TV Schedule

Bottled water industry faces growing opposition

  1. Collective Journalism
    Earth Day
  2. JanforGore
  3. related topics
Image...
Last week’s decision by a York County water board to delay a vote on whether to sell municipal water to Nestle Corp., the owner of Poland Spring, did not happen in a vacuum.

* Last month in McCloud, Calif., after encountering opposition to what would have been the largest water bottling plant in the country, Nestle announced plans to significantly reduce the plant’s size.
* Earlier this month in Enumclaw, Wash., the city council rejected a proposal to allow Nestle to build another such plant.
* And last Monday, the U.S. Conference of Mayors voted to phase out use of bottled water for municipal employees.

Across the country, opposition to bottled water is building, amid growing concerns about the industry’s environmental impact and rising fears about private control of public water supplies.

“There’s no question that there is a groundswell,” said Ruth Caplan, coordinator of Defending Water for Life, a Washington, D.C.-based campaign that opposes the bottled water industry.

There are several reasons for the backlash to bottled water. Some of it is driven by fears about global warming - given the amount of oil needed to bottle and transport the water.

Some stems from concerns about the chemical makeup of plastic water bottles.

Some of the opposition is a byproduct of the huge price disparity between bottled water and the kind of water that comes from the tap for free.

Here in Maine, some of the local opposition to Poland Spring’s operations has stemmed from the traffic generated by the trucks that transport the water.

Perhaps the biggest factor, though, is a fear that as bottled water becomes more popular, private corporations are gaining more control over a natural resource that is central to life.

