Community | February 10, 2010 | 59 comments

Dubai’s Sinking Multi-Billion Dollar Man-Made Islands -- Far More Costly To The Local Ecosystem

Image
sfinfgeld2
Man-made islands shaped to resemble our globe, constructed using 11 billion cubic feet of dredged sand and at an expense of billions of dollars...sounds like a wild and crazy movie plot. In reality, this is one saga that continues playing out at the expense of the marine environment...and now it's being slowly but surely reclaimed by Mother Nature.


http://www.greenwala.com/community/blogs/all/4661-Dubai-s-Sinking-Multi-Billion-...
  1. groups:
    Community,   Green,   Earth and Science,   Science,   6 more
  2. tags:
    Green Environment Nature Architecture 6 more
  3.     
    |

59 comments // Dubai’s Sinking Multi-Billion Dollar Man-Made Islands -- Far More Costly To The Local Ecosystem

  • Shakinah_Armstrong
    • 0
      Shakinah_Armstrong  
    • Man fuck that shit!!! It needs to sink all the way to the ocean floor. Why the fuck are they using tax money to build shit that we wont even get to see. i don't care if no one like what im saying it's the damn truth. We got so much going on in the world that severly needs attention and this is what our world leaders are more concerned with. making more money for themselves but don't want to take care of home with the people that do the hard work to make our country turn. Shit!!!! What is wrong with people as human beings for that matter? I swear to GOD if i was rich... there will be so many people taken care of and there will be so many things to do to help my people and my community. but noooo... rich fuckers dont think like that. GREED!!!!!! Stop the drama stop the bullshit and let's do what we need to do to make a better future for our children, our ancestors did it and so did our elders. Return the fucking favor.

    • 1 year ago
  • Pajarito7
    • -1
      Pajarito7  
    • This is History people. These man made islands will be a landmark or "permanent statue" of history showing how earth looked like in our times of our lives. It's like the Mayans and Egyptians leaving behind those gigantic man made pyramids. Why are they there? What was is for? But islands shaped as the earth? I think this is great whether they win or lose because it will be a historical site (even under sea level) for the humans that live thousands of years to come.

    • 2 years ago
  • onechance
  • Kle_Alasi
  • kreddig
  • bailey78
  • kreddig
    • 0
      kreddig  
    • I thought the West was evil for our decadence and wealth? Say what you will about the west, but we haven't tried to promulgate or build anything this useless or decadent. Down with the Sand Planet!

    • 2 years ago
  • Davidod
  • bailey78
  • thedirtman
  • pandaman2105
    • +2
      pandaman2105  
    • Dubai is totally fucked up, look at all of these things: these world islands, the palm islands, the tallest tower, their unethical employment standards, the raping of women that goes unreported, and their LOCATION! they can't accept that their desert region totally can't support all that they want to achieve.

      oh, not to mention the plans for their underwater hotel!

      all that shit fucks up everything. false islands in the ocean; environmental damage. billion dollar skyscrapers and tourist attractions; money going to their economy that will only want to build MORE. overall goal; useless, considering they should use the money to help improve their system and some neighboring nations.

      the rich, pretentious types who choose to go there are completely blinded by the false glamour and are probably the types who don't understand the serious economic and minority issues we have going on everywhere!

      sinking island is no surprise.

      ...somewhat of a rant, but the place is ridiculous to me.
      DON'T GO. seriously, opt for a place with real culture and natural beauty.

    • 2 years ago
  • samoanj
  • QuestionGeek
  • pandaman2105
  • Shakinah_Armstrong
  • skyblueeyedjenne
    • 0
      skyblueeyedjenne  
    • I don't want to 'diss' Dubai for having grand architectural aspirations. They follow through on some remarkable spectacles, but as with so many developments, concern for precisely what impact it will have on the environment always seems to be at the bottom of the totem pole. Any entity building on such a vast scale should be forced to adhere to a consistent set of ec-principles throughout the entire construction process. That's my feeling, at least.

    • 2 years ago
  • Logos51891
  • Logos51891
  • dalistuff
  • QuestionGeek
    • 0
      QuestionGeek  
    • Doesn't their city now have the tallest building in the world? This title once belonged to the USA, then Singapore, now Dubai holds the world record for tallest inhabited building. It's called the Burj Khalifa Tower. I believe it's an astounding 2,720 feet in height.

    • 2 years ago
  • WrittenWithWit
  • ScorpioGee
  • QuestionGeek
    • 0
      QuestionGeek  
    • That's fine, if they would just get their human rights act together and stop their discrimination against their workers, who are little more than modified slaves, and let's not mention the rape of boys (cause they can't get pregnant and are defenseless), discrimination against gays and women as usual

    • 2 years ago
  • feefer2010
  • ScorpioGee
    • +1
      ScorpioGee  
    • Dubai's Urban planing is Nucking Futs! :O

      They have a 'Disney World' that's three times bigger. They're going to have not one but two more palmetto islands and the third one is going to be huge. And according to Thomas ZD's link they're going to have multiple skyscrapers, and A SPACEPORT?! YES. A SPACEPORT!

      I actually admire Dubai for actually bringing their plans into reality and I wish my country was more zelous in changing it's infrastructure like Dubai. But they're treating their construction workers as indentured servants and there was a lot of injuries/deaths.

      And how will the city will bring in the right amount of tourist. You cant rely on just rich people to bring in income to pay off the debt from construction you have to bring in middle income people too. And how will Dubai deal with the culture clash of westerners if the region they live in is conservative?

