Community | July 21, 2010 | 448 comments

500,000 Jobs Available in Arizona...as Mexican Migratory Workers Abandon Farms Fleeing SB 1070

Image
jubal
Arizona farmers are experiencing a crisis due to the recent departure of over 500,000 Campesinos (Farm Workers). Jose Diaz Balart, reporting on Telemundo this evening interviewed farm owners asking them exactly what they plan to do with tens of thousands of acres of peppers waiting to be harvested. One farmer reported "well we don't exactly know what we are going to do...all our workers have left because of fear around the new SB1070 law. We are putting out the word to Employment Development departments all over the country, but we doubt any self-respecting American is going to be willing to work for what we pay."

Balart asked the gentlemen being interviewed "How much do you pay?"

The farmer responded "We pay $2.00 per bushel."

Balart asked him "How long does it take for the average farm worker to harvest a bushel?"

The farmer replied "The best and fastest workers can fill a bushel in 2 hours. You see all these peppers have to be picked by hand...no one has gone and invented a pepper harvesting machine so it has to be done manually."

Balart then asked the farmer "How many African Americans do you have working for you?"

The farmer looked surprised "African Americans?" he smiles..."You ain't gonna be seeing any African Americans doing these jobs...not because we wouldn't hire them...because they just never apply for these jobs."

Balart says to the farmer "So in reality you are basically paying around $1.00 per hour of work for people on the farm...is that a fair assessment?"

The farmer responds indignantly "That is the way its always been done, but years ago we gave them all a raise...they used to get a dollar a bushel, but we decided to double it to keep them working for us."

Balart responds..."that was mighty generous of you to do that. What about other Americans...we have over 2 million unemployed...what do you have to say to them?"

The farmer responds "Well tell them to all come to Arizona...its back breaking work...its very hot...but they could at least get a job."

Balart responds "But what you are paying is less than the federal minimum wage, how do you justify that?"

The farmer responds "well, somebodies got to do it, it has to be done by people...we can't pay them minimum wage and expect to make any money on this harvest. People are complaining all the time that they "don't have a job...that there ain't any work" well now here you go "we need to fill hundreds of thousands of jobs...people should seriously consider moving her and working for the hundreds of farms in desperate need of workers...otherwise all this food is going to go to waste."

Do you think that Americans would work for the same price that the Campesinos or (migratory farm workers) make? Do you think that this is good for our country? Who is going to do these jobs and work for substandard wages?
  1. groups:
    Community,   US Politics,   US News,   Progressive America,   5 more
  2. tags:
    Immigration Arizona Farming Telemundo 5 more
  3.     
    |

448 comments // 500,000 Jobs Available in Arizona...as Mexican Migratory Workers Abandon Farms Fleeing SB 1070

  • jubal
    • 0
      jubal  
    • Image
    • http://www.takeourjobs.org/

      Here is the unvarnished truth...Americans don't want these jobs...I promised more information about this issue well here is some of it. The video is rendering and I will post that later as a separate post.

      UFW is offering the jobs to anyone who wants them. You can take the job a migrant farm worker is doing right now. All you have to do is apply. You will earn around $8 per hour, but be prepared to produce as much as they do for that kind of money. Slackers need not apply.

      From the site...

      There are two issues facing our nation--high unemployment and undocumented people in the workforce--that many Americans believe are related.

      Missing from the debate on both issues is an honest recognition that the food we all eat - at home, in restaurants and workplace cafeterias (including those in the Capitol) - comes to us from the labor of undocumented farm workers.

      Agriculture in the United States is dependent on an immigrant workforce. Three-quarters of all crop workers working in American agriculture were born outside the United States. According to government statistics, since the late 1990s, at least 50% of the crop workers have not been authorized to work legally in the United States.

      We are a nation in denial about our food supply. As a result the UFW has initiated the "Take Our Jobs" campaign.

      Farm workers are ready to welcome citizens and legal residents who wish to replace them in the field. We will use our knowledge and staff to help connect the unemployed with farm employers. Just fill out the form to the right and continue on to the request for job application.

    • 1 year ago
  • jubal
  • TargetMouse
  • congoboy
    • 0
      congoboy  
    • sounds like an excellent plan. dont need no stinkin guest citizenship program in mexico though. just like they do here we can cross illegally, might not get as warm a welcome as the ones comin here though. mexico has very strict immigration laws and you dont want to end up in a mexican prison if you know what i mean. wink wink

    • 1 year ago
  • jubal
    • +1
      jubal  
    • Twice now Congoboy says that I am doing a disservice to the readers saying that $200 a month is what people live on in Latin American Countries...so I am posting this rebuttal....

