHY do these people need to kill wild animals? of course they don't have the luxury of other choices, if there was LESS of them, there would be no problems. that's why birth control, education, and yes, abortions are a must, to RESTORE sustainability and equilibrium to this planet. and they have no food cause there are no "food" factories, or land don't grow shit...many factors, their governments suck most likely.

      it kinda comes down to this dougy, i don't want future generations to miss out on certain animal species, because they were all eaten, because YOUR cousin decided to have 10 kids and couldn't keep her legs closed and/or was uneducated in life. that's what it comes down to. it's supply and demand, the SUPPLY of humans is astronomical...and the supply of certain species is growing small. out of equilibrium. in 50 years, i want to see chimps when i go to africa, and not humans running around with AK-47s, get it? yes, chimps are more VALUABLE to society and this planet. if you disagree, then you're a spiciest!

    • 2 years ago
  • Wessagusset_Oracle
    • 0
      Wessagusset_Oracle  
    • my dear fellow good humans, who there are less then bad people.

      i say we form a worldwide militia force, and rescue animals, protect poached ones, and find and terminate humans who abuse, enslave, and kill animals. and as anti-meat as I am, animals on farms would be exempt, as long as treated humanely and put down so also.

      it makes me sad and disgusted for eternity to know that we humans cut shark fins off just for soup then throw the corpses into the water, that bulls and dogs are used for games and human pleasure, that we hunt and kill monkeys and gorillas in africa (due to overpopulation of damn humans), and that cats and dogs are murdered and eaten in asia.

      we humans are simply disgusting...there is no god. and i wish captain planet was a real fucker, so he's keep things in check. we humans are the only ones that cause all these problems, and can stop them.

    • 2 years ago
  • Vierotchka
  • Wessagusset_Oracle
    • 0
      Wessagusset_Oracle  
    • Wessagusset_Oracle:

      perhaps, but if there were less mouths to feed, then there would be no demand for more food, hence over population.
      but you bring up an important point, obviously africa is an inefficient place in terms of production of goods and services as well as corruption as you say.

    • 2 years ago
  • DougChristian
  • Chique
  • Wessagusset_Oracle
    • 0
      Wessagusset_Oracle  
    • Image
    • Wessagusset_Oracle:

      oh christian doug, you must live in assumption-ville and in ignorance county.

      that's exactly right dougy, eliminate immoral, disgusting, selfish, greedy, murderous, ignorant, and delusional humans; but a HUGE part of it would be to educate people on "equilibrium" topics, for example, if you get shushi - the hot thing to do now, know that you're supporting overfishing and extinction, not exactly what you think of when getting shushi, but it should be. so you support murder, slavery, animal abuse, pollution, and selfishness i take it? these things that "I" don't approve of huh? i assume most people are good humans (i assume you are), and are just mislead, misunderstand, and under/un-educated. so people deserve a chance, but if you support and immoral and destructive activities, and are proud of it, then say hello to my little friend, game over. degenerates, bottom feeders, rejects, and those who hurt society and this planet are to be purged.

      http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2008/01/11/60minutes/main3700644.shtml

      i'm simply stating that we humans do too many things that put this planet out of equilibrium, and the source of this is overpopulation and corrupt culture and traditions. perhaps these topics are too complex for you, i don't know.

      hey, so you're a christian, or is that just your last name given to ya? cause that would be the icing on the cake.

      and by the way, you DON'T get a vote, this isn't survivor. i hope you understand and don't hate. i know, i'm extreme (but this reflects [like ying yang] how extreme our species has become in everything we do), i represent the truth and nature's equilibrium, NOTHING is stronger.

      cheers!

    • 2 years ago
  • DougChristian
    • 0
      DougChristian  
    • Wessagusset_Oracle:

      Hahaha. My name is ironic and intended to throw off the simple-minded. It distinguishes free thinkers from, well, people like you Wes.

      Come on Chique, read his response. Translation of his response: "Stop making assumptions. But yes, that's exactly what I'm suggesting."

      Stop defending this nonsense. This is what allows people to just write off causes like this by saying that the far left is just as evil as the far right. When it comes to people like Wes, they are correct.

      You claim to be a "good" person, but listen to the hate you're expressing. You're a monster Wes.

      If you do not care about the plight of animals and are just trying to undermine liberal causes, then keep it up, you're doing an excellent job. If you actually do care, then stop expressing your twisted thoughts. You're not helping.

    • 2 years ago
  • Chique
    • 0
      Chique  
    • Wessagusset_Oracle:

      Actually, I wish both of you would stop. When you call someone a psycho and make an assumption expect a backlash. When the backlash is over the top expect it to accelerate. How about we keep the anger and name calling out of it and just tell us where you stand on the issues guys? This is an emotional topic anyway and if you're trying to get someone to see your point of view, insulting them usually doesn't have great results. Peace.

