Community | September 24, 2010 | 86 comments

Colbert (Briefly) Breaks Character in Testimony before Congress

Image
Future_America
Stephen Colbert mostly yucked it up during his congressional testimony today, but towards the end, Democrat Judy Chu actually got him to break his faux-pundit facade. After relating the story of a worker overcome by heat stroke, but unable to find medical help, she asked Colbert why he had chosen to tackle the migrant worker topic. Colbert took a moment to collect himself, and then, with a stammer he said, “I… I like talking about people who don’t have any power.” (See video from CNN at link.)

“This seems like one of the least powerful groups of people in the United States are migrant workers who come and do our work and don’t have any rights as a result.” Then the comedian actually quoted the Bible non-ironically saying, “You know, whatsoever you do for the least of my brothers—and these seem like the least of our brothers right now. … Migrant workers suffer and have no rights.”


Full testimony video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B6kKlnVl3UE
  1. groups:
    Community,   News and Politics,   Culture,   Celebrity,   7 more
  2. tags:
    Stephen Colbert colbert
  3. recommended by:
    remanns
  4.     
    |

86 comments // Colbert (Briefly) Breaks Character in Testimony before Congress

  • hombre76
    • +1
      hombre76  
    • "The state can't give you freedom, and the state can't take it away. You're
      born with it, like your eyes, like your ears. Freedom is something you
      assume, then you wait for someone to try to take it away. The degree to
      which you resist is the degree to which you are free..."
      — Utah Phillips

    • 1 year ago
  • r0nan
  • dwb2585
  • unclepete813
    • +1
      unclepete813  
    • believe it or not, its not about immagration. Its about slavery. See the mexicans or anyone who comes here are free. see the gov doesnt have a lein on them like they have against americans. You get this from birth, socail sec. You are stock. so you have no rights. alienable rights. they not Able to put A Lien on them. thats what this is all about. The greety slave masters of England/vatican/scottisrite/rostchilds. See we,eerrrrrrrrrr I mean you are still a slave and have no rights. Go do your history. Give up this CoRporation call America and get you human rights back. Give up all Drivers licences anything they put a contract on you with. Taxes is just slave debt you paying back. wake up people and get out of that democratic/republican/tea party. FK em all. they all work for the same One eye demon on top of the pyramid on back of your dollar. The Vatican is at the top. peace out 1love to hummanity, IMHOTEP

    • 1 year ago
  • r0nan
  • dwb2585
  • Buddha2112
  • unclepete813
    • 0
      unclepete813  
    • r0nan:

      I would first get everyone to be as ONE not different races. I would stop all the religion and get people to think about everything. NOT what they taught you. I would get rid of the money and have people live off the land and get this greed EGO out the way. But thats how the religion got you into this slavery.

    • 1 year ago
  • r0nan
    • 0
      r0nan  
    • dwb2585:

      I like the central bank idea for some things. Not all. Stricter enforcement of regulations with the current system would help. I like local credit unions for personal use such as small loans, savings and checking. And my wife would LUV a free Fiat Panda.

    • 1 year ago
  • r0nan
  • remanns
    • +6
      remanns  
    • Bring them [ Mexican labor ] In. Bring them ALL IN. Into the fold. NO "non-citizen" wage earners in THIS country. WE ARE - P E O P L E -.

      ........and "business" does NOT 'own" us.

    • 1 year ago
  • remanns
  • gizmoismeno
    • 0
      gizmoismeno  
    • colbert is shedding light on a issue that most people done care about or know about. The pain and surfing of this farm works is bored line in humane. i've me and known people that have work on this farm, and have seen their pain.The year of working pesticides, of working in the 100 plus degree heat, and of lack of good pay of worker's comp. this people work all day and if they get hurt to bad no more work for them. thank mr. colbert you doing great serves to ur fellow man by helping the is hard working people.

