mitekillem
"9 Years in the making"

New York Democratic Rep. Anthony Weiner is plainly fired up and ready to go. In a losing battle to secure passage of a bill to fund health care and compensation for ill 9/11 rescue workers, he unleashed a tirade against what he called unprincipled GOP opponents of the measure. Watch his outburst, which concluded in him smashing down the House rostrum microphone:

The House voted down the bill, which would have provided $3.2 billion over the next 10 years to fund free health care for 9/11 rescue and recovery workers who have fallen ill from toxic smoke and debris they breathed at the World Trade Center site. The bill would have also provided $4.2 billion in compensation over that same span. The legislation proposed to pay for the benefits by closing a tax loophole on foreign subsidiaries that do business in the United States.


The House Democratic leadership employed an arcane procedural maneuver to suspend the rules before consideration of the bill (titled the James Zadroga 9/11 Health and Compensation Act). Democrats reportedly used the gambit to prevent House Republicans from swamping the otherwise popular measure with what Democrats called excessively partisan amendments. But in order for the bill to pass in this form, it needed a two-thirds majority. The final tally was 255 for it (12 of them Republicans), and 159 against (four of them Democrats).

[Photos: Ground Zero construction continues]

Some GOP opponents painted it as a "slush fund" for New York that the rest of America would be forced to fund through tax increases. In response to the measure's defeat, New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg blasted both sides of the aisle.

"It was wrong for the overwhelming majority of Republicans to vote against the bill, and it was wrong for Democrats to bring the bill to the floor under rules that made passage so much more difficult," he said.

The Washington Post's Greg Sargent concurred, citing Democratic incompetence and Republican political chicanery as the principal reasons for the defeat. Sargent wrote that the Republicans are trying to "render government ineffective in order to deny Dems victories, create a sense that government is broken and has failed to deliver, stoke anti-incumbent fervor, and ensure that Dems bear the brunt of blame for government dysfunction." He adds, "Dems need to stop responding superficially to Republican opposition, and tailor their response to the GOP's underlying strategy."

More here:
http://news.yahoo.com/s/yblog_upshot/20100730/hl_yblog_upshot/rep-anthony-weiner...
  1. groups:
    Community,   News and Politics,   Politics,   US Politics,   2 more
  2. tags:
    Health Obama Republican GOP 11 more
  3.     
    |

77 comments // GOP Blocks healthcare for 9/11 rescue workers

  • Nephwrack
  • Dravenlee77
    • +1
      Dravenlee77  
    • Image
    • The Heartless it seems the Neo Con Fox News Tea Party are showing there desire of world that seems more like MAD MAX...
      How can you call you're self a Patriot then disrespect American Hero's like the men and women who risked everything to save others.

    • 2 years ago
  • brit50
    • 0
      brit50  
    • You are looking at almost 8 billion! in money that is really meant to prop up the New York state and local governments that have NO MONEY. Essentially, the compensation is just a cover, there is no way that amount of money is needed to cover a few hundred ill persons.

    • 2 years ago
  • Reaper26
    • -1
      Reaper26  
    • we all know gop dont care about the 9/11 workers they just use that event as a way to get patriots to vote for them. i like this guy though..

    • 2 years ago
  • 2helenahandbasket
  • DRudeBoy
  • Mikeysfake1
    • +1
      Mikeysfake1  
    • Ok ok. Let's get these guys some healthcare but don't try to play off our patriotism by pulling the 911 card. We're talking about a very small amount of people in a specific situation and to make Republicans seem selfish for not supporting the bill. Just because you find the firefighters in need doesn't mean your not just trying to gain support for a poorly thought out bill. I say get the firefighters help but don't try and kill two birds with one stone by playing off our pride.

    • 2 years ago
  • GodIsTheReason
  • im1mjrpain
  • Mikeysfake1
  • EmperorThan
  • Nephwrack
  • Andrew_Douglas
  • EdJoyProductions
    • +3
      EdJoyProductions  
    • Andrew_Douglas:

      I met him a couple of years ago at the Staten Island Gay Pride parade. He knows how to work a crowd. We were hoping that he would run against BillionMayor Bloomberg, but he said that he was too busy concentrating on the health care bill. He would have won, but he has a good sense of responsibility. I will be volunteering for any of his future political endeavors.

    • 2 years ago
  • Andrew_Douglas
    • +3
      Andrew_Douglas  
    • EdJoyProductions:

      Can you imagine how fucking win he'd be as president? And, as an added bonus, when he runs for re-election you can wholeheartedly say you're all for four more years of Weiner.

