Community | October 08, 2011 | 13 comments

Lawrence O'Donnell Defends Herman Cain Interview

Image
Imzadi
Lawrence O'Donnell ignited a controversy on Friday after his contentious interview with GOP presidential contender Herman Cain. Several portions of the lengthy conversation aroused anger, but the one that drew the most fire was the section in which O'Donnell questioned Cain about his participation in the Civil Rights movement. O'Donnell asked Cain if he regretted "sitting on the sidelines" while other black Americans were protesting in the movement -- a notion that Cain heatedly rejected.

After the interview, O'Donnell was castigated from many corners. The Atlantic called his questions "offensive," the Washington Post mocked him, and Rush Limbaugh devoted a lengthy monologue to him, calling him a liberal "plantation master."

Cain himself spoke about the interview on Friday, calling O'Donnell's questions "absurd."

On Friday, O'Donnell did not back down from his aggressive questioning. He hosted MSNBC's Al Sharpton and Melissa Harris-Perry and Goldie Taylor from TheGrio.com to discuss the interview.


Read more and view (if you must) http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/10/08/lawrence-odonnell-defends-herman-cain_n...
  1. groups:
    Community,   News and Politics,   US Politics,   KB723's Den of Iniquities,   1 more
  2. tags:
    Comments cain O'Donnell
  3.     
    |

13 comments // Lawrence O'Donnell Defends Herman Cain Interview

  • kvb1
    • 0
      kvb1  
    • O'Donnell asked good questions. Cain was trying to avoid giving any answer. All he had to say was that he benefitted from those that did protest, he was proud of those people that did protest, and that not everyone can be a leader straight from the womb.

      Cain, like most rich people that came from "nothing", always seem to forget what it was like to not be rich, to indulge in their wealth rather than work to bring everyone up from the bottom. That does not necessarily mean spending your money, but rather getting back to the place where you started and mentoring as meny people as you can. Just because you made does not mean that everyone has the same skill set.

    • 8 months ago
  • grammabet
    • +1
      grammabet  
    • I love O'Donnell,he does an exceptional job.Cain is annoying like faux Fox,Palin,Juan Williams,Alan Keys,West from Florida,King from N.Y.Rosie Odonald,Bachman,you get the jist of my comment.

    • 8 months ago
  • FreetobeyoUandme7
  • RevKen
    • +5
      RevKen  
    • I have been watching Mr. O'Donnell off and on for quite some time. I have always found him to be fair and courteous to his guests.

      I believe Mr. Cain was trying to weasel out of a question that the answer would put him in a light he preferred to stay out of. Mr. O'Donnell caught him in a lie and that is that.

      I agree with the guests on the panel, protesting is not for everyone and no one needs to apologize for not being there. Mr. Cain's answer would have us believe that he was too young. We are never too young to do what is right. If he wanted to be there he should have if he didn't then so what. If you lie about why you were not there, that is a concern.

    • 8 months ago
  • littlelumpo
    • +1
      littlelumpo  
    • Ok... this is a really interesting issue. The idea that a person can be held accountable for *not participating* in revolutionary activities or protests is a little crazy to me! I can't expect everyone to put their lives on the line to make change happen in this world, even if they have a serious stake in what's happening. I wouldn't bash any member of the GLBTI community in the 60s for not participating in the Stonewall Riots. How many left-leaning people on Current have not participated in the Occupy Wall Street protests? I haven't!

      Cain may have been evasive about why he didn't participate in the Civil Rights Movement... but that doesn't give O'Donnell the right to castigate him for it. There are a million reasons why someone may exercise their *right* not to protest. That way isn't for everyone.

      And by the way, the fact that this all came from a white news anchor definitely left a bad taste in my mouth! What does O'Donnell know about being a black man during the 60s in Georgia? If you don't know, don't judge!

    • 8 months ago
  • grammabet
    • +1
      grammabet  
    • littlelumpo:

      What does Cain know about being Black? O'Donnell is among my favorite host on MSNBC,knowledgeable,polite,doesn;t cut you off in the middle of a response like Matthews,like him too.Cain ain't fessing up to nothing he feels is going to cost him votes.Wake up dreamer,"Cain the pain"You're being used.Cornell West is another indiviual who has a lot to say,don't remember him being active in the struggle.Probably quite comfortable in his Princeton U. position.Usually when your evasive,you're stalling,trying to create some type of tale.Leave O'Donnell alone.

    • 8 months ago
  • kvb1
    • -1
      kvb1  
    • grammabet:

      As a young man, West marched in civil rights demonstrations and organized protests demanding black studies courses at his high school, where he was class president.

      He might not have been prominent in the civil rights demonstrations, but he did participate in his own way. He has gone on to be prominent in role of race, gender, and class in American society and the means by which people act and react to their "radical conditionedness." While I find that his "accented black style" can be a bit much, I enjoy hearing him speak.

      Right On, Brother West!

    • 8 months ago
  • DanCastro
    • +4
      DanCastro  
    • I support Lawrence and I think this is the kind of penetrating interviews of public officials that we need. Only blacks can comfortably say the "n" word, but a person running for public office (regardless of color, creed) should be subject to vigorous questioning by all side of the political spectrum so the person can be revealed and voters can make decisions on the person's opinions and not the nonsense we sometimes use (skin color, 'race', national origin, LGBT status, fill in stupidity here....). That this approach is "shocking" or considered "unfair" is a sad comment on the jerk off sessions that Faux tries to pass off as "reporting" and which are therefore considered "the norm"!

    • 8 months ago
  • bike10
  • Progresshiv
  • Kelly_Balthrop
    • +4
      Kelly_Balthrop  
    • I watched the interview and side with O'Donnell. His questions were appropriate given they were based on things in Cains own book, and the fact that Cain seems to oblivious to the plight of minorities in America, and struggles that they have gone through in trying to get equality. I think it shows a great insensitivity when Cain says that Black Democrats have been brain washed, as though they can't think for them selves.

      He overcame the odds and became successful, good for him. But to say that just because he made it, that anyone who fails to become successful has only them selves to blame is just narrow minded and a bit psycho. Here is a man who stands on the backs of giants who made his life possible, and says he and he alone was responsible for his success.

    • 8 months ago
  • Progresshiv
  • grammabet
    • +2
      grammabet  
    • Progresshiv:

      You evidently don't watch O'Donnells show,nothing prejudiced about him.Cain is the prejudiced one in this issue,against Blacks and anything that's not rich like him.I'm looking forward to his "rude awakning"

    • 8 months ago
more from Community:

top videos