Atheist Billboard Stirs God Debate
source: http://bombsfromtheleftcoast.blogspot.com/2009/11/atheist-billboard-stirs-god-debate.html
-
-
- unimatrix0
- added this
http://bombsfromtheleftcoast.blogspot.com/2009/11/atheist-billboard-s...
It is the Central Florida billboard condemned by Christians. Now it is pulling people into a big debate over God in Lakeland. Atheists invited people to join them, and Christians are pushing back firmly.http://bombsfromtheleftcoast.blogspot.com/2009/11/atheist-billboard-stirs-god-de...
-
- groups:
- Community, Current Tonight, Religion, Humanism, 3 more
-
- tags:
- Atheist, Not this again
-
-
Found_Avenue
-
Atheists of Florida, here's a newsflash: You're living in a state where you will likely never be completely accepted. The religious faction of Floridians that I met are close-minded and will preach AT you, and never bother listening to you. They are incapable of intelligent discourse about this topic, and can only hold their beliefs up as "fact." It won't even be an interesting debate, because you won't be communicating with the same vocabulary. You are fighting a losing battle. There are plenty of places in America where you won't be laughed at or looked down upon for your beliefs, or lack thereof. I live in a city where buddhists and muslims and christians and jews AND atheists all respect eachother and acknowledge eachothers' significance. Imagine that.
Remember, some of the most devout Christians practice the OPPOSITE of "Live and Let Live," ironically enough.
- 3 years ago
-
Found_Avenue
-
-
iPedro
-
Found_Avenue:
I actually think that that is likely to change not so long from now.
About 30% of Americans under 30 don't subscribe to any particular religion, most of them not believing in any sort of god.
Florida's population is old and getting older. Once the older demographic dies off, they'll be replaced by those atheist under 30 year olds and things can change fast.
There is a discernible trend that associates higher education with atheism. The younger generations are more educated than the older generations were at their age. It is natural then to determine that within the not so distant future, Atheism in America will rise with the increasing percentage of population attending post-secondary education.
- 3 years ago
-
iPedro
-
-
spanky07 [removed]
- This comment was removed as a violation of community guidelines.
-
spanky07 [removed]
-
-
rwahrens
-
spanky07:
Typical apologist straw man.
They come from a hard 4,000,000 plus years of evolutionary experience with humans living with each other and learning the hard way that certain kinds of actions are harmful to the community.
Bad things (theft, rape, murder, etc.) are bad for a community and cause hard feelings between the victims and the perpetrators. Bad feelings result in wars, family feuds, more murder, and usually escalating violence. Humans are, at least sometimes, smart people, and those with real smarts have figured out that these things are not good.
This has resulted in communities, ever since Hammurabi, setting down those rules where everybody can see them and understand that they are not approved activities by that community. Murder, rape, theft, and other forms of violence have been proscribed actions since long before christianity or judaism ever made the scene. "god" didn't invent morality. Neither did the jews, they just came up with their own rules, just like lots of other human communities have since the beginning of human existence. The change the jews made is that they gave credit to their god so those rules could be elevated to where they couldn't be questioned!
Actually, a brilliant move. The christians have taken that one and made a science out of it!
Unfortunately, the jewish morality largely involved rules having to do with their religion and keeping the faith. The first half of the Ten Commandments have nothing to do with human values, but are proscriptions intended to keep the jews loyal to their god. Given all the trouble he had keeping them in line, it was probably a smart idea...
But also, those first commandments have nothing to do with Western civilization's laws, especially the religious ones the US dumped when we wrote the Constitution!
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
tangibleparadox
-
spanky07:
i could boil it all down to a simple rule i go by: treat others how you want to be treated. i don't want my stuff stolen; i don't steal. i don't want to be murdered; i don't kill anyone. i want to be treated with kindness; i treat others with kindness. i can't always expect others to do the same, but i do my best to adhere to this simple concept anyway. you don't need religion to live by such a rule, and you don't need to be without religion to break it, either. :)
- 3 years ago
-
tangibleparadox
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
spanky07:
Atheists don't have the loopholes that religions usually have built in, so we usually stick by our code of ethics because we have to live with ourselves. We don't get a day of atonement or confession or any other magical sin cleanser. Most atheists that I have come in contact with are good people just because we put some thought into our actions and don't have a deity to blame or appease.
- 3 years ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
rwahrens
-
spanky07:
EJP;
Yes, I agree completely! I hadn't thought of it that way...
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
jubal
-
@Spank......Tell me.....What is sin?
- 3 years ago
-
jubal
-
-
spanky07 [removed]
-
jubal: This comment was removed as a violation of community guidelines.
-
spanky07 [removed]
-
-
jubal
-
spanky07:
I have tremendous faith, I am a pillar of faith and I don't believe that anything is SINFUL.
Sin is a man made concept.
- 3 years ago
-
jubal
-
-
Imjustabill
-
Nobody has ever knocked on my door and asked me to be an atheist. I wonder why that is. Could it be they believe in freedom of choice. Not freedom from choice.
- 3 years ago
-
Imjustabill
-
-
unclecharlie
-
sigh. atheists don't say "what if?" they say "absolutely not!" Now which statement is the closed minded one? So much for being tolerant of ideas that differ from theirs!
- 3 years ago
-
unclecharlie
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
unclecharlie:
That isn't really true. Atheists don't know and neither do any religions. Anyone that says they know for sure that there is a god or isn't a god is deluded. No one knows and NO ONE has the right to say that they do and force it down the throats of others.
- 3 years ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
mrjenks
-
unclecharlie:
You apparently did not read or understand my last post unclecharlie... If atheists said "absolutely not!" as you claim we do, then I wouldn't have brought up all the questions about "What if God did exist?" in my previous post. As I believe in what science can prove by evidence, I cannot 100% declare there is no God. However, given all the evidence, I have come to the conclusion that there most likely, 99.99% chance, is no God.
And as for your statement inferring that religious people are more tolerant to "What if?" than atheists; when was the last time a religious group received a death threat from an atheist over a billboard supporting God? Never.
