Community | November 08, 2010 | 121 comments

Antigay Bullying Suicide in Penn.

Image
TimALoftis
Fourteen-year-old Brandon Bitner walked in front of a tractor-trailer in the early hours of Friday morning, and his friends say the Middleburg, Penn. child was driven to suicide after being bullied about his perceived sexual orientation.

“It was because of bullying,” friend Takara Jo Folk wrote in a letter to The Daily Item of Sunbury, Penn. “It was not about race, or gender, but they bullied him for his sexual preferences and the way he dressed. Which they wrongly accused him of.”

Bitner, a freshman at Midd-West high school, dressed in emo-style clothing and was bullied mercilessly for it, according to fellow students. “Anyone in our school who looks different is tortured,” sophomore Emily Beall-Ellersieck told The Daily Item.

Midd-West high school held an antibullying assembly just days prior to Bitner's suicide, but students said no one took it seriously.
  1. groups:
    Community,   Current Tonight,   Health,   Webmash,   11 more
  2. tags:
    Human Rights Gay Rights Suicide Hate 12 more
  3.     
    |

121 comments // Antigay Bullying Suicide in Penn.

  • MarissaMFer
    • +2
      MarissaMFer  
    • I think this is a social issue that goes beyond "feeling sorry for gays". This is a problem that many teenagers goes through. Where in one of the most formative points in their lives, they are going through an identity crisis, while simultaneously being tormented for being different. Which is something I think we could all relate to in junior and highschool years no matter what our sexual orientation, race or religion. So this should definitely be something we can all come together and agree upon no matter what political stance or religion we hold.

      This is not just a gay issue. It's a social issue. But, I think having a focal point on the gay community is a great way to bring this problem to light. We have to make the young people know that life is worth living.

    • 1 year ago
  • EthicalVegan
  • Mattchicago
    • 0
      Mattchicago  
    • i noticed that too a very big influx in gay suicides across the united states. I wonder what this world is coming to. I am gay i was not really bullied per say in school but i did have my haters but well i never thought about suicide i would just kick the person's ass who was trying to hate against me. Gay but not a push over i guess you can say.

      I feel sorry for the family and friends of the people who do result to killing themselves but also i have noticed that also its the parents fault they cannot detect signs of there children or teenagers that are being mentally tormented and they wont come out to parents mostly since they are afraid the parents will also be against them and either kick them out or be bad to them so its a loose - loose situation on both aspects.

    • 1 year ago
  • EthicalVegan
  • riverratt50
    • -2
      riverratt50  
    • This "bully" bs is an excuse to have someone feel sorry for you enough to justify killing yourself. I would just like to know the number of gay people that were killing themselves prior to it being a fashion statement to kill yourself "because I was bullied." What was the excuse before, because my parents won't except me? Maybe because my boy / girl friend don't love me anymore? Or maybe it was just because one did not have a boy / girl friend. Regardless, I say it's all suspect when every suicide that takes place with a gay person now is "Hate" and "Bully". Just tell me folks. Reminds me of the line, "I was country when country wasn't cool". *shaking head*

    • 1 year ago
  • EthicalVegan
  • lnlm16r
  • r0nan
  • thetrimsmith
    • +5
      thetrimsmith  
    • With the rash of gay/bully related suicides lately, I wonder if add/adhd meds have any bearing. Confusing rationale, creating unbearable emotions. I would imagine that parents of young gays/lesbians try to ''fix'' them with mood enhancers, coupled with the cruelty of High School social tiers...

    • 1 year ago
  • Nephwrack
  • bailey78
  • randallr01
    • +4
      randallr01  
    • The way you handle a bully is to go after his/her weaknesses. Do NOT have mercy. Do NOT be compassionate: A bully must be bullied in order to change. I wish I could personally stand up to all bullies everywhere, on behalf of the bullied... =Z

      Instead, I'll offer advice from my experiences: Take the lowest blow possible against the bully, and you win. It's really as simple as that.

