Image
atomiclegion
Can you imagine an America without a strong middle class? If you can, would it still be America as we know it?

Today, one in five Americans is unemployed, underemployed or just plain out of work. One in nine families can't make the minimum payment on their credit cards. One in eight mortgages is in default or foreclosure. One in eight Americans is on food stamps. More than 120,000 families are filing for bankruptcy every month. The economic crisis has wiped more than $5 trillion from pensions and savings, has left family balance sheets upside down, and threatens to put ten million homeowners out on the street.

Families have survived the ups and downs of economic booms and busts for a long time, but the fall-behind during the busts has gotten worse while the surge-ahead during the booms has stalled out. In the boom of the 1960s, for example, median family income jumped by 33% (adjusted for inflation). But the boom of the 2000s resulted in an almost-imperceptible 1.6% increase for the typical family. While Wall Street executives and others who owned lots of stock celebrated how good the recovery was for them, middle class families were left empty-handed.

The crisis facing the middle class started more than a generation ago. Even as productivity rose, the wages of the average fully-employed male have been flat since the 1970s.


http://www.huffingtonpost.com/elizabeth-warren/america-without-a-middle_b_377829...
  1. groups:
    Community,   Politics,   Current Tonight,   US Politics,   9 more
  2. tags:
    Culture Economy Economics U.S. News 13 more
  3.     
    |

51 comments // America without a middle class

  • FightOn
    • 0
      FightOn  
    • Incomes may have stagnated, but Americans still enjoy one of the highest living standards in the world, and have the richest middle class. Kings never had what a typical American teenager has these days -- iPhone, Car, laptops, etc.

    • 2 years ago
  • QuestionGeek
    • 0
      QuestionGeek  
    • Would it be better if someone with money were to leave the USA so they could keep it? Cause the way things are going, we'll end up like another Mexico

    • 2 years ago
  • freal
    • 0
      freal  
    • There's a new company that has taken the last two years to come up with a way to provide sensibly priced homes with very low utilities, low insurance, low food, furnishings, clothing, etc. and high savings & investment opportunities targeting the middle class. Don't know their background but they claim to have come up with a way to jumpstart housing & get people back to work and they launch in January. Sounds like they might do what the government can't do. Name is Amerisus which stands for something. Guy that runs it seems to be doing everyhing right by pulling in some 50 corporations to make it all happen. Would I like to buy some of their stock.

    • 2 years ago
  • Gravity_Man
    • 0
      Gravity_Man  
    • Image
    • freal:

      Great find. From http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/whirlpoolr-appliances-to-be-featured-in-... =>

      "AmeriSus has expanded on the "kit home" concept, popularized by Sears, Roebuck and Co. in the first half of the 20th Century, allowing such pre-construction activities as design, engineering, procurement and logistics to be optimized for builders. Everything from nuts and bolts to appliances and finishes are included as part of one complete building package available through AmeriSus' proprietary Ready Build System(TM). An ever-growing line of architectural layouts is available to builders and homebuyers via the AmeriSus Web site, where selections and upgrades in such areas as appliances, flooring, fixtures and energy systems can be made. AmeriSus selected products, materials and services from more than 30 "Best-In-Class" companies across the globe, such as Whirlpool Corporation, IKEA, and FedEx, which epitomize sustainability in their products and daily operations."

    • 2 years ago
  • Gravity_Man
    • 0
      Gravity_Man  
    • America is the New Australia? Health care an everyday Luxury? Where?!

      The Middle Class isn't disappearing, not exactly. It's following the outsourced jobs so they're overseas. Retired people who had a decent portfolio also, they went to other places. America got more immigrants and Muslims. It's a lot like a game of Chess.

      And when Americans get overseas and come to find out the American military umbrella is keeping their taxes low and health care a walk-in luxury any day they want it, there isn't much reason for them to return home they have a new home now.

      America is the New Australia => melting smut Incorporated. With no offense intended toward today's Australians, just using it as a reference.

    • 2 years ago
  • Gravity_Man
    • 0
      Gravity_Man  
    • Gravity_Man:

      This realization clarifies to me what the Master Plan is => to democratize the world by forcing the best Americans to flee America and take our beliefs into other countries. This works in tandem with putting American soldiers everywhere.