      I will use Ecuador as an example because that is the country I am most familiar with. My family is from there.

      In Ecuador the minimum wage is $240 per month. The average person not working for the government makes around $400 per month. Government workers who are clerical, accounting, lower ministry type jobs, public servants, make an average of $800 per month. Higher government officials in the Judiciary, Ministries, College professors, make on the average of $1200 per month.

      Some government officials at the top...especially the Judiciary have given themselves raises that put them earning around $4000 per month and this has caused quite a backlash among the people...the president is trying to reign in their parade, but the Attorney General has proven a very formidable opponent and he has not been ousted.

      President Correa wants to put the Judiciary salaries in check because they are way out of line...especially when you consider that most of their expenses are also paid...separately.

      Now as far as expenses here is a sample budget for someone in my family who makes $600 per month:

      $200 Mortgage payment on an Apartment that costs $45,000
      $100 Utilities for Electricity, gas, water and garbage
      $65 Telephone and Cable TV
      $300 Food costs for a family of 4
      $100 Tuition costs
      $100 Transportation Costs

      This monthly outlay doesn't include any cell phones, entertainment, or clothing.

      The total is $865. The only thing that saves them every month is that their father...who lives here in the US and makes $1000 a month...sends them $300 per month. If he wasn't able to make that money here...they wouldn't be able to survive. The kids would have to drop out of University...but that would only save them $100.

      Ecuador is on the dollar...their currency was trading at 25000 to 1 before they switched. My fathers best friend went there in the late 90's when it was like this and bought a 20 acre farm for $2000 and moved there because he could live like a millionaire as a retired doctor...he opened up an orphanage and a clinic and he married a new wife. He lives his name is Dr. King and he sure lives like one with his pension of $3000 a month.

      To solve their economic crisis Ecuador closed all the banks for two weeks and people lost their life savings in the process. Little old ladies who had sold their houses for 2 Million of their currency and thought they were going to be able to live off the interest got $50K in dollars when the banks reopened in dollars. Whereas they had a home that covered an entire city block when they sold...the could scarcely buy a run down apartment for the $50K.

      Luxury condos in town go for from $120K to $180K...a nice decent apartment less than 10 years old goes for around $60K to $100K.

      The average new car price is around $12K and the interest rate they charge if you finance a car through a dealer is 24%.

      Banks only pay 2% on savings.

      When you look at this you will understand that in order for most families to survive...they have to have at least three wage earners and they have to maximize what they have. If they are lucky enough to own land they will usually build a 4 story building that has three apartments that can be rented out so that they can live...and if they are in a commercial zone...they will have store fronts to rent out on the first floor.

      I hope that gives you a better appreciation of what the standard of living there for an average working class person or family...single people can scarcely survive there on Minimum Wage.

    • 1 year ago
  • jubal
    • +1
      jubal  
    • One of the biggest issues about this SB1070, and i have heard many police officers say this...that Latinos are not going to call the police when there is an emergency because of the fear that one of their family members might end up getting deported.

      What people need to realize that there are many, many Latino families that have a mixture of Citizens, Naturalized Citizens, and Illegals...its quite common. Often times the so called illegals are in some kind of process to get legalized...but that process can take 10 years or more. So they wait it out and keep a low profile until they their turn comes up to be considered, heard, and present all their proofs. Lots of times, when someone gets arrested...the fact that they are in the process of getting their status changed is not taken into effect. They are illegal and that is that.

      The biggest fear these people have is that their families are going to be ripped apart because of this law.

    • 1 year ago
  • Joe_Medina
  • Idoknow19
    • +4
      Idoknow19  
    • My question is this: instead of attacking the illegal immigrants who flee deplorable living conditions and militant drug cartels in Mexico, why is no one questioning the businesses that bring them in?

      Yes, I get that if you're in this country, you should be here legally. However, many companies that hire illegal immigrants bring them in under false pretenses. In Tyson chicken factories, workers may toil in unsanitary conditions at subsistence wages for years under promises from managers that they and their family will achieve citizenship by doing so and the lack of a working knowledge of the English language can lead to murky contractual agreements, misleading promises, and broken dreams when the authorities find out.

      Is it so hard to consider that at least some of these people are not the law-breaking monsters we imagine, but instead the victims of a borderline feudal agriculture system and an exploding global gap between the rich and poor?

