TV Schedule

Graduation Racism


  1. embed code
  2. sarahbelle
  3. related topics
At UCLA so called identity-based graduations [separate graduations for specific race and gender groups] are the cause for a lot of discussion on the meaning of diversity. Students express the importance of these graduations, and former UC regents discuss their possible detriment.
sarahbelle

14 responses // Graduation Racism

  • Another one by the same producer
    I like this one better.
    bstein
  • I think it's important that everyone graduate together, even if I only get 3 tickets and it takes 5 hours. What do you think?
    bstein
  • I find "identity-based graduation" bitterly ironic. Barely 40 years after the bloody civil rights struggle in the US, these UCLA grads roll back those advances in the name of comfort.

    These deluded people are doing more harm to civil rights than the Klan or skinheads ever could. To put this in an image, they''ve grabbed away the pistol from the oppressor and instead put the barrel in their own mouths and pulled the trigger.

    The grads said the same thing: "I''m not comfortable with people who aren''t like me." These people have a serious problem: No one''s ever told them the world doesn''t revolve around their comfort.

    Living in a melting pot community means being around people who aren''t like you, it means you get to grow up and realize what unites is our humanity, the characteristics common to all of us which make us human, and not any external physical attributes or psychologies.

    I understand wanting to hang out only with people I''m comfortable with, but if my "comfort zone" extends no further than to people who look like me, act like me, believe the way I do--how the hell is that different from the racial isolation a Klansman believes in? (Actually, I find the Klansman more honest about it. He at least admits his racism.)

    What would happen if some white students wanted a segregated graduation? Would it be allowed? (I bet not. The Political Correctness harpies would fly in, screaming and crapping.)
  • I was apart of the UCLA African Grad Ceremony and acted as the Ceremony Chair for the comencement which was covered in this story. Yes, it was a good piece, however, if you are going to cover something that could be so "problematic" you may want to cover all sides of what is really going on during commencement. Now, although there are "race based" ceremonies, there are more than enough ceremonies where we are brought together as a diverse community. Throughout the weekend we attend, in addition to race based ceremonies, those dealing with MAJOR, SCHOOL, DEPARTMENT and a UNIVERSITY WIDE cermony. Most, if not all "ethnic" students attend more than 2 the entire weekend. That''s not to mention all the events and banquets and ceremonies that are academic and fraternity based as well. NOw if we are going to pick on one aspect of commencement, why not all of them? Furthermore, most ceremonies are way too large for you or your family to feel as if there really is any kind of pomp and circumstance seeing as though there are usually thousands of graduates every year! Race based or even department ceremonies are the only time for a more intimate setting for students to leave their last mark on their college career or to actually be seen by their folks while in ceremony, seeing as though they are all race-based (smaller numbers) and planned and ran by their peers, the students who are in them. The truth of the matter is that UCLA even charges us crazy amounts of money just to hold these ceremonies. So, who is really responsible? Which brings me to this...in a perfect world, race would not be an issue, but in this one it is. And until we are able to apply to any unviersity without checking a box, these acts of so-called "graduation racism" can''t be scruntinized and looked down upon. And you could never understand the importance of having such specialized ceremonies unless you attended the university (UCLA), unless you marched with us on the adminstration for admissions (supported by all races) or unless if you were the first person in your "ethnic" family to be admitted to a 4 year university such as UCLA and actually graduate. What the former regents said was all nice and dandy but there is ideal and there is reality! Race is reality, however, because the race based orgs. and planning committees do not believe in furthering racism, we open our ceremonies for any and everyone who "identifies" with the culture (I noticed that you didn''t have footage of the korean or white jewish graduate in our ceremony). So please, do your homework before you skew the true meaning of such things...BTW we are not the only university to do this. You can find it at more than a few universities and colleges in California.
  • Great pod!! Really opened my eyes! but UCLA can go to hell, this is bullshit!!!! where is the WHITES ONLY graduation????, NO NO NO, you CAN'T do that, because then thats RACIST!!! Not right that these PEOPLE cannot be open to everyone and have to create their OWN segregated graduations. They should just segregate the F'n school then. But great work Sarah and Adam, you got me fired up!
    CrazyDave
  • Really interesting. I went to UPenn where they have a dorm for the African American student body called Dubois, essentially segregating Blacks from Whites. It seems so backward to me that in this day and age my university still has a dorm for people of a different race keeping us separate, essentially promoting segregation.

