Community | February 08, 2012 | 94 comments

Supremacy of the Stupid !

Image
kennymotown
I hope you find this article a good read!



Supremacy of the Stupid
by Abby Zimet


In the wake of the recent study finding that right-wing ideologues are not the sharpest tool in the barn - aka that "conservative ideology is the 'critical pathway' from low intelligence to racism" - a fine rant from George Monbiot in The Guardian on a too-timid, self-doubting left that enables "crackpot outliers" and "social vivisectionists of the right" with an "ever more extreme, ever more fantasy-based ideology" based on an alternative knowledge system, one that proves "there is no pool so shallow that several million people won't drown in it." Great stuff.

The Right's Stupidity Spreads, Enabled by a Too-Polite Left

Conservativism may be the refuge of the dim. But the room for rightwing ideas is made by those too timid to properly object

by George Monbiot

Self-deprecating, too liberal for their own good, today's progressives stand back and watch, hands over their mouths, as the social vivisectionists of the right slice up a living society to see if its component parts can survive in isolation. Tied up in knots of reticence and self-doubt, they will not shout stop. Doing so requires an act of interruption, of presumption, for which they no longer possess a vocabulary.
A billboard put up by a ‘birther' campaigner convinced that President Obama was not born in the United States. (Photo: Bob Daemmrich/Alamy)

Perhaps it is in the same spirit of liberal constipation that, with the exception of Charlie Brooker, we have been too polite to mention the Canadian study published last month in the journal Psychological Science, which revealed that people with conservative beliefs are likely to be of low intelligence. Paradoxically it was the Daily Mail that brought it to the attention of British readers last week. It feels crude, illiberal to point out that the other side is, on average, more stupid than our own. But this, the study suggests, is not unfounded generalization but empirical fact.

It is by no means the first such paper. There is plenty of research showing that low general intelligence in childhood predicts greater prejudice towards people of different ethnicity or sexuality in adulthood. Open-mindedness, flexibility, trust in other people: all these require certain cognitive abilities. Understanding and accepting others – particularly "different" others – requires an enhanced capacity for abstract thinking.

But, drawing on a sample size of several thousand, correcting for both education and socioeconomic status, the new study looks embarrassingly robust. Importantly, it shows that prejudice tends not to arise directly from low intelligence but from the conservative ideologies to which people of low intelligence are drawn. Conservative ideology is the "critical pathway" from low intelligence to racism. Those with low cognitive abilities are attracted to "rightwing ideologies that promote coherence and order" and "emphasize the maintenance of the status quo". Even for someone not yet renowned for liberal reticence, this feels hard to write.

This is not to suggest that all conservatives are stupid. There are some very clever people in government, advising politicians, running thinktanks and writing for newspapers, who have acquired power and influence by promoting rightwing ideologies.

But what we now see among their parties – however intelligent their guiding spirits may be – is the abandonment of any pretense of high-minded conservatism. On both sides of the Atlantic, conservative strategists have discovered that there is no pool so shallow that several million people won't drown in it. Whether they are promoting the idea that Barack Obama was not born in the US, that man-made climate change is an eco-fascist-communist-anarchist conspiracy, or that the deficit results from the greed of the poor, they now appeal to the basest, stupidest impulses, and find that it does them no harm in the polls.

Don't take my word for it. Listen to what two former Republican ideologues, David Frum and Mike Lofgren, have been saying. Frum warns that "conservatives have built a whole alternative knowledge system, with its own facts, its own history, its own laws of economics". The result is a "shift to ever more extreme, ever more fantasy-based ideology" which has "ominous real-world consequences for American society".

Lofgren complains that "the crackpot outliers of two decades ago have become the vital center today". The Republican party, with its "prevailing anti-intellectualism and hostility to science" is appealing to what he calls the "low-information voter", or the "misinformation voter". While most office holders probably don't believe the "reactionary and paranoid claptrap" they peddle, "they cynically feed the worst instincts of their fearful and angry low-information political base".