      Uh-huh, got'cha now baby. The name of the game is infiltrate and penetrate.
      Uh-huh, got'cha now baby. The name of the game is infiltrate and penetrate.
      Uh-huh, got'cha now baby. The name of the game is infiltrate and penetrate.

      I figured I would get the Big Picture sooner or later.
      The game is world conquest via citizen dispersion.

    • 2 years ago
  • Gravity_Man
  • Gravity_Man
    • 0
      Gravity_Man  
    • "Religion" used to be considered a major enemy amongst some on Current but actually it seems it is being replaced by a widespread and catching belief in Destiny, pre-destination that says nothing that happens to us in this life matters. It must be part of some all-inclusive master scheme of things that needs to happen... for each of us to reach the next stage of existence.

      This new belief threatens to make everyone docile & accepting of anything & everything that happens to us "in this life". To me this is little more than an expansion of Dialectics (NOT Dianetics). Dialectics is like religion without God, except this latest movement of the masses seems to be reaching for the highest level of dialectics where we are all a part of one single God. We are God, they say, and it has the potential of wrapping atheists together with evolutionists and spiritualists and everybody else wavering or weak in their faith.

      We may as well all sit down on a lily pad and wait for the great Cosmic Will to do what it intends to do anyway.

    • 2 years ago
  • Krisard
    • 0
      Krisard  
    • "In the boom of the 1960s, for example, median family income jumped by 33% (adjusted for inflation). But the boom of the 2000s resulted in an almost-imperceptible 1.6% increase for the typical family."

      You can't call an increase in income a bad thing.

      "By the early 2000s, families were spending twice as much (adjusted for inflation) on mortgages than they did a generation ago -- for a house that was, on average, only ten percent bigger and 25 years older. They also had to pay twice as much to hang on to their health insurance."

      No one was forced to buy a house they couldn't afford. The 2x increase in insurance costs is ridiculous though.

    • 2 years ago
  • WhiteNoise
  • WhiteNoise
  • kennymotown
  • Daisy909
  • Gravity_Man
    • 0
      Gravity_Man  
    • There is a very bright side. If the overages paid to the middle class are taken and distributed evenly into & across the people below them, then all those people are raised up to a much improved Standard of Living. That would mean the total elimination of any lower classes in America... because he is transferring 35% over to the other column and helping 60%.

      That's a Net Gain in anybody's ledger.

      Instead of a family having two chickens and two cars, everybody has either two chickens and eggs or two cars. There will be no survivors. Plus health care for everyone, which will help prevent diseases from reaching the middle class I mean elite class. So you see, Obama and his money czar are correct to be doing what they're doing.

      Sure, all former socialist countries have had a few problems but not a US Socialist State. We can forge a New Nation, indivisible, where all men and women have every necessity of Life & Health. Just you wait til he gets his hands wrapped around Energy. Obama possesses the paradise formula. Quit fighting the change get with the advanced programme people.

    • 2 years ago
  • extracrazykiwi2008
  • WhiteNoise
    • 0
      WhiteNoise  
    • Image
    • THIRD WORLD AMERICA !
      http://current.com/items/89833556_third-world-america.htm

      “These past years were more than just the most shameful, corrupt and incompetent period in the history of the American legislative branch. These were the years when the U.S. parliament became a historical punch line, a political obscenity on par with the court of Nero or Caligula -- a stable of thieves and perverts who committed crimes rolling out of bed in the morning and did their very best to turn the mighty American empire into a debt-laden, despotic backwater, a Burkina Faso with cable.” - MATT TAIBBI

    • 2 years ago
  • GeorgeCarlin77
    • 0
      GeorgeCarlin77  
    • Because money is necessary, to go anywhere in politics, in large amounts (you must be loaded!!!!) the middle and lower class are not represented well, and thus the rich minority can keep themselves rich! We need to correct this party system bullshit......and don't even get me started on the damn Electoral College system.......

