Berlusconi defends Mussolini, draws outrage from political left
source: http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/01/27/us-italy-berlusconi-mussolini-idUSBRE90Q0B620130127
-
-
- Gordon_Shumway
- added this
http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/01/27/us-italy-berlusconi-mussoli...
"(Reuters) - Former prime minister Silvio Berlusconi triggered outrage from Italy's political left on Sunday with comments defending fascist wartime leader Benito Mussolini at a ceremony commemorating victims of the Nazi Holocaust." ...Berlusconi Quote from the article:
## "Obviously the government of that time, out of fear that German power might lead to complete victory, preferred to ally itself with Hitler's Germany rather than opposing it," he said.
"As part of this alliance, there were impositions, including combating and exterminating Jews," he told reporters. "The racial laws were the worst fault of Mussolini as a leader, who in so many other ways did well," he said, referring to laws passed by Mussolini's fascist government in 1938. ##
Yes, in the considered opinion of a man who was recently Prime Minister (and still hopes to reprise that role) Mussolini had lots of mostly good ideas. And this great body of GOOD work should not be tarnished by a few missteps like going along with Hitler's idea of, "combating and EXTERMINATING the Jews". Besides, Hitler made him do it. (We do know in hindsight what a bully Hitler could be when he wasn't getting his way!)
The European Right seems to be having the same problem as the GOP is here. They spend so much time drinking their own Kool Aid / telling each other how right they are, and so little time debating their ideas out in the broader public arena, that they are increasingly prone to say what they really think in public without any idea of how crazy it's going to sound.
### HISTORICAL FOOTNOTE ###
There are a few small historical problems with Silvio's interpretation.
Italy signed its first treaty of alliance with Germany in 1937, the Anti-Comminturn Pact under which Germany - Italy - and Japan committed to jointly fighting Communism.
In 1937, Hitler was still widely seen more as Mussolini's protégé than the other way around. Hitler did indeed admire Mussolini; and el Duce's enormous ego, which seems to have been larger than even Hitler's own, certainly did not allow him to see the relationship otherwise.
Further, in 1937 Germany was still rearming from WWI and was widely seen to be the sure loser should a major European war erupt.
Italy upgraded its alliance with Germany and Japan to a full military alliance in 1938, nearly a year before England and France declared war on Germany under their treaty obligations to defend Poland.
At this time, Germany was still seen as the underdog in a war with Britain and France. Moreover, Italy, being divided from Germany by the Alps, never seriously feared a German assault had they stayed out of Germany's adventures.
In fact, el Duce was impressed with Hitler's expansionist territorial ambitions, and hoped to piggy back on any military success that Germany might have by realizing his own territorial ambitions, beginning in the Horn of Africa. He liked his odds of consolidating Italy's position in Ethiopia and adding some neighboring British territories while Germany, France, and Britain were busy contending with other. And whatever the result of the hostilities in the North of Europe, he doubted that the war weary winners would have the stomach to contest the "fait accompli" of any Italian conquests in Africa.
This turned out to be another one el Duce's "less than successful" projects, as the Italian military operations in Africa went badly awry.
One has to wonder, which of Mussolini's "good ideas" Italy might be able to build on, if they could just get over that whole Nazi Alliance thing? Judging people by the company they keep is so 20th Century ...
-
- groups:
- Community, News and Politics, Politics, World Politics
-
- tags:
- News, Politics, News and Politics, Italy, 3 more
-
-
BrushwithDeathToothpaste
-
I guess when he is not fucking underage prostitutes or ignoring the molestation of children by the Catholic church, he reminisces about fascism. Wouldn't surprise me if he gets elected again.
Someone once told me that Italy is the Mississippi of Europe.
- 4 months ago
-
BrushwithDeathToothpaste
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
BrushwithDeathToothpaste:
Well, Southern Italy maybe ...
- 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
Culdee
-
Just another dumb statement by an ignorant politician that didn't fully read his history books.
- 4 months ago
-
Culdee
-
-
sedwin [removed]
- This comment was removed by its owner.
-
sedwin [removed]
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
sedwin:
Berlusconi speaks fluent Italian ...
- 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
MAssappeal
-
Not only is Burlusconi a fascist chauvinist pig he really doesn't know his history. He was around doing his fascist racist classist thing before the nazi party.
