TV Schedule

WALL-E film's 'fattist' satire angers fat pride groups


  1. LindseyIndigo
  2. related topics
New animated film WALL-E has got rave reviews for its satire on consumer culture, where future humans are depicted as a group of obese gluttons who never leave their padded floating arm chairs.

But one group is not amused - the swelling ranks of fat pride groups, who believe the film propagates anti-obesity hysteria comparable with the quest for the perfect body by the eugenics movement in Nazi Germany.

The US is the epicentre of the movement, where pro-weight "fat-tivists" are campaigning for human rights for the full of figure.

Fighters for fat rights are calling for legislation to ban weight discrimination in the workplace, denouncing airlines that demand they buy two seats and car manufacturers whose seat belts are too small. They are also battling doctors who won't treat patients who refuse to lose weight and companies that won't insure them. They seek to reclaim the word "fat", dismissing terms like "overweight" and "obese" as morally loaded.

Research published in April by Yale University's Rudd Centre for Food Policy and Obesity suggests they might have a point. It found that one in eight people now complain of weight discrimination, up from one in 14 a decade ago. The report compared the impact on victims compares with racism and sexism.

Fat-ivists argue that our genes not our lifestyles determine the broad parameters of our weight, and favour the 'health at any size' argument that is supported by sceintific research (a study by The Cooper Institute for Aerobics Research found that even the obese who exercise are less likely to die from heart attacks, strokes and cancer than sedentary skinny people.)

They argue for greater acceptance of fat people.

"Overweight people tend to have very low self esteem," says Shelley Bovey. "I have never met anyone who I believe is totally happy with being very large. However much self confidence they have, if you live in a society that hates overweight people it is very, very difficult to be yourself."

Rachel Richardson of the Coalition of Fat Rights Activists (Cofra) objected that the WALL-E film "singles out and targets obese people as the primary cause of mankind's demise."

Miss Wann (41 years in age and 20 stones in weight) is America's best known fighter for fat rights. She told The Sunday Telegraph: "It's the classic stereotype that fat people are stupid, smelly, lazy, disgusting and out of control. These are the same stereotypes that have been used for every group of outsiders: whether it's people of colour, or the disabled, or immigrants."

Miss Wann said the film company would never have considered stereotyping black people "dancing a jig" in the way they have done so with fat people.

She added: "Pixar should be out of business for portraying this level of prejudicial bigotry-mongering. These are 19th-century hatreds repackaged in modern animation. It's amazing."

Is fat-ism really comparable with racism or sexism? Shouldn't we just leave each other alone to get on with our own lives free of prejudice and stigma, regardless of our size?
LindseyIndigo

