Community | January 26, 2010 | 28 comments

CBS 2's Fake Fur Investigation Spawns Legislation - Faux Fur May Be Dog or Cat Hair (and Skin)

Image
EthicalVegan
Jan 25, 2010 5:49 pm US/Pacific
CBS 2's Fake Fur Investigation Spawns Legislation

SACRAMENTO, Calif. (CBS) ―

A loophole in the federal labeling laws allows clothing manufactures to put real fur into clothing without stating anything on the label.



An exclusive undercover investigation on fur garment labeling, which we reported last year, has prompted proposed legislation in Sacramento.

"Obviously this is the reason we are here today," Assemblywoman Fiona Ma of San Francisco said, referring to our investigation, as she introduced a bill to close the loophole in fur labeling laws.

"We will give consumers the right to know what type of fur is contained on a garment," Ma said.

In our investigation, I asked a sales representative if she knew that a jacket she sold contained real fur.

"I thought it was fake fur," she replied.

Our investigation uncovered jackets labeled faux fur, but our expert, Pierre Grzybowski from the Humane Society of the United States, determined it was actually real.

"You can see little pieces of skin that have been stitched together," Grzybowski said.

We also uncovered jackets without any indication of the type of fur on the label. Some of it was, according to our expert, raccoon dog, an animal raised and allegedly slaughtered alive in China.

Even salespeople were unaware when we told them.

"This is real fur. This is similar to raccoon dog. You don't want dog around your neck? No. I don't think so."

It is all legal because of a secret loophole in the federal labeling laws.

"The loophole is that if the fur is valued at less than $150, there doesn't have to be any mention on the label that there is animal fur in the jacket," Grzybowski said.

But the proposed law would mandate that all products be included on the label so consumers know what they're buying.

"Many consumers don't know that this product contains dog. If they did know they may not choose to purchase it," Ma said.

Sponsors credit our investigation.

"He shined a light on the problem and how, not only does it affect consumers, but salespeople are getting deceived by this lack of labeling," Grzybowski said.

If the bill is approved, California would become the sixth state to mandate that all fur be labeled. Sponsors hope that with California onboard, they can convince federal lawmakers to finally close the loophole.
  1. groups:
    Community,   Veganism,   Animal Rights = Veganism,   Animal Rights
  2. tags:
    Dogs veganism Vegan cats 12 more
  3.     
    |

28 comments // CBS 2's Fake Fur Investigation Spawns Legislation - Faux Fur May Be Dog or Cat Hair (and Skin)

  • EthicalVegan
  • EthicalVegan
  • Billy_Goodreasonnews
    • 0
      Billy_Goodreasonnews  
    • Here's a positive spin on this. We're living in a society so appalled by the fur trade that manufacturers think they'll do a better job selling fake fur than real. The market would rather purchase the more humane choice and the manufacturer has to lie just to get the higher-end (but, inhumane) material into the product.

      It's disgusting that these products exist, but it's at least a positive reflection on our society that the animal abusers have to go to such lengths.

    • 2 years ago
  • EthicalVegan
  • EthicalVegan
    • 0
      EthicalVegan  
    • Image
    • ...Continued...

      Fur Seal

      Sea lions and fur seals belong to the family Otariidae. They have ear flaps and can rotate their hind flippers forward, giving them a somewhat ungainly, but very agile, gait on land. These are the "circus seals"—the ones seen in circuses and aquaria—able to stand on their fore flippers and climb stairs. In the water, sea lions and fur seals use their fore flippers to propel themselves, with a wing-like flying motion, using their hind flippers to steer (the exact opposite of true seals).

      http://www.infurmation.com/images/3_furseals.jpg

    • 2 years ago
  • EthicalVegan
    • 0
      EthicalVegan  
    • Image
    • ...Continued...

      Sea Otter

      Sea otters are the smallest of all marine mammals. At birth, they are about 22 inches long and weigh approximately five pounds. Adult males grow to be about 58 inches long and weigh 60Ð85 pounds. Unlike other marine mammals, sea otters do not have a protective layer of blubber to shield them from cold water. To compensate, they have extremely thick fur that traps warm air between hairs and insulates the body.

      http://www.infurmation.com/images/3_seaotter.jpg

      ...Continued...

