Community | October 13, 2010 | 36 comments

Taxi Driver Kicks Out Seven-Year-Old From Taxi | Video

EthicalVegan
Driver kicks 7-year-old out of taxi

By Marina Landis, CNN
October 13, 2010 6:11 p.m. EDT

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

* Police say cabbie Roy D. Sutherland, 66, left 7-year-old alone on a street corner
* The driver had asked the boy if he had money for the fare and got no answer
* Sutherland was arrested and is to be arraigned October 25



New York (CNN) -- A driver for the Valentine Cab Co. in Roosevelt, New York, was charged with endangering the welfare of a child after he kicked a young boy out of his cab Tuesday for not having any money, police said.

Nassau County Police detectives say a 7-year-old boy with special needs was put into a cab in Freeport, New York, by his grandmother and was supposed to be dropped off at his residence in the neighboring Long Island town of Roosevelt.

After picking up the child, the driver of the cab, 66-year-old Roy D. Sutherland, asked the boy if he had money for the fare. When the child was unable to provide any information, Sutherland told him to get out of the cab, police said.

Sutherland left the boy on a street corner in Freeport by himself and drove away, police said.

Sutherland was later arrested and issued an appearance ticket, police said. He's scheduled to be arraigned at the First District Court in Hempstead on October 25.

______________


7-year-old boy kicked out of cab - WABC/TV
Wednesday, October 13, 2010


Lauren DeFranco


FREEPORT, NY (WABC) -- A cab driver is accused of dumping a 7-year-old boy onto the street because he didn't have any money.

He was making a routine trip from his Grandmother's home to his mother's house.

"I was just a little crazy at the moment, because I was like, what do you mean he didn't have fare, he's 7 years old," Joy Allen, Alex's mother said.


Joy Allen is still in a state of shock, she's so angry and upset.

Monday at around 5 p.m., a cab driver left her 7-year-old son Alex alone on a street corner in Freeport.

What's worse, is that Alex is a child with special needs and has difficulty communicating.

"He begged the cab driver not to put him out of the car, and he said that the cab driver told him, he doesn't have time for people who don't have money and to get out," Allen said.

"I said OK, and so I got out and stood by myself," Alex said.

Allen, who doesn't drive, had called the Express Valentine Taxi Company to take her son from her mother's home in Freeport to her house in Roosevelt.

When the cab driver realized the boy didn't have money, he kicked him out of the car.

"I called the cab company screaming, no forget everything, tell me where my son is before we resolve anything, where is my son, where is my son, and he couldn't get an answer out of the driver," Allen said.

Alex was alone and confused and crying for his grandmother who eventually found him.

"I was screaming for Grandma, and I keep saying, Grandma!" Alex said.

Eyewitness News went to the owner of the cab company who said it is company policy to turn away any passenger who doesn't pay the fare upfront.

Allen says a 7 year old child with a disability isn't just any passenger.

"I speak for a lot of people, I could never put a child out anywhere," Allen said.

The driver, Roy Sutherland, 66, will be arraigned on charges of endangering a child later this month.
  1. groups:
    Community,   WTF,   Current Tonight,   Health,   8 more
  2. tags:
    Taxis Children's Rights Special Needs children's health 10 more
  3.     
    |

36 comments // Taxi Driver Kicks Out Seven-Year-Old From Taxi | Video

  • eden49
    • +2
      eden49  
    • ...there seems to have been a total lack of communication here...wouldn't you inform the driver that money would be paid by the mother at the destination...anyhow, apart from that, I would never entrust any child to a total stranger in a situation such as this, especially with a special needs child...this is the third incident I've come across in so many days of this type of bloody dumbness by parents...I stopped a 2 yr old from running onto the road, picked her up, and took her back into the shoe shop and yelled out, does this child belong to anyone...a guy stood and said, she's mine, to which I replied, well, she nearly bloody wasn't...and I won't relate the other, but suffice to say, just as irresponsible...and furthermore, if you're stupid enough to blindly hand over your child to a stranger, you take the risk of that stranger being this dickhead cabdriver...rant over...

    • 1 year ago
  • freecrack
  • eden49
    • 0
      eden49  
    • freecrack:

      ...there are no buses in New York???...maybe not the grandmother...but if this was my child, I'd pick him up personally...but that's just me...I trust no-one...but there are a lot of grey areas here...and different scenarios are painfully obvious...I just would never ever trust anyone with the welfare of my child, even if I have to crawl on my hands and knees...sounds dramatic, I know, but your child is your most prized possession...nothing is too inconvenient...nothing...

