'For Neda,' A Film, Tells the Story of This Young Symbol of Iran's Post-Election Protests - Nedā Āġā Soltān
source: http://www.cnn.com/2010/WORLD/meast/06/12/iran.neda.film/index.html?hpt=C1
-
-
- EthicalVegan
- added this
By Mitra Mobasherat, CNN
June 12, 2010 7:08 p.m. EDT
(CNN) -- Music posters still hang on the walls; stuffed animals decorate a twin bed in the corner of the room. Clothes lie neatly folded in the closet.
Neda Agha-Soltan's bedroom in Iran remains practically untouched since the day she died.
A little more than a week away from the one-year anniversary of her death on June 20, 2009, Neda's family refuses to forget their daughter's spirit.
Journalist Saeed Kamali Dehghan traveled to Tehran to interview Neda's relatives in their home for a new documentary on her life and her tragic death.
HBO's new documentary, "For Neda," tells the personal story of the woman who unwittingly became the symbol of the post-election reform movement in Iran when her death was captured on a cell phone video and shown around the world.
"She is any girl, anywhere, but this just wasn't anywhere," the film's producer and director, Antony Thomas, told CNN. "I wanted to show the people who demonstrated, whatever happened, that their courage has not been forgotten."
Not able to find a professional camera crew that would accept the assignment, Kamali Dehghan, a print journalist who had never handled a movie camera before, took a two-day crash course and smuggled a camera into the country.
Video: 'For Neda' blocked in Iran
"I was ready to be arrested in Tehran at any moment. When I rang the bell to their home, I thought an officer could arrest me at anytime," he told CNN.
Explored through the life of Neda, the film examines the repression and inequality that women in Iran have struggled with since the arrival of the Islamic regime.
"She was a hero, but she was not superhuman; she was a hero like millions of other girls in Iran," Kamali Dehghan said.
Speaking out for the first time since Neda's death, her father, Ali Agha-Soltan, describes his youngest daughter as a woman with "no fear in her body."
Her brother, Mohammed, is still mourning the loss of his best friend. He has not cut his hair or shaved since she died. Neda's picture adorns the front of his mobile phone.
Neda's mother's, Hajar Rostami, describes her daughter as a rebellious girl who never outgrew her independent streak. She argued with her schoolteachers about having to wear the mandatory head covering, or hijab, in class.
Growing up in Tehran, Neda enjoyed the latest Western fashions, singing and dancing, all forbidden to women in public.
"She had this freedom to be herself in that family. They have respect for women's rights, so Neda could be herself in that family. She didn't have to play a role; she didn't have to pretend," Kamali Dehghan said.
The HBO film will debut in the U.S. at 9 p.m. ET Monday, but the network allowed Voice of America's Persian service to broadcast it in Farsi into Iran last week through its satellite TV channel and its website.
Voice of America said attempts to show the film were interrupted by Iranian authorities jamming the satellite signal.
Voice of America viewers also complained of electrical outages during the time slot.
On Friday, the Islamic republic aired its own investigative documentary into the death of Neda titled "Intersection."
In the film, the government points the finger at the People's Mujahedeen Organization of Iran for Neda's death. The PMOI is a Marxist group advocating the regime's overthrow that the government often has blamed for post-election violence.
Prepared for a censorship attempt, HBO and Thomas decided to post the full documentary on YouTube and worked with tech specialists to convert the 70-minute film into a small enough file to play on Iranian mobiles via a Bluetooth connection.
Thomas and Kamali Dehghan said they've received thousands of e-mails from inside Iran since the HBO film has been seen around the world. But the most important approval, Thomas said, was from Neda's family, who still lives in Iran.
"We can't leave Iran; she is still here," Neda's mother told Kamali Dehghan. "She is there, still in that room, still in that house."
-
- groups:
- Community, News and Politics, Politics, Culture, 18 more
-
- tags:
- Iran, Journalism, Tehran, Marxism, 16 more
-
-
freecrack
-
its almost a year since this happened. i shutter to think what iran will look like on the anniversary of her death.
- 1 year ago
-
freecrack
-
-
versasrev
-
Awesome!
- 1 year ago
-
versasrev
-
-
musiker91
-
I guess this just goes to show you that the news, no matter where it comes from, will always be slanted. I never really understood what actually happened because there were so many different sides of the story. They always do say that history was written by the winners. News isn't any different
- 1 year ago
-
musiker91
-
-
Nectarine
-
musiker91:
Musiker91 I couldn't agree more. The other day I saw a diverse photo, and the author showed how by only showing bits of the photo, the media could portray virtually any message simply by omitting the rest of the scene. I wish more journalists would take a factual and unbiased approach when they cover a story.