    • 2 years ago
  • EthicalVegan
    • 0
      EthicalVegan  
    • Image
    • ...Continued...

      Black Bear

      American black bears (Ursus americanus) are usually true to their name, but you might spot one who is brown, reddish, yellowish, or even cream-colored. They are the most widely distributed and smallest of the three bears found in North America. The other two, the polar bear and the grizzly bear, are much more restricted in their distribution.

      http://www.infurmation.com/images/3_blackbear2.jpg

      ...Continued...

    • 2 years ago
  • EthicalVegan
  • EthicalVegan
    • 0
      EthicalVegan  
    • Image
    • ...Continued...

      Seal

      True seals (a group that doesn't include the fur seal) belong to the family Phocidae. Seals lack ear flaps and the ability to rotate their hind flippers forward to walk on land, which sea lions can do. Instead they pull themselves forward by their fore flippers, dragging their hind flippers behind them, with an inchworm-like motion. In the water, however, they are amazingly graceful, using their hind flippers in a sculling motion to propel themselves while steering with their front flippers. Some species are deep divers—the northern elephant seal dives regularly to approximately 2500 feet and stays under routinely for 20-30 minutes per dive.

      http://www.infurmation.com/images/3_harpseal.jpg

      ...Continued...

    • 2 years ago
  • EthicalVegan
  • EthicalVegan
    • 0
      EthicalVegan  
    • Image
    • ...Continued...

      Opossum

      The opossum (properly, the Virginia opossum—Didelphis virginiana) is the only marsupial found north of Mexico. Marsupials are distinguished by their unique mode of reproduction: the young are born in an almost embryonic form and make their way to the pouch in their mother's abdomen, where they are nourished for what in other mammals would be most of the gestational period.

      http://www.infurmation.com/images/3_opossum.jpg

      ...Continued...

    • 2 years ago
  • EthicalVegan
  • EthicalVegan
  • EthicalVegan
    • 0
      EthicalVegan  
    • Image
    • ...Continued...

      Coyote

      The popular name for the coyote comes from the Aztec word coyotl, which can be loosely translated as "trickster." Taxonomy classifies the coyote (Canis latrans) as a close relative of the wolf and the domestic dog. So close, in fact, that it is still a scientific detective story as to how much admixing has occurred between the groups.

      http://www.infurmation.com/images/3_coyote2.jpg

      ...Continued...

    • 2 years ago
  • EthicalVegan
    • 0
      EthicalVegan  
    • Image
    • ...Continued...

      Rabbit

      Few animals are as content to sit unmoving for as long as rabbits are. As prey animals, rabbits go to extremes not to advertise themselves as available to be eaten—but that isn't to say they don't let their guard down once in a while. If lucky, the patient observer may see them in the early morning or evening hours in spirited and spontaneous chases of other rabbits, or energetically hopping and leaping about—revealing this animal's playful nature. While rabbits lead lives full of concern and fear, they sometimes display a joie de vivre that we can envy.

      http://www.infurmation.com/images/3_rabbit2.jpg

      ...Continued...

    • 2 years ago
  • EthicalVegan
    • 0
      EthicalVegan  
    • Image
    • ... Continued...

      Fox

      Of the five species of foxes found in North America, only two are commonly seen: the red fox and the gray fox. Gray foxes are known to be native to North America, but whether the red fox was ever native is a subject of debate. It seems likely that the red fox was, probably arriving by the same land bridge used by the first humans during the last Ice Age. Many red foxes were brought to North America from Europe in the 1700s for sport hunting, and they remain popular prey for hunters and trappers.

      http://www.infurmation.com/images/3_fox2.jpg

      ...Continued...

    • 2 years ago
  • EthicalVegan
    • 0
      EthicalVegan  
    • Image
    • Mink

      The mink (Mustela vison) is a member of the weasel family, which also includes skunks, otters, and wolverines. They are perhaps best know for their dark brown fur, which turns white at the chin and runs to black at the tips of their tails. They have long, slender torsos atop short legs. Full-grown females are usually 17 to 21 inches long and weigh 1.25 to 1.75 pounds, while full-grown males are usually 21 to 24 inches in length and weigh 2 to 3.75 pounds.

      http://www.infurmation.com/images/3_mink.jpg

      ...Continued...

