Community | September 08, 2011 | 215 comments

Pastor Forces Rape Victim To Apologize To Church

KB723
A fundamentalist Christian pastor made a 15 year-old rape victim apologize to the church congregation for having sex and getting pregnant by a married man. Ana Kasparian and Cenk Uygur discuss.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/09/06/ernest-willis-new-hampshi_n_950332.html

"I know... I didn't want to post the link, but it was part of the article, I do not endorse HuffPo!!!"
  1. groups:
    Community,   Humanism,   Opinion,   Current Cultural Issues,   6 more
  2. tags:
    Religion Crime Rape
  3.     
    |

215 comments // Pastor Forces Rape Victim To Apologize To Church // Video

  • PIANORAMA
  • nardo1224
  • savvy7
    • +3
      savvy7  
    • I am not a practitioner of any particular ritual, nor do I personally believe in invisible sky people, but having heard and read tales of Christian creed, I can't help but ask, "What part of this pastor is Christian?"

    • 9 months ago
  • kvb1
    • 0
      kvb1  
    • savvy7:

      There is no part of him that is Christian. He has no comprehension of what the words mean, or the spirit of the bible. He never heard of the words compassion, forgiveness, nor understanding. Unfortunately this girl felt she had no choice but to apologize. She is no different than any other cult member, pressure from the cult and her parents, made her apologize for something she should never have to.

    • 9 months ago
  • HarukoHaruhara
  • Littlewolf
    • +2
      Littlewolf  
    • I can't help but wonder where were her parents? The idea that they would take her to such a "church" seems pretty clear cut child abuse to me.

      Where's Lorena when you need her?

    • 9 months ago
  • KB723
  • Buckeye_Bill
    • +1
      Buckeye_Bill  
    • KB723:

      It's Nancy's "denomination"?...just askin'......!

      Nancy is NOT a friend to other women! Have you noticed that MOST of her storylines are about women? She attacks the women Prosecutors, women defense attorneys, women jurists...all the time!

      As a matter of fact, have you ever heard her say one nice thing about women?

      “Hating Yourself is the Greatest Love of All…”
      Bill Maher

    • 9 months ago
  • KB723
  • Littlewolf
  • PIANORAMA
  • aj727b
    • +3
      aj727b  
    • I know people are angry (and rightly so) but are we served by stooping to the level of the executioners and calling for an individual or the state to kill over it? Are we served by continuing to accept that prison inmates are raped and brutalized on a daily basis? This is funny? This is the justice that WE want? Not in my America... but my America may have only been a dream. Let's condemn the evil that a church like this does, but I for one will do so without condoning rape, torture, or murder of another. Just my choice, and sorry to be preachy, but a lynch mob is a lynch mob: let's leave that violent rhetoric to the Tea Party voters who were in that church.

    • 9 months ago
  • aj727b
    • +3
      aj727b  
    • I agree with those who are outraged by this story, but I would just note that we do not need to insult, denigrate, and dehumanize males in order to respect and value women. Some have chosen to reply and "defend" female humanity by insulting the males. How about we start from a point of UNIVERSAL respect for human dignity and human rights? Just sayin'... it is not a zero-sum game, we don't need to pretend that males have no value in order to recognize the incredible value of the myriad contributions that females have made and continue to make. We can (and must) value the male and female, the yin and the yang.

    • 9 months ago
  • Buckeye_Bill
    • +2
      Buckeye_Bill  
    • Image
    • aj727b:

      I wholeheartedly agree, but some things just rubs one's nub raw...

      Of course, being imperfect humans, we tend to lower ourselves to the level of those that are despised by society by stooping to their height.

      It's only natural.

      We, however, should resist the temptation, though.

      Should we not?

    • 9 months ago
  • savvy7
    • +1
      savvy7  
    • aj727b:

      To me it isn't about gender, AJ, it's really about religion. If you'll notice, all three so-called religions of the 'book', (and coincidentally the three major religions of the world) demand the subservience of women, even to the point of demonizing the true first woman, Lillith, and replacing her with Eve, who falls prey to the same "sin" of wanting knowledge [power]. The pastor seems singularly unfazed by the fact that a married man has committed adultery with a teenager, whether by force or pursuasion. SHE alone must apologize. I don't know why you think anyone is picking on men, but I would urge to to read about the (mis-)treatment of women in religious organizations. This is just one more example.