The madness hasn't gone as far in the UK, but the effects of the Conservative appeal to stupidity are making themselves felt. This week the Guardian reported that recipients of disability benefits, scapegoated by the government as scroungers, blamed for the deficit, now find themselves subject to a new level of hostility and threats from other people.

These are the perfect conditions for a billionaires' feeding frenzy. Any party elected by misinformed, suggestible voters becomes a vehicle for undisclosed interests. A tax break for the 1% is dressed up as freedom for the 99%. The regulation that prevents big banks and corporations exploiting us becomes an assault on the working man and woman. Those of us who discuss man-made climate change are cast as elitists by people who happily embrace the claims of Lord Monckton, Lord Lawson or thinktanks funded by ExxonMobil or the Koch brothers: now the authentic voices of the working class.

But when I survey this wreckage I wonder who the real idiots are. Confronted with mass discontent, the once-progressive major parties, as Thomas Frank laments in his latest book Pity the Billionaire, triangulate and accommodate, hesitate and prevaricate, muzzled by what he calls "terminal niceness". They fail to produce a coherent analysis of what has gone wrong and why, or to make an uncluttered case for social justice, redistribution and regulation. The conceptual stupidities of conservatism are matched by the strategic stupidities of liberalism.

Yes, conservatism thrives on low intelligence and poor information. But the liberals in politics on both sides of the Atlantic continue to back off, yielding to the supremacy of the stupid. It's turkeys all the way down.
  1. groups:
    Community,   News and Politics,   Health,   US Politics,   27 more
  2. tags:
  3.     
    |

94 comments // Supremacy of the Stupid !

  • Timebandit
  • kennymotown
  • vaxart
  • noxidereus
    • +3
      noxidereus  
    • The actions of the Democrats give only the illusion that liberals are weak, but that's because they're not liberals themselves but must try to appeal to a liberal-ish constituency while executing a right-wing agenda for their 1% sugar daddies. So they point their fingers at our lesser-intelligent brothers and sisters (conservatives in general) as the enemy of the liberals. This distracts us from the fact that the Democratic party is actually the enemy (as well as the more obvious Republican party). They divide us against ourselves so that we may never pose a threat to the establishment.

    • 4 months ago
  • kennymotown
  • VFORVENDETTA
  • kennymotown
  • VFORVENDETTA
  • kennymotown
  • Joeydee44
  • kennymotown
  • VFORVENDETTA
  • VFORVENDETTA
  • JustZ
    • +1
      JustZ  
    • Great post Kennymotown! Many thanks for all the good you're doing here at CurrentTVNews.

      Progressives sure better wake up and start challenging planet wingnuttia! Kletus the slack jawed yokel may be stupid... but these days he's extremely well financed with billions from criminals like the Koch brothers.

    • 4 months ago
  • kennymotown
  • 2hellnwait
    • +2
      2hellnwait  
    • The same people who derail the point of those who believe that BO's legitimacy is questionable. . . are much the same as those who believe that 9/11 was a vast government conspiracy.
      Six of those & half a dozen of the other. . . it's all madness.

    • 4 months ago
  • MSII
    • +5
      MSII  
    • Excellent article! So very true! Progressives have been far too polite, too reasonable. The big long-standing mistake in thinking that the other side is somehow just misguided and can be reasoned with is just plain WRONG. They are "true believers", you can't get a conversion out of them by reason. politics is religion, you don't get a "conversion" out of someone with a little polite reasonable talk. Nothing short of some kind of religious conversion experience will break their madness. High time to turn the tide against them, use their own weapons against them, yes get angry, hate, and use fear if necessary! they've used it successfully for years we have to get off our high-horse and FIGHT!