    • 2 years ago
  • EthicalVegan
  • EthicalVegan
    • 0
      EthicalVegan  
    • ...Continued...

      Fur Trim
      The fur industry is working on a whole new line. No longer limited to full-length mink coats or fox-fur jackets, fur trim is the rage. From suit collars to glove linings, fur trim is being used as an accessory for many fashion items. Fur-trimmed items currently are a half billion-dollar industry. Fur trim is a frivolous luxury responsible for the deaths of millions of animals each year. The number of animals killed for fur trim is expected to overtake the number of animals killed for full-fur garments. Because the trim trade doesn't place as much emphasis on pelt quality, color, and uniformity, the quality of care given to furbearers is diminished.

    • 2 years ago
  • EthicalVegan
    • 0
      EthicalVegan  
    • Fur Factory Farms
      More than 45 million animals worldwide, including raccoon dogs, rabbits, foxes, mink, and chinchillas, are raised in cages and killed each year for their fur. Not only are cage-raised animals killed inhumanely, but they suffer from numerous physical and behavioral abnormalities induced by the stress of caging conditions. After spending their short lives in squalid conditions, animals raised on fur farms are killed by cruel methods that preserve the pelt, such as gassing, neck-breaking and anal electrocution.

      Millions of wild animals, including bobcats, coyotes, foxes, lynx, raccoons, and wolves, suffer and die in traps each year. Countless dogs and cats, deer, birds and other animals—including threatened and endangered animals—are also injured and killed each year by the indiscriminate traps. Traps, including steel-jaw leghold traps, body-gripping traps, and wire neck snares, are inhumane devices that inflict great pain and suffering. Both the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) and the American Animal Hospital Association have declared the steel-jaw leghold trap to be inhumane.

      Even companion animals like dogs and cats are at risk of severe injury and death in traps and snares. A sampling of HSUS case history reports reveals just how traumatic the experience can be, both for pets and their owners.

      Cats and Dogs
      A 1998 investigation by The Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) exposed the international fur industry's ugly secret: the widespread slaughter of companion animals—domestic dogs and cats—for the manufacture of clothing, accessories, and trinkets. Investigators witnessed firsthand the brutal slaughter of domestic dogs and cats in China and other Asian nations. Many of these animals are raised in cold, unsanitary breeding compounds. Some are strays. Others are obviously pets who were most likely stolen. And the killing methods are grisly. Dogs—German shepherds, chows, and mixed breeds—are bludgeoned or bled to death. Cats are often strangled by wire nooses.

      Canada's annual commercial seal hunt is the largest slaughter of marine mammals on the planet. Over 300,000 harp and hooded seals are killed for their pelts each year, with many skinned alive, according to independent veterinary reports. The last time this many seals were killed—in the 1950s and 1960s—the harp seal population was reduced by as much as two-thirds. In 2005, 98.5% of the seals killed were just two months of age or younger. At the time of slaughter, many had not yet eaten their first solid meal or taken their first swim. They literally had no escape from the "hunters."

      Newborn and Fetal Karakul Lambs
      Garments made from the pelts of newborn karakul lambs—often referred to as "Persian lamb," "karakul," and "astrakhan,"—are a staple of the fur fashion world. So too are garments made of fetal karakul lambs (known as "broadtail"), which the fur industry claims are crafted from animals born prematurely due to accident or exposure. In March 2000, investigators with The Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) toured a karakul sheep farm near Bukhara, in the former Soviet republic of Uzbekistan, and found that pregnant ewes are in fact routinely slaughtered for these fetal pelts. Graphic videotape shot at the farm shows a pregnant ewe held down, her throat slit and her stomach slashed wide so that a worker could remove the developing fetus—the "raw material" for coats, vests, and other broadtail fashions. What's more, contrary to the industry's claims that karakul lamb fur is merely a byproduct of meat production, HSUS investigators videotaped newborn lambs displayed as "samples" of pelt colors before being sent to their death. The pelts were saved, the tiny carcasses discarded as trash.

      ...Continued...

