The Top One Reason Religion Is Harmful
source: http://www.alternet.org/belief/143912/the_top_one_reason_religion_is_harmful_?page=entire
-
-
- WakeUpPeople
- added this
I've argued many times that religion is not only mistaken, but does more harm than good. But why do I think that is?
Sure, I can make a list of specific harms religion has done, from here to Texas. I've done exactly that. But that's not enough to make my case. I could make long lists of harms done by plenty of human institutions: medicine, education, democracy. That doesn't make them inherently malevolent.
Why is religion special -- and specially troubling? What makes religion different from any other ideology, community, system of morality, hypothesis about how the world works? And why does that difference makes it uniquely prone to cause damage?
The debates about religion usually come in two types: "is religion accurate or mistaken," and "is religion helpful or harmful." And ever since I put together my best "mistaken" arguments, my Top Ten Reasons I Don't Believe in God, I've been trying to wrap up my "harmful" arguments in a similar nutshell.
But I'm realizing that I don't have ten arguments for why religion is harmful. I don't even have 57,842 arguments.
I have one.
I'm realizing that everything I've ever written about religion's harm boils down to one thing.
It's this: Religion is ultimately dependent on belief in invisible beings, inaudible voices, intangible entities, undetectable forces, and events and judgments that happen after we die.
It therefore has no reality check.
And it is therefore uniquely armored against criticism, questioning, and self- correction. It is uniquely armored against anything that might stop it from spinning into extreme absurdity, extreme denial of reality ... and extreme, grotesque immorality.
much more at link....
http://www.alternet.org/belief/143912/the_top_one_reason_religion_is_harmful_?pa...
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Thoughts? Agree, Disagree? Any flaws in the logic? Does logic even matter?
-
- groups:
- Community, Current Tonight, Progressive America, Religion, 3 more
-
-
CarolineS
-
onechance:
I hear u sister!
- 2 years ago
-
CarolineS
-
-
opit
-
Religions can cause divisions within families. What is interesting is how they deal with it. Either people grow to appreciate that people are entitled to their opinions...or they go nuts.
I claim to 'believe in God'...not a problem when all I have said is that the world seems to have an underlying pattern which responds to our input.
Past that...all bets are off.
That's what I call fundamentalist : not stretching ideas past the basics. - 2 years ago
-
opit
-
-
grape
-
everybody blames religion. religions are ideas and ideas alone.
people formulate the ideas. people interpret the ideas. people act on the ideas. people enforce the ideas. the real reason ideas or religions are dangerous is because people (our silly human race) are dangerous. - 2 years ago
-
grape
-
-
booksellergirl
-
grape:
I agree.
- 2 years ago
-
booksellergirl
-
-
CarolineS
-
grape:
I agree too, but we are all born a blank slate, with no hate or prejudice. But it's the institutions that have been built up around us -like religion- that create tensions and make us hate and in turn can make us kill.
- 2 years ago
-
CarolineS
-
-
grape
-
grape:
if you believe that then you must really be critical of parents, public education, and sports programs.
- 2 years ago
-
grape
-
-
CarolineS
-
grape:
yes i am critical of parents and especially public education(the same kind that left out the attrocities of the british empire and the real reason for the black slave trade in history lessons when i was at school)
- 2 years ago
-
CarolineS
-
-
grape
-
grape:
i see what you are saying but...
with regards to everyone beginning as a blank slate this is true. but the blank slates arent put into the same socio-economic classes. one blank slate can have a 15 yr old, uneducated, single mother and another blank slate can be born into a more optimal family setting. i see way more hatred and violence between people because of poverty and the growing gap between rich and poor. if i had the choice, i'd end world poverty over world religion.
if a guy says he killed a guy cuz his god told him to do it are you going to blame the god?
if obama said tomorrow that people over the age of 19 and under the age of 35 should jump off of a tall building and they do are you going to blame the gov't? i'd blame it on stupidity. - 2 years ago
-
grape
-
-
booksellergirl
-
The danger in your point is that it is as intolerant as the "religions" you feel are so harmful. People should be able to believe what they want. "Live and let live" is my attitude and "whatever gets you though the night" as John Lennon said. The problem with people who espouse religion and those that condemn it is that they BOTH feel the need to evangelize their point of view. Sometimes people just don't want to hear it. Sometime folks just want to be left alone to decide for themselves how they want to live. Whether someone chooses to practice a specific religion, or chooses to be agnostic, or an atheist, that is their own business. We really don't need a know-it-all or a holier-than-thou to look down from on high to tell us that what we believe or don't believe is stupid or wrong.