    • 1 year ago
  • bailey78
    • +3
      bailey78  
    • Ok I say this to all who want to send the migrant workers back home GO DO THE JOB THEY ARE DOING! then tell me you want to do it every day. Most of you would not last a day working the fields or the orchards. The work these folks are doing is back breaking at the very least. most get paid by the amount of work they do not by the hour. There is no AC there is no break at ten an two there is no body to say AAH you broke a nail take the day off and get some rest. Most of you would starve if not for those that are doing the work you won't do. So untill you yourself have done the work Don't bitch about those that are. I myself know how to grow what i need to survive. I was raised on home grown everything from milking the cow before going to school to pulling weeds from the garden when we got home from school. i know just how it's done and what it takes to get it done.

    • 1 year ago
  • Incredulous
  • remanns
    • +1
      remanns  
    • bailey78:

      In all seriousness,....I agree with you mostly,....I think,....yep,....thought about it, still think it.
      But I would personally like to do a LOT of immigrant labor,....for about 1/3 more wage,....for 2/3 the working day. ( And that IS very close to the 1955 AVERAGE working mans wage )
      Work outside,....with your HANDS !?! Kewl !!! I just don't want to starve doing it,...or be so exhausted at the end of THE AVERAGE Day,.....that my "working day" - SUMS UP MY LIFE.
      Employers cant "legally" pay the wage they have become acclimated/accustomed to paying for their serfs/peasants.

      ....anyway,....thats my 2 bits.

    • 1 year ago
  • remanns
  • bailey78
    • 0
      bailey78  
    • remanns:

      Ok first off you won't go hungry you will be working in a field full of food. second they pay on how much work you do not by the hour. Third all you have to do is follow the crops and you will find all the work you want. In other words when it's apple season find a apple orchard and hire in picking apples when it's cherry season find a cherry orchard an so on and so forth. The jobs are there for those that want to do them but most w.a.s.p. don't want to do that kind of work.

    • 1 year ago
  • remanns
    • +2
      remanns  
    • bailey78:

      My uncle did that work. Even if you are a bad ass,...it doesn't really pay an acceptable wage anymore "by the bushel" as it were.( It still can be equated to an hourly wage,....adjusted by individual or crew speed ). If there EVER was a business IN THE WORLD in need of a union.......

    • 1 year ago
  • bailey78
  • remanns
    • +1
      remanns  
    • bailey78:

      p.s. I dig that you wont go hungry,.......but you sure as hell cant afford to "age",...or "break down" in any way. (and I sort of think ALL jobs should leave you enough "left over" after a days work,...to read the library book of your choice for 2 or 3 hours at shifts end most days with some degree of pleasure and focus.

      EXCEPTION - - -perhaps the FULLY VOLUNTARY armed forces,....or REAL emergencies,...where you would be doing VIRTUALLY THE SAME THING even if you received NO paycheck for it; "Mississippi flooding" sorts of things.

    • 1 year ago
  • remanns
  • bailey78
  • chillmode
    • +2
      chillmode  
    • bailey78:

      i guess im the only one who sees the hypocracy of supporting these migrant workers and pushing for their "rights" to a decent wage. The only reason Americans dont want to do the work (and why we hire them in the first place) is because of the wages. U think there aren't americans who CAN do the work? Bull shit! I'd do it if the money was right. I know all about "back-breaking" work. I was a pool plasterer, mixing plaster for 10-14 hrs. a day in 105 degree weather; but i was properly re-imbursed so i never complained. The main case for hiring migrant workers is the financial situation most farmers are currently facing, yet fight for their rights is an effort to rais their wages? How does anyone think that makes sense? I'm not saying anyone should be treated like dirt, but the low wages come with the territory. If the wages were higher there would be a flood of lower-middle class AMERICAN citizens ready and willing to do the work; I know because i'd be one of them. I am IN NO WAY trying to prevent anyone from making a living for themselves or their family, but there are people already in this country (legally) who are trying to do just that. Lets take care of them first. (and im all for making citizenship more easily attainable, but not illegal work that takes money out of the american economy)

    • 1 year ago
  • bailey78
  • samonster34
    • 0
      samonster34  
    • bailey78:

      I wonder if the issue is what you are addressing here. Does it have to do with anyone's lack of willingness to do a (maybe undesirable) job? There are plenty of jobs terrible in their own way whatever. You're attacking other's work ethic and their being accustom to a minimum standard in working environments different than those who are filling the jobs. Then you puff yourself up a little bit in a somewhat irrelevant anecdote. But is this the issue with illegal immigrants working in our country?