- 3 years ago
-
mrjenks
-
-
unclecharlie
-
unclecharlie:
given all the scientific evidence, and with the proof of my own personal experiences, I come to the conclusion that it is 100% certain that God exists. Some things are true whether you choose to believe them or not. if there was no God, all would be chaos, no order. And God has shown he is there, in a very personal way.
- 3 years ago
-
unclecharlie
-
-
rwahrens
-
unclecharlie:
Oh? Pray tell, please link to all that "scientific evidence" of god's existence!
Curious minds await!
On the contrary, atheists start from the position that there is no god, not because we can prove it, but because YOU can't! Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof.
If nobody had ever told me that "there is a god", I would not have any clue as to that entity's existence. The only "proof" i've ever seen was the *claim* on some human's part that he does. A claim is not proof.
Don't point to the bible, it is merely very old, unsubstantiated and dubious third, forth and fifth-generation claims of the same sort. You have no way to prove the authorship or the provenience of any of the documents in that compendium, and cannot show what the original documents may have said, it has been altered so many times.
Remember, link to "scientific" evidence, so we may be educated. That means published in peer reviewed, scientific journals. And you said evidence for "god's" existence, and not the existence of the worship of him, which is not the same.
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
unclecharlie:
Yes, please do provide the proof. I have been waiting for it since I was seven. I am at the edge of my seat and depending upon you to show me the undeniable proof of the existence of god. Please don't let me down, unclecharlie.
Seriously. I want to review your facts, because atheists are always open to the presentation of information.
- 3 years ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
02
-
unclecharlie:
Well, I'm sayin' it. There absolutely, 100% is no God. Not the "God" you goof-balls are thinking about.
And how could there be? You haven't got the brains to compete with God - and that is the range of understanding it takes to have any idea what-so-ever.
Since you have no possibility of having enough intellectual juice to comprehend God, ALL of your thoughts, beliefs and ideas - are wrong.Your thoughts, the level of your thoughts - don't compete.
That's it. The God you think/hope/wish for - does not exist.
Or it wouldn't be God...
- 3 years ago
-
02
-
-
rwahrens
-
unclecharlie:
Hmm, over week. Either there's no evidence, or unclecharlie is just having trouble compiling it all. I wonder which it is...
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
spanky07 [removed]
-
EdJoyProductions: This comment was removed as a violation of community guidelines.
-
spanky07 [removed]
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
spanky07:
Faith that defies logic is a form of mental illness.
- 3 years ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
jubal
-
Lets face the truth now, religious adherence is motivated by fear.
- 3 years ago
-
jubal
-
-
spanky07 [removed]
-
jubal: This comment was removed as a violation of community guidelines.
-
spanky07 [removed]
-
-
Varex_Sythe
-
spanky07:
Uh, doesn't that typically happen without religious faith behind it?
If you help little old ladies cross the street, help out at the homeless shelter, and do other good things regardless of whether or not you have a religious doctrine, don't good things tend to happen to you in return? That doesn't seem to be the result of faith or religion, it seems to be the result of of our social structure.
- 3 years ago
-
Varex_Sythe
-
-
mrjenks
-
"Atheists can try every move possible, it will not stop God's plan.....Go ahead try it!" - Spanky07
I will quote a much more intelligent person than yourself, Richard Dawkins, "We are all atheists about most of the gods that humanity has ever believed in. Some of us just go one god further." I am fully Atheist, but, from I scientific standpoint, let's assume the hypothesis that God exists turned out to be true. I think God would rather us make up our own minds about him/her/it than follow someone else's interpretation of him/her/it blindly and without question. Honestly, try to think for yourself instead of believing what another human or a false book tells you to believe, I promise you'll find it quite liberating.
And out of curiosity, if there were a God, what makes the God you believe in the correct one? How do we know the Muslims or Jews aren't correct? What if everyone is wrong? I'm sure you don't believe in the old Greek Gods, that technically makes you an atheist.
- 3 years ago
-
mrjenks
-
-
spanky07 [removed]
-
mrjenks: This comment was removed as a violation of community guidelines.
-
spanky07 [removed]
-
-
mrjenks
-
spanky07:
And I'll bet you think that "one true god" is the one you believe in. That proves why other countries hate us, people like you are selfish and egotistical. God didn't make man, man made god. God is whatever delusion you want him/her/it to be in your own head just as it is for everyone else on this planet.
- 3 years ago
-
mrjenks
-
-
jubal
-
spanky07:
There is no God, not in the way you are trying to promote it.
- 3 years ago
-
jubal
-
-
jubal
-
spanky07:
Monotheism is what fucked our planet up in the first place.
- 3 years ago
-
jubal
-
-
rickm8
-
They have had one in jersey for a while that I've seen. They have a Merry Christmas one too, I mean I suppose both sides get their voice so no one can complain here. Stupid bible thumpers.
- 3 years ago
-
rickm8
-
-
royulery
-
i was very religious, even a missionary in south america. over the years i lost the sincerity that gave me joy and became fanatic. as a fanatic, i needed desperately to convince others of something i had doubts with. i could see this behavior all around me, especially with the constant re enforcement of dogma in a never ending brain washing environment.
i became a terrible person, a phoney, pretending to be open minded while waiting to shove the fear of death in your face. the crimes i commited to finance my mission almost got me killed, as well they should have. a lot of deprograming has worked, for the most part but i have scars and find myself ready to pounce on people with my views. i gotta be careful not to exchange my fanaticism from one side to the other. - 3 years ago
-
royulery
-
-
02
-
royulery:
You only live once - you're right to try and throw off bad stuff.
The key, I believe, is essentially not re-enforcing old thought or fears by constantly re-thinking them - or giving any time to it.
When your brain thinks, it makes that thought, you. You become the thoughts and feelings that you engage in. Those thoughts become strong, the thoughts you do not think, become weak.
Put the past into the past - and it will plague you no more.