    • 1 year ago
  • Introspective
  • onemalefla
  • coleman89
    • -2
      coleman89  
    • onemalefla:

      Not really. The signs for white people should say:

      "Where are my free benefits?"

      "Why aren't other people paying for me to sit around?"

      Blah blah blah.

      Like the "supposed" farmer said, all these unemployed sit around and wait for hand outs rather than get out there and do what they have to do.

    • 1 year ago
  • Idoknow19
    • +2
      Idoknow19  
    • coleman89:

      Speaking as one of those "layabouts", I can fervently assert that your overly-simplistic view of the situation is maddening.

      The job hunt is as bad, if not worse for myself and others like me than the news outlets make it out to be and I have a Bachelor's degree! To then assert that other people, possessing even fewer qualifications, are simply being "lazy" and that's why they cannot find a job is as ignorant as it is vapid.

      But perhaps I'm wrong. I'm sure families with a mortgage and two kids to feed would rather live on $300 a week than the $1,000 a week they made before wild, unregulated financial speculation and massive redistribution of wealth UPWARD tanked their dreams before they even had a chance to make them.

    • 1 year ago
  • jubal
  • jubal
    • +2
      jubal  
    • Idoknow19:

      In Eugene Oregon we have people with Master's degrees working as waiters and waitresses, they work as sanitation workers or get part time jobs working at a retail store. Having a Master's degree is not a guaranteed employment.

    • 1 year ago
  • trut
    • -1
      trut  
    • onemalefla:

      Why do you want the USA to look like Mexico(shithole)?
      What is wrong with doing the work yourselves? If farmers can't pay a decent wage let the whole country starve until food is appropriately priced.

    • 1 year ago
  • onemalefla
  • Joe_Medina
  • Joe_Medina
    • +1
      Joe_Medina  
    • I know people (Hispanic) in Arizona and it is not only the illegals which are leaving or planning to leave the state several Latino business owners are also packing up and leaving. I dont know but I do know that Arizona will definitely feel the abscense, There is a pretty good and actually kinda funny it is called "A day Without a Mxican" I think it's on You Tube but im not sure.

    • 1 year ago
  • jubal
    • 0
      jubal  
    • Joe_Medina:

      Joe Medina...thanks for posting that. It was a poignant film. People should watch that movie because it really demonstrates how much the Mexican people as a whole contribute to our country.

      Yes indeed many business owners are packing up and leaving the state if the efforts to quash it are not successful. Like I said before and I would believe it...the estimates are that as many as 2 million people will leave Arizona if this law becomes a reality.

      Arizona will feel it economically as it already has. There are now, more than ever, homes on the market. Since there is a glut of homes for sale...the prices have started to go down even further.

      When I recently returned from a trip to Ecuador, I was sitting next to a woman from Guayaquil who owned a home in San Diego, one in Riverside, and one in Tucson. She said that her home in Tucson she bought it for $150K three years ago...but now the home has dropped to around $80K as have many of the homes in that neighborhood, because already there has been a mass exodus of people from that community.

    • 1 year ago
  • Bradley_Bleck
    • +2
      Bradley_Bleck  
    • I'd say that even if the "facts" of this story can be called into question, the fundamental notion that migrant workers subsidize our cheap foods remains unchallenged. It is backbreaking work. I've picked strawberries, but only for "fun" and I'm done after a couple hours and a few flats of berries. I suppose if I relied on that for my living, I'd do better. Nonetheless, migrant workers lower the real cost of much of our food. We are either going to have to pay more for food, or get off our high horse about the alleged damage these people do to our economy and society.

    • 1 year ago
  • remanns
    • +6
      remanns  
    • If people REALLY want something enough, they WILL pay what it REALLY costs.
      As UNITED LABOR it is OUR job to help set that REAL cost.

      Even if peppers cost as caviar,....there will still be some peppers,....for some who can afford them. ( Personally,...I would grow my own, fresher, stronger,. and hell, they are YOURS. Worth some points )

      Remember,......WE who pick the peppers want to be the piper that calls the tune, and gives the feudal lords some pipe to SUCK.

    • 1 year ago
  • Daena_Smith
    • +1
      Daena_Smith  
    • Now, having been born and raised here in Arizona (43 yrs) first of all, I have to say, that pic just doesn't look like any place here in Arizona that I can think of. Strange enough, this article doesn't include where this "farmer" is located in Arizona either.

      It also says "Arizona Farmers" so I'm wondering what farmers are they talking about? Here in the southwest part of Arizona we are the lettuce capital of the world. We also do a fair amount of spinach, cauliflower and other vegetables during the winter. The farmers here bus people from Mexico to the fields then back to their homes. There are plenty of workers who live here locally as well.

