QUIZ: Are You an Insulated Snob or in Touch with America?
source: http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/2012/03/white-educated-and-wealthy-congratulations-you-l...
-
-
- Mishima [removed]
- added this
http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/2012/03/white-educated-and-wealth...
This is a quiz that will estimates how insulated you are or are not from the American culture. NOTE THE SOURCE: PBS.http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/2012/03/white-educated-and-wealthy-congratul...
-
- groups:
- Community
-
-
Milieu
-
Much as I would like to be insulated from real life(lmao), I'm quite happy knowing all kind of people, even The RayGun Avatar type. Self-centered they are, yes. Fearful, they are, yes. Pull yourself up by your own bootstraps, even if you haven't any, they are, yes.
But as long as you don't move too quickly or use words that are more than two syllables, you're fine.
- 7 months ago
-
Milieu
-
-
Mishima [removed]
-
Milieu:
The Left-wingers are the fearful ones. That is why they advocate more federal government and SOCIALISM. Socialism brings the false promise that everyone will be taken care of - Get sick? Free healthcare. Out of a job? Government will create one for you. Didn't provide for your old age? The welfare state will house you. Didn't save for your kids education? Hey, in Liberal-Land, college is FREE. Became a junkie or a drunk? The Left-winger social programs will give you counseling and free drugs to help you feel better.
Left-wingers are afraid of reality, they are afraid of the real world. They live in fear; they policies reek of fear.
- 7 months ago
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
gump
-
Mishima posted this test. That means it is an information fishing trap. Do not use it. DO NOT DO THIS SO CALLED QUIZ. I had not noticed this was posted by a software program under development by a right wing think tank. DO NOT FEED IT"S HANDLERS ANY INFORMATION.
- 7 months ago
-
gump
-
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
gump:
"DO NOT FEED IT"S HANDLERS ANY INFORMATION."
- 7 months ago
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
artemis6
-
gump:
Aw man ... i wish you had commented first . I wondered what could be up . I just thought he wanted to feel smug , but i did not guess how .
- 7 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
gump
-
I got 66. But I think it should have been 99. I cannot afford to go fishing. But I discuss politics with people who are fishing when I pass them at the canals on my bicycle. I tell them things that fascinate them about fishing. Then I get into all the bigger stuff. Thats even more fascinateing .I watched a homeless man pull a 24 inch long channel catfish out a couple weeks ago. I see plenty of them in the canals. Often in groups of 5 and 6.
- 7 months ago
-
gump
-
-
Mishima [removed]
-
gump:
"I discuss politics with people who are fishing "
I'm sure they look forward to YOUR coming.....
- 7 months ago
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
B_N_L
-
Charles Murray? No thanks.
- 7 months ago
-
B_N_L
-
-
Mishima [removed]
-
B_N_L:
Why not? Is that how, as a Left-winger, you are SUPPOSED to react?
- 7 months ago
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
B_N_L
-
Mishima:
Let me guess. Questions about popular culture and beer, right?
Everyone lives in some type of bubble. My bubble includes poor to upper middle class and high school dropouts to post-bachelor educated and it includes multiple races (Murray only cares about white folks, apparently). It's a pretty big bubble and I don't need to take some bullshit test to tell me how small or big or thick or thin my bubble is. OK?
Murray focuses on reductive arguments, dividing people up into groups and subgroups and is therefore blind to the big picture (typical libertarian P.O.V.). He offers nothing in the way of viable solutions to our society's problems and IMO, is largely a waste of time.
I think this statistical analysis is much closer to identifying the source of our society's ills and by implication, what needs to be done about it. No doubt you will disagree and respond with some garbage about the inherent "left-winger bias" in the analysis and will ignore the fact that the data is quite robust.
- 7 months ago
-
B_N_L
-
-
Milieu
-
70 points --- but we don't waste our time and money going out to eat when we can make better and much more nutritious food at home.
