India's secret : Walking with Comrades- The Guardian
source: http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2011/jun/05/arundhati-roy-keep-destabilised-danger
-
-
- figgdimension
- added this
http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2011/jun/05/arundhati-roy-keep-destab...
undhati Roy. Photograph: Sarah LeeBy:Stephen Moss
Arundhati Roy: 'They are trying to keep me destabilised. Anybody who says anything is in danger'
This is not an ideal beginning. I bump into Arundhati Roy as we are both heading for the loo in the foyer of the large building that houses her publisher Penguin's offices. There are some authors, V S Naipaul say, with whom this could be awkward. But not Roy, who makes me feel instantly at ease. A few minutes later, her publicist settles us in a small, bare room. As we take our positions on either side of a narrow desk I liken it to an interrogation suite. But she says that in India, interrogation rooms are a good deal less salubrious than this.
Roy, who is 50 this year, is best known for her 1997 Booker prize-winning novel The God of Small Things, but for the past decade has been an increasingly vocal critic of the Indian state, attacking its policy towards Kashmir, the environmental destruction wrought by rapid development, the country's nuclear weapons programme and corruption. As a prominent opponent of everything connected with globalisation, she is seeking to construct a "new modernity" based on sustainability and a defence of traditional ways of life.
Her new book, Broken Republic, brings together three essays about the Maoist guerrilla movement in the forests of central India that is resisting the government's attempts to develop and mine land on which tribal people live. The central essay, Walking with the Comrades, is a brilliant piece of reportage, recounting three weeks she spent with the guerrillas in the forest. She must, I suggest, have been in great personal danger. "Everybody's in great danger there, so you can't go round feeling you are specially in danger," she says in her pleasant, high-pitched voice. In any case, she says, the violence of bullets and torture are no greater than the violence of hunger and malnutrition, of vulnerable people feeling they're under siege.
Her time with the guerrillas made a profound impression. She describes spending nights sleeping on the forest floor in a "thousand-star hotel", applauds "the ferocity and grandeur of these poor people fighting back", and says "being in the forest made me feel like there was enough space in my body for all my organs". She detests glitzy, corporate, growth-obsessed modern Indian, and there in the forest she found a brief peace.
There is intense anger in the book, I say, implying that if she toned it down she might find a readier audience. "The anger is calibrated," she insists. "It's less than I actually feel." But even so, her critics call her shrill. "That word 'shrill' is reserved for any expression of feeling. It's all right for the establishment to be as shrill as it likes about annihilating people."
Is her political engagement derived from her mother, Mary Roy, who set up a school for girls in Kerala and has a reputation as a women's rights activist? "She's not an activist," says Roy. "I don't know why people keep saying that. My mother is like a character who escaped from the set of a Fellini film." She laughs at her own description. "She's a whole performing universe of her own. Activists would run a mile from her because they could not deal with what she is."
I want to talk more about Mary Roy – and eventually we do – but there's one important point to clear up first. Guerrillas use violence, generally directed against the police and army, but sometimes causing injury and death to civilians caught in the crossfire. Does she condemn that violence? "I don't condemn it any more," she says. "If you're an adivasi [tribal Indian] living in a forest village and 800 CRP [Central Reserve Police] come and surround your village and start burning it, what are you supposed to do? Are you supposed to go on hunger strike? Can the hungry go on a hunger strike? Non-violence is a piece of theatre. You need an audience. What can you do when you have no audience? People have the right to resist annihilation."
Her critics label her a Maoist sympathizer. Is she? "I am a Maoist sympathiser," she says. "I'm not a Maoist ideologue, because the communist movements in history have been just as destructive as capitalism. But right now, when the assault is on, I feel they are very much part of the resistance that I support."
Roy talks about the resistance as an "insurrection"; she makes India sound as if it's ripe for a Chinese or Russian-style revolution. So how come we in the west don't hear about these mini-wars? "I have been told quite openly by several correspondents of international newspapers," she says, "that they have instructions – 'No negative news from India' – because it's an investment destination. So you don't hear about it. But there is an insurrection, and it's not just a Maoist insurrection. Everywhere in the country, people are fighting." I find the suggestion that such an injunction exists – or that self-respecting journalists would accept it – ridiculous. Foreign reporting of India might well be lazy or myopic, but I don't believe it's corrupt.
She sounds like a member of a religious sect, I say, as if she has seen the light. "It's a way of life, a way of thinking," she replies without taking offence. "I know people in India, even the modern young people, understand that here is something that's alive." So why not give up the plush home in Delhi and the media appearances, and return to the forest? "I'd be more than happy to if I had to, but I would be a liability to them in the forest. The battles have to be fought in different ways. The military side is just one part of it. What I do is another part of the battle.(more at link )
-
- groups:
- Community, News and Politics, Art and Style, Culture, 5 more
-
-
Incredulous
-
Fabulous post figg, I am a huge fan of Roy and read her "God of Small Things" several years ago, an amazing book. I will have to make sure I read "Broken Republic." I have a friend in India who sends me her articles from time to time. I tend to agree with what she is saying about India's image constructing though, based upon a listserv I was on while working in an industry that India is heavily invested in. There is a definite spin on India's official communication with the outside world, some of it even seeming to border on delusional. I was reading a piece in Travel and Leisure about Hyderabad, one of India's oldest cities, and was struck by a quote from a young man talking about his job in technology. He said something like, "What has happened to our way of life?"
The article, of course, coming from T&L is nothing like Roy, so it was interesting to me when that one quote more or less jumped off the page...sort of a bit of reality slipping through. Article is at the link, not crazy about T&L, kid's school was doing a fundraiser and so I signed up, but T&L is in the business of promoting tourism, not revolution.
http://www.travelandleisure.com/travel-blog/carry-on/2011/3/18/editor-report-goi...
- 1 year ago
-
Incredulous
-
-
figgdimension
-
Incredulous:
Tanks I've just discovered her writing and need to read her earlier work she's fascinating and raw I like people with guts and a different perspective thanks for commenting and I'll check your link very glad you enjoyed it.. :) have a nice day ..and maybe I should try tourism too...I'm sure the pays better :/
- 1 year ago
-
figgdimension
-
-
figgdimension
-
Incredulous:
Oh thats kinda funny cause look -"I drove by the shiny new office complexes of Cyberabad, Hyderabad’s high-tech avatar; I climbed to the top of the Charminar (much to my mother’s chagrin—“I grew up here and never once felt compelled to climb it, why are you making me do it now?” she grumbled good-naturedly); I bargained for quintessentially Hyderabadi bangles at Laad Bazaar; I marveled at the glittering chandeliers and the vintage cars at Chowmahalla Palace; and I went to visit Prince Muffakham Jah (the philanthropist younger brother of the current nizam, Mukarram Jah, who Brenner wrote about in her story) and his lovely wife, Princess Esin, at their beautiful home in Banjara Hills" this totally proves her point perfect its soooo outta touch thanks that was great. It feels like opening your eyes to what was always in front of us she's wonderful...
- 1 year ago
-
figgdimension
-
-
Incredulous
-
figgdimension:
I wasn't working in tourism, I was in a technology field heavily populated by very talented Indian ex-pats, which is why I was on the India listserv. Anyway, used to think I would like working in tourism too, but not so much anymore. Flying is no longer a pleasure.
- 1 year ago
-
Incredulous