103 responses // WALL-E film's 'fattist' satire angers fat pride groups

  • Wall-E was a very good movie in my opinion. As fat as our country is getting I don't think that's it's a stretch to imagine that in 700 years we could all be obese.
    shroomfairy
  • There are 'fat pride' groups?
    Nuevarine
  • Thats ridiculous, and frankly, I'm pissed. I don't want to tell my children that its okay to be fat, because its not; it isn't healthy. I don't need people campaigning and picketing because they're "fat and proud," they are unhealthy - and I don't care if they "choose" to be that way or not. Pixar and Disney movies no longer have people smoking because its a bad influence on children, so what? Now were going to tell children that its okay to be "morbidly overweight." Nope. Its not "discriminating" against fat-people, I mean, insurance companies don't give smokers good policies, so why should they give them to others with unhealthy habits?
    THEREisHOPE
  • And yes, this sure is more important news considering the other important stories that have been here in the last day and seen the abyss. Let' s just talk about obese people on tv... it is so much 'safer' than exposing big coal and their killing of the Appalachians, or the world domination of multi nationals to get our food and water, or the behind the scenes ties they have in Washington DC that are affecting all of our lives, or the fact that climate change is excelerating and will not be addressed properly by world leaders unless we wake up from our stupor and actually do something about it. And to stay on topic, I really don't care who is offended by a child's movie. It is insignificant to me in the world scope.
    JanforGore
  • "fat - ism" ! i'm trying to come up with some other amusing names . how about "obesi-phobia " ? i just knew there'd be some kind of backlash against WALL-E . i mean it so perfectly summed up ( stereotyped ) , in the way only disney can , the "fat for the future" thing .
    and i could not agree more with THERE's comment .
    malathion
  • I would hate it if fat people have being fat as a "lifestyle". In my view, they are always angery for no reason and yell alot. What's going to happen? When ever a fat person is made fun of, are they going to call some Fat People Society to complain to the schools or workplaces and have sit in and eat all our food?
    KefKef
  • "The fat people took to the streets for their march on Washington today. Unfortunately their effort was brought to an abrupt halt as they passed a KFC and decided to take a short break."
    recommended by  saverio
    T_Rose
  • PUT DOWN THE FORK!
    j_wreck
  • That's absolutely absurd!
    "Prejudicial bigotry-mongering?"
    I would call that pompous, stupidmongeringphrase-mongering
    mransom
  • I'm on board with fighting fat-ism and I think this article raises good points about the importance of health rather than the importance of weight loss. We should encourage each other to stay healthy not stay skinny. We're all built differently, besides, some of the skinniest amongs us are the least healthy.
    However, I am so offended that they are launching a campaign against Wall-E of all things. Did they watch the movie!? The fat humans of the future are the heros. The movie does the opposite of perpetuate stereotypes. It shows extremely large people as wonderful, smart, big hearted, friendly people who are just blinded by the repetition and consumerism around them. The movie took a risk making such a gutsy leap of logic and making all the space passengers so huge, but they earned it ten fold by humanizing those characters. We laugh at them at first but then realize how beautiful and human they still are and at the end of the movie they in no way say "Now they can all loose that weight." They say, "now they can start living their lives." A wholesome message that is helping fight the fat-ism cause not hurt it. So I think Miss Wann desperately needs to take a deep breath, watch wall-e again, then go fight makeup, and weight loss advertisers or something.
    dscheinert
  • Obesity pride?? That is wildly unhealthy.
    iOw
    • iOw
    • 2 months ago
  • Wow. The vitriol here is shocking. Why do you all hate fat people so much!? I'm speechless.
    LindseyIndigo
  • if you take up two seats on an airplane, you should pay for both rather than letting the person next to you suffer.

    i'm not sure about everyone else, but if there came a time in my life when i could no longer use a seat belt, i'd get my ass in shape instead of blaming the car company. seriously, no one needs to be telling ford and chevy to make bigger things.
    recommended by  Julie_Soller, saverio
    WayneRegretzky
  • Only a very rare few are obese due to some sort of genetic condition. The vast majority of overweight and obese people are that way because they choose to be. It all comes down to calories in vs. calories out, it's not a complex equation. It's about time for people to start taking self-responsibility and admit that they are fat due to poor lifestyle choices. The fact that some are calling for fat acceptance is not only ridiculous, but actually rather horrifying, seeing as there are people starving all over the world at this very moment.
    recommended by  Julie_Soller, saverio
    SpookyFish
  • Being fat is not an illness! If you eat to much you get fat! That will probably be a serious problem in the future, how can it be illegal?
    thekingbeyond
  • "weight discrimination in the workplace, denouncing airlines that demand they buy two seats and car manufacturers whose seat belts are too small. ...battling doctors who won't treat patients who refuse to lose weight...seek to reclaim the word "fat", dismissing terms like "overweight" and "obese" as morally loaded. "

    This paragraph alone is a joke!
    Personally I thought the word "fat" was the most offensive. If your weight gets in the way of your life, i don't think it is discrimination.

    Maybe the "discrimination" rates are higher because we are fatter than a decade ago? Or we are just sick of it.

    I'm not saying lets condem the fat kid, but lets not support his unhealthy lifestyle. Whateves.
    samonster34
  • While obese people do get made fun of and are portrayed negatively in the media (ugly, stupid, clumsy, etc), being obese is not a healthy state to be in, and I don't know if there should "fat-tivists" advocating this kind of lifestyle. I'm not trying to encourage all of us to become anorexic or bulimic, but to work at slimming down to an acceptable frame. You don't need to look like starving model; you can have a little meat on the bones. It's a feature that you can change about yourself. I know because I used to be fat, but I decided to do something about it, and now I feel that I'm in a healthy condition. "Fattism" is not at all like racism or discrimination based on sexual orientation because those are aspects of a person that can't be changed.

    Also, it is apparent that the members of NAAFA did not even see the movie because it was the effect of living in space (compounded with an inactive lifestyle) that caused the obesity seen in the film. When you see the in-movie clips of people prior to the mass exodus, you notice that everyone is either well-built or has an average frame. It's the 700 years of being in an environment that has a gravity that's just not as strong as Earth's. If you're going to make a criticism about something, make sure you know what you're talk about.
    CCashman
  • Alright I got it. Well, here is a site that sort of answers the growing obesity trend. Everyone knows it is increasing, but I felt like I needed proof.