Oh, and Uncle Ronnie's Avatar is either way at one end or the other; that would be his/hers/its reason for being so in love with an Alzheimer's muppet that we'll be trying to recover from for at least 20 - 30 more years.
Then we'll have to start work on what the Prep School Baseball Cheerleader did to our country.
- 7 months ago
-
Milieu
-
-
Joeydee44
-
So, like, we get to take your little quiz and then you get to comment on our results, but then you don't have to post your results because we will attack, revile, and distort you. Sorry, I won't participate in your self-validation exercise. Good day, mate!
- 7 months ago
-
Joeydee44
-
-
Mishima [removed]
-
Joeydee44:
I have not attacked anyone based on their score and will not, either. I may respond to Left-winger comments and personal attacks, but as you see - I have not made any unfavorable comment about anyone's score.
- 7 months ago
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
trut
-
I scored a 53 for whatever that means.
- 7 months ago
-
trut
-
-
bailey78
-
I wonder how the poster has done on this. I'm betting he won't say.
- 7 months ago
-
bailey78
-
-
Mishima [removed]
-
bailey78:
Of course I won't. This place is infested with Left-wingers, so no matter what my score is, the Liberals will contrive ways to attack, revile, distort, and turn it into something ugly as they always do.
- 7 months ago
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
bailey78
-
Mishima:
Revealing so very revealing
- 7 months ago
-
bailey78
-
-
SIBob
-
Mishima:
" attack, revile, distort, and turn it into something ugly". That defines the rightest's agenda.
- 7 months ago
-
SIBob
-
-
bailey78
-
SIBob:
Thats what I'm thinking. He ranked so low because of the thick walled bubble he lives in is so far from the truth
- 7 months ago
-
bailey78
-
-
wolfess
-
bailey78:
Yeah, but you see -- living in a basement on Fantasy Island qualifies as the ULTIMATE bubble :-)!
- 7 months ago
-
wolfess
-
-
bailey78
-
wolfess:
True I guess he is dug in for the long haul to no where land.
- 7 months ago
-
bailey78
-
-
Varex_Sythe
-
Mishima:
I smell bullshit.
I know, you're talking so I'm stating the obvious... but still, it's fun to point it out.
- 7 months ago
-
Varex_Sythe
-
-
SIBob
-
bailey78:
Yes he lives in a cocoon of his own making.
- 7 months ago
-
SIBob
-
-
bailey78
-
Mishima:
AHA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
- 6 months ago
-
bailey78
-
-
bailey78
-
I got 75 points.
- 7 months ago
-
bailey78
-
-
LiIIianRose
-
I got a 53.
I agree there should have been questions about books. I do not watch the tv shows listed because we do not have cable; cable is expensive but a library card is free.
- 7 months ago
-
LiIIianRose
-
-
Mishima [removed]
-
LiIIianRose:
" I do not watch the tv shows listed because we do not have cable"
That indicates, in part, the kind of person you are, what you value, and what is important to you. Good to hear you do not have cable. Speaks well of your values.
- 7 months ago
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
artemis6
-
LiIIianRose:
And , once you learn to read , there is nothing you cannot learn !
- 7 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
Mishima [removed]
-
artemis6:
"I couldn't wait to finish school so I could start my education."
-Mark Twain (paraphrased, but close) - 7 months ago
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
artemis6
-
49 . I read a lot , there were no questions about books . There is no TV reception where i live .
- 7 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
youngdebater
-
I got a 43
- 7 months ago
-
youngdebater
-
-
Mishima [removed]
-
youngdebater:
Looks like you came from a good background but have not insulated yourself from others of differing educational and economic levels. In other words, a person who comes from a well-educated, well-off family who mixes with all types of people. Does it fit?
- 7 months ago
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
artemis6
-
Mishima:
Insulated , is that like censoring ? Limiting other opinions ?
- 7 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
wolfess
-
Mishima:
He's a kid -- still in high school if I'm not mistaken -- he hasn't had the opportunity to do all the things the questions asked.