    • 9 months ago
  • aj727b
    • +1
      aj727b  
    • Buckeye_Bill:

      Believe me I know what it means to get angry, to go off half-cocked, to go into a rant, to want to do something ANYTHING to stop the craziness out there.... I don't mean to say that I am a saint or an example of tranquility and perfect compassion at all times... far from it. I am a very flawed human, hoping that the species is not fatally flawed, just blindly stumbling about in the dark trying to do the next right thing.

      Like the song says "Christ you know it aint easy... You know how hard it can be?... The way things are going... They're gonna crucify me..." (J.Lennon)

    • 9 months ago
  • Buckeye_Bill
    • 0
      Buckeye_Bill  
    • aj727b:

      You...are farther from imperfection and closer to perfection that you will admit!

      That's what makes you a real, live human being!

      The greatest compliment one could ever bestow upon another!

      And I gladly, without hesitation, place that title upon you!

      I've read your comments and I think you are a very misunderstood person.

      People misunderstand that you are a kind, humble, thoughtful and respectful person.

      And I better cut it short before someone gets the wrong idea...which happens here far too frequently!

    • 9 months ago
  • aj727b
  • mickyjon420
    • 0
      mickyjon420  
    • aj727b:

      High AJ, I was just wondering what your take, and others, on the statements made to children, " Snips and snails and puppy dog tails, that's what little boys are made of, Sugar and spice and everything nice that's what little girls are made of."......

    • 9 months ago
  • Buckeye_Bill
    • +4
      Buckeye_Bill  
    • Oh...Hell! I can't keep myself from sharing this video with all here!

      There is MORE than one way to "skin a cat"!

      Some subhumans DESERVE what they get!

      That's all I'm sayin'.............

    • 9 months ago
  • Littlewolf
  • Buckeye_Bill
    • +3
      Buckeye_Bill  
    • Littlewolf:

      Those Dixie Chicks, the best thing since sliced bread when it comes to empowered "womanhood"!

      I love 'em dearly!

      They're one of the few that stood up against the Bush Administration and his senseless wars and paid a heavy price for it, too!

    • 9 months ago
  • EdJoyProductions
  • Buckeye_Bill
  • EdJoyProductions
  • Buckeye_Bill
  • Littlewolf
  • Littlewolf
  • aj727b
    • 0
      aj727b  
    • Buckeye_Bill:

      Oh my god... that movie and that other one where Farrah Fawcett turns the tables on a home-invading rapist and would-be murderer are crazy! I think that one ends with her making him eat a can of RAID bug spray and tying him up in an unused fireplace! He picked the wrong model to mess with!

    • 9 months ago
  • bike10
  • Buckeye_Bill
    • +5
      Buckeye_Bill  
    • Women are far stronger than men will ever comprehend. After all, if it were up to a male to carry a child to full term and give birth the population of the earth would be zero in a hurry.

      But after thousands of years of being put down, I can only imagine what a woman experiences in the deepest corners of her soul.

      But things are changing fast in relation to the annals of human history for women, I am proud to say! However, in many parts of the world they are still second class citizens.

      How a woman could think wearing a bedsheet with slits for eyes is considered being a devout, religious servant to her God and husband is beyond me. Maybe it's because there is a form of mind control that permeates in certain societies that prevents a woman from opening her mind to what's reality. That I do not know.

      I have been telling my "story" for decades how God created Adam and then sat back and thought, "I know I can do better than that!", and promptly proceeded to create Eve. If you're a believer in that story of the First Man and Woman thing.

      My suggestion to all women is, from human being to human being, do not back down. The world, or people, can not do anything to you unless you allow it.

      It's not the time to make nice. It's not the time to backdown. Not any more.

      It's all I've got for my fellow human being sisters, my support.

    • 9 months ago
  • good_stuff
    • -2
      good_stuff  
    • Buckeye_Bill:

      You're technically incorrect. Women are NOT "stronger" than men. The example that you use, would define women as being "tougher" or more "reliient" than men, but certainly does not mean that they are "stronger". If women were "stronger" and/or "more resilient" than men, then a average female boxer should be able to beat an average male boxer. We know this isn't the case, so you're clearly incorrect.

      This has nothing to do with men versus women being better or worse than one or the other. It has to do with religions being wrong a lot of the time.

    • 9 months ago
  • Buckeye_Bill
    • +3
      Buckeye_Bill  
    • Image
    • good_stuff:

      I see you feel strongly about using the word strong in one of it's many definitions.