“The fundamental issue is, who owns the water?” said Jim Olson, an attorney for Michigan Citizens for Water Conservation, which has been engaged in a legal battle with Nestle. “If this company gets to do it, all companies get to do it, and you’re not going to be able to say no in the future.”
~~~~~~~~~~
We need to stop the commoditization of this resource which is the lifeblood of the Earth. Water is a human right. It cannot be bought by Nestle at the expense of the poor in countries where water is already scarce. It is a good sign to see people finally standing up to these companies.
JanforGore

73 responses // Bottled water industry faces growing opposition

  •  

    I am with you Jan. Water and clean air are a human right.

    jubal
  •  

    If I'm not mistaken, nestle bought the water rights in one of the southamerican country's already. HUH, something for me to look into to check my facts. Anyway,, greenlight. excellent post.

    victimofcoal
  •  
    Image...

    This is a good site with updates about the corporatization of water resources around the world. I don't know off the top of my head if Nestle was or is in South America regarding water, but I wouldn't be surprised if they were. I do know Coca Cola was/ is as well as in India. Matter of fact I recall a big case I believe in South America In which Coca Cola was accused of murdering workers trying to unionize. I think the case was eventually dropped. If I can find that I will post about it here.

    JanforGore
  •  

    OK, here it is. I don't vouch one way or the other for what is on here, but I don't totally discount it either.So you also have companies like Coca Cola going down to these countries in Central and South America and India and taking the water to use it to make their soda.... in countries where water scarcity and pollution are major problems.

    recommended by Vierotchka
    JanforGore
  •  

    This pod is excellent, in that it focuses attention on yet another instance of the damage that can be done if corporations are not held in check. Do not doubt for a moment that if they could, they would buy the rights to the very air we breathe and charge us for it.

    recommended by Vierotchka
    nyingma13
  •  

    Good, shut em down.

    onechance
  •  

    I say, boycott them all.

    recommended by uroborus8
    JanforGore
  •  

    nyingma13: I'm sure they will get around to that soon enough when they run out of resources to exploit.

    JanforGore
  •  
    Image...

    Coca Cola is even in Afghanistan. A country where water most certainly is scarce and what is left is polluted. This is why this government also invades countries to set up puppet regimes... to make their corporate benefactors $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$. And it isn't just for oil.

    JanforGore
  •  
    Image...

    One more. ;-).

    Defending Water for Life In Maine

    This site gives current updates to Nestle's desire to own the water of Maine and the efforts of the people to stop them. Very encouraging.

    JanforGore
  •  

    It's still, unfortunately, all about money and increasing their bottom line... When will these large corporations realize that they should be investing in the people...that is the most valuable resource on the planet...

    recommended by uroborus8
    PlatoTacius
  •  

    Drinking water bottled in plastic is stupid. People do it thinking they are getting clean safe spring water. Not much wrong with the water except it is just filtered overpriced water. The bottle on the other hand is plastic. "Toxic", and the softer it is the more toxic. This is one of the biggest scams going. Buy a filter for your faucet. Keep a glass pitcher of water in the refrigerator. Free after the initial filter, pitcher purchase.

    Marilynn_Murray
  •  

    It also shows how gullible so many people are to ad campaigns. The subliminal messages passed to people in these commercials are what activate the part of the brain emotionally rather than reasonably. i watched a water commercial where people were climbing a mountain, and even though it was a hot day the bottled water in their belt looked cold, crisp, and appetizing... of course, people watching this will be influenced by the images they see rather than thinking about the fact that it is refiltered tap water in a plastic bottle sitting in the same hot sun where chemicals from the bottle can mix with the water.

    recommended by Marilynn_Murray, uroborus8
    JanforGore
  •  

    I remember back in high school my english teacher would comment on what a joke bottled water is and make some reference to bottling air. That was when the whole bottled water fad was just beginning. Since then the bottled water industry has exploded. I still think its a joke and almost never buy bottled water. Just another example of Americans being turned into consumer zombies. I'm glad that actions are being taken to limit bottled water production and consumption.

    sapere_aude
  •  

    Bottle water, suffocate water.

    uroborus8
  •  

    Well said sapere_aude bottled water is on the same par with Starbucks. Either one is great example of Americans being turned into consumer Zombies. Incredible what you can get the American consumers to buy with the right promotion. How gullable can people be?

    recommended by Marilynn_Murray
    Robroy1
  •  

    I can still remember when I was a kid growing up in the Sacramento Valley in California. It was damnably hot. Our water was from the Sierra Nevada Snow melt. Even in summer it was really cold out of the tap and wonderfully clean and tasty. Can't bottle that. I heard a radio personality visiting there and broadcasting commenting on how wonderful the water is the other day and could almost taste the water. Maybe we should work on cleaning our water supplies instead of bottling up fantasies?

    Marilynn_Murray
  •  

    We dont need no... pla-stic bot-tles.

    dennet.... denet, denet, denet.....

    stephenthomson
  •  

    Hey now, hold on, bottled water in plastic bottles is not in itself a bad idea. I think the trick is to use the plastic bottles in a responsible manner, such as reusing them and filling them with your own tap water... it's pretty simple really.

    As for the companies looking to control water in an entire state, isn't it kind of redundant to say that a private company can't control it but the government can? Regardless of who controls the water don't people without access to their own wells still have to pay?

    M_Pavlov
  •  

    I live in the valley and the water isn't like it was when I was growing up. The amount of chlorine in it is bad. I haven't been able to drink water out of the tap for years. I admit that I buy bottled water, 6 gallon bottles. I have always drank a lot of water. I switched because of the taste of spring water. It really doesn't taste the same through a filtered tap. I see people drinking from many types of plastic bottles and I've heard that the problem is the plastic is leaking into the fluid. There's suppose to be a number on the bottle for recycling that tells how bad it can happen. I remember something on current about this.

    cibalin
  •  

    Don't just stop your ignorance at plastic bottles hippocrites! what are your cell phones, computers and faucet filters made of?

    Plastics make our life better and next time you use your cell phone think of me, yes Stephenthomas I can already hear you saying next time you take a crap you will think of me. . . . . .

    Blah blah blah

    God bless me
    God bless big oil that made your computer possible

    mrburns
  •  

    Hey! Smithers ! Leave that oil alone.

    dennet, denet, denet.....

    recommended by Marilynn_Murray
    stephenthomson
  •  

    Mr. What is your job with Big Oil? We aren't drinking from our cell phones, or computers. Plastic is toxic and should never be used for food or drink containers. It should absolutely never be microwaved.

    recommended by Chique
    Marilynn_Murray
  •  

    why drink bottled water when it comes out of the tap for (relatively) free? as other posters have stated, buying bottled water is one representation of american consumerism at its worst.

    recommended by Chique, Marilynn_Murray
    bishopobispo
  •  

    at my job we give out plastic bottles on a daily basis, and they STILL do not recycle them nor paper, PATHETIC

    recommended by Marilynn_Murray
    lfm
    • lfm
    • 5 months ago
1 - 25 of 59

Add your response

Login/Registration is required to add a response