The good thing is that, often, most of the stuff we have thought, really was just a bunch of crap that a youth wrestled with themself over. And that as you have grown and grown up, it truly is gone.
Give it no weight, and it will disappear; - away on the constantly flowing river of time.
- 3 years ago
-
02
-
-
unclecharlie
-
royulery:
maybe read kris franklin's story. they were evangelical missionaries to guatemala. They lost their faith in evangelical protestantism, and found their faith authentically in the universality of the catholic church. the cayholic church is not divided by denominationalism- it truly is universal......
- 3 years ago
-
unclecharlie
-
-
rwahrens
-
royulery:
Oh, bull pucky.
If the RCC really WAS universal, there would be no other christian denominations, but you see, there ARE. Martin Luther, bless his pea-pickin little anti-semitic heart, took care of THAT one.
So much for universality, as there are also other complete, different religions, altogether!
There will never be a universal church, as people are too fractious, too different, too willing to disagree with one another.
If there really WERE a god, and he had the real powers of an omniscient, all powerful universe creator, he would surely have the power to see that there wouldn't be any cheap, false competitors. If, that is, he had the fatal, *human* flaw of needing any kind of acknowledgement from the likes of US regarding that power.
Which I really doubt.
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
02
-
Religion is 100% self-service. Me, me, me. But of course, it's only important after understanding that we are small, small, small.
So frightening. So profound. So they exchange this obvious insignificance for full blown self-engrandizing ego trip. (which, of course and tragically forsakes any real mental, emotional, "spiritual" progress for the rest of their life)Little children, safe from unease until they die.
The whole universe was created just for them, so they can live beyond their years in the clouds.tweedly-dee.
Utter, whole and complete stupidity.
- 3 years ago
-
02
-
-
IronLionZion
-
02:
That was one of the best paragraphs I have read in a long time. Short. Succinct. Major props.
- 3 years ago
-
IronLionZion
-
-
spanky07 [removed]
-
02: This comment was removed as a violation of community guidelines.
-
spanky07 [removed]
-
-
Varex_Sythe
-
spanky07:
Yet there are a lot of people in religion who not only make it about ME ME ME, but they do it rather successfully.
Besides, if religion is about God God God, that seems to me like God is saying, "ME ME ME!" which is a very petty thing for a higher being to do.
- 3 years ago
-
Varex_Sythe
-
-
dusty_red_rivet_head
-
Lakeland!?!? Seriously, Lakeland? Why don't you try that in Badenton while you're at it? You can't get much more right wing than Lakeland. This would have been a bit more successful here in Tampa, or maybe Orlando or Miami. Lakeland? not likely. I really like the idea of the billboard, but the execution kind of failed. Lakeland is just a bit too ambitious to start with. They should really try a more progressive city first before trying to expand out into the sticks.
- 3 years ago
-
dusty_red_rivet_head
-
-
rwahrens
-
dusty_red_rivet_head:
Your post assumes that they were trying to convert theists.
Nothing is further from the truth.
They are simply trying to let those that do not believe know that they are not alone. If you think that there are no atheists in a majority christian county, then you have another think coming.
Places where there are large, strong majorities of christians are places where this word needs to get out to first, to comfort and reach those that are "in the closet". They don't have to DO anything, just be comforted that they are not alone.
Believe me, that IS a comfort!
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
dusty_red_rivet_head
-
dusty_red_rivet_head:
I'm not sure where you got the idea that I thought that they were trying to convert theists, but what I was trying to say was that they would have been more successful in reaching and comforting "in the closet" atheists in a more populated/less right-wing city.
Please don't read "right-wing" as "christian-majoritied." They're not the same thing. Most counties in the United States have a christian majority, but many are not right-wing. I live nearby in more populated and slightly more progressive Tampa and I haven't successfully "came out" to my family. I haven't had reason to mention it to my until-recently-absent father. With our recent reconciliation, it hasn't really come up. And despite my best efforts, my mother has not accepted my beliefs.
I would have appreciated the opportunity to talk about my beliefs if I had heard about it, but apparently the news didn't even make it a few miles down the road. This was the first I'd heard of it. I'm not saying that the sign was a bad idea, just the location could have been better thought out. Just because those of us who live in more populated areas aren't surrounded by right wingers, doesn't mean we live an easy and accepted existance.
- 3 years ago
-
dusty_red_rivet_head
-
-
rwahrens
-
dusty_red_rivet_head:
Believe me, I understand, I grew up in Texas. It is easier now that I live in Md, but I haven't talked to the family in Tx for years about this, and am not about to start now.
But my point is the same, that if I did still live there, I would feel much better hearing the message in that billboard. Again, it's not like anybody seriously expects large organizational gains in those areas, but the billboard serves to do two things. It lets those in that area that are in the closet know they are not alone, and it shakes up the fundies. Both are good, in my book.
I mean, look at the publicity they've gotten - that's almost like money in the bank, it IS like the major media has paid for a major publicity campaign!
You cannot buy that kind of publicity otherwise. Not without a few million dollars.
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
CalgarC
-
fuck Faux News
- 3 years ago
-
CalgarC
-
-
randallr01
-
wait.... people are still hung up on this shit?
god doesn't exist; get over it.
- 3 years ago
-
randallr01
-
-
LowShred
-
Old news is old.
- 3 years ago
-
LowShred
-
-
dabne
-
Religion has always been the target of so many. So many want to pin all the evils of the world on Christianity and other religions. The truth is that Religion has never been the problem. The problem is called RESOURCES.
Resources have always been and always will be the cause of all war. Who ever controls them has POWER.
Sure, over the centuries, people who identified themselves as believers, have sought those resources, and caused destruction and loss of life along the way. But it was never really about GOD. Read your history books. It's about Resources.
As if atheists are immune to power, greed, and of securing the worlds resources.
Wipe Religion off the face of the earth and man will still seek power, dominion, and RESOURCES, in the name of his choosing, or no name at all.