    The proof is in the pudding! Stop your gluttony!
    samonster34
  • "...swelling ranks..."
    Hey, man. Nice shot.
    Let the blobs rant.
    Soon, they won't have legs to stand on.
    huntre
  • im fat but good lord im not gunna bitch and gripe "waaa in the future according to this kids movie were all going to be fat, obese, slobs like 80% of the country is right now" gaaaa get over it.
    StuArt_Gould
  • WALL-e should have angered those that don't want to see us OR the planet end up like they're depicted,... in this Pixar movie with a 'real' message. I "think" I liked it, and I don't like movies.

    As far as Fat-Priders getting offended, they may have missed the underlying messages.
    PajamaDan
  • I am amazed that people have time to sit around and gripe at something as simple as a child's movie that was only depicting what could happen if you let everything get taken care of for you. Humans were created to work; not sit around all day - it is a FACT that if you are not physical or even mental (no one showed any type of problem solving skills in this movie) that you will become sluggish. Everything in the movie had nothing to do with "this is what will happen in 700 years" or "haha look at the fat people"
    jpettw
  • fat pride groups... sigh.
    bishopobispo
  • stupid stupid activists.

    I do so love how they compared Wall-e to Nazi's.
    AswegoAsdego
  • Nobody should be made fun of because of their physical appearance. However, fat people should not claim they're being discriminated against and require changes in the laws similar to antidiscrimination laws for homosexuals, women, or people of different races. You can't change the color of your skin, but you can change how much fat sits under it.
    Julie_Soller
  • People will complain about anything nowadays.
    Razgriz2234
  • Fat pride groups?

    What's next? Unbathed pride groups?

    How can you be proud of a bad habit?
    Saladin
  • FAT PRIDE? that seems rediculously lazy and unhealthy and an excuse to not do anything to try to get healthy.

    BEYOND THAT, if any of them had actually seen WALL-E they would know the reason these people were fat is because they were in space so long that they lost bone mass and had to ride those things. It's clearly explained in the movie
    SilenceNoMore
  • while i totally agree that people can be large and both beautiful and healthy...i think its absolutely preposterous to call Wall-E a bigoted movie. First of all the humans in the movie are fat on their own accord (being lazy and poor eating) not because they are born with a lager frame. i understand that some people have difficulty losing weight and will never be a size 0, i have many friends who are plus sized and not only absolutely gorgeous but in better shape than people half their size!
    imo there is nothing wrong with having pride in being large or curvy or whatever...but in being fat and unhealthy that is another.
    and of course complaints of weight discrimination are up...people find any reason to complain and blame lifes problems on others now instead of accepting their own role in their problems.
    recommended by  jade_azul16
    seanalyn
  • Is that the movie with the Robot, because if it is my wife and kid loved it.
    clayjj05
  • Oddly enough I had no real desire to see Wall-E, but now I do...
    Varex_Sythe
  • Fat pride? It's so annoying when there are obese women who think, despite all the medical problems and such, that it's just so great to be fat. Obesity is a disease.
    FallenMorgan
  • It's amazing the extremes people have to go to gain acceptance and get some respect.
    bamboombango
  • There are fat-pride groups? There shouldn't be. I am a "fatist" and proud. Don't settle into your large selves we all know you aren't ashamed of your fatness, but the problem is: you should be.
    brz
    • brz
    • 2 months ago
  • Oh please.
    Its a cartoon.
    Come on.
    kristianbrodie
  • People are proud to be fat?
    What is this world coming to?
    jerseyjack21
  • this film shows many things to children in an innocent and ,frankly ,well pull way.
    first is that relying on automation and machines will make you fat. expecting rides from your parents instead of easily walking leads to obisity. not using the energy store in your body will only allow it to be kept in your body in the form of fat.
    second is that litter/rubbish/the environment is an important issue. showing children what will happen if we dont recycle and just throw everything away will only make the world uninhabitable.
    the film isnt making slandish claims aboutfat people, instead it is showing the causes, and doing so in a simple way.the residents of the space centre say things like "wow we had a pool ?" " i didnt know there was a jogging track" and act curious but most importantly, enthusiastic. they want to exersise.
    i would consider this film to be a pretty good example of something enjoyable, funny, educational and something for the entire family even the small kids.