- 7 months ago
-
wolfess
-
-
hombre76
-
Mine was 67.
So what was your score Mish?
- 7 months ago
-
hombre76
-
-
artemis6
-
hombre76:
Yep . This is fun ! I am voting everyone up !
- 7 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
northernexpat
-
I'm scared I got a 24. Which would put me in the 11–80: A first-generation upper-middle-class person with middle-class parents. Typical: 33. Although I may dispute myself being upper middle class - more like lower upper middle class. But I do not consider myself living in a bubble. I know more about what is happening in America then many Americans.
- 7 months ago
-
northernexpat
-
-
cpad
-
-
northernexpat:
We definitely know more about America than Americans know about Canada!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BhTZ_tgMUdo - 7 months ago
-
cpad
-
-
artemis6
-
northernexpat:
It did not ask anything about internet , so , i think the test needs an update , no videogames ( i don't play , but i understand many do ) and differing vehicles and food choices may figure prominently on the updated test ....
- 7 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
artemis6:
The full test is in the book that Left-wingers should read.
But Liberals like pictures and TV, so here is a discussion of it on YouTube.
- 7 months ago
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
SIBob
-
Mishima:
"Liberals like pictures and TV". What kind of asinine statement is that? The rightist reading list is certainly no badge of honor. It keeps you in ignorance.
- 7 months ago
-
SIBob
-
-
trut
-
cpad:
We probably know about America than the Americans know.
- 7 months ago
-
trut
-
-
northernexpat
-
artemis6:
Very true. The question about restaurants only applies if you live where they have these restaurants. I also don't drink or smoke, does that isolate me? I may live in a small town in the Northwest Territories, but that doesn't mean that I can't see what is happening in the rest of the world. I've traveled extensively in both the US and Canada, and I've been to Mexico. I haven't had the privilege to travel aboard, but I still pay attention to what is happening over there. I'm an avid reader and a news junky. Paying attention to what is going on the world seems more important then what restaurant or TV show you watch. To me it was a stupid quiz.
- 7 months ago
-
northernexpat
-
-
northernexpat
-
cpad:
I can definitely attest to that. I couldn't believe how ignorant I was about Canada when I moved up here after marrying a Canadian and I grew up in New York. So it's not like I grew up in an area that didn't border Canada. I just feel that there are too many Americans that think they are so superior to others that they can't be bothered to learn about the rest of the world.
- 7 months ago
-
northernexpat
-
-
s_peak
-
Mishima:
I like that you constantly talk about how divisive and closed-minded (or stupid) left wingers are... but almost every sentence you type is an attack on them... You catch more flies with honey, you know? ... But from what I've seen... you're not out to "convince" people... just carpet bomb conversations with your malformed opinions...
I've seen you formulate intelligent and reasoned responses... so I KNOW you're capable of NOT sounding like a jackass... but you tend to bury your credibility under a mound of self-righteous bullshit.
- 7 months ago
-
s_peak
-
-
Varex_Sythe
-
Mishima:
Just out of curiosity, what was your score Mishie-poo?
- 7 months ago
-
Varex_Sythe
-
-
Mishima [removed]
-
SIBob:
{"Liberals like pictures and TV". What kind of asinine statement is that? The rightist reading list is certainly no badge of honor.}
Thank you for validating what I have been asserting. Not a single Left-winger has been able to write a cogent comment about a single book, even though many have condemned the books - just as you have.
Revealing....
- 7 months ago
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
Mishima [removed]
-
northernexpat:
"I also don't drink or smoke, does that isolate me?"
Read the explanation in the article. It is clear. That question is clearly answered.
- 7 months ago
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
Mishima [removed]
-
northernexpat:
"there are too many Americans that think they are so superior to others that they can't be bothered to learn about the rest of the world."
In that respect, Americans are no different than people in any other country. I am open to discuss and explain this.
- 7 months ago
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
Mishima [removed]
-
s_peak:
I will ask you a question for purposes of beginning a discussion, but you will probably read into it beyond what is there. But I will try.