- 2 years ago
-
booksellergirl
-
-
IngloriousBitch [removed]
-
booksellergirl:
xxxooo you are so right!
- 2 years ago
-
IngloriousBitch [removed]
-
-
grape
-
booksellergirl:
so true...the exact same could be said for political discussions.
- 2 years ago
-
grape
-
-
dusty_red_rivet_head
-
I agree with you, and also with hayden_augustus as well. It's tough being an atheist in the south. My own mother doesn't accept me as an atheist. Anything that has no reality check and divides families is a terrible thing.
- 2 years ago
-
dusty_red_rivet_head
-
-
CarolineS
-
I agree 100%, as child i had too many questions that religion could not answer, you know the usual "if god loves us then why doesn't he stop wars"? "if god loves us so much and can do anything he wants then why do so many people die of starvation everyday"? then there's the big one "if god is real then why do so many catholic priests abuse kids, what does god think of that?" if i was to leave my thoughts down to religion, i would be an extremely small narrow minded individual, to me religion is another controlling institution that separates us as humans, and that we dont need.
There's a quote by someone whom i forget the name.
"religion is regarded by the common as true, by the wise as false, and by the rulers as useful" - 2 years ago
-
CarolineS
-
-
Ares
-
CarolineS:
This is a fundamental fallacy that has always fascinated me among atheists' logic. You are quick to dismiss religion because the sermon on Sunday doesn't tell you why war exists, yet you readily rationalize your dismissal of faith because you are being logical and asking questions about the organization.
Do you not see that there is a Catch-22 there? You are completely unwilling to put forth the effort to learn more about God and religion, and perfectly content to step back and say that none of it is real, and that this is "reality," simply because it's right in front of your fucking face. Put in the work to develop a relationship with God, and you just might catch yourself more fully considering the flaws and triumphs of atheist "logic."
- 2 years ago
-
Ares
-
-
onechance
-
CarolineS:
@ Ares: MORE angry religious fanaticism... Par for the course I suppose.
- 2 years ago
-
onechance
-
-
CarolineS
-
CarolineS:
Ares, i know why war exists, i dont need a sermon to tell me that. And just because i choose to live in the reality that is right in front of my 'fucking face' (nice choice of words u prick!) does not mean i like it, there are aspects of this world i despise.
I know about god, i know quite a bit about a few religions actually, I just mentally can't take them in, i can't even watch sermon's on TV as my reasoning takes over my head and alls i see is lies and faults (a bit like looking at the government)
and instead of allowing god or jesus to show me the way, i would rather find it out by myself, I do my own research and i know my own truths. I don't go on ones that have been passed down through thousands of years and have been conveniantly edited by anyone. oh and last but not least, i am an agnostic. - 2 years ago
-
CarolineS
-
-
ii386
-
CarolineS:
Ares is assuming that people of no faith are ignorant about the concepts of religion and have never attempted to be religious. I know I went to catholic school for 9 years, sunday school, kairos spiritual vacation, church on sundays, etc. Don't you dare try to dismiss disagreement with your faith *which you cannot backup with any sort of evidence besides your own faith* by saying that we just haven't tried and don't know enough. I could easily counterclaim that you know just enough to keep you catatonic and mindless enough to believe in religion and yet have not delved into the history and creation of those institutions--the writers, selection, and compilation of the bible, the similarities/plagiarism of other ancient religions, and so on.
I fail to see any logic in faith...it is the antithesis of logic.
- 2 years ago
-
ii386
-
-
JulianCommongold
-
CarolineS:
Ares
I will tell you why war exists.RELIGION !!!
Plain and simple my man.
No illusions there at all. - 2 years ago
-
JulianCommongold
-
-
Ares
-
CarolineS:
"Ares is assuming that people of no faith are ignorant about the concepts of religion and have never attempted to be religious."
False. I'm claiming that people without faith never put forth adequate effort to understand faith, and are content with saying "screw it, I'm atheist," instead of actually trying to achieve any higher understanding.
The only cause of war is religion? Really? What about the Spanish-American War? Or the Civil War? Or the Vietnam War? Or WWI?