    • 1 year ago
  • randallr01
  • ayipis
  • randallr01
  • xiola
  • ozoneocean
  • timetide
  • Manatee_man
    • +3
      Manatee_man  
    • http://around.ye

      Bullying is a very complicated thing these days. I'm currently a freshman in th Hopkins School District in Minnesota. They have a HUGE anti-Bully campaign. Every single room at the high school has a sign that says "LGBT Bully Free Zone." It is very hard to tell if there is actual bullying or joking around. Yes, sometimes joking around is accident bullying.
      At the school I've been to while in Hopkins, I've actually seen no bullying (or accident bullying) anywhere. I have friends in every social situatation and everyone seems to just love each other. The only major thing I've seen is the usual talking-behind-someones-back thing but most of the time it just stops.
      I really have no idea what's happening around this country with teens, but I'm so glad none of this shit is happening at my school.

    • 1 year ago
  • toyotabedzrock
  • randallr01
  • xiola
  • xiola
    • +5
      xiola  
    • Hmmm... this conversation has me pondering where it begins. I was bullied quite a lot as a kid, until I reached high school and got out of that terribly awkward phase. So, why was I bullied?
      I wore thick glasses, was painfully thin, wore headgear for a while (tragic!), had unruly hair and didn't give a damn about clothes or girlie stuff. I liked to read. I liked to study. I liked being in band, and I wasn't interested in being a cheerleader. But is that WHY I was bullied? I'm not really sure. I wasn't then, and I'm not now.
      I'm sure some of you are right: they just smelled the vulnerability on me--the lack of confidence, and they went in for the kill. That's probably true, but that's not entirely it. I tried to stand up for myself. But with each episode of bullying, my confidence weakened, making me more vulnerable to the next attack. A vicious cycle.
      It occurs to me that it was usually just a few who did the bullying, but they were relentless. And usually they were older kids. The witnesses just laughed nervously or fell into awkward silence.
      Perhaps the bullies won't stop bullying, but if some of the witnesses stood up against it, it might make a difference. I still remember the few who quietly stood up for me, retrieving my trumpet for me when someone would steal it on the bus and hide it. Or maybe just a smile and a pat on the back. But those people knew if they stood up, they'd be bullied for it.
      When I reached high school I didn't change on the inside. I did, however, get contacts, lose the braces and headgear, learn how to use a straightening iron, develop a bit and got a couple of decent outfits. And, voila! All is well. I'm acceptable.
      I still remember this older guy telling me, "God, you're not nearly as retarded as you used to be." But, really, I hadn't changed a bit.
      ...and he meant it as a compliment.

    • 1 year ago
  • unimatrix0
  • xiola
    • +5
      xiola  
    • unimatrix0:

      Thank you for reading. Kinda cathartic to share some of it. Just trying to figure out where this behavior starts and how to end it. Wish we could find the answer.

    • 1 year ago
  • PzLuvHappeniz
    • +3
      PzLuvHappeniz  
    • I'm so sick of small minded fucks like that preying on people for being different, that shit happened to so many people at my school when i saw it i tried to stop it. People need to learn that bulliyng in all forms is wrong and should be fought against when it is seen. This truly infuriates me because i know what pennsyltucky is like and the bigots that come from there are terrible, they love to protest on the PSU campus and i always try to debate with them.

    • 1 year ago
  • Ares
  • Radical_Centrist
  • PzLuvHappeniz
    • 0
      PzLuvHappeniz  
    • Ares:

      It is not bullying, it is me defending a friend or a random peer by stopping the bullying from happening, its not like I'm bigger than the bullies and constantly pick on them

    • 1 year ago
  • Jake_Leonard
    • +4
      Jake_Leonard  
    • This bullying mentality needs to stop; but it appears to be an issue often swept under the rug. It carries on through older age, too. It's a matter of survival of the fittest, and cutting ethics out in order to gain any sort of upper hand.

      I'm no expert on the matter, nor have I done much research into bullying, but the relationship between the parents and their child needs to be more closely knit. Between both parents working a minimum of 40 hours/week, and the kids being influenced the rest of the time at school, there is just too little time to bond.