      Ghandi was "strong", yet he didn't raise one finger against violence.

      1) "If our principles are right, why should we be cowards?"
      Lucria Mott (1793-1880)

      2) "I only know that people call me a feminist whenever I express sentiments that differentiate me from a doormat or prostitute"
      Rebecca West (1892-1983)

      3) "But now having seen Him Who is invisible, I fear not what man can do unto me."
      Anne Marbury Hutchinson (1591-1643)

      4) "If women of the world had not been excluded from world affairs, things today might have been different."
      Alice Paul (1885-1977)

      5) "Remember our heritage is our power; we can know ourselves and our capabilities by seeing that other women have been strong."
      Judy Chicago (1939- )

      Is it me, or are there one Hell of a lot of STRONG women that have lived and are living today in this world?

      I've got many, many more of these "quotes" made by STRONG women.

      Just ask and I shall provide them.

      After all, we certainly do not want any closed minds wandering around unattended, do we?

    • 9 months ago
  • Buckeye_Bill
    • +3
      Buckeye_Bill  
    • Image
    • good_stuff:

      "Women are far stronger than men will ever comprehend."

      Explain to me good_stuff, how did you arrive at your conclusion that my statement implied women were stronger than men?

      Just wonderin'...

    • 9 months ago
  • artemis6
    • 0
      artemis6  
    • good_stuff:

      You confuse physical strength with mental strength and service to creation . Man are for more vulnerable to the lure of war/violence , non life affirming ideals . Females have more empathy , better communication skill and emotional perception - they support and create LIFE . There are exceptions , and this is a gross generalization , but , right now it is a mans world . Try to imagine if it were different .

    • 9 months ago
  • Buckeye_Bill
    • +1
      Buckeye_Bill  
    • artemis6:

      So, are you implying that women AREN'T equal to men?

      And what does, "service to creation", mean?

      I would like to here your understanding of this statement.

      "Females have more empathy , better communication skill and emotional perception"

      Are you saying that I am not capable of empathy" Do I not communiate well enough for you to comprehend my thoughts I "place" upon this medium of internet ink and intertube paper?

      That's a sexist remark in and of itself!

      "Try to imagine if it were different ."

      I have no idea where you reside, but in my world all the women I associate with are strong, independent, intelligent and confident.

      I respect them and JUST as important, they respect moi!

      I feel sad for where you are, if you do not experience what I do on a daily basis.

      For where I Iive, I don't have to TRY to imagine it differently. It's my reality!

    • 9 months ago
  • EdJoyProductions
  • Buckeye_Bill
  • savvy7
  • Buckeye_Bill
  • aj727b
  • Almibry
    • +1
      Almibry  
    • I really want a shotgun right about now. I've always wanted to see that "pink mist" in real life, especially when it used to be an asshole.

    • 9 months ago
  • aj727b
    • 0
      aj727b  
    • Almibry:

      And someone on the Right Wing is saying they want to shoot you right now, or shoot someone else they disagree with. You are better than that, I am betting, let's leave the guns and ammo fantasies to the loons...

    • 9 months ago
  • artemis6
  • Almibry
    • -2
      Almibry  
    • aj727b:

      No, actually I'm not better than that. Few things give me as much pleasure as imagining bathing in the blood of my enemy. The only thing spoiling that fantasy is the fact that I'm almost positive that in real life, it would make me vomit.
      But fantasies often have little to do with reality.

    • 9 months ago
  • Almibry
  • ThirdSection
  • KB723
  • ThirdSection
  • KB723
  • ThirdSection
  • EdJoyProductions
  • KB723
  • ThirdSection
  • Buckeye_Bill
  • ThirdSection
  • Simone_Castillo
  • Hardytoo
    • +4
      Hardytoo  
    • Was reading an article yesterday about Warren Jeffs, "The Prophet" of the FLDS Mormons - he was listed in critical condition last week (starving himself in prison), very near death. They revived the bastard and he's been upgraded! Fancy that - a child rapist, saved by modern medicine, and no doubt, followers of his who are doctors and nurses - this rapist and slave-trader should have been simply "let go." He desired it and we should have granted him his wish. Prophet indeed!

    • 9 months ago
  • KB723
  • Almibry
    • -1
      Almibry  
    • Hardytoo:

      Well, if he was starving himself to death, making him live is probably a better punishment. People who rape children don't survive long in prison. Their only real shot is to spend all that time in the hospital wing.

