Image
tverdell
The layer of human turmoil - looting and scuffles for food or services - that often comes in the wake of disaster seems noticeably absent in Japan.

“Looting simply does not take place in Japan. I’m not even sure if there’s a word for it that is as clear in its implications as when we hear ‘looting,’" said Gregory Pflugfelder, director of the Donald Keene Center of Japanese Culture at Columbia University.

Japanese have “a sense of being first and foremost responsible to the community,” he said.

To Merry White, an anthropology professor at Boston University who studies Japanese culture , the real question is why looting and disorder exist in American society. She attributes it largely to social alienation and class gaps.

Click on the article for more.
  1. groups:
    Community,   Art and Style,   Humanism,   Earthquakes/Tsunamis/Volcanoes
  2. tags:
    Looting japan earthquake 2011
  3.     
    |

65 comments // No Looting in Japan

  • wonka7
    • 0
      wonka7  
    • I'm japanese.I think looting is bad!but i think" looting is bad"is common in all countries,no?
      I'm not sure no looting here.
      I always surprise sometimes i saw looting or big demo in another countries.
      I haven't thought try looting.
      If i cant get foods or something by disaster.just think about waitting for come support-foods(?).
      Many people want help.not only me.have to care another people.its normal.so never think of looting.

    • 1 year ago
  • Raffielo
  • Rick_Carufel
    • 0
      Rick_Carufel  
    • Yeah, No looting until the American Church Groups get there and start looting children...
      They are like carrion eaters, they show up at every disaster and try to steal as many childern as possible and sneak them out of the country while everything is still in a state of chaos.

    • 1 year ago
  • radmellow
    • 0
      radmellow  
    • Why is there no looting in Japan during the disaster? I will tell you why. Life expectancy in a Japanese prison is very short due to no penthouse accommodations and only fish heads on the menu. Our government is trying to decide to cut money from education or prisons. Well maybe we should ask the Japanese what they would do since they have a better education system and a small prison population. JP’s are no joke …they will beat you down on the streets. They are feared and respected and therefore everything is conducted in an orderly fashion. Just my opinion.

    • 1 year ago
  • HaloedGriot
    • 0
      HaloedGriot  
    • You fools are still drinking the Kool-Aid about no looting in Japan? If I could find a Japanese source for you I would, but its not gonna happen; you won't find it in print...its just something Japanese won't do...why report something to outsiders that will incriminate the entire people? So of course you guys will be shown the images of Japanese "behaving"...I guess I just overestimate the intelligence of you all...I thought if you at least read the name of Marnie Hunter as the contributor, you would see her as an unreliable source, namely because she is not Japanese and secondly, she is with CNN. The Japanese news has completely different numbers than the US in regards to number missing, dead, radiation reports and the like...and of course, amount of violence and looting.

      If left up to Japan, you guys would believe everyone in Japan is earning over $100,000 a year and there is 0% crime. Sadly, some of you DO BELIEVE IT.

      My info comes straight from the mouths of Japanese people IN JAPAN!

    • 1 year ago
  • alexandrek
  • HaloedGriot
    • 0
      HaloedGriot  
    • alexandrek:

      Whoa, my bad Godzilla...I didn't realize you had a bird's eye view of the entire country...did I say Tokyo? You must've been out there with Anderson Cooper making sure everything's in order, giving your nod of approval.

      Get over yourself, geek.

    • 1 year ago
  • Pawper
    • 0
      Pawper  
    • I wish people would quit using this to bash America. Yes, America is fucked up, but so is Japan. Japan does not have peace among its peoples; there are invisible "undesirable" minorities who are discriminated against in marriage, employment, etc. They're generally also rather xenophobic (including some bad feelings towards Americans for our continued military presence), so I would definitely hesitate before saying America should be more like Japan. We should, however, continue to support the Japanese people's peaceful behavior in this terrible situation, behavior which is certainly inspiring.

    • 1 year ago
  • GlobalSherpa
    • 0
      GlobalSherpa  
    • Image
    • A very high 75.9% or 194,139 of 255,844 wallets and 94.7% or 95,000 of 100,247 cell phones reported lost in Tokyo in 2005 were turned in to authorities according to the Tokyo Metropolitan Police Lost and Found Center. In 2002, the Tokyo Lost and Found Center took in $23 million in missing cash, 72 percent of which was returned to its rightful owners. Japan’s remarkable penchant for returning lost items and refusing to loot are products of a culture that emphasizes the importance of group harmony or “wa.” Japanese are still human but taking advantage of the situation or someone else’s hardship for one’s own benefit, even in such desperate times of need and necessity, seems to fly in the face of the core values that guide Japanese behavior and hold Japanese society intact.