- 1 year ago
-
Nectarine
-
-
freecrack
-
musiker91:
well iran changed the official story about seven times, from shes alive in greece, to her friends killed her, to the cia did it.
- 1 year ago
-
freecrack
-
-
nursediesel
-
Keep her memory alive!
- 1 year ago
-
nursediesel
-
-
acontradiction [removed]
- This comment was removed as a violation of community guidelines.
-
acontradiction [removed]
-
-
tommic
-
acontradiction:
what liberals support Iran? Are you NUTS? You must be getting your info from sarah palin
- 1 year ago
-
tommic
-
-
Andrew_Douglas
-
acontradiction:
Would you do every intelligent person on Earth a favor and shut the fuck up?
- 1 year ago
-
Andrew_Douglas
-
-
freecrack
-
tommic:
shes right and wrong all at the same time.
of course all liberals are against all that iran is, and if presented with the full story of everything would clearly see iran, and all its endevours as malevolent.
but at the same time liberal media (as all political driven media) spins information to serve its own purpose wich is to demonize israel (as they have the perogative to do) wich ommits that israel is fighting iran in a proxy war through hamas, and hezbollah.
so while liberals dont like iran, they support those who are against israel, and unknowingly are supporting the very government they dont like, as iran is the only government needling israel.not egypt,jordan,saudi arabia,iraq, or any other muslum nation.by dissasociating hamas from hezbollah from iran it is sold as three seperate things, while all being iran.ever notice its only iran who has a palastinian holiday reminding its people why to hate israel.no other arab nation does this.iran is the actual opposition to israel, the palastinians are are the pawns.
- 1 year ago
-
freecrack
-
-
Einsam_Data_Old [removed]
- This comment was removed as a violation of community guidelines.
-
Einsam_Data_Old [removed]
-
-
freecrack
-
Einsam_Data_Old:
actually this proves my statement that you neednt mention her out of context cuz clearly as this story shows, and the responses and views show, your fear was unwarrented.she will never be forgotten wether you bring it up or not.
if you posted a memorium to her as a story and it got no views or responses that would prove your position that neda's sacrifice is in danger of being forgotten.
- 1 year ago
-
freecrack
-
-
crystalman
-
http://www.debbieschlussel.com/23164/saying-no-to-hbo-e-mail-exchange-of-the-day...
From: Katlynn Brunkhorst
Date: Thu, Jun 10, 2010 at 2:15 PM
Subject: RE: For Neda Premieres in HBO’s Documentary Films Summer Series
To: writedebbie@gmail.comHello Debbie,
This is Kate on behalf of HBO. I wanted to let you know about For Neda, an important and critical piece premiering this coming Monday, June 14th at 9 PM ET that is not to be missed. You can view the trailer in the link below:
http://www.hbo.com/#/documentaries/for-neda/video/for-neda.html
For Neda chronicles the life and death of Neda Agha Soltan during protests which followed the June 20th, 2009 protests of the presidential elections in Iran. Within minutes, Neda became a symbol of up-rise and hope for the Iranian people when the footage of her death quickly spread among social media lines. Soon, the world turned its eyes to the protest due to the testament and symbolic death of this heroic woman.
The film explores the Iranian struggle through interviews of those closest to Neda and the tragic incidents surrounding her death. It reveals the impact of an interconnected media world which includes the homespun authorities that brought her story to light. For Neda premieres as the third in the HBO Documentary Films Summer Series. A new documentary airs weekly on Monday nights through August 9th.
I encourage you to share news of the premiere with your readers. If you have any questions feel free to ask.