Suppose someone were a member of the Klan and was convinced that his racist views were correct, and that people who did not go along with them were traitors, immoral and cowards? I mean he is really convinced.
How would you respond to his dogmatic assertions of the inferiority of certain groups?
- 7 months ago
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
artemis6
-
Mishima:
Like pictures on TV ?! I am sure you abhor it . What an attitude !
- 7 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
artemis6
-
SIBob:
Agreed .
- 7 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
artemis6
-
northernexpat:
Quite right . i think the "snob" in the title of this post is a projection of the tremendously insecure nature of the designer of said test . So really , it's a head game . Nothing more .
- 7 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
Mishima [removed]
-
artemis6:
Like pictures AND television. Not "on." I never see Left-wingers on these threads discuss books or ideas. All of what they say comes from the media and they put up cartoons to express themselves very often, so I assumed.....
- 7 months ago
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
artemis6
-
Mishima:
I personally have discussed many books here with others .. it is a great place in part BECAUSE they recommend a good read . You have not been here as long as i , no doubt .
- 7 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
Mishima [removed]
-
artemis6:
Glad you have discussed books. I have never seen any real discussions of ideas, concepts or books. For example, I have asked Left-wingers many times to discuss their Socialism, and they always refuse. Or, they start the nonsensical attacks, like "Don't you care about the poor?" or some other such crap.
- 7 months ago
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
s_peak
-
Mishima:
Well going into this situation I would already feel that logic would be lost on someone like that. I couldn't explain my point from a scientific or logical perspective like: "the success of greater lifeforms is essentially based on a pattern of symbiosis. Hatred and division are logically inappropriate in dealing with others. It essentially represents a movement against the system that allowed for life and civilization to function and flourish"...
Something like that would be lost on him... So how do you relate to someone who's views on morality are clearly destructive? (It's also important to note that there is some degree of ethics (morality) that is logically "right" or "wrong". Morality has some aspect of subjectivity to it, but cannot be considered entirely subjective.)
If he were able to follow my logical assertion that our connections (not divisions) drive history in a positive direction, I could simply explain that his views will eventually become extinct because they shut him into a corner... but that won't work. I would try, and probably fail... because someone with views that deeply disconnected would most likely come from a splintered and troubled mind... but I would still try.
How corrupted must you become to prefer death and division over symbiosis and cooperation? The former group is self-defeating. It leads only to extinction.
Please continue with your point if that was satisfactory enough.
- 7 months ago
-
s_peak
-
-
Mishima [removed]
-
s_peak:
"Well going into this situation I would already feel that logic would be lost on someone like that. I couldn't explain my point from a scientific or logical perspective"
Exactly. I concur.
"Something like that would be lost on him... So how do you relate to someone who's views on morality are clearly destructive?"
Virtually impossible, as you seem to also conclude.
"I would try, and probably fail... because someone with views that deeply disconnected would most likely come from a splintered and troubled mind"
I do not necessarily agree with that kind of "psychological" diagnosis. Often, those sorts of viewpoints and ideas can be from the culture, wanting to fit in (then it becomes part of the psyche), hearing this from people the person respects, and so on. But sometimes it is a result of emotional/personal problems, failures, etc.
"The former group is self-defeating. It leads only to extinction."
You and other rational people can see that, but that person probably cannot. But pointing it out to him, as you wrote, will probably not change anything, even if you use logic, appeals to history, and so on.
"Please continue with your point if that was satisfactory enough."
Yes, very satisfactory. Thanks for your candidness, thoughtfulness and completeness.
It is exactly what it is like dealing with today’s more strident LIBERALS.
- 7 months ago
-
Mishima [removed]
-
-
Varex_Sythe
-
Here's my score...
Scoring
You got 50 points.
See below for scores Charles Murray would expect you to get based on the following descriptions. Note that there are ranges of possible scores for categories and some overlap. In the graphic, your score is denoted by the horizontal black line, and typical scores for each range are marked with gray lines. The possible overlap is represented by the blue bars.