- 4 months ago
-
MAssappeal
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
MAssappeal:
Quite true. As I note in my "Historical Footnotes" above, Hitler did see el Duce as something of a role model; and Mussolini saw himself as a mentor to Hitler.
It's hard to comprehend now; but Hitler was very much the junior partner in that relationship the first few years he was in power. Germany had been weakened by WWI and was just beginning to rearm; and Hitler was still consolidating his power at home, while el Duce was already an established figure on the world stage.
- 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
MAssappeal
-
Gordon_Shumway:
Right, that was a really interesting aspect of their relationship because of course the way hitler had to bail il duce out in africa and elsewhere you saw how the two diverged a bit later on, but Mussolini was really one of the progenitors of the idea of corporate fascism in the true sense before national socialism was really cemented as a concept.
- 4 months ago
-
MAssappeal
-
-
alexandrekBack
-
and remember, in Italy the left is so divided in so many party that they count for nothing... sadly
this is a call to get the extremist back in his party, don't think that was a lapsus or a mistake from him, that was a planned political call - 4 months ago
-
alexandrekBack
-
-
alexandrekBack
-
sad thing it's, like some Beck or Rush ignoble burp, that might help him, crisis always bring the worst in of the people!
- 4 months ago
-
alexandrekBack
-
-
ThirdSection
-
That had all the class and cunning of a disgruntled employee trying to creatively get himself fired.
- 4 months ago
-
ThirdSection
-
-
artemis6
-
Is he ... insane ?
- 4 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
artemis6:
No. Possibly drunk ...
- 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
artemis6
-
Gordon_Shumway:
Ah , not a drinker myself . I forget the possibility when consideration of self destructive actions ....
- 4 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
artemis6:
Spoken like someone who's never been to a Bunga Bunga Party ...
- 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
artemis6
-
Gordon_Shumway:
Enlighten me !
- 4 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
artemis6:
"I suggest you start drinking heavily." -Bluto
- 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
pumpdust49
-
he's a pig.
- 4 months ago
-
pumpdust49
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
pumpdust49:
Pigs are awesome and smart. Only humans can be this stupid and insane.
- 4 months ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
alexandrekBack
-
EdJoyProductions:
he's smart, he's an awful person, a political bully, a corrupt, deviant a most horrible power hungry man but do not underestimate is brain!
- 4 months ago
-
alexandrekBack
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
EdJoyProductions:
Thanks. True enough. I've already had to defend pigs against unjust comparisons to Berlusconi once in this thread!
- 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
Gordon_Shumway:
Why are the poor pigs getting so abused? :D
- 4 months ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
alexandrekBack:
He may be, but saying something like this in public displays a serious lack of judgement, especially when one is seeking to get back into politics.
- 4 months ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
alexandrekBack
-
EdJoyProductions:
it's calculated, he's trying to attract the extremists, he needs them, lots of them right now, crisis, he has no shame, proved it too many times
It's a global awful trend, look at the awful thing said during the presidential, some even started the idea after 70 you should let yourself die instead of plumbing the economy!
- 4 months ago
-
alexandrekBack
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
EdJoyProductions:
It's shameful, I agree!
- 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
alexandrekBack:
You have an uncomfortable point. I am hoping the extremists are a minority and his attempts to garner their support is unproductive.
- 4 months ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
alexandrekBack
-
EdJoyProductions:
you know that i do not approve people and ideas like Berlusconi, i am just maybe too cynic, but extremist call works better than their scandal
people get upset few days but below, in the dark corner, many will remember and think he has guts!
How many support a Beck or Rush, how many will revote for that asshole who said raped girl can't be pregnant to justify anti abortion!the world we are living today is uncomfortable, maybe i am ageing bitterly but i found that, like here in current, the arguments are getting worst and worst, more absurd, more biased, look, check the gun topics, not one gun post here without a link to hitler, when the references is totally biased, nut it works with the idiots, and we have many of them!
- 4 months ago
-
alexandrekBack
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
alexandrekBack:
I understand that what you are saying is sadly true. I try not to let it drive me crazy and just try to keep pushing reason and humanity into my own little sphere of influence. The only thing we can do is to point out the insanity and hope there are enough people who appreciate it and see through the sham that is politics.