Best,
Kate–
Kate Brunkhorst
Attention for HBO***
My response:
From: Debbie Schlussel writedebbie@gmail.com
Date: Thu, Jun 10, 2010 at 2:44 PM
Subject: Re: For Neda Premieres in HBO’s Documentary Films Summer Series
To: Katlynn BrunkhorstKate:
While I am interested in reviewing and promoting other HBO specials and movies (I’ve contacted the network, without success, asking for a screener of “John Adams,” way back when, for instance), I am not interested in this movie. I’ve gotten many anti-Semitic and anti-Israel messages from Iranian “democracy” protesters just like Neda, who are supporters of Hezbollah and hate Jews and Israel. I’m sure she felt just like them, embraced the same intolerance, and I don’t mourn her one bit. Moussavi, the candidate Neda and her ilk supported, was the architect and founder of Hezbollah, the terrorist group that murdered hundreds of Americans and Jews. The people who protested in the streets of Tehran were every bit as radical and extremist as the ones in office in Iran.Although you say this is a “critical” program, your promotional e-mail below makes clear that there is no such criticism or critical look at who the Iranian “democracy” protesters really were . . . as in, not much different from HAMAS “democracy” proponents. Contrary to your assertion, in truth Neda is a symbol for nothing more than one rival Islamic mob of hatred that is out of power versus another rival Islamic mob of hatred that is in power. Same difference. Whether or not she left Islam and wore a cross is a distinction without a difference, as the people and candidate with whom she associated are vicious anti-Semites and Israel-haters, most of whom embrace Islam and whose chosen candidate, Moussavi, was picked by the Ayatollahs who run Iran to be on the ballot in the first place. This is a total waste of film on HBO’s part.
When it comes to the Mid-East, HBO–the network which hired you to do PR–seems to have quite a bit of difficulty with the truth and giving it to its viewers. For example, HBO’s “Death in Gaza,” was a one-sided anti-Israel diatribe, er . . . “documentary.” And even liberal Washington Post critic Tom Shales took offense that HBO’s “documentary” on Helen Thomas, “Thank You, Mr. President,” skipped any mention of her hatred of Israel and the Jewish people and her open praise for Islamic terrorist groups, including Hezbollah, the same one that your newest heroine Neda’s fellow “democracy” protesters support.
I hope you will keep me in mind for other HBO programming (not just this one on Iran), but on this one, I’ll happily pass. Sorry, but HBO is propagating BS with this “documentary,” which appears to “document” only a fantasist mainstream media narrative. The real truth about the Iranian “democracy” protesters is not your portrayal of Neda, but, rather, their vicious anti-Semitic hate displayed in e-mails, tweets, and FaceBook posts and comments since last week, when Israel defended itself against a HAMAS terrorist flotilla. I don’t need an HBO documentary to whitewash the truth.
DS - 1 year ago
-
crystalman
-
-
versasrev
-
crystalman:
You know there is a reality at work here. First, yes a strong percentage of people in Iran and other Islamic countries are antisemitic. Second a good percent of Israelis are anti-Islamic. Third; A blatant support one way or another from independent sources, in this case Americans, only really shows their own biased against one or the other.
Yes some liberal groups are trying to skew peoples interpretations of some Islamic nations, and yes some conservative groups have been skewing interpretations of Israel for decades; however that doesn't mean I have to choose some imaginary line in the sand. Neither of these groups of people is on anyone else's side but their own.
All that being said you have clearly shown your hand in revealing an anti-Islamic/pro Israel stance, by the comments and stories you have consistently posted, voted, or replied too. Out of 5 pages of your replies about two have been on any other subject.
So seriously, what the hell is the deal? Does nothing else in the world hold any significance to you, with exception maybe for Denis hopper.
I only say this, as your interests and replies seem to show a racist agenda.
- 1 year ago
-
versasrev
-
-
freecrack
-
crystalman:
you know you are shooting yourself in the foot.if the iranian youth overthrow the present regime, internet access will be uncensored, and all that jew bashing stuff will come with a counter balance thus negating antisemetism proliferating.it may take a few generations, but thats the genesis.support freedom where ever it exists.
- 1 year ago
-
freecrack
-
-
EthicalVegan
-
-
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/jun/11/neda-agha-soltan-iran-killing
Neda Agha-Soltan: 'She is dead but regime is still afraid of her'
Heartbreak continues for family of slain woman who became symbol of Iran protests when her death was caught on video
Every Thursday just after midday Hajar Rostami leaves her small flat in the east of Tehran and makes the 12-mile journey to Behesht-e-Zahra cemetery on the outskirts of the Iranian capital.
When she arrives the 48-year-old picks her way through the sea of tombs and headstones until she reaches the grave of her middle daughter, Neda Agha-Soltan.
There are normally people gathering around the simple monument and Rostami passes round a notebook so that they can write down their memories of her daughter, before laying fresh flowers and tending the grave.
But even here the mourners are not left in peace. At a discreet distance, two officials from the Iranian secret police watch as the scene unfolds.
It is almost a year since Rostami's daughter was killed during an anti-government protest in her home city of Tehran. Her death has transformed the lives of the family she left behind.
