How Far Should Interrogation Techniques Go?
-
-
- wayseeker
- added this
Waterboarding? Hasn't been used in years. Walling, stress positions, abdominal slaps? They're no longer allowed. But if the CIA can no longer use the interrogation techniques described in chilling detail in the so-called "torture memos," what can it do to extract information from terror suspects?
The CIA's Willful Ignorance on Harsh Interrogations
On his second day as President, Obama ordered the Agency to use the Army Field Manual as its interrogation playbook. The manual, originally written for Cold War prisoners but updated in 2006, states that "no [detainee], regardless of nationality or physical location, shall be subject to cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment or punishment as defined in U.S. law." It also categorically states that harsh interrogation techniques are essentially useless. "Beyond being impermissible, these unlawful and unauthorized forms of treatment are unproductive because they may yield unreliable results, damage subsequent collection efforts, and result in extremely negative consequences at national and international levels."
* * * * * At what level of causing the Interrogated discomfort, beyond prolonged questioning, acceptable? What techniques would you consider appropriate?
The CIA's Willful Ignorance on Harsh Interrogations
On his second day as President, Obama ordered the Agency to use the Army Field Manual as its interrogation playbook. The manual, originally written for Cold War prisoners but updated in 2006, states that "no [detainee], regardless of nationality or physical location, shall be subject to cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment or punishment as defined in U.S. law." It also categorically states that harsh interrogation techniques are essentially useless. "Beyond being impermissible, these unlawful and unauthorized forms of treatment are unproductive because they may yield unreliable results, damage subsequent collection efforts, and result in extremely negative consequences at national and international levels."
* * * * * At what level of causing the Interrogated discomfort, beyond prolonged questioning, acceptable? What techniques would you consider appropriate?
-
- tags:
- Barack Obama, People, u.s. government, World Affairs