    • 2 years ago
  • EthicalVegan
    • 0
      EthicalVegan  
    • Image
    • http://www.genesis-wildlife.org/gallery/BabyFoxTree.jpg

      Facts About the Fur Trade

      Each year the fur industry kills over 50 million animals for fashion, not including rabbits (no reliable data on rabbits killed worldwide for fur is available).

      Number of Animals to Make a Fur Coat:
      12-15 lynx
      10-15 wolves or coyotes
      15-20 foxes
      60-80 minks
      27-30 racoons
      10-12 beavers
      60-100 squirrels

      MORE Facts About the Fur Trade... Continued...

    • 2 years ago
  • EthicalVegan
  • EthicalVegan
    • 0
      EthicalVegan  
    • Stella McCartney on Fur and the Environment

      "Well I don't do leather and I don't do fur and it's not just because I don't eat animals or that I think that half a billion animals a year shouldn't be killed for the sake of fashion. It's because I also believe very much in the connection between fur and leather and the environment. There's a huge connection.

      Now, I think more and more people will start to take notice of that—the use of water for tanneries, the chemicals that are used—there's a huge impact environmentally. I try and just think responsibly in the way that I approach business."

      "Stella McCartney on ecology, luxury and life," International Herald Tribune, March 24, 2009

    • 2 years ago
  • EthicalVegan
    • 0
      EthicalVegan  
    • Image
    • http://www.hsus.org/furfree/cruel_reality/enviro/fur_environment.html

      Toxic Fur
      Fur production is harmful to animals, the environment and human health.
      Now you can add another reason to avoid fur, besides the inherent cruelty: it's bad for the environment.

      Over the past several years, investigative footage of animals being skinned alive in China has caused an outcry.

      Many apparel companies have also been tied to falsely advertised or falsely labeled fur, much of it from China.

      For these reasons, more and more companies and consumers have rejected fur, adopting fur-free corporate policies and discriminating with their purchasing power.

      Perhaps in a bid to turn attention away from these troubling issues, in 2007 the Fur Council of Canada revived its past advertising campaign touting animal fur as synonymous with eco-fashion, using the slogan "Fur is Green."

      At a time when "green" fashion is popular, however, eco-conscious consumers are wary of "greenwashing"—marketing a product as more environmentally friendly than it really is.

      Polluting and Energy Inefficient

      According to criteria stipulated by the Fur Council of Canada, "environmentally friendly apparel and accessories should be made from natural materials that are...renewable, durable, long-lasting, reusable, recyclable, biodegradable, non-polluting, [and] energy efficient in their production, use and disposal."

      Our new paper "Toxic Fur" addresses the fur industry's claims and demonstrates how the use of animal fur by the fashion industry is far from environmentally friendly. Rather, the production of fur for fashion imposes significant adverse impacts on both the environment and human health.

      If you or your company cares about the environment, avoid buying, wearing, or selling animal fur.

    • 2 years ago
  • EthicalVegan
  • EthicalVegan
  • EthicalVegan
    • 0
      EthicalVegan  
    • ...Continued...

      David Goldstein: "This is real fur. This is similar to raccoon dog. Dog. You don't want dog around your neck?

      Salesperson: "No."

      David Goldstein: "I don't think so."

      The salesperson said she didn't know. The owner told me his wholesaler said it was fake fur.

      "What if I told you this was dog? What do you think?"

      We also found fur that our expert said was consistent with what they have found to be raccoon dog on a coat at the Burlington Coat Factory in Huntington Beach. It's made by Rocawear, the line created by singer Jay-Z. The salesperson didn't seem to care.

      David Goldstein: "In the dog family. What do you think of that?"

      Salesperson: "I don't care. I come to work. I do my job and I go home."

      The label said nothing about the fur on the collar. Neither did the label on a men's jacket we found at Bloomingdale's. The salesperson said it was a fake.

      "I really don't think it's real fur," the salesperson said.

      Our expert said real fur, possibly fox or rabbit. The bottom line is none of these manufacturers or stores are doing anything wrong because of a secret loophole in the federal labeling laws.

      "The loophole is that if the fur is valued at less than $150, there doesn't have to be any mention on the label that there is animal fur on the jacket," Grzybowski said.

