Couple Finally Reveals Child's Gender, Five Years After Birth
source: http://shine.yahoo.com/parenting/couple-finally-reveals-childs-gender-five-years-birth-18030...
-
-
- MotherForTruth
- added this
"I wanted to avoid all that stereotyping," Laxton said in an interview with the Cambridge News. "Stereotypes seem fundamentally stupid. Why would you want to slot people into boxes?"
Take a look at the most controversial parenting stories of the year.
Laxton, a UK-based web editor, and her partner, Cooper, decided to keep Sasha's sex a secret when he was still in the womb. The birth announcement stated the name of the gender-neutral name of their child, but skipped the big reveal. Up until recently, the couple only told a few close friends and family members that Sasha was a boy and managed to keep the rest of the world in the dark. But now that he's starting school the secret's out.
For years, Becks has been referring to her child, the youngest of three, as "the infant" on her personal blog. But guarding the public from her son's gender was only part of her quest to let her kid just be a kid.
Sasha dresses in clothes he likes -- be it a hand-me-downs from his sister or his brother. The big no-no's are hyper-masculine outfits like skull-print shirts. In one photo, sent to friends and family, Sasha's dressed in a shiny pink girl's swimsuit. "Children like sparkly things," says Beck. "And if someone thought Sasha was a girl because he was wearing a pink swimming costume, then what effect would that have? "
Sasha's also not short on dolls, though Barbie is also off limits. "She's banned because she's horrible," Laxton says in Cambridge interview.
On a macro level she hopes her son sets an example for other parents and makes them reconsider buying their sons trucks or forcing their daughters into tights. She's seen how those consumer trappings affect how and who kids play with in the sandbox.
See how one preschool is fighting gender bias in the classroom
But the sandbox is just a precursor to the classroom. When Sasha turned five and headed to school, Laxton was forced to make her son's sex public. That meant Sasha would have to get used to being a boy in the eyes of his peers. Still, his mom is intervening. While the school requires different uniforms for boys and girls, Sasha wears a girl's blouse with his pants.
"I don't think I'd do it if I thought it was going to make him unhappy, but at the moment he's not really bothered either way. We haven't had any difficult scenarios yet."
Last year another couple, Kathy Witterick, 38, and David Stocker, 39, of Toronto made a similar decision when they had their baby, Storm. At the time, certain psychiatric experts voiced concern over their decision. "To have a sense of self and personal identity is a critical part of normal healthy development," Dr. Eugene Beresin, director of training in child and adolescent psychiatry at Massachusetts General Hospital, told ABC News. "This blocks that and sets the child up for bullying, scapegoating and marginalization."
But as parents well know, bullying is hard for any child to avoid. It's more important to raise someone who's confident enough in himself to overcome peer pressure. It's also important to have his parents have his back (remember the mom who defended her son's choice in a Halloween costume?) Maybe Sasha's early years will be character building, maybe he'll have a higher emotional quotient being raised with dual perspectives on gender. Or the reverse could be true: Sasha may have less of a formed identity because of his upbringing, and feel angry at his mom for dressing him in flowery shirts and telling the world about it. Then again, maybe he'll get over it.
As for Laxton, she says she's open to her son pursing any career or sexual preference he chooses as he matures. "As long as he has good relationships and good friends," she says, "then nothing else matters, does it?"
http://shine.yahoo.com/parenting/couple-finally-reveals-childs-gender-five-years...
-
- groups:
- Community, Current Cultural Issues, Gender Equality
-
- tags:
- Parenting, Child Abuse, Gender
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/4075523/Its-a-boy-Couple-reveal-sex-of...
"Sasha's gender was almost revealed when he took to running around their garden naked, but Beck was resolute and encouraged him to play with dolls to hide his masculinity."Why was this boy encouraged to pay with dolls to HIDE his masculinity?
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
unimatrix0
-
This is a fairly harmless publicity stunt meant to get a rise out of the ignorant, the bigoted, and those threatened by the unconventional.
- 4 months ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
unimatrix0:
No, this is a child abuse.
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
treewolf39
-
MotherForTruth:
In what way?
- 4 months ago
-
treewolf39
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
treewolf39:
This boy is sent a message being a boy is not acceptable by the very people who should be unconditionally accepting and loving. The parents need to model ways to be acceptable in society regardless of the gender but not suppressing the child's gender. Every child should be celebrated for their masculine and feminine qualities. There is a huge difference between being an open minded parent who supports a child by the way a child exhibits his/her personality and the obvious suppression of a child's needs based on his/her sexuality. Keeping this child's gender a secret sends a obvious message that he is not accepted for who he is.
Every parent knows the importance of their child's acceptance by his/her peers. This child most likely has no friends.
P.S. take a look how this boy is dressed - as a girl.