      I was homeschooled all of the way up until college. My mom always detested emotional and physical abuse among us siblings; she taught us empathy and communication. And my dad never encouraged us to be "hardasses," nor did he ever use condescension such as "You're being a wussy..." etc. He taught us honesty and honor. Kids who have a mother that does not foster love, and a father who does not provide guidance to the high road of "being a man" feel disconnected and turn to complete selfish and survival instincts. I would have. I am fortunate in being able to get along with nearly anybody--save for maybe snobs and hypocrites.

      It's a cliché, but I believe the most important thing a parent can do is be there for their kids; not always reprimand, per-se, but be their wise man, or counselor. I have seen good friends of mine go the bully route; and it's contagious...

    • 1 year ago
  • Ares
    • -2
      Ares  
    • Jake_Leonard:

      I'm not sure about the parenting theory on this matter. Sure, it's important for parents to be actively empathic in their children's problems, but one of the chief purposes of public schooling is to incite solidarity among peer groups. Those that either fail to make friends or, in this case, actively put forth an effort to avoid "fitting in" suffer the consequences of their self-induced isolation.

      I'm not condoning bullies' behavior, but the strong (or more often, the insecure) prey on the weak. The weakest push it inward instead of seeking the support of peers, family, or educators. It's a shame this kid took such a radical approach to his problem, but you can't coddle every extreme case like this. There are resources available to kids in his situation. No fourteen year old is so cemented in a personal image that they are condemned to that life forever. He chose to dress differently, dissociate himself, and he reaped the consequences of those choices. Kids are bad at making adult decisions.

    • 1 year ago
  • xiola
    • +2
      xiola  
    • Ares:

      "The weakest push it inward instead of seeking the support of peers, family, or educators." I get what you're saying, but when you're a kid, ratting people out is THE WORST. You do that, and you're guaranteed retribution from the people you ratted out. It's not that you're weak, it's just that you know how it works...

    • 1 year ago
  • div
    • 0
      div  
    • Ares:

      The strong don't really prey on the weak anymore. We outgrew that mentality a long time back. Don't you notice that the worst bullies are also the biggest cowards when they don't have support?

    • 1 year ago
  • libertyforall
    • 0
      libertyforall  
    • Gay or not, almost everyone who ever went to high school has been bullied at some point. For some reason, kids today are killing themselves over it. Is it bad parenting and parents not teaching kids how to stand up for themselves?

      This is really just a recent phenomenon and not something that you heard of 20 years ago.

      One thing is clear, this kid was clearly selfish to walk in front of a semi and ruin the life of another person.

    • 1 year ago
  • Dmerza1989
    • +2
      Dmerza1989  
    • Hmmm here is a thought maybe parents should be more involved in this? Why is it up to the school officials to be the ones mainly dealing with bullying?
      "students said no one took it seriously. " im not sure about you but once i parents put a foot up my ass i was fucking serious about shit.

    • 1 year ago
  • toyotabedzrock
    • +2
      toyotabedzrock  
    • Something tells me he was gay, just didn't tell his friends yet.
      After last week I wouldn't be surprised to see more of this. Especially because of losses in state races.

    • 1 year ago
  • bailey78
    • +10
      bailey78  
    • thats messed up in more ways than one. Why did he deside to ruin the life of a truck driver? To take ones life is uncalled for. But to take your life at the exspense of another is even more fucked up. yes being bullied is bad yes being bullied is wrong so is ruining the life of a complete stranger by useing them as a weapon to kill yourself is just fucked up.

    • 1 year ago
  • xiola
  • Dmerza1989
    • +4
      Dmerza1989  
    • bailey78:

      You make a good point, that truck driver is probably having some emotional issues right now because someone forced him to kill them. We don't see the truck driver to blame but how do we know how he sees it, he could be blaming himself. I know i might be. Anyone who goes out of their way to send messages to the family should go to the truck driver and and make sure he is okay. He was an innocent victim in all this. Suicide itself is selfish, but forcing someone to be a part your own is just plain wrong.

    • 1 year ago
  • bailey78
    • +1
      bailey78  
    • Dmerza1989:

      This very thing happen to a friend of mine up in W.V. a few years back a mentally disturbed person walked out in front of him. He was running at Highway speeds he hit the guy and never drove a truck again. He was so freaked out by it that it was quite a while before he would even drive his family car He still has nightmares about it. There are so many things you can do besides kill yourself. That is one othe most selfish things a person could do. I have tried it a couple of times I think about it quite offten but I will not do it because I know it is a permanent solution to a temporary problem.