      Jason
      Global Sherpa
      http://www.globalsherpa.org/japan-culture-earthquake-japanese-wa-tokyo-police

    • 1 year ago
  • JohnA
    • -1
      JohnA  
    • If we only had that sense of self determination in this country. Responsibility of the individual is largely lost on the citizens of this country, sad to say.

    • 1 year ago
  • LaelW
    • -2
      LaelW  
    • There is news coverage from around the world. There has been no widespread looting. The question of why? - There is some truth in several of these posts (including the ones that disagree in principle). I believe it IS because there is a feeling of community in their society that is lacking in the United States for example. We have disconnected, depersonalized, and demoralized not only our "minorities" but our majorities as well. Our society is splintered into factions (as an earlier poster noted) that are pitted "against" one another by the simple (and wrong) technique of laying blame for what happens to one group, at the feet of another - I have relatives and friends in Japan who are NOT Japanese. Their response to the qstn is - residents of Japan consider themselves a community with certain common goals, and when it doesn't happen, they don't immediately whine, and complain that "someone else" that group over there - is to blame/get them! I am sick of it personally. The much vaunted "american dream" is not a reality-it is a joke - and as long as they tiny percentage of the uber-rich control the politics (and the people) of this country, it will never be any better. We no longer lead the world in anything, our health care sucks, our wages are pitiful for the majority of folks, the standard of living is ridiculous for the majority of people, and our child mortality rate is soaring - get a grip folks - until the "little people" of ALL "races" & "religions" get it together and stop fighting for the bones we are thrown by the fat cats, it will never change. It is not the fault of the blacks, the mexicans, the "illegals", the immigrants, the ANYTHING groups - it is the fault of all of us (the community) of little folk who allow our little tiny worlds to be controlled and used against each other, to the detriment of all of us - oh, except people like the Koch Brothers, and others like them.

    • 1 year ago
  • superheat
    • +1
      superheat  
    • Haloedgrit - You're the one who doesn know what he's talking about. Stop your lying. Your statement about the Japanese media failing to "report to the world and locally that their own people are looting" is pure garbage. There are news organizations from all over the world in Japan right now. Go to Google and search "Looting in Japan". Read the comments. 99% of them are right on target.
      "Certain races" around the world are where they are because they put themselves there. Sorry, but that's just the way it is.

    • 1 year ago
  • HaloedGriot
    • 0
      HaloedGriot  
    • superheat:

      You ave got to be out of your rabid mind if you really think that Japan is going to report to YOU that they haven't got a grip on anything. Take for instance the chief of the nuclear facility problems in Japan. You think he will tell the US "We have no control of the situation."

      You don't know Japanese like I know Japanese...its not even thinkable to admit such incompetence to the face of foreigners, namely Americans who are seen as less than them. You play right into their plans of falling for the okey-doke...but I have been told BY JAPANESE RIGHT AFTER SPEAKING FRIENDS IN NORTH JAPAN that people are looting...all I had to do was read the name of the author of that article to get the truth...I suggest you learn some Kanji and find out facts because if you are taking some gaijin's word for it, then sorry for ya.

      "There are news organizations from all over the world in Japan right now. Go to Google and search "Looting in Japan". Read the comments. 99% of them are right on target."

      Here's a reality check clown...when the foreign press arrives in Japan, who is taking them to where the "action" is? You think their guides are going to take them to where "Japanese people are behaving badly."?

      Imbecile. Fuck you and your race theories.

    • 1 year ago
  • Gigi_Rodriguez
    • +1
      Gigi_Rodriguez  
    • I agree with your comment Pheena187...when there's an intelligent and morally built society like Japan..this is what's expected, no looting, mutual respect, and amazing people who just help. Unlike here for example in the U.S., when we had Hurricane Katrina or the Northridge earthquake, a lot of looting occurred and the store prices went up. A lot of hoarding also happened, relief goods that were meant to be given to the devastated areas were not received by the right people. I continue to pray for the Japanese people especially affected by this earthquake and tsunami, to continue being strong and having their faith and strong morality and respect to guide them.

    • 1 year ago
  • EyoYo3
    • -2
      EyoYo3  
    • By Liberal Democrat standards, Japan is politically incorrect. They need more minorities. Since Pres.Obama likes social engineering he should mandate that Japan increase its minority population as requirement of receiving US foreign aid.