    • 1 year ago
  • samonster34
  • bailey78
    • 0
      bailey78  
    • samonster34:

      i have read that three times and still I don't understand what your trying to say. can you reword it so I can reply? as far as people not wanting to do the work of course they don't it's hard work to do. maybe if those getting welfare were to have to work these jobs then the Migrant worker would not be needed but the goverment is not going to make people get off there fat ass an go to work they find it so much easier to pay welfare. is that the answer you were looking for? i don't care if ten thousand people come across the border every day so long as they are willing to work. There are jobs here for those that want to work. Do they pay big bucks hell no will you get rich hell no but you can find work if you want to work. I have never had a hard time finding a job when I wanted to work. only those that feel they are above digging a ditch or getting dirty or flipping burgers are without work those that feel that they are above those that will do what it takes to get by are not working those that will stay in the same town or same state because moveing is so hard are not working. What did those of the great depression do ?? they packed a bag and found a new place to call home where they could find work or reinvent them selves. Those that lost there homes because they took out a note that had a ballon payment or the interest went sky high knew that was going to happen when they signed the contract.
      So all I can say is it's up the single person to do what is best for themselves. Those that think sitting down and waiting for a hand out is best then let them wait for that hand out. I myself have moved more times than I care to think about to find work but I did and I also found work be it working as a pipefitter or shucking oysters or cleaning horse stalls. there are to many people that are not willing to get out there and do what it takes to get the job done they are soft and lazy. Is that what you wanted to hear HELL no it's not why because it's the truth. People don't want to have to do the hard work they want to sit in a room with AC and get paid big bucks to do squat.

    • 1 year ago
  • onemalefla
  • Incredulous
  • bailey78
  • bailey78
  • Argon18
  • bailey78
  • Argon18
  • bailey78
  • Argon18
  • bailey78
  • Argon18
  • bailey78
  • Incredulous
  • bailey78
    • +2
      bailey78  
    • Image
    • Incredulous:

      Yea Yea Yea everybody says they love the bailey but do I ever get asked to the prom? Hell no! I don't I'm just a boy toy for all the people to poke fun at. Just another ugly duckling.

    • 1 year ago
  • remanns
    • +2
      remanns  
    • bailey78:

      Hey man,...........I got a goat I'm taking to the prom,......but if you got a ticket already,.....

      Uhm,.....one word,.....how do you feel about ........."threesome" ?

      purely hypothetical question.

      plus,....tux is expected.

    • 1 year ago
  • remanns
  • remanns
  • remanns
  • bailey78
    • +1
      bailey78  
    • remanns:

      Well so long as the goat don't mind being sealed air tight I'm down with it. I don't have a tux but I have the suit we buried my Father in as far as tickets i have a few of them that were never paid so I guess i could use one of them to get in hypotheticaly of course. Um what time will Ya'll be picking me up?

    • 1 year ago
  • remanns
  • bailey78
    • +1
      bailey78  
    • remanns:

      No problem I have to pull whats left of dad out of the suit. I sure thought he would break down faster than he has. oh well :} time to get him out of it.

    • 1 year ago
  • Incredulous
  • bailey78
  • Incredulous
  • remanns
    • +1
      remanns  
    • Incredulous:

      Not to slander goats,....but they HAVE been known to "play the field"......Just wait a bit till the goat breaks up with us,...I'm sure he would hit the sack with you ! ( Or have I let the cat out of the bag ) ? +^d

    • 1 year ago
  • Incredulous
  • NickerBocker09
    • -1
      NickerBocker09  
    • I thought the presentation of the speech was poor and degraded it all a bit, reminded me of 5th grade but the actual content of the speech was good. He has some good points (invisible hand not working).