      500,000 illegal immigrants gone. Remarkable amount of people leaving Arizona even before the law is enforced. I don't believe it for one minute. Where are they getting this information?

      Back in the late 80's I was a cashier for a local grocery store and on paydays the field workers would come in the store to cash their paychecks. Even THEN their bi-weekly paychecks were $500.00 or more, and that is over 20 years ago. I was amazed at how much they got paid. While I earned $5.00 an hour, which was good money then, they were earning more, tho I have to admit they work many more hours.

      You should see the brand new trucks and car field workers drive. I should be so lucky to buy a used one!

      So, again, I don't believe this article for one bit. It's a bit far fetched.

    • 1 year ago
  • congoboy
    • -2
      congoboy  
    • Daena_Smith:

      glad to see a first hand account and perspective. most of this story is hogwash hooey. but i am sure there will be some on here who will call you a liar, since many people want to only believe the negative of our society not caring whether its fact or fiction A+

    • 1 year ago
  • jubal
    • +1
      jubal  
    • Daena_Smith:

      First of all Daena...the report on Telemundo estimated 500K have already left Arizona...that number is a mixture of legals and illegals. They also estimate that close to 2 million are going to leave if the and when the law goes into effect. The estimate of 500K new jobs opening up would be a conservative estimate of jobs if all the 2 million legal Latinos and Hispanics leave the state.

      In the same report they did interview a farmer that seemed to be the worst of the exploiters that actually hire illegal aliens to work at their pepper farm.

      Next time they report on something like this I am planning on recording it and posting it so people can verify the facts. Some of what I reported is not perfectly accurate because I was cooking dinner and didn't get all the details. I reported what I recollected.

      Next time I will be more precise.

    • 1 year ago
  • remanns
    • +6
      remanns  
    • This is my deal----12$ an hour,....for 6 hr days ( not 10,....hell you can do this in shifts ) and I will make it to Arizona. And I wont do it without workmans comp because some idiot DAMN WELL MIGHT run over me with a tractor!

      The land owner has NO INNATE RIGHT to any certain profit level,....or even to be in any particular business. Tough breaks. Business does not have a " RIGHT " to serf/peasant/disposable/expendable "not quite a citizen so not-quite-human" employees used as cogs in their fucking agricultural machine.

    • 1 year ago
  • onemalefla
  • galwayman
    • +3
      galwayman  
    • remanns:

      I'd not do it for less then 12 an hour,with health benefits,sick days,workmans comp,all the usual benefits you get when you work! It's about time that these "farmers" got a dose of reality!

    • 1 year ago
  • congoboy
  • remanns
  • congoboy
    • -3
      congoboy  
    • remanns:

      a business owner has every right to make as much profit as he chooses. of course not all business owners care much about employees, from farm labor or other private sector jobs to government jobs. a man has a right to be a greedy bastard or take his profits and willing give them to someone in need. the government however has no right or place to redistribute the wealth of a hard working entrepreneur to where it sees fit, unless of course it is through fair and equitable taxation.

    • 1 year ago
  • Idoknow19
  • congoboy
  • Idoknow19
  • congoboy
  • congoboy
  • onemalefla
  • remanns
  • congoboy
    • -2
      congoboy  
    • remanns:

      well that suit at least picked a peck so he must be able to empathize with his workers. up here in wa state they make $10 an hour, not too bad for slave wages.

    • 1 year ago
  • congoboy
  • telcod
    • +2
      telcod  
    • So does this mean that Arizona will be the first state to achieve 100% employment? Go Arizona. It was those Mexicans that caused our unemployment problems all along. Hope to see Sarah Palin out in them fields next week. And for congoboy below. You got it all wrong. We need to work in Arizona then sneak into Mexico where we can live on the cheap? Maybe Mexico can be urged to set up a guest citizenship program for Americans. Sounds like a plan that even Sarah can get behind.

    • 1 year ago
  • congoboy
    • -1
      congoboy  
    • telcod:

      many americans retire in latin american countries including mexico. mainly because of the cheap economy. not always easy to live here on ss and retirement bennies

    • 1 year ago
  • Daena_Smith
    • 0
      Daena_Smith  
    • telcod:

      Actually I know Americans who work here in the US and then live in Mexico. For $300.00 a month rent you can get a nice 3 bedroom home, $20.00 a month-cable TV and phone, $100.00 a month (during the hot summer months) electricity, and so on. One can live very comfortably in Mexico. However, the lines to cross back into the US takes forever. One co-worker leaves his car in the US side and rides his bicycle back and forth across.