    • 9 months ago
  • aj727b
    • +2
      aj727b  
    • Almibry:

      So now we think that prison rape is a good thing? Did you support torturing terror suspects too? I am not saying to give pedophiles a cookie and a hug, but many of them were abused as children themselves, and NONE of them is rehabilitated by repeated forced sodomy by other inmates. In fact by condoning prison rape we INCREASE the recidivism rates for sex-offenders AND we teach someone locked-up for dope to become a prison rapist (but they will just stop raping cold turkey when they get out, right? PLEASE...) WE ARE BETTER THAN THIS. Even when we are just shooting the sh1t on the interwebs.

    • 9 months ago
  • David_H
  • ACSUS
  • Hardytoo
  • David_H
  • David_H
  • David_H
  • artemis6
  • Hardytoo
    • +2
      Hardytoo  
    • David_H:

      They've been shipping girls down to Jeff's compound for years and everybody know that, including the AG, the RCMP & Crown Counsel - they continue to investigate, then drop the investigation - wonder whose paying them off. It's a crying shame that the AG's Ministry keeps letting this one pass - there are books written about Bountiful and its goings-on. I think it's pretty cut and dried, what's happening there. One of the leader is a Jeff's follower, one SAYS he is not. So one of them is lying, cuz they're both doing the deeds.

    • 9 months ago
  • Almibry
    • 0
      Almibry  
    • aj727b:

      I didn't say it was a good thing (though I'm finding it to be excessively hard to think it's a bad thing), I said it was a better punishment. Punishments (from my understanding) are SUPPOSED to be unpleasent.

    • 9 months ago
  • Almibry
  • Almibry
    • +1
      Almibry  
    • aj727b:

      I'm just curious why did you choose to pick on me when I didn't say a thing about prison rape. Why don't you go confront ThirdSection and Buckeye_Bill who implied they'd be willing to rape the man to teach him a lesson; or KB723 and EdJoy who think the idea is funny? The "viagra fed horse" comment didn't bother you as much as the making him live because it's a "better punishment " comment did?
      What kind of "logic" is that?
      Or did you just single me out due to some mistaken belief that I was a bigger threat or an easier target? After all, there's just one of me, and I'm obivously female (and therefore wrongly demanding for him to suffer out of spite) whereas there are 4 of them, and their genders aren't obvious (so you can't stereotype or "shout them down").
      Serioulsy dude. What the fuck are you thinking?

    • 9 months ago
  • EdJoyProductions
  • Almibry
    • -1
      Almibry  
    • EdJoyProductions:

      In theory, I have no problem with it. In practice... Undecided... It sounds better when I think of how I wouldn't have to participate in the cleanup. I'm all for "turn about is fair play" even when I know it won't fix much, except in this case it might make things worse: with a punishment like that, what's to stop rapists from murdering their victims to make sure they can't testify? However, it's an incredibly fun thought to crush certain people completely and with their own tactics.
      By the way, I'm not trying to put any of you guys in the line of fire, I enjoyed reading the exchange (made me giggle), I'm just wondering why I was being singled out for something I didn't even say. It's pissing me off.
      P.S. +^'d

    • 9 months ago
  • EdJoyProductions
  • aj727b
    • +4
      aj727b  
    • Almibry:

      I certainly did not mean to "pick on you" or to put words in your mouth that were in someone else's. If I did that I am sorry. I thought we were just having a discussion, and if you felt attacked or singled out, I am sorry for not communicating my intentions. I certainly did not think of you as a "threat" or a "target" nor was my intention to make ANYONE feel bad. I have locked horns verbally with the other folks you mention, and I know for a fact that at least one has told me that they are female. What I was thinking was that all the people who were posting about this issue shared an outrage about the story that I also feel. I also believe in non-violent protest being the single greatest force for good in the history of humankind. I have posted violent thoughts about polluters, animal abusers, human abusers, etc... I also usually feel bad about it afterwards, and it never has gotten me or any movement I cared about anywhere to resort to that kind of words. You don't have to agree with that, (although you may agree for all I know) and I certainly never meant it to sound as if YOU were the problem or that YOU did or said anything particularly bad. It just seemed that in the time that I had to post before work, you and a few others I spoke to were the ones who were there... then I left for a nine hour day after apparently dumping a mess on you. Reading back, I realize that I seemed to be targeting you, when in fact I was responding to stuff from about ten different posts. Sorry for that.