    • 1 year ago
  • freecrack
    • 0
      freecrack  
    • eden49:

      i cant speak to the exact location this grandmas house is in relation to a bus stop, but i can tell you a bus ride in freeport for the weak is asking for abuse straight up.

      it is common on long island for kids to utilize taxi's.from the spoiled pricks whos parents cant be bothered to bring them to ballet class, to those who cant afford cars and still need to send thier kids to places like school.

    • 1 year ago
  • Radical_Centrist
  • timetide
  • ThatdBMe
    • +1
      ThatdBMe  
    • timetide:

      The kid is special needs. Do you really think a random stranger has the experience to handle a situation with the kid if he freaks out? More than likely not.

    • 1 year ago
  • EthicalVegan
    • +2
      EthicalVegan  
    • Radical_Centrist:

      Up until recently, at least, I've known of bonded taxi companies accepting a ride, knowing that at the end of the trip, there will be someone awaiting such individuals, so that the driver can be paid. Can't speak for either 2010 or most cities' public taxi services.

    • 1 year ago
  • freecrack
    • +2
      freecrack  
    • Radical_Centrist:

      its common on long island.i was a dispatcher for five years (not too far from there actualy) and it is a neccesity.and turning this kid out is bullshit.my company, and my imediate competitors would never accept such a thing.one of our drivers kicks out a kid (forget the special needs part) and they are done.period.

    • 1 year ago
  • freecrack
    • 0
      freecrack  
    • ThatdBMe:

      maybe some one whos job requires the ability to deal with the general public, the retarded included, isnt for this driver.
      i am afraid of hieghts, so im not a roofer.
      this guy shouldnt be unleashed on the public

    • 1 year ago
  • ThatdBMe
  • Radical_Centrist
    • 0
      Radical_Centrist  
    • timetide:

      To my mind it would matter not if it was a chauffeur driven Bentley. She did not know this guy from Adam and TRUSTED him with her Grandchild. When my Daughter was younger there very very few people I trusted her with. I certainly would have NEVER trusted her with a STRANGER in Public Transportation. Maybe I am just paranoid, but thats just me.

    • 1 year ago
  • Radical_Centrist
  • Radical_Centrist
    • 0
      Radical_Centrist  
    • freecrack:

      From the comments I have been reading on here I understand it is a common practice in your neck of the woods. I just think it is fool hearty to trust your kids with STRANGERS especially when they are special needs. I will assume that is politically Correct speak for retarded.

    • 1 year ago
  • freecrack
    • 0
      freecrack  
    • ThatdBMe:

      people who work with the general public (myself included) should come prepared to do so.it isnt the general public who needs to curtail thier behavior for the worker, but the worker who needs to curtail thier persona for the public.the public from whom they are being paid.take away the monitary compensation element, and you can be an asshole all you want, shit its a right.but when you are functioning in the public as a vocation, you are paid to not be yourself.

      tech support,retail,and food services employees should be expected to function in a manor that accomidates what ever they come across.in my case i spend my day being schizophrenic.im a republican in one house, a flaming liberal in the next.telling dirty jokes to the dirty old men, and placating stupid children at others.i play along with my customers who have long since lost thier minds, and those whos children never fully had them.from the autistic screamers, to the deaf speach impared grunters who for some reason really really want me to look at the picture they drew.

      im an asshole, and dont really like people in general.if i can do it, anyone can.if this cab driving scumfuck couldnt suck up his greed for the few moments it would take to be a descent human being, fuck him.put him on the bread lines, as it is what he deserves.

    • 1 year ago
  • freecrack
    • 0
      freecrack  
    • Radical_Centrist:

      $$$$$$$$$$$$$
      is a luxury.not everyone has both the option of distrust, and the means to afford it.
      i highly doubt any of the kids i had to send drivers to pick up were the result of trusting parents, but the only means by wich they could get it done.hell a whole lot of them were stuck in a cycle of needing cabs to go to work, to earn the money, to buy a car.but the thing is that cycle is hard to get out from.i mean if they saved all the money they spent on cabs in a year they could buy a car, but then they couldnt have gotten to the jobs they did, that earned that money.

    • 1 year ago
  • freecrack
    • 0
      freecrack  
    • Radical_Centrist:

      freeport and roosevelt are on long island, and are places that it is common to have to pay upfront.(they are places white people dont go alone)
      but similarly it is also understood equaly that 7 year olds arent the ones who skip fares, wich is just the nature of the job.