    • 1 year ago
  • congoboy
    • 0
      congoboy  
    • telcod:

      sounds like an excellent plan telcod. dont need no stinkin guest citizenship program in mexico though. just like they do here we can cross illegally, might not get as warm a welcome as the ones comin here though. mexico has very strict immigration laws and you dont want to end up in a mexican prison if you know what i mean. wink wink

    • 1 year ago
  • congoboy
  • jubal
  • congoboy
    • -2
      congoboy  
    • even though $200 a month is a pittance by most standards you do a disservice to the reader by failing to mention the cost of living in those country's is much lower than the u.s. in most latin country's the majority of people dont own cars and those that do most likely dont insure them. depending on how socialistic they are utilities may be government run and provided. so even though $200 seems like and is little compared to u.s. standards it is a living wage in many of these country's. also with a strong faith in catholicism and strong family bonds these people are more inclined to help each other out, unlike people in the u.s. in many ways the latin culture, with their faith in god, their strong family ties and values are in better shape than many north americans. would they like to make better money and increase their standard of living? who the fuck wouldnt? are we obligated to provide them with what they seek? other than minimum wage for honest work, fuck no. do we owe them health or medical care? fuck no. do we owe them an easy path to citizenship? fuck no. should we be sympathetic or empathetic to their plight? fuck yes, create guest worker programs, document the workers and allow them to work here according to our laws.

    • 1 year ago
  • logicpocket
  • treewolf39
    • +1
      treewolf39  
    • logicpocket:

      I paid $4.00 for a organic red bell pepper this year. I was shocked that one pepper could be so expensive. The pepper only weighed one pound so a Bushel would be worth $120.00 to the store.
      Not all pepper pickers are exploited but if you are paying under a dollar a pound a picker is most likely getting the short end of the stick.

    • 1 year ago
  • csmonut
    • +2
      csmonut  
    • logicpocket:

      You're right about this being a very complicated matter.
      Proccessing costs, shipping costs, and the list can get much longer, before the food ever reaches your local grocery store.
      The "middle-man" is the one that makes the money.
      Part of the problem is large conglomerate agriculture, Monsanto types, etc. that have helped bring about the the whole process of just getting goods to market.
      Even if stores wanted to buy locally grown veggies and fruits, the farmers would have even higher costs to meet the USDA laws that were shaped by large agri-businesses.

    • 1 year ago
  • UtopianSky
    • +2
      UtopianSky  
    • So Arizona's laws against illegal immigration will result in the death of their agricultural industry.

      They made a choice- now let's see if they stick to their guns and ruin their economy, or grow a pair and say "oops, we made a mistake! Come back Mexicans, we will help you file the paperwork now!"

    • 1 year ago
  • Nephwrack
  • jubal
  • remanns
  • remanns
  • Nephwrack
    • +2
      Nephwrack  
    • pure unadulterated right wing bullshit... ( cries ) we cant afford to pay citizens a living wage so we'll just have to employ illegals... what a fucking crock of shit. i picked grapes as a kid and sold lemonade on the side. farmers aren't hurting for money, they are just living in a different century than we are.

    • 1 year ago
  • remanns
    • +1
      remanns  
    • Nephwrack:

      If they were allowed to screw the workers wife and occasionally round -em-up to serve as cannon fodder in petty wars we would call them "feudal lords"
      That the time period you had in mind for "century" ?

      oh,....p.s. +^d

    • 1 year ago
  • Nephwrack
  • Daniel_Morales
    • +2
      Daniel_Morales  
    • @im1mjrpain . so besides ignorant you don`t know how to count ? if you get paid 2 dollars by the hour and you work 8 you make 16 dollars if you make one bushel every 2 hours in 8 hours you make 8 dollars
      also if are illegally working and have an accident .... forget about the patron paying for any help they don`t even have drinking watter ...
      so for all those red necks with guns in the border doing what they call " saving america from the wet backs " are gonna have to star pay a lot more money if they want pepper in their dinner table
      i hope you don`t like pepper otherwise you are gonna have to paid a lot from now on

      the messenger

    • 1 year ago
  • im1mjrpain
    • +1
      im1mjrpain  
    • So if I work an 8 hour shift I'll gross $4 per day. The difference is if you are working illegally you don't have to worry about taxes knocking your $4 dollars to about $2.50 per day.