- 2 years ago
-
Ares
-
-
ii386
-
CarolineS:
Once again, you are claiming that people are ignorant and not as enlightened as you are. They simply "haven't put the effort in to understand." What a load of crap. There is no higher understanding of faith. Don't act like you've got something that other people wish they had cause you have nothing but fairy tales in your head. Glad you have confidence in it, but don't say that other people are wrong because they haven't put in the effort and come to the same conclusion that you have. Many people, and myself included as stated above, have put in many years into trying to develope some relationship. People see things differently and it surprises me that you are so steadfast in something with such a shaky foundation from the start. The bible is the base of christianity. Take a history of western civilization class, or bible study classes for 9 years, or survey of world religions. You'll see why the bible is so lacking in credibility.
- 2 years ago
-
ii386
-
-
jubal
-
CarolineS:
Morality is never rational.
- 2 years ago
-
jubal
-
-
Ares
-
"Religion is ultimately dependent on belief in invisible beings, inaudible voices, intangible entities, undetectable forces, and events and judgments that happen after we die.
It therefore has no reality check."
Death is the reality check, and it drives you up the wall because you can't prove what happens when we die. Deal with it.
I'm sorry that for whatever reason you don't have a relationship with God or a Pastor, or either one; but I do, and I'm tired of being made out to be inferior to people like you because of it. This is what makes people hate atheists.
- 2 years ago
-
Ares
-
-
onechance
-
Ares:
Is it "religious" to HATE?
- 2 years ago
-
onechance
-
-
CarolineS
-
Ares:
I think it is religious to hate, definatly. and it's also catholic to abuse kids!
- 2 years ago
-
CarolineS
-
-
unimatrix0
-
Ares:
Sometimes the truth hurts. Your Pastor is a con man and you have been conned. Don't let your fear of death drive you to absurd irrationalities. You are smarter than that, Ares.
Let go of ignorance and superstition. - 2 years ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
Weepowopo
-
Ares:
Those rebuttal post made me laugh so hard.
On topic:
I love how Ares does most of the work for me by contradicting himself.
"you can't prove what happens when we die"
Yet you argue for, live life based on, and make decisions based on a theology that say it does.
Too easy.
- 2 years ago
-
Weepowopo
-
-
H3ADLINE
-
Ares:
"You can't prove what happens when we die. Deal with it." You're right. There is no evidence that anything happens after we die, aside from decomposition, and claims of non-physical immortality have no way of being proven. Death, as far as we can tell, is final. It's something we all have to come to terms with, and wishful thinking about surviving your own death is counterproductive to that end. Like you said: deal with it.
- 2 years ago
-
H3ADLINE
-
-
Ares
-
Ares:
"Sometimes the truth hurts. Your Pastor is a con man and you have been conned. Don't let your fear of death drive you to absurd irrationalities. You are smarter than that, Ares.
Let go of ignorance and superstition."You seem laughably confident of yourself, given that you have just as much evidence as I do. Let go of superstition indeed.
- 2 years ago
-
Ares
-
-
H3ADLINE
-
You're precisely right on this point. Religion's immunity from reality lends itself to insanity.
- 2 years ago
-
H3ADLINE
-
-
grape
-
H3ADLINE:
very well put. i would submit tho that religion is and has always been just an idea. so the one real reason religion is harmful is cuz there is a silly human race trying to interpret it.
- 2 years ago
-
grape
-
-
neocongo
-
I think religion is harmful because it is based in "belief" rather than fact, and people become much more irrational and potentially harmful in the name of belief than in the name of fact. To question someone's facts is typically a small thing, but to question one's beliefs can be a very large thing indeed. I believe this to be true because beliefs are so strongly tied to passion, and facts are tied to evidence, or more facts.
- 2 years ago
-
neocongo
-
-
carmalite
-
Interesting. I think that the majority of all Fundamentalist religions,
either right or left. have done more harm than any spec of good they have done. - 2 years ago
-
carmalite
-
-
hayden_augustus
-
I know exactly what you mean by talking about causing harm. Try spending your life telling this to people in the South. Almost all of the people here are taught to never question religion; hence: no reality check. And due to no reality check, religions commit violent atrocities against fellow human beings. e.g.: Crusades, 9/11, & the Holocaust. The ole "my god can beat up your god" complex. Seems more like you found out why and how the harm is being produced by religion & that that is the reason why religion is harmful in itself. Good post & I agree.
- 2 years ago
-
hayden_augustus
-
-
onechance
-
Awesome post. Wholeheartedly agreed. It could be equated to George W Bu$h's famous "you're with us or you're against us" no way out speak.
- 2 years ago
-
onechance