    • 2 years ago
  • kingkongAOE3
    • 0
      kingkongAOE3  
    • there is all ready a dieing middle its mostly just supper rich and really poor in the united states ill take a long ass time before we have a middle class again instead of upper middle class and lower middle class

    • 2 years ago
  • Cynic2
  • JonRaymond
  • Gravity_Man
    • 0
      Gravity_Man  
    • America is the greatest nation on Earth. Average income is truck driver wages. After deregulation of the trucking industry in 1970 or so I had this really dang good idea I would go to truck driving school and make some big money. I finally managed to scrape the money together with Mom working, the wife working 2 jobs and me working nights, and somehow we did it with just one car driving all over Richmond Virginia.

      Out of school I didn't get hired right away, but all of a sudden an opening came up at E. R. Carpenter Co. at 2400 Jefferson Davis Highway and I was In Like Flint. Big Money come on down! They hired me to drive 2nd seat to complete my training. I was paid 2nd seat pay below 4 cents per mile.

      hahahahahahahaha I never made it to "Middle Class" because of deregulation. What is happening to all you guys happened to me in 1975. I guarantee you swabs you ain't gonna like it. When your kid wants a toy the answer is no. And no vacation. I didn't make enough money for one so we never had one.

      You DEFINITELY are not going to like living my life.

    • 2 years ago
  • Gravity_Man
    • 0
      Gravity_Man  
    • Gravity_Man:

      Oh, I forgot to add this gem. The reason the job at Carpenter suddenly came open I found out later was that a driver got fired for mentioning he'd like to have union representation for decent livable wages...... All this stuff that is catching up with Middle America is a pill I already lived starting in 1970.

      It's like a slow-moving tsunami and now it's YOUR turn at the grain stile beside Samson with chains around your ankles, but, you're so used to calling this Freedom you won't do nuthin. Just hmm, show em your dissatisfaction by buying lots of Christmas junk. Yeah, that'll teach em how mad you are.

      Buy your kids plenty of electronics that their screens waste their retinas out over time and the plastic in their sweaty hands is poring a steady drip drip drip of BPA coursing through the little tike's bloodstream.

    • 2 years ago
  • ChristopherX
  • CarolineS
    • 0
      CarolineS  
    • Thank you for these facts and figures, it really hits home when you see things like "One in eight Americans is on food stamps"
      This is simply stuff you never see in the news, and is extremely frightening, I'd love to know what the figures are for Britain! but i guess we are all just on the dole!
      So soon we will be split into two groups, those struggling to eat each day, and Billionnaires!
      Well I for one can't wait to see the revolution when it comes!

    • 2 years ago
  • ahappymintleaf
    • 0
      ahappymintleaf  
    • The measure of unemployment is a sham and a joke. Unemployment, underemployment and discouraged workers should all be summed up to show the real suffering of the country. Just because the failures of the nation are swept under the rug in statistical splitting of hairs doesn't mean it's working. Good article.

    • 2 years ago
  • shanklinmike
  • Found_Avenue
    • 0
      Found_Avenue  
    • http://current.com/items/89801783_why-i-left-nyc.htm
      Well, NYC is already well on it's way to existing without a middle class. To live "within your means" in manhattan, and by "live" I mean to have YOUR name on a mortgage OR a lease in this popular little borough, you must be either rich or poor. Middle class families cannot get into the projects because they earn too much, but cannot afford to spend $3000/month to rent a tiny two bedroom apartment.

      If you took all the student subletters and hipster transients out of Manhattan and focus on those how have considered it their "home" throughout their lifetime, you'd be left with a bunch of poverty-level families, starving artists, and rich people.

      It doesn't paint a pretty picture... as the Bowery Bums watch billion dollar hotels go up where their homeless shelters used to be. When the middle class becomes the lower class, those already living in real poverty truly lose all their options. You find yourself in a place that proudly values real estate over humanity. If this obnoxious mentality overtakes America in light of those statistics up there, the new America might be a pretty horrible place to live...

    • 2 years ago
  • RaceBannon
    • 0
      RaceBannon  
    • Workers of the world unite!