    • 1 year ago
  • jubal
  • QuestionGeek
    • +1
      QuestionGeek  
    • The interviewer is a racist pig. Interesting how the first question out of the interviewers mouth wasn't, "How many white people applied for the job to pick these peppers?' Of course the first thing that comes to his mind is Blacks and brown Mexicans. There are plenty of white people that work in tobacco fields (dangerous and back breaking work)

      The farmer is right, no blacks apply for that job, because no legal citizens of this country is going to do that kind of fork for pauper wages. They're not even pauper wages. $1.00 an hour? Are you kidding me? Why pay them anything? And have you seen the price of peppers in the stores? They cost $1.00 to $2.00 each. I guess I'm missing something here.

      And gee, why don't they pay a living wage? How is it legal for them to pay a $1.00 an hour for that work? Isn't the minimum wage at least $7.25/hr

      The peppers will end up being destroyed (tilled back into the soil) The farmer wouldn't dare think of giving them away, even though he can't sell them. He should just open the farm to the public and let people pick peppers for $3.00 a bushel. Gee, what a concept.

    • 1 year ago
  • congoboy
    • 0
      congoboy  
    • QuestionGeek:

      no one in this country makes $1 an hour. migrants in ca and wa state make around $10 an hour. who would risk crossing the arizona desert for $1 an hour? the story is full of bullshit holes.

    • 1 year ago
  • manny1m
  • manny1m
    • +3
      manny1m  
    • diabolical44 you are an idiot! None of the farmers make millions and billions of dollars for hiring illegals. they are barely ably to make a profit. Why don't you get off your lazy ass, stop living with mom and pick vegetables!

    • 1 year ago
  • BRAVATRAVELS
  • CalgarC
  • alexandrek
  • CalgarC
  • csmonut
  • diabolical44
    • +4
      diabolical44  
    • thank god they are leaving. now if those big corporate farmers decide to pay a living wage to their workers maybe they'll find some help. maybe cut into their millions in profits . there is a big lie out there . a myth that most farms are poor mom and pop farmers just making it by. sure there are a handful of those. but nearly all of the farming in america nowadays is corporate owned with executives making billions and profits through the roof. Its time we start making these jobs well paid.

    • 1 year ago
  • QuestionGeek
    • +1
      QuestionGeek  
    • diabolical44:

      The farmers don't make millions you nincompoop, the executives that pull their strings and who they are consigned to make millions. Get and education before you start spouting off at the mouth.

    • 1 year ago
  • ezrierin
    • +1
      ezrierin  
    • The Unites States does not need anything from the rest of the world. Stop import dependence. Stop foreign workers from entering our economy without a four year degree recognized by the United States Government as accredited. All immigrants have to go through channels. Foreigners are banned for life from entering the country if they attempt to enter illegally
      This would end the trade imbalance.

    • 1 year ago
  • ArchDruid
  • ezrierin
    • -1
      ezrierin  
    • ArchDruid:

      Not true. We have the technology which allows us not to have to import anything. We just have not chosen to do it. As for America being part of the trading world, we can change our minds about that as well.

    • 1 year ago
  • jubal
  • QuestionGeek
    • +3
      QuestionGeek  
    • ezrierin:

      Please, where have you been? This is a global economy whether you like or not, and has been long before anyone realized it.

      The United States does need outside help, because "no one" wants to buy USA made. Case in point: Who wanted to buy a Ford, RCA, Magnavox, or Philco television once Sony televisions came along? Those Sony TVs lasted 20 years without needing any repairs. The list goes on and on. From gross poor quality GM cars, to the crappy USA electric dishwashers we now make. I can see why people don't want to buy USA made. Made in USA simply means CHEAP and subpar, with a few exceptions of course.

    • 1 year ago
  • Daena_Smith
    • +1
      Daena_Smith  
    • QuestionGeek:

      Not true... We did make products that lasted forever! Before tv's became "disposable" you got your set fixed at appliance repair shop, and if you needed a tube for your TV you went to the drug store or grocery store. Ford cars at one time were dependable and reliable, but then the 70's/80's happened and all American cars took a turn for the worse and Toyota/Honda/Datsun became more popular brands to buy. Ever hear of the "K" car from Chrysler/Plymouth/Doge? Pffffttttt...junk.

      America did and can make excellent products, however, because of cheaper labor, they started going over seas to make a bigger profit.