Believers and Non-Believers are not much different than many like to believe. At the end of the day they both need RESOURCES to survive, and both groups will resort to anything to secure them. Whether he exists or whether he does not, God has nothing to do with man's free will to seek and secure his survival.
- 3 years ago
-
dabne
-
-
JeremyTG77
-
dabne:
I agree with this. If religion didn't exist, people would just find something else to fight about.
However, I still find it offensive when Western Christians (especially American ones) complain about how supposedly oppressed they are when Christians in other parts of the world face actual persecution every day.
- 3 years ago
-
JeremyTG77
-
-
darinK
-
Here we go again. Atheists looking for their freedom from religion. If they all got together and wrote something of a constitution or law banning any sign or utter of religion they might be happy. In the U.S. we can practice any religion we want to. Thank God an atheist didn't write our constitution.
- 3 years ago
-
darinK
-
-
iPedro
-
darinK:
Actually, Thomas Jefferson, Abraham Lincoln and George Washington are widely believed -- through their actions and their recorded speeches -- to have been atheists or at best non-religious theists.
Additionally, the Constitution of the United States is based upon a secular foundation, not theist principals -- much less Christians ones.
- 3 years ago
-
iPedro
-
-
MOK
-
darinK:
darinK, are you aware of the irony of your statement?
From one perspective, christianity and atheism can be compared on common grounds as belief systems One of The Constitution's primary goals - That of freedom of faith - is first touched on in the first amendment. If, as you suggest, our founders were writing from a christian perspective, then without their version of the constitution, atheists wouldn't be allowed to practice(or, not practice, as it were..). And you suggest that atheists would strike down those laws that allowed it's existence.Kinda funny!
Furthermore, you'll note that in this article, there was no imposition by atheists upon others. Rather, they put up a rather benign and nonthreatening sign (comparable to billboards from a church) and the Christians came out with the pitchforks and torches.
You aren't making terribly much sense here, darinK.
- 3 years ago
-
MOK
-
-
iPedro
-
darinK:
Here are quotes from some of the most important fathers of the US constitution:
"But it does me no injury for my neighbor to say there are twenty gods or no God. It neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg."
-Thomas Jefferson"Question with boldness even the existence of a god; because if there be one he must approve of the homage of reason more than that of blindfolded fear."
-Thomas Jefferson,"The Bible is not my book nor Christianity my profession. I could never give assent to the long, complicated statements of Christian dogma."
- Abraham Lincoln“The government of the United States is in no sense founded on the Christian Religion.”
- George Washington
So in fact, the Constitution was written by Atheists.
George Washington put it best:
There is nothing which can better deserve our patronage than the promotion of science and literature. Knowledge is in every country the surest basis of public happiness. [George Washington, address to Congress, 8 January, 1790]
....and President Thomas Jefferson was ahead of his time when he said:
Priests...dread the advance of science as witches do the approach of daylight and scowl on the fatal harbinger announcing the subversions of the duperies on which they live.
-Thomas Jefferson
- 3 years ago
-
iPedro
-
-
darinK
-
darinK:
I actually support the right to put up that billboard. Atheism to me is a religion of non belief or the belief in no higher power. Any group with the same belief is a religous group if the belief has to do with higher powers. Free speech to all. I have seen the attack on christianity in public especially around Christmas. Only atheists have attacked such a religous occassion. Even terrorists restrain from those events. Your attacks have greater consequences that you'll regret rather than enjoy.
- 3 years ago
-
darinK
-
-
rwahrens
-
darinK:
darinK,
Atheism is not a "belief about a higher power". It is a LACK of such belief.
I do not live my life telling myself "There is no god", but simply live my life according to values I have learned to make my life easier and richer - do no harm, help others, be kind to animals, etc.
Sorry, but there will be nothing to regret, as I have not been giving my money to a non-existant god's adherents to spread their poison, but have used it to improve the lives of my family and those charities I have chosen to give to.
I am not religious, and do not have such a belief.
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
MOK
-
darinK:
darinK, if you could perhaps post a link to one or some of these 'attacks' as you call them, perhaps that would support your stance. I would be keen on knowing more if this is a frequently occurring. By highlighting this issue you suggest that, proportionate to the atheist population, more 'attacks' of this sort are perpetrated by atheists than by Christians. I doubt the facts are on your side here, but if they are, I'd like to know.
My suspicion is that people feel hyper-sensitive about their holidays being questioned, and create much sensationalism around something that seems to undermine them. It's a natural human reaction. An 'us or them' mentality gets created, and the snowball topic rolls and rolls downhill.....
When in reality it was never a big deal to start with.But I could be wrong. Ahh, atheism, gifting me with comfort despite unknowns and uncertainties.
- 3 years ago
-
MOK
-
-
darinK
-
darinK:
MOK Some of the attacks I was refering to are well known. Many companies changed policies to not say or display Christmas during Christmas time. Most companies did this under pressure from the aclu. Christians and many others celebrate the birth of Jesus Christ. Why is that harmful to any atheist. It's one of the few global holidays and will be forever so you better learn to live with it.
- 3 years ago
-
darinK
-
-
rwahrens
-
darinK:
You see, that's the problem with many christians.
A company changing their policy regarding customer relations, intended to adjust to the realities of the modern world, where not everybody is christian, is NOT AN ATTACK ON CHRISTIANITY!!
Geez, get over it, not everybody believes the same religious crap you do. Some have their own, different crap to believe in that does NOT include something called christ or christ's mass. Others do not believe in religion at all, and someone else adjusting their attitudes to that new reality is not an attack on someone else.
Believe me, when atheists really begin attacking religion, you'll know it. While a lot of us are live or let live types, others are now beginning to think that going into attack mode is better than keeping quiet. Your attitude in calling atheists' attempts to merely protect our legal rights "attacks" is a large part of the reason why this attitude is beginning to gain traction.
Keep your religion where it should be - in your church, paid for by donations to that church. Keep it out of government, and stop trying to advance your faith through the power of government, using government funds, and we'll be happy to let you worship as you please. Just have the courtesy to give us the same rights, and stop pushing your faith into the public sphere.