    • 4 months ago
  • kennymotown
  • Arizona_Huey
    • +2
      Arizona_Huey  
    • MSII:

      I have come to that conclusion over the last year or two! I no longer argue with these right wing teapublican religious zealots because they are far too ignorant to even attempt an intellectual conversation about any issue. It pretty much came to me while I was trying to get a very straight answer from a 'conservative'. The conversation was sorta like this:

      Me: You say you are a conservative who votes only for a candidate that supports that - exactly what is a conservative then?

      Him: Fiscally conservative/responsible, small government, balanced budget, faith base, pro middle class, less regulations,

      Me: I get that, but then why do you support the teapublican party? Then proceed to illustrate, with facts, that the teapublican party since Ronnie Reagan have exploded government size, exploded the deficit, loosened corporate restrictions while exploding personal restrictions, doled out massive tax breaks for the elite while hammering the middle class,

      Him: Obama is a socialist who is forcing churches into handing out birth control, he is a socialist, a Muslim that associates with terrorist, wants to redistribute the wealth to the poor by handing them tons of cash through entitlements, is anti business, etc.

      Me: Refute every one of those points with actual facts.

      Him: Obamacare is socialism and unconstitutional, he isn't even a US citizen...

      Me: Okay - you're just too ridiculously damaged from Fox exposure to ever talk to again!

    • 4 months ago
  • VFORVENDETTA
  • Wyley_Wombat
    • +3
      Wyley_Wombat  
    • Great post Kenny!

      I heard a comment from a right wing moron last year regarding NPR: “All they have are professors, doctors, and scientists talking about stuff”. This is a really profound indicator of just how far the “dumbing down” has progressed. There are a large number of people that are not only repelled by intelligence, they are actually proud of their own lack of it. This is a fertile ground in which to cultivate ideas that have no basis in reality and are little more than rumors. To combat this we cannot simply ignore it, but must counter it by presenting actual facts. Yes, these facts will have to be presented in simple terms but we have to start someplace.

    • 4 months ago
  • kennymotown
  • warman1138
    • +3
      warman1138  
    • So very true kenny, good post as to the photo above '' Oh my god, the dumb are buying billboard space ''. It's long past time for liberals to take a stand against mean stupidity.

    • 4 months ago
  • kennymotown
  • VFORVENDETTA
  • kennymotown
  • Mitekillem1
    • +7
      Mitekillem1  
    • Guess it's time for a new breed of liberal. One that's not afraid to stand-up for themselves, for others, who can win in any debate and use Republican's own tactics against them.
      We're far too nice. What's funny is seeing what happens when a liberal looses his cool about republicans or to one specific right-winger. They suddenly turn into children pointing out "liberal violence" or "hatred" just for standing up for ourselves.

      I think we should embrace these titles. Why can't we be bullies for a while?
      Do I hate stupidity? -Yes! Yes I do.
      Does it make me angry? Yes it does.
      Do I care if they call me a bully - hell no!
      If they can bully the poor, those dependent upon welfare/disability and demonize them, if they can introduce laws that appeal to one religion (but not others) and reduce a woman's freedom over her own body, If they can limit the right to vote by eliminating the means for many impoverished, out-of-state college students, etc....if they can take away our god given rights for the sake of "freedom" or "taking america back" - then I say it's time we give them one-for.

      Call them out on their bullsh!t, and beat them at their own game.
      Be smarter than them, and air out their dirty laundry for everyone to see.
      The time for pleasantries is at an end. Being Civil, and Compromising is off the table. We've tried that, and when they want to compromise...they don't give an inch. Neither should we.

      We need to educate people to their flaws, and to their lies by promoting truth, results, and facts.
      We can't sit idly by as they dismantle our country from the inside-out.
      It's time we put our foot down. If they wish to behave like children, then we should treat them as such.

    • 4 months ago
  • kennymotown
  • ecoalex
    • +1
      ecoalex  
    • The liberals are bought off.$$ is at the root of the capitulation.Yes,conservatism is stupid,moronic,and is a backward cult that only benefits the oligarchy.