The higher your score, the thinner your bubble. The lower, the more insulated you might be from mainstream American culture.
48–99: A lifelong resident of a working-class neighborhood with average television and movie going habits. Typical: 77.
42–100: A first-generation middle-class person with working-class parents and average television and movie going habits. Typical: 66.
11–80: A first-generation upper-middle-class person with middle-class parents. Typical: 33.
0–43: A second-generation (or more) upper-middle-class person who has made a point of getting out a lot. Typical: 9.
0–20: A second-generation (or more) upper-middle-class person with the television and movie going habits of the upper middle class. Typical: 2.
What's yours?
- 7 months ago
-
Varex_Sythe
-
-
Varex_Sythe
-
Varex_Sythe:
Is it humorous or not that Mishie put up a quiz to determine how in touch people are with America, I scored what appears to be pretty decently despite having very different political opinions than our esteemed Mishie-poo, and for some reason I'm being voted down for posting my score...?
I myself think that it is humorous, in a kind of pathetic and sad way, but anyone else's opinion on this matter would be appreciated.
- 7 months ago
-
Varex_Sythe
-
-
HarukoHaruhara
-
Varex_Sythe:
I got a 65. Is that good?
- 7 months ago
-
HarukoHaruhara
-
-
Varex_Sythe
-
HarukoHaruhara:
I think the higher your score the thinner the "bubble" that isolates you from being in touch with America is.
- 7 months ago
-
Varex_Sythe
-
-
HarukoHaruhara
-
Varex_Sythe:
The big long list of restaurants? We don't even have any of those in my town.
- 7 months ago
-
HarukoHaruhara
-
-
cw9000
-
Varex_Sythe:
I got a 67, is that good?
- 7 months ago
-
cw9000
-
-
cpad
-
Varex_Sythe:
Oh, I got 150, which means I'm more in touch than the dumb fuck who put together the test.
- 7 months ago
-
cpad
-
-
Varex_Sythe
-
HarukoHaruhara:
About the restaurants, I agree. The chain restaurants that I sometimes go to aren't on the list. Screw Denny's, why isn't Sherri's on that list?
- 7 months ago
-
Varex_Sythe
-
-
Varex_Sythe
-
cw9000:
You're guess is as good as mine... I think that higher is better, at least that is what I get from reading the end summary after the quiz is done.
As the end summary says alongside the scores,
"The higher your score, the thinner your bubble. The lower, the more insulated you might be from mainstream American culture." - 7 months ago
-
Varex_Sythe
-
-
HarukoHaruhara
-
Varex_Sythe:
Oh, I take that back. There is a Denny's. Yeah, we're gonna drive all the way out to the freeway truck stop and eat at Denny's because it's just so scrumptious.
- 7 months ago
-
HarukoHaruhara
-
-
artemis6
-
HarukoHaruhara:
No Denny's here either ... Does the Starbucks in the grocery store count , i wonder ... One would think starbucks to be quite mainstream .
- 7 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
artemis6
-
Varex_Sythe:
yep , i go to the libary , and do not watch TV , i am real insulated .
- 7 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
artemis6
-
Varex_Sythe:
I wait to get my movies from the library ... , so i think this quiz may be a bit dated .... since i had seen a fair few .
- 7 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
artemis6
-
Varex_Sythe:
It is delightful ! I voted everyone up ( you too ) , because they had been voted down for reasons i do not agree with , nor could honestly justify .
- 7 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
wolfess
-
cpad:
Excellent score! Now I understand why you are such a joy to 'converse' with :-)!!!!!!!!!!!
My score was 68.
- 7 months ago
-
wolfess
-
-
wolfess
-
HarukoHaruhara:
Yeah, I went to a Denny's once .... says volumes, don't ya think :-)?????
- 7 months ago
-
wolfess
-
-
cpad
-
wolfess:
Why, thank you wolfess. That means a lot coming from you :)
- 7 months ago
-
cpad