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
02
-
darinK:
Mass for Christ was pulled out from under a rug only because they knew no one would ever give up on Saturnalia - the oldest and most loved winter holiday that was always celebrated on Dec 25th. It was the Xmas magic feeling but also a bit of New Years too. When everybody loosened up and had fun.
Jesus wasn't born anywhere near Dec - if there ever really was a Jesus in the first place.
- 3 years ago
-
02
-
-
BoomChaka
-
what happened to live-and-let-live?
or at least live-and-let-live-and-let-the-other-guy-burn-in-hell - 3 years ago
-
BoomChaka
-
-
kennymotown
-
If you don't like it, get your own billboard. A real debate is needed just like a national debate about abortion is needed or when does life start! Too bad bigger heads and assholes prevail all the time. Go atheist fight like hell we have herd from the other side for far too long!
- 3 years ago
-
kennymotown
-
-
ii386
-
They mentioned Atheists attempting to "recruit members" twice. I cannot understand how some might think that Atheism is group orientated. Atheism is not a defining characteristic, unlike some religious who define themselves as such: a Christian, Catholic, Muslim etc. There is no attempt to be a 'good Atheist' in the same way one might try to be a 'good Christian.' There is no meeting for ritualistic singing, readings from Atheist scriptures, or ceremonies. There is no recruiting of members to any Atheist organization. These billboard may go against the grain but they provide people that question their faith with the support that they are not evil for doing so. The support of knowing that you're not going to go to hell if you don't believe what, in most cases, you were forced to believe by your parents. I don't see what's wrong with that. Just as its hard for theists to understand how one cannot believe in a god, it is equally as hard for an Atheist to understand how one could pretend that there is a god.
ps -the link was an accident and i can't get rid of it.
- 3 years ago
-
ii386
-
-
EtVoila
-
No, the people who say that they are offended by the billboard are, in fact not offended by the billboard itself. The billboard is not at all offensive in any way, it doesn't challenge anyone. It just give members of the widely frowned-upon Atheist minority in America a bit of reassurance that there are plenty of others like them. These people are, for some strange reason, offended by the fact that people don't share their same belief and I find that deplorable.
As an Atheist myself, I see religion as an interesting natural phenomenon exclusive to humans, a phenomenon that must be studied in order to get a full understanding of ourselves. But, these people seem to want to eliminate diversity and make everyone like themselves, and they go about this by shoving their beliefs down the throats of others. They also believe that they are doing others a sort of favor by pushing their beliefs on them, for example "saving their soul". If they had any sense of empathy, they'd be able to see how annoying, innervating, and offensive it is to have someone elses' belief pushed onto them.
I appreciate the efforts of the people trying to build a sort of understanding between the secular and nonsecular, but I think we have quite a ways to go.
- 3 years ago
-
EtVoila
-
-
Ajil
-
Spanky, no one is trying to stop "God's plan". We just want you to accept that there is a group that does not believe God ever told anyone his plan. God is not a person. There is no man in the sky. We only have this life to live for, so we'll do what we will with it. What I see as truth is that I will measure the standard of my own life, without accordance to the standards that meet your interpretation of what "God's plan" is.
That does not mean any disrespect. In fact, just the opposite. There needs to be general acceptance and mutual respect. For the sake of sharing this planet with not just ourselves, but for all other life. That means a new look on our relationship with this planet, from other forms of life, to resources, and every ecosystem.
Taking responsibility of the progress we make, not anarchy, but to break from monotheistic rule. Just look at every problem in the world. It can be traced to the Monetary System, which enslaves and profits of our suffering. With theists having much involvement in humanity's development, while remaining in major powerful positions, it is time to accept humility and ease off building your factions to ward off the Devil.
Thanks to what spawned out of the Renaissance, much of our current progress takes after the advances in Science: especially psychology. You may face many harsh and nerving comments online from atheists, but the truth of the matter, the group has been quieted for too long. Thanks to a certain scientific advancement im sure you appreciate, called the internet, we discuss whether or not we should value a type of people that rely on scientific methods, and evidence, rather then measure them up to another several groups that believe they have the absolute correct interpretation of "God's plan", praying for better days, or at least ending theirs in the name of their God hoping for the best after-life. We do not seek to battle, but have open dialog and mutual acceptance, consideration, and if its not too much to ask, some understanding.
- 3 years ago
-
Ajil
-
-
IronLionZion
-
Ajil:
I get what your saying, but the problem with that notion is Jesus didnt just say hippie, non violent things. If you think the wickedness was only in the old testament, Jesus said, "It is easier for Heaven and Earth to pass away than for the smallest part of the letter of the law to become invalid." (Luke 16:17 NAB) , it doesnt matter, because Jesus wants you to apply the Old Testament way of living to your life. Even worse in one instance, Jesus is more cruel than Big Guns up stairs, the OT says adultery is punishable by death, Jesus said even lusting/thinking about adultery is punishable by death...So the point Im trying to make is that when you say "authentic", what you really mean is people who cherrypick the good quotes and follow them, "love your neighbor etc", but ignore the truly wicked ones..they then become "hypochristian" also dont they?
- 3 years ago
-
IronLionZion
-
-
jubal
-
Ajil:
@IronLionZion, about the quotes from Luke....Have you ever heard about hyperbole or irony? I interpret those quotes from Jesus as using one or both of these devices to drive a point home. I don't believe Jesus wanted people to follow the OT way of life, especially after he condemned the Pharisees for being the Children of Satan for being such strict adherents to the law, demonstrating to them that following the Law would never lead to everlasting life. Jesus came to save the world, not enslave the world to a system of laws created by Moses and plagiarized from the Egyptians. The history of the Israelites is rife with them adopting the customs of other gods into their dogma and rituals.