    • 4 months ago
  • VFORVENDETTA
  • Arizona_Huey
  • arnie1961
    • +5
      arnie1961  
    • all i can say to them is if you get your head out of your ass you might see it. thanks Kenny man what a moron they are.and disgrace to America

    • 4 months ago
  • kennymotown
  • arnie1961
  • alovejoy
    • +6
      alovejoy  
    • They can't win on the issues so they use fear ,"race- baiting", and religious intolerance as weapons. Conservatives are so predictable.

    • 4 months ago
  • kennymotown
  • rwmoser53
    • +6
      rwmoser53  
    • I think we, progressives, need to be ten times more agressive in countering the exploitation of the stupid people by the greedy and evil-minded republicans. We don't need to be nice about it anymore! We need to confront the racist stupid people with harsh facts until their heads explode!

    • 4 months ago
  • fiberbundle
    • +6
      fiberbundle  
    • The Tea Party was formed the very month a black man was elected to the Presidency. What! !None of their "government spending and growth issues" were pressing enough before the election of a black man? I know better. I have Tea Party bigots in my family. Luckily because they are composed of that segment of the population who are bitter, hateful bigots (and have always been that way) there is a natural limit on their numbers. They all flock together at Fox news. But they can never persuade normal compassionate fair minded Americans to their cause. They can just Twitter and Facebook with other Nazis.

    • 4 months ago
  • NEVERSCARED
  • Paratus
    • -9
      Paratus  
    • I read as far as the phrase, "Enabled by a Too-Polite Left" and realized that this is either very tongue in cheek or a monstrous lie. Either way it did provide some morning entertainment and laughter. If there is one thing that the left absolutely cannot lay claim to is being too polite or even just polite. They generally are not even nice, unless you agree completely with them. Now if the author would have penned that liberalism thrives on control of the people and large, overreaching government it would have had some credibility.
      Had to give this a thumb down in spite of the belly laugh it generated.

    • 4 months ago
  • rerushg
  • BrushwithDeathToothpaste
  • rwmoser53
  • VFORVENDETTA
  • PeteLeS33
    • +8
      PeteLeS33  
    • I said years ago when I was posting on that sellout bolg Huffington Post that we (progressives) should start taking these conservatives seriously, but no, we were too busy laughing at the comments of Palin, O'Donnel, ect, saying that thoes things will never ever happen. Fast foward five years and here we are. There is a chance that a Romney, Santorum, (google it), could become president. With the changes in voter laws, redistricting and states changing from winner take all to winner take county, ( thank you very much Gov. Corbett of Pa.). One of these crackpots can actually get in. Now is not the time for politics as usual of our society.

      We have started to finally get angry (Occupy), we just need to treat them as they treat us. So the next time someone tells you they are a Republican, give them the old eye roll with a disgruntled "OH BOY", reply. They immediately go on the defencive and the look on their face is amazing. Try it. Call their ideology on the carpet, and do so mockingly. Since this is a so called "class war", have fun, we have already allowed the loss of everything else, what else do we have to loose? At least we will have our humor.

    • 4 months ago
  • VFORVENDETTA
    • +1
      VFORVENDETTA  
    • PeteLeS33:

      I am in complete agreement with what you are saying, and as far as your second paragraph is concerned, I have been calling out conservative bullshit for the last 25 years, and I will do so anywhere at any time, particularly in a public place.

      Just a little FYI, one of the greatest documentaries ever made on the third Reich, was a black and white one made in the 1960s ironically entitled Mein Kampf (My struggle) The same title as the book by Hitler published in 1925 (second edition in 1926) In the documentary, as they are discussing the publication of that book, they state:

      "the book was read by a few and laughed at by many, a few years later.... they no longer laughed" and "the Nazi revolution.... became a fact."

      Speaking for myself, I do not find the tenets of conservatism (or libertarianism) funny,
      but utterly repulsive and repungent, I always take sociopathic doctrine VERY seriously, and so should everyone else.