      Unions are great, in most of western europe all businesses can't do anything unless the unions agree. The workers, and students can shut down a country in the name of labor. They're time hasn't gone, and in the US its sad to see how weak they have become. It says a lot about the state of this country, as the unions went so did the american socialist, the anarchist, the thinkers, the real progressives, the people who were the real revolutionary class and kept the establishment on edge. Now the workforce is made up of desperate centrist packed with debt who are less educated than their grandparents to even consider a real alternative. Social programs are a joke, and the country is toying with selling public services to privatized companies. I doubt this was accident, the eroding of this class, this thinking was planned, marketed and sold to people, and this is what we have a plutocracy were libertarians seem like the radicals, wtf?
      Making money for a few never benefits the state, keep that in mind.

      As for the declining middle class things will get worse, actually much worse. As each "crisis" hits along comes with inflation, longer hours, workers willingness to do more for less and no social safety net. A worker in the US can't just walk off the job because he needs the job to provide healthcare, food or education to his children, whereas a european worker could do so, and not worry about "needing" a job to exist. I think some who've never even glanced at a psych class would say this means european workers are un motivated, but this is completely wrong. The american worker is working out desperation/ survival and is far more vulnerable to the whims of the manufacturer which would correlate with the lower life expectancies of americans vs western europeans. Those who are doing better (the upper middle class), know how lucky they are and wont even question the unethical nature of our system. Why should they they're making x amount of dollars at company b, so why ruin their plan. Its quite sad. Knowing my history I already decided that I'll moving back overseas before I get married or start a family, I would never want any child to grow up in country where they desperately needed a job or the basic and higher needs are left to chance.

    • 2 years ago
  • raiderguyx
    • 0
      raiderguyx  
    • GEE!!! yet another azzclown telling us what we already know,,, everybody's hip to complain, whine, snivel, about the state of everyfuckingthing,,, it ain't like we don't know the goddamn questions already,,, how about some answers to these problems? ? ?

      fuckthis

      oooohhhh i had to edit this after i read the post by diabolical44....

      strong unions huh? ? ? you know what man, it's great if you're the union worker(speaking from experience), not so, if you're not. back in 97,98 i was a sheet metal mech. working on the upgrade to the ontario apt. in calif. we were "on the clock" 50 hours a week, whether we had something to do or not. i was getting paid $26.65 hr to do damn near nothing except watch the glaziers hang glass, then myself and five others(two other apprentices. and two journeymen) would probably expend two tubes of calk around the metal. we'd go through maybe a box(12 tubes) a day. talk about shit,,, that was probably about $150 bucks an hour doing what could have been done by an apprentice and a laborer, but.... due to "union contracts", that is what was called for, and since it was a gov't job, "who gives a fuck, we're getting ours". once again,,,,

      fuck this

    • 2 years ago
  • diabolical44
  • RaceBannon
  • telcod
    • 0
      telcod  
    • The game is rigged. Wage slaves and a declining middle class. Slaves to the HMO's and drug companies as well. My copay's are killing me. Went to the US post office yesterday. Good service, fair rates and they pay their employee's well. Better all around than private enterprise. Now if this socialist program can work, what about our health care system? Recovery is a myth and the "recession" is a depression and it ain't over, baby.

      I believe the New America will never resemble the old one. Those days are over and they ain't coming back. No manufacturing, no expanding property value, skyrocketing educational and medical costs, better educated foreign influx, a nation of sheep. Our children are being groomed to be the perfect conforming consumers or weapons of our corporate masters.

      The American dream, two young semi professional technicians hook up and buy an overpriced mediocre home and live happily ever after, if neither get sick and they are not among the 50% of couples who end up divorced. The rest of you can work hourly for $10 to $15 and wave tiny flags around on the fourth of July. Used to be a term used, I believe it was Commonwealth, referred to politics, the nation and the social contract.

    • 2 years ago
  • Gravity_Man
    • 0
      Gravity_Man  
    • telcod:

      Maybe Americans spending $3 billion a year on Internet porn has caught up to them, plus another couple billion at the Box Office. Add more billions on iPod's and stuff. We make ourselves poor and the elite lap it up. After every holiday they tally up what everybody paid for the stuff and then laugh at the people crying about not having health insurance or losing their homes.