I just like to think that people are starting to come around. I don't know if it is true but I hope it is. There is not a liberal or conservative answer. The answer really lies in trying to make the world a better place for everyone.
Blatantly insane statements and ideas need to be addressed. Inflammatory statements can not go unchallenged.
- 4 months ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
alexandrekBack
-
EdJoyProductions:
I am all in with you, that's the very reason i am back here, we have to do whatever it takes to stop the insanity spreading.
I am trying to get around my first reflexes, the usual the outraged answer (not always successful) to understand more their methods to fight them better!
Hope, we can
- 4 months ago
-
alexandrekBack
-
-
artemis6
-
alexandrekBack:
What an awful idea !
- 4 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
artemis6
-
EdJoyProductions:
(sigh) yes , "insanely stupid" , that , is not nearly so common in other species ... or at least nature weeds them out .... and some pigs are kinda cute .
- 4 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
alexandrekBack:
That reflex reaction is hard to squelch sometimes, but sacrifices must be made for the good fight. :)
- 4 months ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
artemis6:
http://www.tvacres.com/images/pig_arnold3.jpg
Pigs are great animals.
- 4 months ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
Vic_Romano
-
Bunga Bunga with Il Duce, baby!
- 4 months ago
-
Vic_Romano
-
-
kennymotown
-
He does act like a dictator!
- 4 months ago
-
kennymotown
-
-
JanforGore
-
And he's a pig.
- 4 months ago
-
JanforGore
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
JanforGore:
Why do you disparage pigs in that way? What have pigs ever done to you?
- 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
JanforGore
-
Gordon_Shumway:
My humble apology to all pigs.
- 4 months ago
-
JanforGore
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
JanforGore:
Apology accepted! It's good to see that you are someone who can be big about it. Having seen other posts from you, I was confident that you were such a person.
- 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
JanforGore:
Yes, I have to agree with Gordon. Pigs are awesome and are smarter than Berlusconi.
- 4 months ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
unimatrix0
-
Even if he believed such a thing, why would he say it out loud? What possible benefit could come to him by admitting admiration for such a monster?
- 4 months ago
-
unimatrix0
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
unimatrix0:
It really is one of those imponderables. Like why does any Republican Senate candidate comment on abortion? Or why does Donald Trump go around with his hair looking like that?
I have only the explanation I posited in my original post. From above:
"The European Right seems to be having the same problem as the GOP is here. They spend so much time drinking their own Kool Aid / telling each other how right they are, and so little time debating their ideas out in the broader public arena, that they are increasingly prone to say what they really think in public without any idea of how crazy it's going to sound."
Plus, in Berlusconi's case, there may be an issue with poor impulse control. Maybe ...
That's my theory and I'm stickin' to it. At least until I think of a better one.
- 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
LivingPong
-
Shooting himself with his revolver perhaps?
- 4 months ago
-
LivingPong
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
They need to go back to electing porn stars in Italy. Cicciolina would have made a rocking PM.
She is famed for being the first woman to uncover her breasts live on Italian television, for recording a song entirely about the male organ, and for offering sex to Osama bin Laden (in return, she said, for giving up terrorism).
http://danieljmitchell.wordpress.com/2011/09/20/how-elected-officials-screw-taxp...
- 4 months ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
MSII
-
EdJoyProductions:
she couldn't be worse then a lot of them, which in and of itself says a lot...
- 4 months ago
-
MSII
-
-
bailey78
-
EdJoyProductions:
boobies
- 4 months ago
-
bailey78
-
-
artemis6
-
EdJoyProductions:
That was very cool .
- 4 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
HarukoHaruhara
-
Sigh .. anti-Semitism remains alive and well...
http://ponyhq.files.wordpress.com/2011/07/pinkie-pie-disgusted.jpg
- 4 months ago
-
HarukoHaruhara
-
-
Leen61
-
This idiot is so clueless about political interpretation it's amazing that he was able to be elected PM in the first place.
- 4 months ago
-
Leen61
-
-
maasanova
-
There seems to more about Hitler and the Nazis here then Mussolni and his political and economic ideas about fascism.
Oh well guess it goes with the territory. Either way, Berlusconi for all his faults has got it about right; Mussolini probably wasn't all that bad considering he had many American admirers and that the Holocaust is getting a bit boring and long in the tooth.