    • 1 year ago
  • Pawper
  • Juipter
    • 0
      Juipter  
    • danitassin I agree this is the kind of news we need to see. To Japan: May God comfort you in these troubled times, our thoughts and prayers are with you.

    • 1 year ago
  • danitassin
  • HaloedGriot
  • HaloedGriot
    • -2
      HaloedGriot  
    • This is one of those "if only the US were like them" articles...funny, its always when comparing to some homogeneous country like Japan or Russia...you suckers fall for it each time. Dream on, your "good ol' days" are long gone.

    • 1 year ago
  • alexandrek
  • HaloedGriot
  • alexandrek
  • HaloedGriot
    • 0
      HaloedGriot  
    • alexandrek:

      What is it you want to say? What did Katrina have to do with me? Spit it out...you're a degenerate...you want to go sit in an onsen with Japanese men and praise them with how good their behavior is in the face of disaster. Its not hard to see.

      Focus on YOU and YOUR culture and stop being such a degenerate and THIS country will become a better place. As for Japan, its too bad what's happened, but trust me, YOUR opinion of them really doesn't mean shit to me, them or Katrina looters for that matter.

      You're a retard for even acting like you were wronged in some way by Katrina.

    • 1 year ago
  • HaloedGriot
  • Psychomelody
    • +2
      Psychomelody  
    • I live in Iwate, Japan. The quake was one of the scariest things I have ever lived through. If it wasn't for the resilience and kindness of the people around me I don't know how I would have been able to get through these past few days.

      And I've had power and water for almost 36 hours. This is amazing. We are going to recover from this so fast... It's the same bit of respect and care that will bring Japan back and keep us together to help rebuild.

    • 1 year ago
  • Pheena187
  • nowherefast
    • +1
      nowherefast  
    • It's no surprise. Japan is the most racially homogeneous country on the planet. Only about one percent of the population is foreign born. The homogeneous nature leads to a strong sense of community and the obvious realization that stealing from their own community is adverse to their own interests.

      Since there is no significant ethnic minorities, there is no group for liberal leaning, politicians to play race politics with. There is no-us vs. them, mentality in Japan. It's not a zero-sum game from one group to take advantage of the misfortune of another group. Because they identify as one community.

      Across the the sea liberal politicians have long ago sown the seeds of racial and ethnically distinction to the point of voluntary de facto segregation. These seeds have blossomed into animosity and racial/ ethnic compartmentalization, pitting one community that now views themselves as "distinct" in direct competition with another community that views themselves as " distinct" . There is no community because these sub-communities now believe their fortunes and misfortunes are distinct and unrelated to each other.

      The modern day competing communities mentality was shown during the Rodney kings riots, the members that identify as being part of a distinct black community , took advantage of the chaos to attack and loot stores, that belong to members that they identified as the distinct Korean/Asian. But these stores of this artificially distinct group that was viewed as a separate community was in the very Neighborhood of artificially group that view itself as distinct.

      Of course liberal politicians encourage and enjoy this sick "competing community mentality" and will perpetuate it forever. Because they are notorious for pitting one group against another for their own political gain.

    • 1 year ago
  • HaloedGriot
    • 0
      HaloedGriot  
    • nowherefast:

      You don't know what you are talking about.

      You honestly believe that Japanese media would report to the world and locally that their own people are looting? Be serious. It is correct in saying that the action would be damaging to a homogeneous society, but Japanese themselves have confirmed that it is happening...too many individuals view Japanese as a noble people to aspire to be like...you are a fool. Japan spent centuries spilling their own blood to unify and after WWII desperation led to unspeakable acts both by thugs and common people. Japan has spent the last 50 years seeking to repair their image in the eyes of the West, specifically the US...and here you are swallowing it.

      Ask an Ainu or Ryukuan (Okinawan) about being a NON-FOREIGN minority of Japan...or better yet a Taiwanese or Korean over the age of 60 years old and stop getting your information from anime movies, James Clavell and Tom Cruise.

      And how dare you make a distinction between Japanese and African-Americans. You think your weighing of morals went unnoticed? You are a degenerate. You make light of topics you have little information or knowledge about. I anticipate you'll respond with some bullsh*t numbers from an unworthy source to back up some weaksauce claims. Here's an idea, converse with people and get the info straight from the horse's mouth instead of speculating in a contemptive, quasi-racist fashion.