The way I understand Jesus is not typical of Christianity today. And when you say "Cherry Picking" that is exactly what you must do with the Bible, because it is a sociopolitical hybrid based on age old Astrological foundations. The "loving father" that Jesus came to reveal to humanity, is not the same "Father God" of Abraham and cited author of the Law of the Torah. The loving Father of Jesus is not a personality in the sense that you and I are personalities. Jesus Father is an active force in the universe, that creates and exists in natural laws on the level of Earthly Nature, Cosmological Nature, Microbiological Nature, and Quantum, String, and Chaos levels of Nature; not in the imaginations, pretensions, myths, fears, and oppressive legal structures created by mortal men. We must Cherry pick because the Mother of the Bible, the Catholic Church perverted the original writings adding scriptures to support their authority and strengthen their interpretations of dogma or deleted scriptures that contradicted their authority and exposed their dogma as false teachings. Anti-Christs have existed from the very beginning and were at work to establish an Official Christianity that Jesus would never have sanctioned in the first place.
When I think of Authentic Christians I think of peace makers, of the kinds of souls that Jesus described in the Be-attitudes.
Also I must declare that the Daughters of the Mother Church, continue on the course of manipulation of dogmas and have employed brainwashing techniques for centuries, they capitalized on the inhumanity of the Inquisition to Protest and to establish a New World Order based on new dogmas developed by Luther and Wesley. The current Kings, the Evangelical/Pentecostals have carried on this tradition but have returned to legalism as their faith foundational cornerstone.
Merging the OT with the NT and with all the corruption of the Mother and Daughters has created a BI-POLAR BIBLE that has been practically rendered meaningless.
But again I assert that IMHO Authentic Christians should be peacemakers who do not judge anyone, who love unconditionally all of God's children, whether they be poverty stricken, sick, sexually deviant, thieves, liars, pagans, atheists, or any other category of stratification you can add to this list; everyone considered the "other". The job of an Authentic Christian is to ennoble the human spirit, to exalt the human condition, to bring social justice through acceptance of differences of lifestyles and ideologies.
Authentic Christians would be involved in conflict resolution, not be the arbiters of practically every conflict known to man.
- 3 years ago
-
jubal
-
-
02
-
Ajil:
jubal - this is one of the best things ever put forth in the christian debate. Very well done.
- 3 years ago
-
02
-
-
jubal
-
Ajil:
Thanks O2. I appreciate your taking the time to read it.
- 3 years ago
-
jubal
-
-
tangibleparadox
-
Ajil:
that was awesome, jubal. *recommend^infinity*
- 3 years ago
-
tangibleparadox
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
Ajil:
Bravo, Jubal!
- 3 years ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
Ajil
-
Ajil:
whoa. i just read these responses. jubal did a great job. i gotta say, he does a much greater job at using facts; synthesizing, defining and explaining it all.
- 3 years ago
-
Ajil
-
-
rwahrens
-
Ajil:
Yes, Jubal's post was good, but what I don't get, and he doesn't really explain, is: What are the criteria by which one chooses the verses to follow vs. the ones to trash and forget?
Because Jesus' teachings are split between more than one gospel, the outlook, and the particular quotes chosen by each writer, are different in tone and character. In one he says he is coming to begin things anew, and in another, he says that the law will never pass away and must be obeyed. He preaches peace and light in one place, and yet, lets go with the fire and brimstone in another. In each of the various gospels, his message is not only different, but often contradictory.
Yes, the fundies that want to follow the bible literally have those problems, but while the more liberal denominations throw out much of the contradictory stuff, they never do seem to come up with a satisfactory set of criteria for determining which to keep and which to trash.
Why toss out the stuff about diet, slavery, violence, etc., in the old testament (which the fundies do too), but keep in the prohibition against homosexuality? What excuse do they have for denying polygamy? All the old testament based Hebrew leaders had more than one wife, and the bible does not prohibit it, as the Mormons before Utah's statehood would have told you. (and some of them will still say so today) Yet, all of these "values", strict diet, human trafficking, violent real estate acquisition and so forth, also "just happen" to also be ignored or frowned upon by modern, post-enlightenment western societies, for reasons that have NOTHING to do with theocratic gymnastics.
Coincidence? I doubt it. Christianity in western society has had to adjust itself, and its theology, to the realities of secular law within the societies in which it operates, because IT NO LONGER CONTROLS THE LAW in those societies.
Western culture officially frowns upon slavery, and has since beginning in the 19th century - earlier in some European countries. The US fought a war to re-integrate itself after a split-up, over, among other things, human trafficking. Christian theology had nothing to do with this, as there were christians on both sides of that issue, both using biblical quotations to back themselves up.
The International community has, since the emergence of the UN, officially frowned upon violent acquisition of real estate, and most western industrialized countries now have outlawed capital punishment. Many States in the US have also. Again, the anti-death penalty crowd do not use christian theology in their arguments. Their arguments are most often decidedly humanist in nature.
Most European countries now have dropped any legal discriminations against gays, and the US is now in the midst of a culture "war" over that issue, in which the leading lights against gay "liberation" are fundamentalist christians and the RCC. To their credit, many liberal christian denominations now have joined the fight to stop legal discrimination against gays in this country.
I guess that invisible line of criteria have finally crossed the Rubicon to drop the last, great old testament rule into the rubbish bin of history.
But I'd still like to see some kind of admission by those liberal christians that secular values are truly at the bottom of those rule changes.
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
jubal
-
Ajil:
Rwahrens, I appreciate you calling me out and I will try, in my own understanding of things, tell you how I cherry pick. The key to Gnosis, first and foremost, is to know yourself. Know thy self. How does one go about knowing one's self.
Well first of all you must take an honest and thorough inventory of everything that makes up your consciousness, your beliefs, your convictions, your resentments, your anger, your fears, and the things you are proud of. The main factor here is that we especially want to identify the fears, because fear is the greatest mind killer their is. Almost every psychosis and psychological problem is tied to fear. This process is not something that is accomplished in a day, it may take months or even a few years to fully flush everything out. Once everything has been identified and tied to anger and fear, then it must be analyzed in order to take ownership of the good and the bad, the comfortable and the uncomfortable and in the process of doing so begin to remove the labels and remove the self from the light/dark, good/bad dichotomies. Everything simply exists without judgments or values placed on them and we take ownership of everything that is our being. Once we have achieved the ownership there will be a release of fear, anger and resentment and we will experience what many call love or grace. This is the process to Gnosis; self knowledge where we are elevated from the Doxa to the Logos.