    • 2 years ago
  • thecoyote23
  • Gravity_Man
    • 0
      Gravity_Man  
    • telcod:

      If you choose not to think that's your prerogative, but around here as soon as Black Friday was over they were blasting Sales numbers all over the place. hahahaha They tally how much the population is spending and it makes the whole population look like dumb snots for misspending their money.

      Begging for health care just looks like whining. From their perspective we're oink oinks addicted to the electronic feeding trough. And they're right.

      You want the system to change stop buying at Christmas and watch it change.

    • 2 years ago
  • Gravity_Man
    • 0
      Gravity_Man  
    • telcod:

      People are making theirself sick from electronics. Also, staring into a single lightsource for hours on end is beginning to affect people's eyesight. Holding devices in our sweating hands that are putting BPA (Bisphenol A) poison through our palm pores is also happening.

      Enjoy your movie.

    • 2 years ago
  • QuestionGeek
    • 0
      QuestionGeek  
    • telcod:

      Gravity Man, the only thing I bought were several articles of clothing for ex boyfriend, friends and myself and some Christmas cards. I didn't go hog wild and give into what is known as Black Friday frenzy, simply because it looked more like sports to me, than shopping. People are such pigs and animals when they shop....sad

    • 2 years ago
  • diabolical44
    • 0
      diabolical44  
    • we need to rebuild a strong union movement to rescue the middle class. unions and the new deal built the strongest middle class we ever had, and gave America the most prosperous times it ever saw in the 1950's and 60's, before Nixon and then Reagan busted it all back to the gilded age. We need to regain what was lost. It is not too late, but the clock is ticking. Ten Years from now we could be the equivalent of a Latin American nation. the rich keep getting richer, and the middle class goes down. it is the American dream in reverse. One income can no longer support a family of four or five. not even close. our families are being destroyed as a result. we are moving towards slavery. and have no doubt that is the goal for the powers that be.

      the pie is growing disproportionately. in the mid 1970's the average business executive made roughly 40x that of the average employee of his company. today, the average executive makes well over 500x that of the average employee of his company. that tells you all you need to know. the money is being concentrated at the top of the food chain. thats trickle down economics for ya. thank you Mr . Reagan. fucking bastard.

    • 2 years ago
  • Ares
  • diabolical44
  • Ares
    • 0
      Ares  
    • diabolical44:

      The time for unions has come and gone. They established and normalized organizations like OSHA and MSHA, and that was great. I don't mean to undermine what they have accomplished. Nowadays, however, worker safety is paramount, but unions linger in the interest of their own self preservation. All they do is pollute the labor system they operate within with nonsensical regulatory practices to ensure worker "happiness."

    • 2 years ago
  • thecoyote23
    • 0
      thecoyote23  
    • diabolical44:

      The time for Unions has come and gone because the Conservatives have destroyed them. The Unions existed to keep the American workplace from looking like those in impoverished countries, where the workers are endlessly exploited. The same argument the Right uses to claim that Unions are bad is the same argument that actually validates their existence. The Neo-Cons say that Unions demanded too many rights and benefits, thus driving the company to another country where they exploit the people exactly because they don't have Unions. I goes to show that without a strong labor movement the Corprotocracy will not stop until they have re-instituted a feudal dictatorship. Human rights and American Prosperity are at the bottom of there list of concerns.

      "Our merchants and master-manufacturers complain much of the bad effects of high wages in raising the price, and thereby lessening the sale of their goods both at home and abroad. They say nothing concerning the bad effects of high profits. They are silent with regard to the pernicious effects of their own gains. They complain only of those of other people."-- Adam Smith, Wealth Of Nations

    • 2 years ago
  • kennymotown
    • 0
      kennymotown  
    • diabolical44:

      You are so right diabolical44, remember the overlords have kids with lots of money and nothing better to do then put down unions. Little do they know they also will be swinging from the gallows for their corrupt daddy's ways. Long live the Workers of America and may the rich be a good BBQ dinner for us all.