- 4 months ago
-
maasanova
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-

-
maasanova:
"Mussolini probably wasn't all that bad" - Really?
When your time as head of state ends with you and your mistress being dragged into the street, shot, and hung upside down from the front of an Esso gas station, maybe you really were "that bad".
- 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
Gordon_Shumway:
Hung upside down ...
- 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
maasanova
-
Gordon_Shumway:
Uhh...yeah they were killed by their political enemies, a bunch of vicious Communist thugs. You'd expect nothing less from these these people.
- 4 months ago
-
maasanova
-
-
BrushwithDeathToothpaste
-
maasanova:
The Holocaust is getting a bit boring? I'm not even sure how to respond to that.
- 4 months ago
-
BrushwithDeathToothpaste
-
-
MSII
-
Gordon_Shumway:
right-wingers do luv them the right-wing-corporate-FASCISTS, so no surprises.
- 4 months ago
-
MSII
-
-
maasanova
-
MSII:
I don't "love" political or economic fascism, but who was Britain, France, and America to tell Italy and Germany how to govern their nations?
- 4 months ago
-
maasanova
-
-
maasanova
-
BrushwithDeathToothpaste:
Think about it. You're a smart guy I'm pretty sure you'll come up with something.
- 4 months ago
-
maasanova
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
maasanova:
I normally don't like the U.S. involving itself in telling other nations what to do regarding their own affairs. However, on 11th December 1941 both Germany and Italy made unprovoked declarations of war on the United States and immediately began hostilities. Their declarations of war were made in support of their ally, Japan, which had not shown the decency to declare war in advance of its own initiation of hostilities on 7th December 1941.
So to answer your question as regards America, we were the country that Germany and Italy went to war against. And that gave us every right to tell them how to run their countries if we could. It turned out that we could; and we did. No apologies for that ...
- 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
maasanova
-
Gordon_Shumway:
No, it did not give America the right. This is precisely what is still wrong with America, and American thinking today.
- 4 months ago
-
maasanova
-
-
MSII
-
BrushwithDeathToothpaste:
...the right-wingers were always "bored" with it. As long as it didn't effect the w.a.s.p's and the monied-class, well...
- 4 months ago
-
MSII
-
-
maasanova
-
Gordon_Shumway:
Wherever Communism is established, murder, rape, starvation and general exploitation of the people generally follows. Perhaps fascism wasn't the best solution for everyone, but it definitely was the solution to Communism at the time.
- 4 months ago
-
maasanova
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
maasanova:
DID !!! :-)
- 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
maasanova:
Good heavens! That's appalling! I had no idea. Really ...
Do I understand then, that there were no such issues with the fascists? I mean, if the fascists were also prone to murders, rapes, exploitation, and say mass genocide on top of those, that might negate the rationale for supporting them as the lesser of two evils?
I'm just asking ...
- 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
ThirdSection
-
Gordon_Shumway:
I might add, that with the Marshall Plan being extended to Italy and Germany, we were most generous victors at that!
- 4 months ago
-
ThirdSection
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
ThirdSection:
The Marshall Plan was a wise and effective decision ..
- 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
-
Mark701
-
maasanova:
Two wrongs don't make a right.
Hitlers Fascism and Stalin's Communism both resulted in millions dead. They were both extreme and both deadly. Fascism wasn't a "solution" to communism so much as a reaction to it. Communism was supposed to take power from the elite and hand it back to the people. It didn't work out that way. Hitlers Fascism handed power to corporations and dictatorial powers to the state at the cost of individual freedoms. Both systems sucked.
- 4 months ago
-
Mark701
-
-
ThirdSection
-
maasanova:
If by "vicious communist thugs," you mean "the entire population of Milan," then yes.
- 4 months ago
-
ThirdSection
-
-
artemis6
-
Mark701:
Thank you for that straight forward explanation . I wish everyone understood it .
- 4 months ago
-
artemis6
-
-
Gordon_Shumway
-
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/world/2013/01/27/berlusconi-defends-mussolini...
EVERYBODY LOVES A WINNER !!!
USA Today:
"Former Italian Premier Berlusconi defends Mussolini's choice to ally himself with Hitler and his antisemitic views during World War II. He believed Mussolini wanted to align with the winning side." - 4 months ago
-
Gordon_Shumway