    • 1 year ago
  • HaloedGriot
  • MDBard
    • +1
      MDBard  
    • Japan is an inspiration of how disasters should be handled, helping each other, taking care of the problems in a calm and orderly way. We could learn a lot from them here in the states but unfortunately there is a lot of xenophobia and the "christian" values keep it that way. (At least here in the "Lone Star State"

    • 1 year ago
  • Shannon_Box
    • +1
      Shannon_Box  
    • acting civilized and humane is the correct way to act especially since its only been a few days since the Quake hit. if this type of disaster (man made or natural) happened in the US there would be massive looting in places like the 9th ward. Taking food is understandable, but as we all now know, MANY useless items were taken, like tv's when there was no electricity. The police for godsake were video taped looting. The looting here would start the day of the disaster. After a few days or a week when the average household would run out of food/water, then I could understand venturing out to find food/water, even if it came to looting. But just for food and formula.

    • 1 year ago
  • HaloedGriot
    • -1
      HaloedGriot  
    • Shannon_Box:

      TV's and things you call "useless" are invaluable for barter when in need of things like "food", "water", "shelter" and "clothes"...if I came to your door with a flatscreen and wanted a couple gallons of water, wouldn't you consider?

    • 1 year ago
  • JohnA
    • -1
      JohnA  
    • HaloedGriot:

      I live in Mississippi. I was ashamed to see people stealing flatscreen TV's when bodies are piling up so high they don't what to do with them anymore. It was disgusting to see the way some people acted down here. Instead of dragging a new flatscreen out, how about dragging an eighty year old in a wheelchair out, asshole. TV's are useless when compared to human life. Give them the water if they need it in a time of emergency, this is not the time for barter.

    • 1 year ago
  • HaloedGriot
  • chief_longhair
    • +1
      chief_longhair  
    • I think the Japanese people have a great amount of respect for each other and in the culture it would be a big embarrassment to an individual to steal from each other,,,, also I think the fact that there are not very many poor people,,, just look at the pictures and videos of this disaster,,, I have yet to see a lower 9th type area,,, most of the people are doing pretty well financially,, this is a horrible event for those people and I wish them a speedy recovery.......

    • 1 year ago
  • bailey78
  • forcis12
    • +2
      forcis12  
    • I am sure the rates of looting are not entirely absent in Japan. Regardless, their strength is definitely within fellow countrymen.

      Prayers are with them. Please donate to the Red Cross.

    • 1 year ago
  • JanforGore
    • 0
      JanforGore  
    • Not everyone in America loots during a disaster. I don't really see the point of always comparing everything to Americans. Granted, it is true that there are always those who take advantage of catastrophe (and that happens in other countries as well) but to give the impression that we are all uneducated violent goons is a bit unfair. The media in this country I think as well is a culprit as that is all they seem to focus on. They don't focus on the good people helping others and there are plenty of us out here too. And while I do respect the Japanese people and their culture it is also a bit bizarre considering the circumstances in the sense that we don't even see an expression of urgency(?) Oh, and just to add: I am not one to be violent, lawless, loot or act in that manner, but if my and my family's SURVIVAL depended on it, basic human nature to survive would kick in and I have no doubt it would in any culture if driven to the point where it was necessary to survive.

    • 1 year ago
  • Jpwhoregan
  • ArchDruid
  • JanforGore
    • 0
      JanforGore  
    • Jpwhoregan:

      I hope you never have to be in that situation to find out. The point being, that at some point all humans break down to their baser instincts regardless of what boundary line we may stand on. Lack of food and water at some point WILL make you break as well though you will never admit it because I suppose you need to look superior? Even the most equal among us still has a survival instinct when pushed to the brink. That was the point I was making so you can try to understand that point or come back with another rude comment. And I agree with chief_longhair that there also doesn't seem to be as many people living in 9th ward type conditions that would prompt them to such behavior, which is a good point as well. All that aside however, this is an horrific catastrophe and I pray that people do get the help they need. I do have the ability however to discuss the topic at hand as well, without being rude BTW.

    • 1 year ago
  • JanforGore
  • hammywill
    • 0
      hammywill  
    • JanforGore:

      Janforgore: You're absolutely right. I like the story on it's face, that there is minimal looting, and the communities are helping one another. The comparison to America is simply a way for the media to take a tragedy and turn it into a socio-political debate.

      I live in California in the San Francisco Bay Area. I remember the Loma Prieta Earthquake that caused massive devestation. (Relatively speaking of course.) A lot of others may remember it as well as it interrupted a historic World Series between the San Francisco Giants and the Oakland A's. Anyhow, a lot of the news stories at that time focused on how many people came out to help one another. There were neighbors climbing ladders into buildings to help people get out of collapsing structures. Civilian volunteers were crawling under the collapsed section of the Bay Bridge to help those who were trapped inside. This was the norm, and any theft that occurred was the aberration.