Many of those who have achieved Gnosis realize that the mythos of Judeo/Christian/Islamic theism is man made; it was meant as advice and guidance, not laws to be enshrined as idols to be followed, worshiped and adored. More people put their faith in the idol of the written word than the word that is written within our hearts and our consciousness. Getting in touch with the inner self, emancipating it from the mythos brings the self into Gnosis.
If you haven't been through this process of enlightenment then you cannot cherry pick very well. Everything will seem confusing and contradictory. But with enlightenment, discernment comes into focus and becomes like a highlighter, causing the deeper meanings to jump out of the words to us and we find that they confirm what we already knew in our hearts and minds; we experience an Aha! moment. The written words confirm the internal reality that we already understand through Gnosis, rather than using the words we are reading to create the understanding.
In my experience, I came to the conclusion that Jehovah was not the father of Jesus. It wasn't until later that, after achieving Gnosis, was I able to re-read the bible and find that the scriptures confirm that internal reality, that I came to on my own, without anyone telling me to think or believe it. I stumbled upon it and at first it caused me great consternation, fear and worry that I was treading into blasphemy. But I persisted, calming my self. I realized that I had to open my mind to the possibility of things not being the way that I had always thought they were, the way that I was taught things were; that reality was something entirely different than faith and charity, or money, property and prestige.
This is the beginning...
- 3 years ago
-
jubal
-
-
jubal
-
Ajil:
There are other paths to Gnosis, but this is the one that worked for me.
- 3 years ago
-
jubal
-
-
rwahrens
-
Ajil:
Jubal,
That was very good, as good an explanation of how gnosis works I've ever heard.
But that theology is as far from modern christianity as you can get; it was pronounced heresy by the RCC 1500 years or more ago. As such, it does not represent an answer to my question.
Don't get me wrong. I believe in the spirituality of man, and gnosis is a lot closer to a personal spirituality than modern christian theology could ever get. If it works for you, that is great - for you. If it worked for more people, we'd have less of an issue with fundies wanting to restructure American history and government to suit their twisted ideas.
But again, it does not explain how or why modern christians can take verses from the christian bible and, using that bible, which is what christians have to explain and document their faith, decide what to follow and what to toss out as "outmoded" or merely "allegorical" instead of an actual, you know, command. (which is how many of these verses are structured.)
I'd still like more christians admit that their cherry picking depends more upon modern values expressed as a result of the enlightenment and secular philosophy than biblical passages.
Thanks for the post though.
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
jubal
-
Ajil:
I got you now, sorry for misunderstanding. I don't speak for Christianity so I couldn't be able to answer your question specifically for them. But I completely understand that ALL Christians cherry pick to their advantage. I agree that most are not honest about the fact that they are cherry picking and asserting that their interpretations are the only real and true ones. Perhaps that is why we have over 30000 Christian denominations registered as Non-Profits with the Internal Revenue Service.
This fact alone, being that there are so many with beliefs so diverse, that they had to register as a separate entity is very telling. It means that the bible as an ultimate source of law and truth has been rendered irrelevant.
- 3 years ago
-
jubal
-
-
rwahrens
-
Ajil:
Now THAT I can agree with completely!
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
jubal
-
We need more Authentic Christians and less Hypochristians.
- 3 years ago
-
jubal
-
-
xiola
-
jubal:
OMG that is so true. Very well put! I am spiritual, and I'm am so saddened by the hate I see perpetuated in the name of institutionalized religion. Humanity can fuck most anything up.
- 3 years ago
-
xiola
-
-
ibrake4rappers13
-
jubal:
agreed
- 3 years ago
-
ibrake4rappers13
-
-
DeliaTheArtist
-
jubal:
"Hypochristians" is a great term!
- 3 years ago
-
DeliaTheArtist
-
-
IronLionZion
-
jubal:
The definition of authentic is : genuine, true. So by authentic do you mean the real christians in the sense of following every law in the bible as Jesus instructed and beleiving in the punishments prescribed in the bible for not following said laws (death)? Thats a scary notion Jubal..As much as I hate hypocritical christians who know nothing about the history of their texts, and whats even IN those texts..I'd much rather live amongst them rather than living in a nation full of fundamentalists.but what the hell do I know...
- 3 years ago
-
IronLionZion
-
-
jubal
-
jubal:
I am so glad you asked that question, IronLionZion (cool rhyming nickname btw) what I mean by my statement of "Authentic" is those that follow Jesus's actual teachings and not the Hypochristian Political Propaganda passing as Evangelical Pentecostal Moral Majority Christianity.
How many Christians in the media seizing headlines do you see practicing "turn the other cheek"? "Loving their enemies"? "Praying for their enemies"? "Walking the extra mile"? "Suffering for the sake of the least of Jesus brothers"?
Like Jesus said in the parable in Mathew 25:40 “The King will answer and say to them, ‘Truly I say to you, to the extent that you did it to one of these brothers of Mine, even the least of them, you did it to Me.’
I think its pretty obvious to realize the distinction I am making here.
- 3 years ago
-
jubal
-
-
rwahrens
-
jubal:
spanky,
We aren't trying to tell YOU how to live, we're trying to keep YOU from telling US how to live.
There IS a difference!
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
Still_Falling
-
I always ask the pious hypocrites, whenever they try to scare me with eternal damnation because I do not believe in a God:
" Where were you before you were born? "
When they fail to answer this simple question, I then ask them another:
" If you did not "exist" before birth. Why do believe you are going to "exist" in a eternal paradise after you die? "
What these Christians fail to understand about me, is that I grew up in the church. I used to attend services three times a week .... so I know the scare tactics religious groups use to indoctrinate.