    • 1 year ago
  • ezrierin
    • -2
      ezrierin  
    • ezrierin:

      It is too bad so many hours have passed on this one. However, I still feel a need to respond. This is for the comments that do not agree with me above. There are so many I decided to just respond here. I figured it was easier. Forgive me the order.
      What you folks seem to have forgotten is that we live in a Democracy. We can as a nation decide we can take our economic marbles and go home. We do not have to play with other countries if we do not want to do it. As for the value of our money in the world, money value is based on a pretend psychology anyway. Money is worthless unless we decide its worth. If the world decides our money is worthless, we can decide it has worth right here at home. Then we can make what we need for ourselves, feed ourselves, etc. WE DO HAVE a high enough technology to never have to import anything if we choose not to.
      I think my dissenters need to look in the mirror and ask themselves if they have been brainwashed into thinking we are at the mercy of the rest of the world. We are not. We are a Democracy. We can choose whatever we want to choose, that is what freedom is all about. Wake up folks, WE ARE FREE!!! ENJOY IT!!!

    • 1 year ago
  • ArchDruid
  • ezrierin
    • 0
      ezrierin  
    • ArchDruid:

      I have to laugh at how silly you are sounding. I know it may sound like something to be afraid of. However, I beg you to entertain the belief that three hundred-million Americans cannot decide to change their minds. It is an absurd notion. We can choose the future we desire, and the world can do nothing about it. No one will go to war with us, as we would annihilate them if they crossed onto our shores in any way.
      On the contrary, the world would be hungry to maintain economic ties with us. This can be allowed as long as manufacturing is under the United States Government trust for the American people. The trust guarantees through the Economic National Security laws that all production must occur within the United States. If you want to ship us goods to manufacture your products here, we will be sure to sell the finished product to others and ourselves. A reasonable share of the profits, not to exceed 14% of the profit margin can go back to the owners of the foreign manufacturing. Nevertheless, the factory cannot leave for at least 15 years unless Economic National Security laws prohibit sale to a foreign entity at any time.
      As for our debt, we tell our creditors we will pay them off in good time. Good time for us means a surplus after sale of products marketed under the Living Wag Laws in the United States. If a foreign entity decides to dump our dollar, we will respect the value of our dollar inside our own country. This will put millions of Americans back to work providing for ourselves.

    • 1 year ago
  • CarlosIsDown
  • CarlosIsDown
  • CalgarC
  • CarlosIsDown
  • CalgarC
  • CarlosIsDown
  • CalgarC
  • alexandrek
  • CalgarC
  • wally60
    • +2
      wally60  
    • this article is bull no one will work for 1$ an hour and you can pick a hole lot more chile than that in an hour.i live in new mexico in the farm fields an these guys will pick 20 sacks 50 pound sacks a day.but you arnt going to get lazy americans off the couch not when they can collect welfare disability and every
      other free be.i am sorry i have a lot of respect for hard working mexicans and know a lot of them.americans have become the lazyest in the world and i am not saying all americans but what is the ratio does anyone know how many collect welfare and disiability?

    • 1 year ago
  • diabolical44
    • +1
      diabolical44  
    • wally60:

      total bullshit. the work is peasant slave work and they get paid pennies. Americans aren't lazy. they just won't work for less than what you'd could get paid at mcdonalds flipping burgers. Americans are among the hardest working cultures on earth. We work ourselves to death compared to other cultures.

    • 1 year ago
  • KSirys
  • diabolical44
  • TheEmpireGuy
    • -5
      TheEmpireGuy  
    • I'm gonna get flamed for this, but..... Minimum wage laws should be repealed.

      Here is how Hans F. Sennholz(1922-2007) said it,

      "Good intentions, when guided by error and ignorance, may have undesirable consequences. There is no better example than minimum wage legislation.

      It means to raise the wages and improve the living conditions of poor workers but actually condemns many to chronic unemployment. It forcefully raises the costs of unskilled and inexperienced labor and thereby lifts it right out of the labor market. Yet, many politicians who neither own nor manage a business and do not employ such labor never tire of lamenting and deploring low wages and promising to raise the wage minimum by law and regulation.

      No employer can overlook the mandated fringe benefits which he is forced to pay above the minimum. There are employer Social Security taxes, unemployment and workers' compensation levies, and paid holidays.

      In some industries the workers' compensation levy alone may amount to more than one-half of the wages paid. And if the employer should carry his workers' health insurance costs, employment costs may be double the minimum rate. If eager members of Congress should be successful in raising the minimum by two or three dollars an hour, many young people may be condemned to permanent unemployment.