      I make these puns, but I truly admire this man. One of my heroes.

    • 2 years ago
  • EdJoyProductions
  • Found_Avenue
  • keanu101
  • putdownmypants
    • +2
      putdownmypants  
    • As John Stewart said: "I Give Up."
      All of the hope that was inspired by Obama with his election is gone now. I'm back to square one (as I was leading to the end of Bush's reign). I can't stand this country, sometimes... well most times.

    • 2 years ago
  • ThakurSherSinghParmar
    • +2
      ThakurSherSinghParmar  
    • Image
    • 1.It's really dismaying to read - "GOP Blocks healthcare for 9/11 rescue workers"...It seems to be an unwise move on the part of the GOP which consists of politicians who boast of standing up for and protecting the USA citizens against terrorism of all kinds, yet these very GOP pals have belittled the brave efforts of all those BRAVE rescue wprkers who had risked their own lives to save the lives of all those trapped in the Towers due to the acts of the terrorists...

      2. A good question indeed - why should THEY get free healthcare when the rest of us (who are paying for it) don't get it?

      REPLY:

      Simply, because under normal circumstances, even these rescue workers would not have got this special treatment like you don't get. But, these BRAVE rescue workers had gone out of their way, risked their own lives and saved many precious human lives trapped inside the Towers. If these rescue workers wished, these rescue workers could very well have done a routine job, not taken any personal risks and saved their own health/lives!

    • 2 years ago
  • artemis6
  • dariusvons
  • dariusvons
    • 0
      dariusvons  
    • why should I have to pay out anything to them? afterall it would be MY tax money. and simply put, I don't care to give them a dime.

    • 2 years ago
  • kep
  • dariusvons
    • +2
      dariusvons  
    • kep:

      I don't think you understand this issue. it's NOT that rescue workers should be payed (they already are)... it's that they should have their health care payed for by all of us.

    • 2 years ago
  • dariusvons
  • putdownmypants
    • +1
      putdownmypants  
    • dariusvons:

      "The truth is that this is a limited program, with a cap, because it is
      restricted to 9/11 responders and others directly affected by the toxic
      substances. As we all remember, the victims of ground zero dust came
      from all over the nation — they weren’t just New Yorkers. And, frankly, I
      don’t see what’s wrong with trying to close a loophole that lets
      foreign multinational corporations avoid paying taxes on income they
      have earned in the United States."
      -Anthony Weiner

      We'll be taxing corporations who make money in the US, but have offshore P.O. Boxes to avoid taxes. This was the perfect bill. Even if we get taxed from it, these people are sick/dying and we could've helped these heroic citizens.

    • 2 years ago
  • figgdimension
  • existentialist
  • devanshi
    • +2
      devanshi  
    • existentialist:

      thats very true. nypd, emts, etc. all have insurance i'm sure, but there are many who volunteered to help who arn't a part of that group..who where just average ppl who don't have insurance or may have crap insurance and now have chronic lung conditions and so on. i know many people don't like michael moore and i don't know if you do or not...but thats something he addresses in his documentry 'sicko'. very sad.

    • 2 years ago
  • ThakurSherSinghParmar
  • Nephwrack
  • dreamsenvoy
  • shallowside887
    • +5
      shallowside887  
    • So we can justify 2 multi-billion dollar wars for the past 7 years with that attack but we cant provide healthcare for the people who helped clean up the mess? The republicans are truly the party of "No"

    • 2 years ago
  • cztheday
    • +6
      cztheday  
    • As the Republican buried this bill, I was reminded of the strong feeling of community that existed across this country in the days immediately following 9/11. I am struck by the degree to which Republicans have cynically leveraged those feelings ever since.

      Bush used them as political cover for his cowardly, corrupt, and genocidal invasion of Iraq (has there been a more shameful image of the ugly American than that of Colin Powell, fed lies by his President and Vice President, lying in turn to the United Nations?). I am convinced that the true danger of a repeat attack was exaggerated into near-hysteria into an equally cynical bid by the Bush Administration to funnel hundreds of billions of dollars to major defense contractors under the guise of "securing the homeland." Now, when a bill comes forward to deal directly with the fallout of 9/11, the Republicans kick it to the curb. Am I bitter...maybe a little...

    • 2 years ago
  • Brazil617MA
  • nanac
    • +5
      nanac  
    • The GOP is a group of spineless inhuman politicians...They are anti-labor every step of the way! Regardless of the legislation, the outcome is very predictable....NO is their solution to every issue except for permanent tax-cuts for the rich..