    • 1 year ago
  • bailey78
    • 0
      bailey78  
    • xiola:

      One must think things out before acting. I know I talk to some of the folks Here at current when I don't feel right. i sure wish this person had done the same

    • 1 year ago
  • EthicalVegan
  • EthicalVegan
  • oppressed1
  • PzLuvHappeniz
  • Ares
  • oppressed1
  • div
  • oppressed1
    • 0
      oppressed1  
    • div:

      I know that, but the feminist movement has turned our boys into pussies. Most kids today cant fight for their own defense. So that only leaves the bullies to run the schools. Meet me by the oak tree to settle this has turned into these kids pussy parents goign to the school counselor, to talk about the situation. Which turns into more fuel for the bully.

    • 1 year ago
  • div
    • +1
      div  
    • oppressed1:

      The feminist movement showed boys that being beaten up isn't the only way they have to live. It showed them that they were human too, and entitled to actually having feelings and desires of their own that did not include having the shit knocked out of them.

      There is nothing in this world that is NOT fuel for a person who wants to hurt another. If a kid doesn't go the the counselor, it's fuel. If the kid does go to the counselor, it's fuel. But at least with the kid going to the counselor, he's got some kind of help on the other side.

    • 1 year ago
  • PzLuvHappeniz
  • oppressed1
    • -1
      oppressed1  
    • div:

      The feminist movement taught men they can have feelings....lol

      If any male says that they have feelings because of some chick movement. They should be bullied.

    • 1 year ago
  • oppressed1
  • div
  • EthicalVegan
  • div
  • titan50
    • +4
      titan50  
    • This is a horrible situation. What I don't get is why are we just focusing on anti-gay bullying when all kinds of bullying goes on day to day. Bullying of any kind is not good, so we need to focus on all types.

    • 1 year ago
  • xiola
  • maasanova
    • 0
      maasanova  
    • Brandon Bitner left a note suicide but we are not told what the note said. The note may have given us more clues to explain this tragic event, but instead, we are relying on hearsay, basically rumors from teenagers and other aquaintances tell us why Brandon Bitner actually committed suicide.

      I am not saying that Bitner did not commit suicide because he was bullied, I am saying that in this particular instance, we are relying mostly on hearsay when we should be relying on stone cold facts.

      We all know that there is anti-bullying campaign that is currently being used to usher in legislation in many parts of the world, especially here in the United States, and that there is enough evidence to suggest that these suicides are being as propaganda to pass that legislation.

    • 1 year ago
  • ayipis
    • -4
      ayipis  
    • again (i am sure those familiar with my rant already knows )

      you cannot stop bullies with "anti-bully" laws or wearing Purple..you have to fight these fucking bastards..

      its time to stop trying to baby these kids and time to teach them to FIGHT for what is right..

    • 1 year ago
  • dreamsenvoy
  • littlwarrior
    • +8
      littlwarrior  
    • "Midd-West high school held an antibullying assembly just days prior to Bitner's suicide, but students said no one took it seriously."
      That right there is the problem, highschoolers never take things serioulsly until it i made serious, teacher administrators, everyone needs to make this somthing to be serious about and when they catch this crap going down make sure the shit hits the fan hard.

    • 1 year ago
  • TimALoftis
  • ayipis
  • bailey78
    • +4
      bailey78  
    • ayipis:

      i'm thinking about the man or woman driveing the truck what about him/her? what is he / she going to do now I'm sure the driver is never going to be the same. Thats a fucked up thing to do to somebody.

    • 1 year ago
  • ayipis
  • randallr01
  • randallr01
    • +2
      randallr01  
    • TimALoftis:

      "When will the HATE stop?" The answer: when parents stop teaching their children to hate.

      ALL of this bullying lies on the shoulders of the parents. Fuckin' majority of good-for-nothing Baby Boomers.....

      (note: i said 'majority;' not 'all')

    • 1 year ago
  • div
more from Community:

top videos