    • 9 months ago
  • David_H
  • Almibry
    • 0
      Almibry  
    • David_H:

      Now that I can agree with. I'd like to see some rehabilitation thrown in as well but I know for a fact that shrinks are the first to suffer from budget cuts because (in the USA at least) incarceration is about punishment and no one cares about convicts. It's a damn shame. Who knows how many good lives were lost this way.

    • 9 months ago
  • Almibry
  • aj727b
  • David_H
  • Buckeye_Bill
  • Almibry
    • +1
      Almibry  
    • David_H:

      It doesn't help that there are judges who partially own prisions and that there's little profit from preventative medicine since the best (and in most cases only) options for preventing disease is eating/sleeping well and getting plenty of excersize. Herbal medicine has also been proven to be great for preventative care and for treatment of chronic illnesses, though the FDA's definition of a "cure" is worded in such a way that you can only call manmade compounds a cure. Saying "Oranges can cure scurvy" is illegal, even though it's 100% true.
      Though I don't understand why insurance companies aren't focusing more on preventative medicine. You'd think that they wouldn't want to pay for expensive treatments when a personal trainer or a nutritionist is a hell of a lot cheaper.
      I don't know why you were downvoted, but I'm guessing it's because the truth hurts.
      +^'d

    • 9 months ago
  • Almibry
    • +1
      Almibry  
    • aj727b:

      There is a desperate need for a sarcasm font (maybe we could just use "comic sans" for that), and a skeptical font, and a I-can-hardly-type-because-I'm-laughing-too-hard-font... Among other things.

    • 9 months ago
  • Almibry
  • David_H
  • aj727b
    • +2
      aj727b  
    • Almibry:

      Well said... and on the downvote for David and some folks hating the truth,
      I am reminded of the old Harry Truman story about a supporter calling out to him at a speech about his Republican opponents' policies:
      "Give 'em Hell Harry!"
      and Harry Truman replied: "I don't give them Hell. I just tell the truth about them and they think it's Hell."
      Someone voted down your post that was nothing more than you saying you accepted the apology... (I guess it is plausible that they were saying "No don't accept! He's staggering! Go in for the KILL!! ) lol ;-)

    • 9 months ago
  • aj727b
  • Almibry
    • -1
      Almibry  
    • aj727b:

      I have a lot of unfriendly followers, and I bet the same is true for a lot of people. They vote down everything regardless of how decent I'm being at any given moment.

    • 9 months ago
  • Almibry
  • kvb1
  • artemis6
    • +7
      artemis6  
    • If empathy were to REPLACE religion or other political dogma , the world would be better served . It is , after all the golden rule .

    • 9 months ago
  • KB723
  • Almibry
    • -2
      Almibry  
    • artemis6:

      Sympathy might be a better "treatment" than emapthy. After all, just because you understand what a person is experiencing internally, it doesn't mean you give a damn.

    • 9 months ago
  • aj727b
  • aj727b
    • +1
      aj727b  
    • Almibry:

      Empathy IS the ability to not only UNDERSTAND but to FEEL what they feel. You cannot have empathy for someone if you don't give a damn. Once you reach the point of empathy you DO care... or you never experienced empathy to begin with. You just experienced a rational and factual comprehension of a condition, empathy involves the added emotional spark of FEELING what they feel. Doesn't mean that you ACT any different... you can still be a jerk to someone you empathize with, but it requires a lack of conscience or the ability to put your own wants above the other even when you know it is immoral or selfish. Sympathy as "treatment" is actually very condescending and most offenders of low-average intelligence and/intuition can smell the sympathy of the detached do-gooder a mile away. It is a slap in the face, of sorts, like saying: "I know you are a wretch but the fact that I am so great and good makes me help you anyway." Instead of saying "I know that you are human like me, I know how you got to this wrong choice, I will help you to become a better person because we all can make mistakes." This does not mean I support a lack of punishment/rehabilitation for violent offenders and those who harm others... just that I would go about the prison system a LOT differently. Sorry if I was snarky.

    • 9 months ago
  • artemis6
  • Almibry
  • Almibry
  • Almibry
    • -2
      Almibry  
    • aj727b:

      BTW I can empathize with a person who is being selfish, or jumps to conclusions based on emotion rather than logic, and I still don't give a damn. I'm not going to feel sympathy for you when you're wrong or stupid. The only thing I'd accomplish is enabling bad behavior; I save my sympathy for those who deserve it.

    • 9 months ago
1 - 100 of 215
more from Community:

top videos