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
treewolf39
-
MotherForTruth:
I have a 7 year old girl and a 24 year old girl. Male or female makes no different to a child unless he or she is made only to think it maters. Children are cool being children until older than 10. This is a big deal to you as an adult but my 7 year old could care less. When I was a child it didn't mater to me ether but I have seen young parents think it maters like to be attracted at five.
- 4 months ago
-
treewolf39
-
-
treewolf39
-
MotherForTruth:
He doesn't look like anything is wrong. In fact he looks happy. War is so much more of an important issue that fucks people and families up.
- 4 months ago
-
treewolf39
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
treewolf39:
Friends and acceptance are important to children. Do you raise your children this way?
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
treewolf39:
This child will need years of therapy. I have memories back to when I was 2 and I thank my parents for the happy memories. What will this boy remember? Will he have happy memories of his parents celebrating him for who he is or will he remember dressed as a girl?
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
treewolf39
-
MotherForTruth:
friends are important but the sex doesn't mater like it they are kind and not bullies.
- 4 months ago
-
treewolf39
-
-
treewolf39
-
MotherForTruth:
They let him pick out what he likes. Not every country has pants for the men. Dressing is only a big deal if adult people make it a big deal. Teach your children that all people are important along with animals and plants. Life is important not gender unless you need a certain partner for a certain type of relationship.
- 4 months ago
-
treewolf39
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
treewolf39:
This child lives in an artificially created world. How do other children and their parents view this child? I have no doubt that this child will be stigmatized.
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
treewolf39:
I respectfully disagree, gender is important.
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
treewolf39
-
MotherForTruth:
If only people make important. Eating and cleaning are way more important at five years old. Boys and girls don't act a certain way. they act what they learn about.
- 4 months ago
-
treewolf39
-
-
treewolf39
-
MotherForTruth:
I think that now he is in school he going to have to use the boys bathroom. it only maters because people are pushing their world views. Does it mater is he is taught about a God? Some people would think different on that subject. I am having fun talking to my little girl about her thoughts on this subject being a 41 year old father. by the way I really do respect you and your thoughts.
- 4 months ago
-
treewolf39
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
treewolf39:
We do not need to always agree to have a respect for one another and for our individual opinion.
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
Nabe8
-
MotherForTruth:
Please define child abuse.
- 4 months ago
-
Nabe8
-
-
Truthitswhatsfordinner
-
treewolf39:
If he's in Colorado he can join the girl scouts if he wants to.
- 4 months ago
-
Truthitswhatsfordinner
-
-
treewolf39
-
Truthitswhatsfordinner:
For a boy, I would call that child abuse.
- 4 months ago
-
treewolf39
-
-
Truthitswhatsfordinner
-
treewolf39:
I'm with you. I was blown away when the Colorado girl scouts recently admitted a boy.
- 4 months ago
-
Truthitswhatsfordinner
-
-
treewolf39
-
Truthitswhatsfordinner:
Maybe a new gender needs to be created. Something that is boy and girl but not just one.
- 4 months ago
-
treewolf39
-
-
crabbyoldguy
-
Like life isn't hard enough without your parents playing gender bending mind tricks with your life.
- 4 months ago
-
crabbyoldguy
-
-
Naumadd
-
crabbyoldguy:
I rather see it as his parents shielded him as long as they could from gender mind games so he could form his own identity without all social pressure to "be this". The fact is, such pressure to "be this and not that" never goes away the rest of your life. Why not give the kid some time without it? It's quite a gift they gave him if you ask me.
Now, the rest of culture will commence its childishness.
- 4 months ago
-
Naumadd
-
-
Nabe8
-
crabbyoldguy:
Gender-bending mind "game," or rather, Mind-bending gender game: black = boy, pink = girl.
- 4 months ago
-
Nabe8
-
-
crabbyoldguy
-
Naumadd:
I don't see the benefit of their modeling, other than being different for the sake of being different and throwing the kid in neutral for part of his life.
Time will tell.
- 4 months ago
-
crabbyoldguy
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
Naumadd:
I see it as parents denying this boy to be himself.
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
crabbyoldguy:
I see it as a message to this child that he is not good enough to be who he is, a boy.
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
Naumadd:
Do you have children?
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
crabbyoldguy:
Time will tell, but loving parents would not treat their child as an experiment. Would they?
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
crabbyoldguy
-
MotherForTruth:
Something make me think it's all a dog and pony show to garner attention. The only info is what the parents told the press. It could be another "Ballon Boy" situation. But I would rather err on the side of caution since I don't believe that the shrinks have figured out all of the social/sexual imprinting that occurs in early development of children.
- 4 months ago
-
crabbyoldguy
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
crabbyoldguy:
You are right is is very possible.
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
Naumadd
-
Allowing the child to decide in what direction(s) they wish to go is the best kind of parenting I can think of.
As for what other people will think or do, that is THEIR burden to bear and their consequences to face.