    • 1 year ago
  • freecrack
    • 0
      freecrack  
    • Radical_Centrist:

      a tard is a tard, fuck it.
      you are stuck on this trust issue.i dont trust a lot of people, but i need thier services none the less.it isnt a matter of choice.and i asure you anyone using a cab in either freeport or roosevelt and doing so soley by choice.it is like snow blowers to new england, and sunscreen in florida.poor areas are slaves to taxis.trust has nothing to do with it.

      the special needs part doesnt even equate.would it be any less horrific if some one abandons a straight a student who is 7? it is just as awefull to me.the tard part is just the bleeding heart icing on the cake in demonizing this already sorry excuse for a human being.

    • 1 year ago
  • ThatdBMe
    • 0
      ThatdBMe  
    • What? Really? I get the point of protecting the kid and all but, don't stick your kid in a paid service expecting a free ride, especially don't stick your kid in a paid service with no money, he's mentally disabled, and ALONE. That's bad parenting. Darwinism at its finest.

    • 1 year ago
  • timetide
    • 0
      timetide  
    • ThatdBMe:

      The parents were going to pay when he was dropped off.... or did you skip that part? I know everytime I take a taxi I pay at the end when i arrive, not shaked down in the middle of the trip.

    • 1 year ago
  • ThatdBMe
    • 0
      ThatdBMe  
    • timetide:

      Please quote that because I just went through the article like 5 more times and I didn't see that so, I'm really missing where it says that.

      Added: Reread again. I think you missed the part about "Eyewitness News went to the owner of the cab company who said it is company policy to turn away any passenger who doesn't pay the fare upfront." Pay the fare upfront.

    • 1 year ago
  • freecrack
    • 0
      freecrack  
    • ThatdBMe:

      bad parenting is raising some one who abandons a child.and by the way both freeport and roosevelt, not really known for being good areas.they are the areas you dont go out at night.

    • 1 year ago
  • freecrack
    • 0
      freecrack  
    • ThatdBMe:

      apparently not so much policy as he took the kid for a litle bit of a ride before letting him out.he didnt put the kid out at moms house, wich is what would have happened had he been demanding payment up front.

    • 1 year ago
  • ThatdBMe
  • freecrack
    • 0
      freecrack  
    • ThatdBMe:

      you want to buy them a car? the thing is no one else wants to either, so that is the situation they are in.
      from personaly knowing freeport and roosevelt, as i was raised in the town between them (merrick) of all the options possible, taxi is the safest option.

      a bus ride in freeport is no place for a child, no less a special needs one.

      i hope for your sake you never find yourself in the position these people are in.or maybe you need to, in order to appreciate how truly defenseless and victimized they were.

    • 1 year ago
  • ThatdBMe
    • 0
      ThatdBMe  
    • freecrack:

      The grandmother couldn't ride with the kid? They didn't have friends? The mom couldn't take a taxi to the grandmother's and picked the kid up and rode home with him?

    • 1 year ago
  • freecrack
    • 0
      freecrack  
    • ThatdBMe:

      a trip from freeport to roosevelt cross's three towns in total.call your local cab company and see how much it costs to do that round trip.maybe the grandmother had a pressing appointment to be at, like work,or a doctors appointment.maybe she is old and weak, and such a trip is bad for her health.a zillion reasons exist as to why she wouldnt go, and they are irrelevent.

      if picking the kid up alone is wrong, then the driver shouldnt have done it to begin with at all.the driver is just wrong above all other parties no matter wich way you slice it.he took the obligation of picking the kid up.he took the kid a percentage of the way.then abandoned him for lack of money when requested.not at the begining or end of the trip, but randomly in the middle.

      if they had friends, they wouldnt need a taxi.statisticaly the more people ya know, the more options for a ride.if they had friends to rely upon, i dont see a taxi as the prefered choice by a mother who freaked as she did.

      you really are lost at how $$$$ plays in to this huh.
      try paying for a taxi for a month as your only means of transport, and see what the bill is like.then ask if you would turn trips into round trips, with an additional person charge.then ask if some one who may be chosing between feeding her kids or not would do it?millions of kids get picked up and dropped off by taxis everyday.millions of them re handicapped as well, as the handicaped make up a sizeable number of taxi clientel.less than people commuting to work or trains, but more than hookers and drunks.

    • 1 year ago
  • ThatdBMe
    • 0
      ThatdBMe  
    • freecrack:

      I never once said the driver wasn't in the wrong. My point is the mother/grandmother are in the wrong, also. The driver was wrong for throwing the kid out, granted. The only reason I bring up anything or comment on this is to show the mother and grandmother are wrong, as well. We can't put the blame totally on the driver.

      If the mother or grandmother couldn't afford feeding their children versus a round trip taxi ride, then they need to get their priorities straight. If for whatever reason they couldn't make a trip with this kid, then they should've made the visit for another day.