    • 4 months ago
  • PeteLeS33
    • 0
      PeteLeS33  
    • VFORVENDETTA:

      In total agrement, though I have not seen the movie, I did see a documentary about the rise of Hitler and they mentioned the fact that his book was mocked before his rise. That was what made me think.

      Having been raised catholic in the northeast and lived in the south for some years I have seen the distructive ways mythological religions combined with conservatism can cause.

      I do think that the republican party is following the same path that Hitler did in the fact that the majority of society is busy laughing and not paying attention to what is really going on.

    • 4 months ago
  • bike10
  • BrushwithDeathToothpaste
  • gypsysailor
  • Saladin
    • +13
      Saladin  
    • "Frum warns that "conservatives have built a whole alternative knowledge system, with its own facts, its own history, its own laws of economics". The result is a "shift to ever more extreme, ever more fantasy-based ideology" which has "ominous real-world consequences for American society"."

      That's been my experience with them, even on this site.

      They just live in a fantasy world where Ronny Raygun beat the commies and Jesus wrote the Constitution there really were WMD's in Iraq, etc. etc. etc.

    • 4 months ago
  • MSII
    • 0
      MSII  
    • Image
    • Saladin:

      Politics is religion. These people are the fundamentalist "true believers" It's the core "beliefs" we need to target and KILL. Attack their lunatic absolute faith that america is infallible, perfect, the very gleam in their mad-gods eye! Identify their other "sanctified" core beliefs and KILL them, drive those wooden stakes through them!

      Very interesting interview on Bill Moyers show, I don't agree with everything the person says, not by a long-shot but still he has some very interesting things to say, we can learn some things from him to use to attack the enemy.
      http://billmoyers.com/segment/jonathan-haidt-explains-our-contentious-culture/

    • 4 months ago
  • ThirdSection
  • KB723
  • ThirdSection
  • pjacobs51
  • ThirdSection
  • bailey78
  • coolplanet
    • +12
      coolplanet  
    • Bill Clinton has an IQ of 172.
      George W. Bush has an IQ of 95.

      Jimmy Carter has an IQ of 168.
      Ronald Reagan was 105.

      An IQ of 100 is considered average.
      Liberals will understand where I'm going with this. ;}

    • 4 months ago
  • wolfess
    • +10
      wolfess  
    • coolplanet:

      Finally! I've been writing for awhile that 'most' reptards are probably 2 standard deviations below the mean ... the shrub is probably at 1.8 b/c an IQ of 90 is 2 deviations below ...

      Pwr 2 the true liberal 99%! Now, GET. ANGRY. and take back our country!

    • 4 months ago
  • coolplanet
    • +7
      coolplanet  
    • wolfess:

      Yes, W is 5 points away from being classified a moron.
      But Bill is borderline insane genius.....
      It doesn't require brains to make money which is the entire problem.
      Pwr 2 the 99%!!!

    • 4 months ago
  • wolfess
    • +2
      wolfess  
    • coolplanet:

      Bill is borderline insane genius..... I read somewhere many years ago that he was probably hyperactive (I think in many cases hyperactivity is b/c they are so intelligent that their minds have trouble settling down and thinking about just one thing). I can certainly see Clinton that way, and also JFK; I believe Obama is extremely intelligent, I just don't know how he got so sidetracked :-(.

      Pwr 2 the true liberal 99%! GET. ANGRY. and take back our country!

    • 4 months ago
  • MSII
  • budsnews
  • kennymotown
  • ZiggyStrange
  • kennymotown
  • Anonmaly
  • northernexpat
    • +8
      northernexpat  
    • Excellent read. If people can be convince to go along with things that are in their worst interest, then we should be able to convince them of what is in their best interest. So it's time for liberals to stop being nice and start speaking up loudly about what is right. We cannot continue to roll over and allow the extreme members of society to decide the rules of the road or we all lose. Come on people wake up and speak up. Are we a society for all individuals or for just the ones that think they are better than everyone else?