      I am not sure why the media focuses so much on the negative aspects of just about any occurrence. But, it is what it is. There are many opportunities to turn the Japanese Tragedy into a political discussion, but for me, all I want to do is focus on the well being of those people. My thoughts and prayers are with them and that is all for now. There will be plenty of time to discuss any sort of social or political ramifications later. But it is inappropriate at this time I think.

      My prayers are with the Japanese people at this time.

    • 1 year ago
  • JanforGore
    • +2
      JanforGore  
    • hammywill:

      My prayers are with them as well, but I too in all honesty can do without the potshots being thrown and comparisons made just to have a way to as you stated start a socio-political competition as to who is better.There are many variables up for discussion on that topic and it isn't all black and white. Right now we should be concerned with getting medical attention and clean water to people who may need it and making sure a nuclear catastrophe doesn't follow all of the suffering already inflicted by this disaster. And I'm grateful that you understood my point that there are good people here who go out of their way in a disaster to help others.

    • 1 year ago
  • cmc101
    • 0
      cmc101  
    • JanforGore:

      they survived two atomic bombs ,total defeaf,and ressions ,earthquakes, tsunamis and this week and they don't have basic human nature to surive. I do believe that all natural religion the desire to surive together out weigh the excuse of coping out with human nature survival laws

    • 1 year ago
  • JohnA
  • damush
    • +2
      damush  
    • Shows you how an highly eveolve society works whereas in Los Angeles, we relish the premise as though it was a religious right of societal ruin. Dog eat dog begets poop! Get it?

    • 1 year ago
  • mii
    • +1
      mii  
    • Wow, the Japanese people have demonstrated that we
      can still be our brothers keepers in the worst of circumstances.
      What an inspiring observation.

    • 1 year ago
  • Pawper
    • +4
      Pawper  
    • Japan is collectivist, the U.S. is Individualist. There are pros and cons to both. For example, Japan has a high-pressure society that leads to a lot of suicides. On the other hand, the U.S. has a more relaxed society which enables people to pursue their own happiness where it counts, like in their educations, careers and relationships, without the high risk of shame and alienation of Japanese collectivism.

    • 1 year ago
  • Jake_Leonard
    • +1
      Jake_Leonard  
    • Pawper:

      Voted up. This could definitely be a good research project. Though I don't know if I would venture to say U.S. is relaxed (I note you only compared by saying "More relaxed"); there seems to be a lot of parallels between Japanese and American "work hard--party hard" mentality. I could be wrong, though.

      I'm also curious how anti-depressants are used in Japan compared to here. There are A LOT of problems American people have--we just prefer masking it half of the time.

    • 1 year ago
  • HaloedGriot
    • -1
      HaloedGriot  
    • Pawper:

      The only intelligent and credibly researched comment I've read as response to this article so far...lemme continue down the page...

      People think it has to do with race...WRONG! Japan is also an old country in comparison to the US. Likely 4 times over...many century have led to what it is...it was only 50 years ago, this country was hosing people of different color in the streets.

      Japan went through it too, believe me.

    • 1 year ago
  • JohnA
  • HaloedGriot
    • 0
      HaloedGriot  
    • JohnA:

      Don't start with me. Some people like Superheat, Nowherefast and even you at times use buzz words that you believe are over the heads of people when you are making such implications regarding race. They are buzzwords to give a specific message to YOUR audience. You underestimate or doubt that others know what your words reveal regarding your heart and character...

    • 1 year ago
  • alexandrek
  • JohnA
  • alexandrek
  • HaloedGriot
  • alexandrek
  • HaloedGriot
    • 0
      HaloedGriot  
    • alexandrek:

      You put the Japanese on too high of a pedestal...so you'e been to Japan and went to Tokyo, didn't see any looting and deduct that there is NO foul play going on AT ALL? Do you know any Japanese people? Or are you one of these otaku fanboys?

    • 1 year ago
  • HaloedGriot
  • alexandrek
  • HaloedGriot
  • deane
    • +3
      deane  
    • "Responsible to the community," unfortunately America is first and foremost about freedom. Freedom to be selfish, ignorant, rich, and in debt. Or as Fox news would say.. the greatest, bestest country in the worlds.

    • 1 year ago
  • ApeFace
more from Community:

top videos