    • 2 years ago
  • magnusdeus
    • 0
      magnusdeus  
    • diabolical44:

      Economically speaking, unions either force an inefficient quantity of labor (lower) or an inefficient wage rate (higher) upon the industries they organize within. Higher wages cause unemployment because firms shift employment back to cover increased wage costs. They force a lower quantity of labor by requiring that employees join the union and restricting entry.

      If the market is left to adjust itself, equilibrium employment levels and wages rise on their own. Unions seem nice for the worker, but in the end the whole economy loses.

      For example, GM paid 75$/hr in wages and benefits for union factory line workers they could have hired for 15 or 20. This is not competitive in a global economy and GM, as well as the tens of thousands of its employees now unemployed, has paid the price.

    • 2 years ago
  • diabolical44
    • 0
      diabolical44  
    • diabolical44:

      wow. you mean they could pay them 15 or 20 an hour? who they hell is supposed to work for that? that's what workers are supposed to live on? 30, 40 K per year? good luck living on that wage. so basically what your saying is that all workers can be wage slaves for the benefit of the company they work for?

      and, that GM 75$ an hour figure was a total fabricated bullshit line floated by fox news and the right wing when the recession broke. it's complete nonsense. how many autoworkers you know making 150K / yr?

      there's aren't any. that number included the hourly costs of health insurance for each employee, which was over $40 / hr per employee. the workers were actually making 30 an hour (or in that ballpark) with more than double that GM paying towards health insurance corporations. which brings us to another way the right has been fucking over the working man. HMO's.

    • 2 years ago
  • magnusdeus
    • 0
      magnusdeus  
    • diabolical44:

      "For example, GM paid 75$/hr in wages and benefits"

      I generally classify health insurance as a "benefit," but you must have thought I was referring to something else? It doesn't matter what portion of the wage rate goes to the worker in cash; that is still the cost of their labor.

      I also said "economically speaking." This should have indicated to you that I was about to comment on your post using economics. Economics is a mathematical science. It does not care how you feel or what is comfortable. What it does do is predict and explain economic outcomes in the free market with the assumption that people will act in a way that most benefits themselves. This they will surely do. They always have, and they always will. It is why socialism doesn't work and never will; there is no incentive.

      The point is that there is no level of income everyone *should* have in a free market economy. Wages are determined by supply and demand impartially, and they will reach their fair equilibrium based on the supply of labor/demand of firms on their own. Unions disrupt this balance and cause unemployment to rise, which is presumably less desirable than having a lower wage. If this wage isn't high enough for the worker they should become more educated or find another way to make themselves more valuable to firms to justify higher pay.

      This is all assuming, of course, that companies are also staying true to the free market and not using shady tactics to keep wages artificially low. In that case regulatory agencies should step in or unions will develop as they have.

    • 2 years ago
  • artemis6
  • Dagum
    • 0
      Dagum  
    • Most depressing article I read in a while. Doesn't suprise me, nobody looks out for the Middle class,Its social programs for the poor and tax breaks for the rich, all payed for by taxes on the middle class!

    • 2 years ago
  • asherp
    • 0
      asherp  
    • And people say we have a consumer driven economy. HA!

      If it was consumer driven, the consumers would have choice! If you gotta choose between rent, and eating, you're going to buy whatever is cheapest, no matter what. No luxury to make "ethical purchase decisions."

      Policy needs to lead the way to a stable economy.

    • 2 years ago
  • heimbachae
    • 0
      heimbachae  
    • There will always be classes. The only reason people are saying this is due to the recession. The dollar is inflated so it's giving people the false identity that they have more money than they actually do have. The rich are staying somewhat stagnant, but I'm sure once this whole thing rolls over completely they'll be rolling in cash. The middle class will need more money to stay middle, and the lower class will remain there.

      What is this world coming to...

    • 2 years ago
  • Mr_Ben
    • 0
      Mr_Ben  
    • This doesn't paint a pretty picture. Any sort of recovery will take a long time to help those unemployed and economically stricken people. Will anything change or will the rich get richer and more got poorer?

    • 2 years ago
more from The Real Recovery:

top videos