    • 2 years ago
  • biggranny
    • +4
      biggranny  
    • there is plenty of blame to go around why this bill did not pass. i find it refreshing that he said what we all are thinking. the american people have been pissed off for a long time. shame the repub don't give a shit what we really think

    • 2 years ago
  • artemis6
  • NaranjaCabeza
    • +2
      NaranjaCabeza  
    • It's so refreshing to see people so passionate about true justice, instead of seeing them just spewing bullshit so that their party can somehow benefit from the losses.

    • 2 years ago
  • wellhunggimp
  • Andrew_Douglas
  • Paratus
    • -8
      Paratus  
    • Democrats made the bed thay are laying in. Next time don't shut out the other side. That is a good lesson both parties need to learn.
      I watched this as it unfolded. NO wonder congress has such a low approval rating.

    • 2 years ago
  • Saladin
    • +9
      Saladin  
    • Paratus:

      Bullshit.

      The Republicans got up that day and DECIDED to not give 9/11 workers the healthcare.

      They were not shut out.

      They were not alienated.

      They just said no.

    • 2 years ago
  • tommic
  • artemis6
  • tommic
  • bike10
  • Kaveh_Kompani
  • dragon1984
  • mbeharry
  • madworld128
  • Prijedor
    • +6
      Prijedor  
    • How will fox news spin this... and sense repablicans in senate hate 9/11 rescue workers does that mean all their backers hate them as well...

      ohhh and Michael Bloomberg should stfu, if he really cared he would give up some of his own money, he spent how many millions on his re-election *dictatorship* and he cant spend some to help the peoples out...

    • 2 years ago
  • toyotabedzrock
    • +3
      toyotabedzrock  
    • Prijedor:

      They will cut up the video and make sure to not mention what he was yelling about. Or they will fabricate a new bigger story to avoid it. Which it seems they have already done about immigration.

    • 2 years ago
  • BKsaysAction
  • bc_f
    • bc_f [removed]  
    • This comment was removed as a violation of community guidelines.
  • TomTucker
  • dreamsenvoy
  • Stoneyroad
  • Kaveh_Kompani
  • blackheartman
  • Tyr
    • +4
      Tyr  
    • This is the kind of response to the GOP that i would love to see our president take, I admire a man who takes the gloves off and is willing to rumble! Be strong my brotha! Be strong!

    • 2 years ago
  • gurillamack
    • +18
      gurillamack  
    • Man. I love the fact that Rep. Weiner has the biggest balls in all of congress.

      If you haven't heard of this guy before, check out his daily show appearance. It is great and this man should be a transformative force in the next couple of years.

      I hope this man is president someday.

    • 2 years ago
  • zHellas
  • Stoneyroad
  • gurillamack
  • blackheartman
  • kennymotown
  • toyotabedzrock
  • timetide
  • littlwarrior
    • +8
      littlwarrior  
    • The gop doing something heinously evil, I’m so shocked I just don’t know what to say... Other than the GOP is so fake you could melt them all down and use the resulting plastics to keep the world in bottled water for a millennia. Metaphorically speaking of course.

    • 2 years ago
  • derk
    • +21
      derk  
    • If I was in NY I would be volunteering for this guy. It's been a long time since I saw anything on the House floor that got my blood pumping like that.

    • 2 years ago
  • Idoknow19
  • derk
  • treewolf39
  • TimALoftis
  • mitekillem
    • +15
      mitekillem  
    • I think it's evil to deny those hero's who sacrificed their lives, their health, their safety, and well-being, the proper funding for the health care they deserve. These men and women were there at Ground Zero on 9/11 aiding people without the worry if the dust from the debris would cause health risks, cancer, damage to their body's.
      Hero's act, regardless of the consequences...and this is how we thank them?
      We thank them by telling them, " 'Thanks for volunteering and saving so many people, sorry that you got sick because of it, good luck with that.' -GOP"

      These are the same people who block unemployment benefits, but always want more money for the war.
      It's evil. What they are doing is wrong.

      "Republicans are trying to "render government ineffective in order to deny Dems victories, create a sense that government is broken and has failed to deliver, stoke anti-incumbent fervor, and ensure that Dems bear the brunt of blame for government dysfunction." He adds, "Dems need to stop responding superficially to Republican opposition, and tailor their response to the GOP's underlying strategy.""

    • 2 years ago
more from Community:

top videos