    • 1 year ago
  • bailey78
  • r0nan
    • 0
      r0nan  
    • NickerBocker09:

      How ever you judge Stephen Colbert testimony he brought attention to an important issue in the U.S. that other wise no one in this forum would be giving a second thought to.

    • 1 year ago
  • Pollo_Loco_
  • Argon18
  • sudopinion
  • ayipis
    • -9
      ayipis  
    • he testified that he wants the rights of illegal immigrants to pick your vegetables..bus his table..mow his lawn..be his SLAVE

    • 1 year ago
  • hombre76
    • +5
      hombre76  
    • ayipis:

      yes, thats right, democrats want to pay these immigrants..um I mean slaves... a fair wage and acknowlage their "unailienable" rights. Fuck if thats slavery sign my ass up!

    • 1 year ago
  • PressCore
    • +7
      PressCore  
    • ayipis:

      Tell me that humans aren't all slaves to money, and I'll point you
      towards your nearest boneyard. It's early yet in the day, and I
      haven't had a good horse laugh at the idiocy of the human condition.
      Money brought humans out of the jungle, but It can't bring the jungle
      out of humans. Our reptile brain is too old for that to happen this
      soon in the course of human evolution. Webster's Dictionary definition
      of slavery involves domination as the essence of it's modus operandi.
      So again, tell me that the need for living humans to have enough money
      to survive doesn't dominate 80 % of the 6-7 Billion people in this world.

      We feed off the death of other living organisms to survive. And we condone
      the slavery of Manual Labor, the produce picker, because we have to live
      within our means. Mr.Colbert was refering to seeing their human rights
      observed, as in recognized, and enforced, because our hypocrisy shouldn't
      exceed our sense of decency & chivalry. Caesar Chavez would agree.
      I topped some bushels of onions on a muck farm in upstate New York
      when I was a teen. It's damned hard work for too little money for w.a.s.p.s
      to want to perform. And dat's da fact, jack.

    • 1 year ago
  • UtopianSky
  • freecrack
  • Incredulous
    • +1
      Incredulous  
    • UtopianSky:

      LMAO...feeling that, and while I know I should be grateful to have a 'good' job, it's a different kind of oppression, the kind that leaves you yearning for days where you can get up in the morning, walk outside and enjoy the sunshine, or the rain, and think about what you want to do today.

      It's funny that Colbert should quote the Bible, because I recently read the book of Ecclesiastes, supposedly written by King Solomon, and he goes on and on about how he gave his heart to indulge in every single pleasure known to mankind, all of it, everything, and in the end he concluded that the best thing for anyone, is to enjoy their labor...to enjoy the work of their own hands.

      In so many ways, I feel as if capitalism has stolen that from most of us. We are working to survive and to make the man wealthier, not doing the kind of work that we can sit down at the end of a hard day's work, look back at what we have done, and say, it is good. Some people get more compensation for what they do than others, but I think that disconnection is there, no matter what you do, because we are all working for someone else, not really ourselves, or our families, or to make the world a better place. We all have some giant government inspired demand or obligation hanging over us...gotta make the rent or the mortgage, gotta send the kids to college, gotta pay the bills, gotta buy health insurance now, on top of paying taxes. What would happen if we all said fuck you, I'm going home, and learned how to live again? It seems the harder we try to free ourselves, the more companies like Monsanto and the government try to enslave us. Maybe Oliver Stone's new film sums it up best, "Money Never Sleeps":

      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rS0PJSKJoxw&feature=player_embedded

    • 1 year ago
  • EtVoila
    • +2
      EtVoila  
    • ayipis:

      If your comments weren't so idiotic, I'd respect you. Why? Because, you're very good at what you do. The best on Current at what you do, I shouldn't wonder. In fact, I've never seen an instance where you haven't accomplished what you're good at doing.