      That is right, so no matter what the label says if the garment just has a small amount of fur, they don't have to tell you if it's real or fake! So how do you know?

      One way is to try and look deep into the fur.

      "You want to push the hairs apart and try to get down to the base of the fabric," Grzybowski said. "If you see skin, that is real fur."

      On fake fur, if you look closely you see fabric -- not skin -- at the base of the fur.

      "The differences are stark," Grzybowski said.

      If you cut them open you can really tell the difference.

      "This is your real fur, it's leather," Grzybowski said while pointing out a sample of real and fake fur. "This is your fake fur. This is fabric."

      That's the best way to tell -- not looking at the label or listening to the salesperson.

    • 2 years ago
  • EthicalVegan
    • 0
      EthicalVegan  
    • http://cbs2.com/goldstein/Fake.Fur.Dog.2.1287638.html

      Original investigative video...

      Is Your Faux Fur Really Dog?

      David Goldstein
      LOS ANGELES (CBS) ―

      Is it fur or is it fake? We went undercover with hidden cameras looking for fur-free fashions. But no matter what some of the salespeople said, we looked inside. You won't believe some of the things we found.

      "This is real fur, this is similar to raccoon dog. Dog. You don't want dog around your neck? No
      I don't think so."

      We sent our undercover producer out shopping. Along with Pierre Grzybowski, a fur expert with the Humane Society of the United States.

      At Arden B. -- a popular chain of women's clothing stores -- at South Coast Plaza in Costa Mesa, we found a vest for $68. The label says suede faux fur.

      "Does it have fur," our producer asked.

      "Anything that we have... we don't carry real fur," the salesperson replied.

      "You don't carry real fur?"

      "No," the salesperson confirmed.

      She said Arden B. is fur free! A second salesperson said the vest was too cheap to be real.

      "OK, so no chance?"

      "Absolutely, no way," the salesperson said.

      So we bought it.

      In the car our fur expert cut open the backing.

      "This is the inside of the fur trim," Grzybowski said adding, "you can see little pieces of skin that have been stitched together."

      It turns out, according to our expert; this faux fur is a phony!

      David Goldstein: "That's actually the skin of an animal?"

      Pierre Grzybowski, HSUS: "Yes, whatever animal has been killed for this, this is their skin."

      David Goldstein: "Definitely real?"

      Pierre Grzybowski, HSUS: "Definitely real. Absolutely."

      He says it's consistent with rabbit or fox that has been dyed. You might think that kind of fur is worth a lot of money. But not these small pieces.

      Pierre Grzybowski, HSUS: "This could have cost a couple of dollars if even that much."

      We went back to Arden B.

      David Goldstein: "Did you know this was real fur?

      Salesperson: "I thought, I think it's fake fur."

      The salesperson says she was duped by the label. The company said when we told them what it was, they pulled it off the rack.

      Across the mall at Grasshoppers children's clothing we asked the same questions about a $350 girl's jacket.

      "Is that fur?"

      "It's not real fur," the salesperson replied.

      "I just don't want to put real fur on a baby."

      "I know."

      "So, it's faux fur?"

      "It's fake."

      This time the label said the shell is nylon, lining and padding polyester. No mention of the trim. The salesperson said that means it's a fake.

      "If it's real fur they say real fur," the salesperson said.

      But after cutting it open...

      "Let's see what the backing is," our fur expert said while opening the jacket. "This is the skin and it has absorbed the pink ink."

      Animal skin. Our expert says it's consistent with something called raccoon dog.

      David Goldstein: "What is raccoon dog?"

      Pierre Grzybowski, HSUS: "It's the most misrepresented and unlabeled fur sold here and this animal was found to be skinned alive in massive numbers."

      Investigators from the Swill Animal Protection Agency found raccoon dogs being raised by the millions in China -- caged and in inhumane conditions. A member of the dog family, their pelts sell for less than it would cost to make fake fur.

      David Goldstein: "This is real fur. This is similar to raccoon dog. Dog. You don't want dog around your neck?

      Salesperson: "No."

      David Goldstein: "I don't think so."

      Continued...

    • 2 years ago
more from Community:
from the community

top videos