I support these parents fully and only wish I'd have been given the same freedom as a child. Happily I have that freedom now as an adult and and exercise it as often as possible.
Those who live differently aren't criminals simply because culture as a whole is immature.
- 4 months ago
-
Naumadd
-
-
TheForeteller
-
Naumadd:
but none the less,
different from social norms = potential target for bullying - 4 months ago
-
TheForeteller
-
-
Naumadd
-
TheForeteller:
Yes, the social norm is to concern oneself with social norms.
As for bullies, bullies are gonna bully. That's what they are. Their psychology is about fear. Don't live in fear of bullies unless you want to become one of them.
- 4 months ago
-
Naumadd
-
-
MSII
-
TheForeteller:
fuck conformity
- 4 months ago
-
MSII
-
-
MSII
-
Naumadd:
Well said! Bullying should never be tolerated, -PERIOD-!
- 4 months ago
-
MSII
-
-
coolplanet
-
I will file this under he/she/it.....
- 4 months ago
-
coolplanet
-
-
beck7422
-
If a child choses to wear or play with non-gender normative items then that is fine. Making a child wear non-gender normative items to make a point is problematic, especially in public spaces with other children around that have been pushed to believe strongly in gender normative clothing.
- 4 months ago
-
beck7422
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
beck7422:
As shown on this picture this boy is dressed as a girl. This child will need some serious therapy when he grows up.
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
warman1138
-
Thats different, interesting but different.
- 4 months ago
-
warman1138
-
-
treewolf39
-
Anyone who has problems with these parents needs to grow up. It is not a real issue unless people make it one before puberty.
- 4 months ago
-
treewolf39
-
-
Buddha2112
-
This is a little strange... And setting up the kid for a rude awakening. There are social norms and safety is part of it, especially regarding bathrooms, locker rooms... Especially in the design of schools. This plays on a very strange and dangerous line. Society is not yet open enough for this to be safe for the child, and could potentially be threatening and unfair to other children, raising even MORE problems.
Ideally, no one would be judged based on gender, but gender, hormones, etc play a huge role in how we act and relate with one another. There's nothing wrong with wearing any type of clothing, or having sexual preference (I think humans are just sexual, not hetero or homo)... But there is an order between male and female. Society is struggling to accept transgender situations...
Why on earth would you do this to your kid? Maybe if it was some new school or community that did this with a bunch of kids, but... to single this poor bugger out is wrong.
You should not experiment with your children to this degree... As they grow older, they mature and make their own decisions, fitting into what is comfortable... giving the child no grounds is leaving him on the edge. He will have time to make the decisions the mother is so worried about later in life.
- 4 months ago
-
Buddha2112
-
-
Leen61
-
I don't agree with this. These kids are going to be so confused and so conflicted. They will be targeted. You don't gamble with kid's lives.
- 4 months ago
-
Leen61
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
This is a child abuse pure and simple.
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
Nabe8
-
MotherForTruth:
It could be argued that extreme religious devotion is child abuse, which could leave a child susceptible to bullying.
Other things that people are bullied over: height, athletic ability, ethnicity...
- 4 months ago
-
Nabe8
-
-
MSII
-
Nabe8:
"extreme religious devotion" -IS- child abuse! And bullying should -NEVER- be tolerated! -PERIOD-!
- 4 months ago
-
MSII
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
Nabe8:
The child will believe he was not accepted by his parents for who he is. It is parent's job to help a child grow up to be a part of the society not using a child as a science project.
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
Nabe8:
It's parent's responsibility to teach their child to respect himself or herself for who he/she is.
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
Nabe8
-
MSII:
Bullying should not be tolerated.
And extreme religious devotion is not necessarily child abuse. - 4 months ago
-
Nabe8
-
-
Nabe8
-
MotherForTruth:
And what if he is androgynous?
- 4 months ago
-
Nabe8
-
-
Nabe8
-
MotherForTruth:
How will the child believe that he is not accepted by his parents for who he is? It's much more likely that the child will view society as not accepting who he is.
"Science project" is loaded language. I disagree with your assessment that this is an experiment or a project.
- 4 months ago
-
Nabe8
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
Nabe8:
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/4075523/Its-a-boy-Couple-reveal-sex-of...
"Sasha's gender was almost revealed when he took to running around their garden naked, but Beck was resolute and encouraged him to play with dolls to hide his masculinity."
Obviously his parents have an issue with masculinity. Why?
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth
-
-
MotherForTruth
-
Nabe8:
but he is not. see my comments on how his parents posting all pictures of this boy dressed as a girl, play with dolls and instruct him to hide his his masculinity.
"Sasha's gender was almost revealed when he took to running around their garden naked, but Beck was resolute and encouraged him to play with dolls to hide his masculinity."
- 4 months ago
-
MotherForTruth