    • 2 years ago
  • Almibry
    • 0
      Almibry  
    • ScorpioGee:

      Their workers are more along the lines of chattel, many of them have their passports confiscated as part of their contract, and when they lose their jobs (which is happening more often with the economic downturn) they are not returned. Yes the city is big and modern and there's all sorts of shiny things, but I would like to see it firebombed.

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
    • +4
      KSirys  
    • hahaha... all that money could've been used for something good... but noooooo... why help the poor when the rich can look pretty!

      KARMA is a BITCH!!

    • 2 years ago
  • Tim_Hjersted
  • QuestionGeek
    • -1
      QuestionGeek  
    • KSirys:

      That's easy to say when you're poor. How do you know you wouldn't do the same thing if you were rich?

      Here's an example: I drove a small car for many years(Toyota Corolla, Chevrolet Sprint, etc). One day I got tired of being cramped. I'm 6'1" 182lbs. Now I drive a Chrysler 300 and although it burns more energy, it's engineered better, and most importantly my knees don't have to be in my chest when I drive - I'M COMFORTABLE for a change.

      I have a good friend who is the same physical build as me that went through the same thing. He used to drive a small Dodge Colt, now he drives a large Honda Accord.

      Assuming that you are American, that automatically makes you one of the worst offenders of the rest of the world in terms of frivolous waste. It's called affluenza. The USA wastes more resources and energy than any place in the world, regardless if the country is rich or not. I believe it uses 65% of the worlds resources, and yet it's only 5% of the population. What other country would come up with paper cup guards (Starbucks) because the cup is too hot? Did anyone ever stop to think that if they hold the cup a different way, the wasteful cup guards wouldn't have to be used, and we could save millions of trees and resource waste? Or gee, how about using that napkin to hold the cup that you're going to grab anyway when you buy your Starbucks drink and other adult candy substances?

    • 2 years ago
  • KSirys
  • QuestionGeek
    • -1
      QuestionGeek  
    • KSirys:

      I do know what I'm talking about. Do you? You made a blanket statement about them not helping people. Well gee, who do you think builds all those buildings and works at all those restaurants, sells real estate, drives the limousines, etc.. Do the people that check into the hotels just check themselves in or do bell hops help them? Dubai is a boom town and helps lots of people get employed and have a better life. You can't just look at one side of the coin.

    • 2 years ago
  • Davidod
  • KSirys
    • 0
      KSirys  
    • QuestionGeek:

      Of course i do, that's why i didn't target just one individual unlike you, who said, "That's easy to say when you're poor. How do you know you wouldn't do the same thing if you were rich?"
      Well, since you decided to target me and ask me a stupid question, I figure i lower my standards and make a stupid comment.

      How about next time, you get to know the person you want to question before you make a stupid comment?

    • 2 years ago
  • QuestionGeek
    • +1
      QuestionGeek  
    • Davidod:

      It tastes nothing like the delicious and inexpensive espresso in Europe, but what can I do. I live the U.S.A.
      And ok. I'm stupid...You seem nice, wasn't trying to make assumptions about anything/

    • 2 years ago
  • 02
    • +1
      02  
    • Yes, just a little piece of the money people throw away on stupid stuff could change the whole world - for the good.

      But - no - just stupid stuff...

    • 2 years ago
  • Bushido
    • +4
      Bushido  
    • "Listen, lad. I've built this kingdom up from nothing. When I started here, all there was was swamp. All the kings said I was daft to build a castle in a swamp, but I built it all the same, just to show 'em. It sank into the swamp. So, I built a second one. That sank into the swamp. So I built a third one. That burned down, fell over, then sank into the swamp. But the fourth one stayed up. An' that's what your gonna get, lad -- the strongest castle in these islands."

    • 2 years ago
  • EdJoyProductions
    • +1
      EdJoyProductions  
    • Bushido:

      King of Swamp Castle: We live in a bloody swamp. We need all the land we can get.
      Prince Herbert: But I don't like her.
      King of Swamp Castle: Don't like her? What's wrong with her? She's beautiful, she's rich, she's got huge... tracts of land.

    • 2 years ago
  • derk
  • Agent_Alpha
  • Idiolect
  • kreddig
  • keanu101
  • EdJoyProductions
  • H3ADLINE
  • Davidod
  • bailey78
  • kreddig
  • bailey78
  • kreddig
  • bailey78
  • KSirys
  • everydayxangels
  • jjammedjr
  • Davidod
    • 0
      Davidod  
    • jjammedjr:

      Setting aside the effects on the ecosystem, the over-building of Dubai was HUGELY successful from a stimulative standpoint. Think of it: the trickle-down was massive, and even the poorest laborer benefited from the growth during the period of peak growth. During the boom, Dubai had a hard time finding laborers, and hence paid competitive salaries (and even relied on imported workers).

      Problem always is, such massive boom/bust periods are ultimately unsustainable, and follow a cyclical path. Such patterns are as old as Man has been here: remember the Tower of Babel, where Man's hubris said they would build a tower that went to the heavens as a sign of their greatness? Same ol', same ol'.

      News-flash: China's experienced a similar building boom, with recently-completed buildings still vacant with a vast over-supply of offices (commercial real estate boom to be followed by crash). Do you think a country that built the Great Wall of China, one of the Planet's biggest government construction projects ever, might be a TAD prone to overbuilding, too?

    • 2 years ago
  • jubal
    • +1
      jubal  
    • This whole project smacked of opulence and failure when I first heard about it. Yeah it had the wow factor going for it, but in the end, wow is just shock and awe.

    • 2 years ago
  • ThomasZD
  • bailey78
more from Community:

top videos