      Ayipis, you're extremely good at posting comments that:
      1. Everyone from all walks of life disagrees with
      2. Completely miss the point of the entire article
      3. Piss people off/Annoy people/Make people scoff/Make people down vote you

    • 1 year ago
  • ayipis
    • -19
      ayipis  
    • if you really can read between the lines here..this man made such an important issue and made a mockery out of it....thus desensitizing the whole issue

      http://www.latimes.com/news/politics/sc-dc-0925-colbert-congress-20100924,0,2028...:+latimes/news/politics+(L.A.+Times+-+Politics)

      "A hearing on giving undocumented farm workers the right to earn legal status by continuing to work in agriculture turns into an extended skit for the Comedy Central talk show host."

      Stephen Colbert, cable TV political satirist-cum-political activist, was ready to testify.

      "I certainly hope that my star power can bump this hearing all the way up to C-SPAN 1," he said.
      Not quite. Colbert's role as a witness on migrant farm labor before a House Judiciary subcommittee only rated C-SPAN 3. But his appearance in character as a bloviating right-wing talk show host quickly made the rounds on the internet, and marked a permutation of the brand of humor that he and fellow Comedy Central host Jon Stewart have honed. No longer content with parodying politicians, they are extending the joke into the very halls of government that they mock.

      The two comedians have built large followings, especially among liberals. They will step further into the arena they satirize on Oct. 30, when they hold twin rallies on the National Mall. Stewart bills his as a "Rally to Restore Sanity" to political discourse, while Colbert counters with a "March to Keep Fear Alive." Both events are intended as send-ups of a rally led Fox News commentator by Glenn Beck last month. But for participants and viewers, the line between joke and advocacy appears to be getting thinner."

      **************************************

      he was quoted that to "stop illegal immigration is to stop eating vegetables"? what does mr colbert know or have any association with that is even remotely close to the issue??? was he picking vegetables and his rights were abused?? how is even qualified to make a testimony about illegal immigration??

      i want to help these poor souls...whats the proper way of doing it???

      GO AFTER THEIR HOME GOVERNMENTS and force them to "up the living conditions" there so they dont have to come over here and pick vegetables for the likes of mr. colbert..

      do you really think this guy sees a south american illegal immigrant as someone in his own level??? would this motherfucker really eat in the same table as these poor soul??

      sometimes you guys really need to stop patronizing these poverty pimps,..because all it does its misguide the whole issue and make it even worse..

      after everything is said and done..illegal immigrants will still pick his vegetables..he would still call the police when sees an illegal immigrant come close to his house BUT his ratings would be off the chart

    • 1 year ago
  • DougChristian
  • ultravphunter
    • +7
      ultravphunter  
    • ayipis:

      Mr. Colbert's humor did seem a little out of place, at least at first, in the testimony. However, I think that by approaching the situation with humor, Colbert might have made this situation more accessible to the masses.

      If you read between the lines of what Mr. Colbert was saying, he was making some great commentary on how poor the conditions actually are for the migrant farm workers. He did spend a day picking beans with migrant farm workers, and while a single day is nothing compared to making a lifetime career out of field work, Colbert does have some connection with these people, on some level. Are you saying that it's wrong for Colbert to try to defend the rights of migrant farm workers because he hasn't spent a lot of time living as a migrant farm worker?

      It's true, Colbert is doing very well for himself. He's got a successful cable TV show, a few books out, and even has a rally coming up in October in Washington, DC. But I don't think that in itself can prove that Colbert is out of touch with people and has no humanitarian goals, as your comment seems to suggest. I sincerely hope you are not confusing Mr. Colbert with Mr. Beck or Mr. O'Reilly.

    • 1 year ago
  • r0nan
    • +3
      r0nan  
    • ayipis:

      Have you ever visited Sipiya, Azerbaijan in the Summer? Bet it gets hot there huh? Good to have your insanity back. I like having to spend some time down the rabbit hole to reply to ya.
      Is it 4:20 yet?