      The rate of unemployment tends to be directly proportional to the excess of labor costs over productivity. In many European countries with official minimum wages of more than $10 an hour, the rate of unemployment is measured in double-digit rates although governments spend massive amounts on make-work projects. Some victims readily submit to their fate and endure a life of idleness and bare subsistence. Many learn to labor in black markets where goods are produced and services are rendered in violation of minimum wage edicts and other regulations and controls. But most victims are young people with little training and know-how who tend to react angrily and violently. Their rate of unemployment actually amounts to multiples of the official rate. And if society should be divided ethnically, youth training and productivity may be lower yet and its rate of unemployment may approach 100 percent. Such a labor situation is laden with anger and fury which not only breeds high crime rates but also, at any time, may turn to violence by mobs of unemployed youth. The recent riots of French youth clearly resembled the riots of unemployed Americans in Watts in 1965, in San Francisco in 1966, Detroit and Baltimore in 1967, Chicago and Cleveland in 1968, and in Los Angeles in 1992.

      The situation is most dangerous and explosive in cities and states with state minimums even higher than those set by the Federal government. Minimum wage legislation had its beginning in states long before there was a New Deal that made the Federal government the primary labor legislator and regulator. State governments continue to lead the way in raising labor costs; state rates of unemployment tend to indicate the political strength of the minimum wage movement.

      Few economists have the courage to point to labor legislation and regulation as the very cause of mass unemployment. A few who muster the courage may emphasize the infinite demand for labor but are ever mindful that its costs set limits to the demand. Few employers, if any, knowingly buy labor that costs more than it produces, just as few workers are likely to purchase consumer goods which, in their judgment, cost more than they are worth. Yet, economists who dare to point to labor legislation and regulation as important causes of mass unemployment are criticized, denounced, condemned, and vilified as callous and ruthless agents and spokesmen of greedy employers..."

      "...To alleviate minimum-wage unemployment is to restore freedom in the labor market; it would permit the cost of labor to readjust to labor productivity and offer employment to every young man and woman willing and ready to work. A free labor market would welcome young people, which not only would exhort and restore the spirit of work but also improve labor skill and know-how. The labor productivity of American youth soon would rise and exceed the ominous minimum levels that presently condemn millions to idleness. Freedom has a thousand charms even in the labor market."

    • 1 year ago
  • Saladin
  • TheEmpireGuy
    • +1
      TheEmpireGuy  
    • Saladin:

      "mindless", "waste of intellect","useless human being". Now, that hurts. But, this is, after all, the internet, so, it is what I have come to expect from it's community.

      Saladin, regardless of how you feel, which seems to always be a vulgar tirade of hate filled remarks and which, more often than not, offer absolutely nothing to coherent and intelligent debate, it is wholly unacceptable and contradictory to the Current community guidelines.

      Allow me to quote them, " Be Respectful: Everyone is entitled to an opinion. Remember what we all learned in kindergarten? Treat others the way you'd like to be treated"

      Furthermore, "Personal Attacks: We can't always agree on everything, and that's fine. But stick to debating the point, not attacking the other person."

      And let us not forget, "Excessive Profanity: We're all adults here, and we understand that things can get heated. But excessive profanity isn't cool."

      Yes, that's right, we are all adults here, now how about we act like it? I refuse to tolerate any more of your vulgar tirades and until you clean up your act, I will not be responding to anything you have to say.

    • 1 year ago
  • RaceBannon
    • +2
      RaceBannon  
    • TheEmpireGuy:

      Interestingly concept and your proposal has been around since then end of slavery. However to correct you the french riots were more than complaints about unemployment. It was to address french prejudice, inequity, the failure of the state to provide the promised society, and most importantly the failure and death of the old approach by the left. I'll write about the state of the left another day, maybe in a syndicated publication if my timing is right ;)

      Anyway we have really few options for producing a fair wage except to either mandate a national minimum wage, or return to the era of robber barons and child labor while pretending the markets so called "invisible hand" will fix things (I loathe economics soo much, ugggh). Honestly I'd prefer if companies who violated a minimum wage law lost their charters and were nationalized as a public trust.

    • 1 year ago
  • RaceBannon
  • artemis6
  • TheEmpireGuy
    • 0
      TheEmpireGuy  
    • RaceBannon:

      The state should not have promised anything because it is always doomed to failure. Very rarely if ever does the state make good on it's promises, often going back on it's word entirely. I would love to hear what you have to say about the state of the left.

      And I happen to love economics. It's one of my main interests.

    • 1 year ago
1 - 100 of 448
more from Community:

top videos