If you have ever read the bible, you will realize that the scriptures are a horror novel - Stephen King has nothing on those demented bastards.
- 3 years ago
-
Still_Falling
-
-
tangibleparadox
-
Still_Falling:
i asked myself those same two questions by the time i was... let's see... 9. i had no answers, but continued to believe because the thought of going to hell terrified me.
- 3 years ago
-
tangibleparadox
-
-
rwahrens
-
Still_Falling:
The problem with that paradigm is that one cannot MAKE oneself believe what one does not believe. One either believes what one sees or experiences or is told - or one does not. One can have a tentative belief, pending proof, but one cannot force belief on oneself.
You CAN fool yourself into thinking that you do. You CAN fool OTHERS into thinking that you do. But without doing some fancy psychological dancing around your internal mulberry bush, you cannot fool yourself, not really.
This is why religion breeds hypocrisy and teaches our young to lie.
We all have the desire to be like those around us - to BELONG. When a child is told by adults that they see/hear/talk to a deity, and they see and hear nothing, at first they will be confused, but will rapidly learn to play along, since they see that those that DO seem to see/hear that deity get approval from their elders.
But they still KNOW that they've seen or heard nothing. Hence, they learn that lying about their religion is ok, if not outright approved of and rewarded.
Religious training of the young is just plain child abuse.
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
dabne
-
Still_Falling:
Well you don't remember being born either, so that logic is stupid. There is as much evidence for an afterlife as there is a non-afterlife. It's not worth debating. You either find God or you don't. But neither side should worry about it.
- 3 years ago
-
dabne
-
-
rwahrens
-
Still_Falling:
What? Can't you read?
I was talking about children, who, as a matter of course, must be educated by their elders, and has nothing to do with your being able to remember anything.
Perhaps you should take a course in logic, it may expand your horizons!
It is the theists that are claiming something extraordinary, let them come up with the extraordinary proof. In the meantime, I'll just keep on living my life as if there's nothing there.
After all, I've never heard a god speak - when I do, I'll rethink the god thing...
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
Ragan
-
Christian theocracy or any theocracy is suicide to the human race. It could reinvent the inquisitions, the Salem witch trials or even give impetus to other dangerous theocracies like Islam or Zionism. And that would stir up the heat for theocratic wars. Didn't the dark ages of Galaleo and dark dungeons teach the brain dead that the brain needs freedom to discover reality and liberties. How many people know the sentence that Theocracy imposes of the human races and prevents civility and sanity that is needed for a society to coexist peacefully, How many of the youth have been informed of the Theocracy imposed on the people of Iran and of the deaths of the youth who were and are trying to break the chains of theocratic brutality? Europe suffered long under christian cruelty. Christianity is a mental prison and as long as society worships the tenets of this kind of self imposed mental punishment, the spirit or template of mankind will suffer just as a soul in an iron mask.
- 3 years ago
-
Ragan
-
-
spanky07 [removed]
- This comment was removed as a violation of community guidelines.
-
spanky07 [removed]
-
-
Still_Falling
-
spanky07:
What is "God's" plan ?
Please enlighten me, since you privy to this information... - 3 years ago
-
Still_Falling
-
-
jubal
-
spanky07:
God's plan is shit....and that is the plain truth. God is dead and the war's begun.
- 3 years ago
-
jubal
-
-
MOK
-
spanky07:
From all outward appearances, God's plan is whatever Christians think ought to happen.
- 3 years ago
-
MOK
-
-
Loren_Singley
-
spanky07:
Anything that you know or think you know has been told to you from when you were too young to know any better, just like how you were told that Santa Clause exists, and that the Tooth Fairy came at night to take away your tooth that fell out. You have NEVER been witness to a "plan" being carried out by anyone other than humans. Action and Re-Action are the only things that affect what goes on in our world, and let me tell you what you've probably noticed, no action is coming from any "God". Ever. Not when people made up the Bible stories, the Koran stories or mythical Greek stories and definitely not now. Action comes from US. Love and pain and evil and beauty... these are all things WE represent and created. Without humans there is no God. Without the IDEA of God there is no God. All I want from the religious population of the world is to stop killing each other in God's name. Whatever God you pick to help you find meaning in your life.
- 3 years ago
-
Loren_Singley
-
-
mako2424
-
spanky07:
@spanky07
...well, I thought it was funny.
- 3 years ago
-
mako2424
-
-
rwahrens
-
spanky07:
Yeah, funny as in roll on the floor laughing, cause it's so nuts!
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
02
-
spanky07:
You don't have to "sin" - just try growing up. You'll find you like yourself fine and can always be proud of yourself - because you genuinely act like you should and everybody who knows you, will know it.
No more faking your way through life.
It is so much better when you throw stupid away and become everything you should be in this life. You won't need no dumb-ass religion to keep your childish shit propped up.
- 3 years ago
-
02
-
-
rwahrens
-
spanky07:
I don't need faith. The things I believe in to govern my behavior are solid, well reasoned rules that have governed mankind for generations.
I have hope because I can see the good in people and am not told by a misogynistic, evil god that I am bad.
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
rwahrens
-
Actually, those ads are not intended to recruit or convert the religious. They are intended to let other non-theists know that they are not alone! this reaction only goes to show how prickly theists are about anything that disagrees with them.
It is called intolerance.
Note, please, that recent polls have shown that the under 30 crowd are close to 30 - 40% non-religious, and also self-identify with groups other than Republicans.
Sorry, theists, but you are, within the next 20-30 years, going down to the trash-heap of history!
- 3 years ago
-
rwahrens
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
rwahrens:
Amen :)
- 3 years ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
scameron
-
This same billboard was forced to be taken down in Cincinnati after a bunch of death threats were called in. At least this forum seems pretty civil from what we saw, even if those party poopers came and crashed what was supposed to be a good ol' God-bashing hoedown ...
- 3 years ago
-
scameron