    • 1 year ago
  • freecrack
  • bailey78
  • remanns
  • PressCore
    • 0
      PressCore  
    • remanns:

      Yes, indeed he is imho. I 2nd your emotion, Remanns. Considering how
      the Corporations pull their stings...How they vote on Statutes they haven't
      " bothered " to read(as if being conscionably responsible were a bother)...
      And how they spend $14 Billion on themselves every year, while toying
      with the idea that the unemployed shouldn't be supported until the uber rich
      get tax cuts to continue the vicious cycle of them squeezing the middle class
      wealth into their hands like a tube of toothpaste...If people of character like
      him, Dennis Cucinich, and Ron Paul were the norm sitting in the H.R.,while
      the Senators get chosen by the States they're supposed to represent we'd
      have an America that wouldn't be on the decline. And we'd be voting for
      real leaders like JFK who wouldn't cotton to being the CEO of a corporate
      conglomerate. People like Ron Paul would have the balls to enforce Executive
      Order 11100. And they wouldn't be installing Monsanto into the Dept. of
      Agriculture. You bet he's a credit to being human, especialy in a world where
      too many are a waste of human skin, not worth their salt looking to sell us
      out to the highest bidder, which would have to be the crooks who've stollen
      the most money, since honest people don't generaly own that much....

    • 1 year ago
  • BKsaysAction
    • +1
      BKsaysAction  
    • Nice one Colbert. Sure people are against Illegal immigrants but the fact that these are American industries in the us with these working conditions is pretty sad.

    • 1 year ago
  • PressCore
    • 0
      PressCore  
    • BKsaysAction:

      Do you know what's sader ? Like horses, we're sadled with a national
      legislature that would make all the founding fathers vomit to death were
      they alive to witness their shenanigans. They refuse to tie the minimum
      wage with the Silver standard, as it was in 1963 because then they would
      have to deal with the can of worms, aka the national debt, they've also
      saddled us with, that they've been putting off for the past 40 years of the U.S.
      Government's bankruptcy. And worse, they would have to deal with the
      root cause of that U.S.Government bankruptcy, the existence of an institution
      owned by a foreign Bankster cartel who's been legaly counterfeiting " money "
      ready to collapse under the weight of a national debt now over more than
      1 year of the GDP of the USA. When NOONE, legals or illegals can be
      guaranteed, by law, to work for a living wage, then the uber rich who own
      controlling shares of stocks in all the publicly traded Corporations, can
      exploit the working class people who are forced to buy produce picked by
      cheaper labor than w.a.s.p.s would work for. I heard them laugh at Mr.Colbert's
      sarcasm. Why shouldn't they ?. They're in show business too. It's Pelosi
      with her ideas of " political correctness " that I'm not laughing at. She's tragic.
      Anyone who say's: " We have to pass this bill to know what it contains " is
      too tragicly sad for words to express.

    • 1 year ago
  • freecrack
  • Argon18
    • +11
      Argon18  
    • I was awed by his quick wit that Stephen could do both comedy and some heartfelt pleas on the behalf of labor in the same appearance.

      http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/09/24/stephen-colbert-hearing-v_n_737813.html

      "I like talking about people who don't have any power...I feel the need to speak for those who can't speak for themselves....We ask them to come and work, and then we ask them to leave again. They suffer, and have no rights."

      Yes there is a demand for labor but there doesn't seem to be any enforcement of the rights of the people doing that labor. It is asked "How many people are unemployed but are unwilling to go work in the fields? The answer: Many."

      Would that answer change if the rights of the people doing the work were properly protected? If all the power is on the side of the people reaping the benefits of that labor then why would that motivate anyone to do that work unless they were forced to by worse circumstances?

    • 1 year ago
  • remanns
  • remanns
  • PressCore
  • UrbanGypsy
    • +1
      UrbanGypsy  
    • Colbert actually impressed me with the way he did some reporting on this issue. Usually I don't really expect much more from the people in the Colbert Report when it comes to serious reporting, but the way they looked at the issue if migrant workers and labor in agriculture was refreshing.

      He did so in a comedic way, but also brought some light on a topic we like to talk about a whole lot, but that we are not very willing to actually look into and talk about in depth.

      There is a demand for labor in agriculture in this country... labor that Americans feel is below them. How many people are unemployed but are unwilling to go work in the fields? The answer: Many.

    • 1 year ago
  • UtopianSky
more from Community:

top videos