    Then again, people chose to live in these dorms, no one ever imposes it on them. It seems to be a vicious circle. Once a dorm is there supporting a common ethnicity, people are attracted living with people they can "relate" to. I just think Universities shouldn't be encouraging this at all.
    julietp
  • we're not one big happy family! why do folks always imply that? white folks already have white graduations, schools, etc. they're the institutions of america, owned and dominated by white culture. as a first generation immigrant that was the first to graduate from college in my family, i would have loved a separate celebration with people who have shared in my experiences. sitting next to the upper class white women that were about the tenth generation to have access to higher education, and a lot of what they wanted from this country, like real opportunity and freedom (something people of color are fighting for), did nothing for me at my college graduation. plus my mom understood nothing! (and if you say it's her fault for not learning english, i can suggest some really great books on unlearning racism).
    cvazquez
  • I don't know what you think you're talking about cvazquez. Here's one "white folk" who certainly doesn't imply this country's one big happy family. Oh, and no, I don't get white graduations. I get school graduations, thank you.

    I go to UCLA, and I fully agree with the former regent's statement that allowing functions like this only segregates groups that already feel disadvantaged. Once you've started highlighting differences between racial groups through these ceremonies, you're only going to end up with more problems. College is about challenging students to get out of their comfort zone, not to reject anything that makes them uneasy.

    And don't even give me your "white folks don't know crap, they've got it good" bull. My family didn't immigrate here, but they sure as hell worked their asses off to make the opportunities we've got today. My mom paid her way through college as a full-time student while working a full-time job cutting hair. Sounds like easy sailing on the big bucks, huh? My mom hardly got a steady job before I made it into college, so now I'm stacking up the debt to get myself through this too. Nobody's gonna give you a free ride, why don't you do like the rest of us and put some effort into reaching your goals?

    And one more thing, it's not white. European, Slavic, Russian, Iberian, Italian, Anglo, whatever you want. But I have culture too, so start recognizing it.
    bruin
  • I honestly don't know how I feel about race-based graduation ceremonies. Actually I do-- I don't believe in it. Parties, receptions, sure, but graduation is different. You take classes with people...then you graduate with them, not just with your best friends. UCLA can do whatever it wants, but I know that Northwestern would never, ever have ceremonies like this, but NU isn't exactly friendly when it comes to that sort of thing anyway.
    ChardaeD
  • hey bruin

    i know you have culture, it's been imposed on me my entire life as a chicana in the US. for example, all history books until getting to my major in college...so stop acting like we don't live in a white dominant society...
    cvazquez
  • I think you can have Italian, Russian, German ceremonies if you want. . . .
    CarlosIsDown
  • God bless America, and all its contradictions.

    I'm black, and I'll admit that this is racist. Every race in America, white, black, brown, yellow, can be racist. In fact, the minorities are usually the most racist of them all. I think that the point about it being in their language is valid, but otherwise, it seems like these were all people who weren't brave or mature enough to get out of their own little Filipino or Black or Hispanic bubble during their time at UCLA.
    timunuhe
  • if taken in isolation, race-specific graduation might be reasonably viewed as troubling...but considering these events occur in conjunction with larger ceremonies, I see this as little more than celebrating with a group of people who want to celebrate together.

    but to press the matter further, many non-white college students feel alienated by the prevailing white-culture on campus (e.g., sexually liberal, sacrilegious, hyper-competitive, individualistic, expensive, etc.) and want to accent their experience by publicly projecting their selves onto the wider whiter campus.
    BooksBrown

Add your response

Login/Registration is required to add a response.