    • 4 months ago
  • kennymotown
  • JanforGore
    • +4
      JanforGore  
    • northernexpat:

      Russ Feingold did that the other day. Where was his support? People always say that should be done but when those who see what is wrong with all sides decide to criticize Obama or something he does they get lambasted. It is wrong to bow down to the whims of corporations and lower yourself down in order to "win." The majority of Americans now are against money in politics and would rally around any sincere American running for the presidency who made an iron clad promise to distance themselves from that money and who asked for THEIR help in crushing the opposition that only cares about those same corporations in lieu of doing what is right for them. It might also help to have an actual platform of fresh ideas rather then just spending millions to bash the other side. It would look bold, strong and committed to finally moving us beyond the type of government where the people have no voice. It would show that anyone who is confident they have a record they can stand on in this age of social media and who already has the bully pulpit doesn't need Citizens United to win an election. But that isn't what is going to happen.

      Some think because Citizens United is here we HAVE to abide by it. Well, having a moral center believe it or not does matter to many people out here and it would mean even more now... look at the Occupy movement and its premise. You couldn't have had a clearer look at the pulse of this nation right now and it is being betrayed by both sides. So by your logic if we are to speak out about what is wrong, that means we should speak out when we see those who are supposed to be doing right doing wrong on any side. But it is hard here in an atmosphere where allegiance to the man on any side goes beyond and above what is right. It is wrong to continue policies that support the destruction of our planet and climate balance. It is wrong to suppport policies that continue this phony war on terror and war in general. It is time to take the high road and really call for change, not keep saying you want it while continuing the status quo that benefits you. And until we can call those out on it who claim to be above the fray, nothing will really change.

    • 4 months ago
  • Leen61
    • +4
      Leen61  
    • JanforGore:

      Excellent comment, Jan. On a side note, I did support Russ the other day. He always speaks out. Also, that's why Obama didn't go out of his way to help him get re-elected in 2010. He doesn't like Russ because Russ always let him know when he disapproved of something he did. Right now Russ is working to overturn CU. But I would like to see him run for governor. The Koch money is already coming in here in the form of ads talking up Walker. I cried election night 2010 when I realized Russ didn't get re-elected.

    • 4 months ago
  • Leen61
  • wolfess
    • +5
      wolfess  
    • Leen61:

      Happy Valentine's Sis -- like your new avi :-).

      I spent some time with Mike today -- he is seriously doing remarkably well ... he's flirting with his nurses :-)!

      Pwr 2 the true liberal 99%! FREE Bradley Manning AND Julian Assange!

    • 4 months ago
  • Leen61
    • +3
      Leen61  
    • wolfess:

      Happy Valentine's to you as well, Sis--glad you like the new avi...just in time for Valentine's Day. :)

      I'm so glad to hear Mike is doing so well! Good on him for flirting with the nurses! ;) Way to go Mike! LOL!

      Pwr 2 the true liberal 99%! FREE Bradley Manning AND Julian Assange!

    • 4 months ago
  • cmc101
  • kennymotown
  • wolfess
    • +2
      wolfess  
    • cmc101:

      Awesome comment! That was truly quite an ad, and as you have so intelligently shown -- WE are free to read into it whatever we want to :-)!

      Pwr 2 the 99%! OUR American Spring can't come soon enough!

    • 4 months ago
  • Incredulous
  • kennymotown
  • letsliveinpeace
  • Kelly_Balthrop
  • letsliveinpeace
  • cmc101
  • kennymotown
  • wolfess
  • thedirtman
    • +11
      thedirtman  
    • Ah, the complete freedom from the burden of thought. Becoming nothing but a reactionary cog in a degenerating environment. What could be easier?

    • 4 months ago
  • kennymotown
  • cmc101
  • ZiggyStrange
  • thedirtman
  • thedirtman
  • ZiggyStrange
  • wolfess
more from Community:

top videos