    • 2 years ago
  • DougChristian
    • 0
      DougChristian  
    • Wessagusset_Oracle:

      What assumption? He said we should kill people who don't treat animals right. I pointed that out, perhaps in a dickish way, but he had his chance to retract.

      Normally, I'd agree with you, but I don't really care to get him to see another point of view. I don't believe that's possible. I've seen enough extremists and I've never seen one respond to reason. In my experience, it's better to poke them and let them flip out and show their true colors.

      I just want YOU to stop defending extremism because you're a higher level user and should operate on a higher standard.

    • 2 years ago
  • Chique
  • Wessagusset_Oracle
    • 0
      Wessagusset_Oracle  
    • Wessagusset_Oracle:

      Dougy:

      we live in an extreme world, so your fake "lables" of extremist, leftist agenda, the far right...dude, slap yourself, really, you're talking generic rubbish!

      I have NO AGENDA, left or right, perhaps you didn't read my posts, i represent the truth and eqalibrium. i don't think you understand and are even worthy of my time and wisdom, people like you why i don't post on current, because 95% of people on here and in this world simply aren't intelligent and/or evolved enough, but it's not their fault, they were born with a certain IQ and awareness of things. i just wish they would all shut their stupid repeating generic mouths and learn to listen instead of talking nonsense all their miserable lives.

      and by the way dougy, i am on the highest standard, i do bring fury to those who disrespect evidence, fairness, justice, equality, and equilibrium. i'm all done here.

      BTW - what is the OPPOSITE point of view (i consider all points of view), that it's ok to murder animals until they are extinct, just so we can feed a few more assholes? you're part of the problem if you think that. honestly you could be a cool cat, i don't know, i'm not here to crucify you, but your logic and motives are weak and shameful. and i never flipped out, i stated the facts in pure form and left you in the dust, you have nothing to say, but to label me as a monster, that was the best think you've said on here, thank you. that's all folks.

    • 2 years ago
  • blaino
    • 0
      blaino  
    • Its amazing how much of ourselves we see in other species of animal.

      It helps to break down the notion that we are superior beings.

      We are all equal on this planet.

    • 2 years ago
  • Manatee_man
  • cabinettags
  • Chique
    • 0
      Chique  
    • Vierotchka is right, this is true not only for our domesticated animals but for most species. I remember an article in National Geo years ago discussing various animals and whether they are parroting or communicating. In one instance a parrot owner (no pun intended) was leaving his long time vocal pet at the vet's overnight and had never left him before. The parrot turned to him as he was leaving and formulated words in a series never used before to tell him (paraphrasing) "don't go, scared". We need to show compassion for the animals we share the planet with and not assume we're more entitled to be here than them.

    • 2 years ago
  • lookatmypix
  • Chique
  • Vierotchka
    • 0
      Vierotchka  
    • There are countless stories of dogs grieving for their dead masters - I recall at least two stories in which the grieving dogs lay down on the grave of their dead owner and let themselves die.

    • 2 years ago
  • annabell
    • 0
      annabell  
    • Vierotchka:

      I grew up with 2 boxers, they were 6 months apart and spent every moment together. The male died at age 11 and our female died soon after, about 3 months. She stopped eating and constantly searched the house and yard for him. She couldn't stand being without him. It broke my heart to see her that way.

      There has been plenty of documentation of not only domesticated animals, but wil animals showing signs of emotion. It's crazy to think that ALL mammals do not have emotion, it's impossible.

    • 2 years ago
  • Vierotchka
    • 0
      Vierotchka  
    • Of course they grieve. Many mammals grieve. Some of my cats have grieved upon the death of another to whom they were very close - they went into depression for a while after searching and calling out in vain for the dead ones, and stopped eating for a few days.

    • 2 years ago
  • Chique
    • 0
      Chique  
    • I'm way to sensitive to the plight of animals to watch these videos, they'll haunt me for days. But applaud you for bringing their suffering to light. I believe we're supposed to live in harmony with all wildlife. It's been proven time and again that most animals have the same emotions as humans but just can't speak or defend themselves. Truly heartbreaking.

    • 2 years ago
  • lookatmypix
  • lookatmypix
  • lookatmypix
    • 0
      lookatmypix  
    • TAKE ACTION:

      http://www.janegoodall.org/stop-illegal-commercial-bushmeat-trade

      "I am outraged by the killing of chimpanzees and other imperiled wildlife species for the commercial bushmeat trade—a shortsighted and cruel practice that is pushing great apes and other endangered species to the brink of extinction.

      As your constituent, I strongly urge you to support legislation to discourage the bushmeat trade and other destructive activities—like irresponsible logging and mining practices—that contribute to it."

    • 2 years ago
  • lookatmypix
more from Community:

top videos