Neda's final moments were captured on jerky mobile phone footage and within hours the grisly images became the defining moment of the thwarted uprising against the Iranian regime – and a rallying point for a movement in need of a hero. Since then Neda – and her very public death – have become an internet phenomenon and her image has been printed on placards and brandished at demonstrations around the world.
But back at the small first-floor flat that she shared with her mother, father and brother it is clear that Neda's posthumous fame has not eased the family's pain. "We were not mother and daughter," says Rostami as she busies herself in the kitchen. "We were two friends. Anything that happened, she used to come to me."
She pauses before adding: "I used to tell her that if I'm ever ill, bring me to Shariati hospital. I never believed that we would be bring her to Shariati hospital to die. I used to tell her to bring tuberose flowers to my grave. I never believed that I would be bringing tuberose flowers to her grave."
During the month that Guardian journalist Saeed Kamali Dehghan spent with Neda's family to film the documentary For Neda, a picture emerged of a typical young Iranian woman. Neda enjoyed new fashions and make-up, she went to the gym and loved dancing. She was fiercely independent and a voracious reader whose favourite novel was Emily Brontë's Wuthering Heights.
Sitting around the kitchen table, this is the way her family remember her – not as a symbol of the resistance but as a dynamic and determined woman, quick to laugh and quick to stand up for what she believed in.
"She was always very brave and defended herself," says Rostami. "She was given the nickname Tayeb [after a 1970s South Tehran street tough]. All the children in the streets were afraid of Neda, because she was so strong. Even her older sister, Hoda, deferred to her."
Neda married her first love, Amir, in her early 20s but his family's social conservatism grated against Neda's more liberal background, and the couple drifted apart.
They remained on good terms, but eventually divorced, and Neda returned to the family home, where she grew close to her 23-year-old brother, Mohammed. They shared a passion for music – he used to play the guitar and she used to sing. A few weeks before she died they went shopping for a piano that he now plays twice a day "to remember her" – once in the morning before leaving for work and once at night.
"I can't still believe that she's gone – when I play the piano I feel she's here in this room," says Mohammed. "First we were brothers and sisters but in recent years we were like two friends, we had the same group of friends, we used to go to same parties."
Until last year's disputed elections Neda had never shown any interest in politics and she and Mohammed used to spend time dancing and going to underground parties. Since his sister's death Mohammed has vowed not to cut his hair or beard.
"On the last day of her life, in the morning, we met each other and I had no time to shave and at that time my hair was longer than usual. She said that she liked me this way, with a beard and long hair. Since her death, I couldn't shave neither my hair nor my beard."
Neda's death has also left a hole in her mother's life. Unusually in Iranian culture she has decided to keep her daughter's bedroom exactly as Neda had left it: Neda's favourite teddy bears are scattered on the bed, a poster of Dire Straights guitarist Mark Knopfler hangs on the wall, her make-up bag is open on the dresser.
But the political circumstances surrounding her daughter's death have also had an impact on Rostami. As an Iranian housewife concerned predominantly with her children and their wellbeing she had never shown much interest in politics. Over the last 12 months she has been thrust into the maelstrom of opposition politics in Iran.
"I'm not a politician, I'm a very ordinary Iranian mother, but since Neda's death I had to keep myself updated by the political news, I can't remain indifferent to what's happening in my country."
Rostami now speaks to other mothers who have lost children at the hands of the authorities, attends women's rights meetings and gives online interviews.
"Because of the world attention to Neda's death, her story is spread around the world," she says. "But what about the story of those others who were killed, raped and tortured after the election and nobody knows about?"
The authorities take a dim view of her new life and Rostami suspects her home is watched and that the regime monitors her phone calls and keeps tabs on who she meets. But the family believes the prominence of the case means the government has no choice but to keep its distance.
"The more the government tries to stop people from remembering Neda, the more her story spreads among people," says Rostami.
Neda lies buried at Behesht-e-Zahra, Iran's largest cemetery, and a place synonymous with the country's "martyrs" – the hundreds of thousands of young men killed in the Iran-Iraq war.
Her grave has been desecrated several times. But Rostami remains defiant. She says she will not be intimidated and claims the regime is scared her daughter is becoming a martyr for a new generation. "Although Neda has been murdered and is dead, they are still afraid of her, they come to the graveyard and want to kill her again. She's dead but her memory is getting brighter and brighter every day."
- 1 year ago
-
EthicalVegan
-
-
Incredulous
-
EthicalVegan:
she was so beautiful
- 1 year ago
-
Incredulous