    • 1 year ago
  • Radical_Centrist
    • 0
      Radical_Centrist  
    • ThatdBMe:

      The Cab driver was as wrong as two left shoes. You do not put a 7 year old kid out on the street for ANYTHING. I mean if the cabbie thought it was a scam he could have taken him to the Police Station.

    • 1 year ago
  • ThatdBMe
  • freecrack
    • 0
      freecrack  
    • ThatdBMe:

      if i remember correctly at some point you labeled me a neocon, or something to that effect.but here you are doing thier schtick.you are making judgements with little or now information.
      the mother and the grandmother could very well be world class fucktards, who should have never been able to breed.but nothing in the story, as it was told indicated anything about why they used the cab, what thier financial situation is,why the kid needed to be transported, or really anything aside from what the driver did.

      you are completely ok making judgements about things that no information either way is available to evaluate.if that isnt trademark republican behavior (tea party personification) i dont know what is.

      the mother and the grand mother may be very much so in the wrong, but im not going to even touch that with the complete absence of information about them, other than they were in need of a taxi.

      personaly though, aside from catious judgement, i dont care about who was wronger (hurts to even read that huh) when a child was abandoned.that exceeds anything else.lets say i go to a customers house and the parents are nowhere to be found, and the kids are living like lord of the flies.sure the parents are guilty of neglect, but far worse would be me walking away like i didnt see it.far worse would be me having opportunity to help these kids, and choosing to turn my back on thier well being.i dont care if the kid was barking like a dog the whole ride, had no money, and was bouncing up and down on the seat, you just dont ignore the fact that they are defenseless children.mom and grandma may have been wrong on many levels, but nothing that compares even remotely to a member of society throwing a 7 year old to the wolves.

      its like the "she was asking for it" rape defense.it really doesnt matter if she was dressed like a whore, the greater error is the rape.putting a kid in a taxi without money isnt the best idea in the world, but doesnt even come close to abandoning a child.

    • 1 year ago
  • ThatdBMe
    • 0
      ThatdBMe  
    • freecrack:

      --Snip--if i remember correctly at some point you labeled me a neocon, or something to that effect.--Snip--

      Moot point but, I'm going to argue it anyway because I hate when people misquote me. Here are all my replies to you:

      --Snip--Well, hate speech or not, if it's true, then it's true. I seek truth whether it makes people happy or not.--Snip--

      --Snip--Thank you for your concern. =) I'm very aware of the propaganda machine.--Snip--

      http://current.com/news/92690740_israel-breaking-records-around-the-globe.htm

      --Snip--That's surprising, how? LDS are very, very educated about their beliefs. Whether you agree with them or not, they do know why they believe what they do, contrary to most main-stream Xians I've talked to.--Snip--

      http://current.com/entertainment/comedy/92692993_study-atheists-know-the-most-ab...

      --Snip--Thank you. That was kind of you to say. =)

      I don't really care about the vote ups. I'm not here to be popular. I just don't understand why people scream for fair and balanced, for truth, but still want to censor things they don't agree with. I get *a lot* of crap for saying I watch Fox, too bad people can only see that far into who I am and don't let me get the chance to say I also read/watch CNN, MSNBC, HuffingtonPost, USA Today, NY Times, on and on. Merely mentioning Fox causes the masses to spasm and get blinders.--Snip--

      http://current.com/news/92692864_obama-fox-news-is-destructive-to-america.htm

      This is pretty much our first real interaction. =)

      Now, to the real topic at hand! You have your point of view on how people should act, I have mine. I think it is so incredibly wrong to One -- Put a child in a taxi with a complete stranger. Two -- That said child has a mental handicap. You disagree. That's fine. You raise your kids how you want and, if I ever decide to spawn, I'll raise mine how I think is appropriate.

    • 1 year ago
  • freecrack
  • ThatdBMe
    • 0
      ThatdBMe  
    • Image
    • freecrack:

      Maybe a tad defensive. I knew you were kind to me a couple of times and our interactions haven't been that bad so, I wanted to see if I did call you any names. There's only one person on this site that I can't stand and it isn't you. =)

      Not a lot of work. Two minutes, at most, via Google. 86 results (Most of them the same page) for ThatdBMe Freecrack site:current.com

    • 1 year ago
  • freecrack
    • 0
      freecrack  
    • ThatdBMe:

      im a tech tard, so it would have been a lot of work for me lol
      i try not to be a dick, cuz then my points are dismissed.
      let me guess does your nemisis start with an a and end in s?

    • 1 year ago
  • ThatdBMe
more from Community:

top videos