And other unexpected truths.
By Fareed Zakaria
Everything you know about Iran is wrong, or at least more complicated than you think. Take the bomb. The regime wants to be a nuclear power but could well be happy with a peaceful civilian program (which could make the challenge it poses more complex). What's the evidence?
-
- groups:
- News, Green, News and Politics, Politics, 4 more
-
- recommended by:
- Vierotchka
-
-
- Highr0ller
- added this
-
continued:
Iranians aren't suicidal. In an interview last week, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu described the Iranian regime as "a messianic, apocalyptic cult." In fact, Iran has tended to behave in a shrewd, calculating manner, advancing its interests when possible, retreating when necessary. The Iranians allied with the United States and against the Taliban in 2001, assisting in the creation of the Karzai government. They worked against the United States in Iraq, where they feared the creation of a pro-U.S. puppet on their border. Earlier this year, during the Gaza war, Israel warned Hizbullah not to launch rockets against it, and there is much evidence that Iran played a role in reining in their proxies. Iran's ruling elite is obsessed with gathering wealth and maintaining power. The argument made by those—including many Israelis for coercive sanctions against Iran is that many in the regime have been squirreling away money into bank accounts in Dubai and Switzerland for their children and grandchildren. These are not actions associated with people who believe that the world is going to end soon.
-
Iran isn't a dictatorship. It is certainly not a democracy. The regime jails opponents, closes down magazines and tolerates few challenges to its authority. But neither is it a monolithic dictatorship. It might be best described as an oligarchy, with considerable debate and dissent within the elites. Even the so-called Supreme Leader has a constituency, the Assembly of Experts, who selected him and whom he has to keep happy. Ahmadinejad is widely seen as the "mad mullah" who runs the country, but he is not the unquestioned chief executive and is actually a thorn in the side of the clerical establishment. He is a layman with no family connections to major ayatollahs—which makes him a rare figure in the ruling class.
-
people just never took the time to learn, about iran or israel or jordan or anyone. they made their choices without thought or intelligence and stuck with it as they stick with their faith.
sigh. thanks for sharing, good post.
-
I lived in Iran in the last years of the Shah. I know the area well.
Loads of Propaganda and Israel is desperate to be the only military power in the region. -
Part of the problem is that a vast majority of people learn from the 10 oclock news. When the news is controlled by........the jews........it's hard for them to learn the truth. And even when it is showed to them, they now have been taught by the MSM for so long that israhell is good, Middle East is bad, that they have a hard time dealing with the truth, or accepting it.
-
-
- Ihatethemall
- 6 months ago
-
-
I agree.
AIPAC has a lot to answer for.
-
A lot to answer for, to bad no one in a position of power has the balls to ask the questions
-
-
- Ihatethemall
- 6 months ago
-
-
They have asked the questions.....read the book online....I already posted it on current.
http://current.com/items/89867855_book-the-israel-lobby-and-u-s-part-1.htm
Click on link above.
============
BOOK: THE ISRAEL LOBBY AND U.S. (PART 1)THE ISRAEL LOBBY AND U.S. FOREIGN POLICY yOU CAN ALL READ THIS BOOK ON HERE AND YOU CAN ALL USE IT TO DEBATE AGAINST THE ENORMOUS PROPAGANDA IN OUR MEDIA, AND ON CURRENT.COM... more
Highr0ller added this 3 months ago | 24 responses===========
http://current.com/items/89867855_book-the-israel-lobby-and-u-s-part-1.htm
-
I read The Israel Lobby a year ago just because I like Mearsheimer's other works, and it is an extremely concise analysis of lobby and its effects on the U.S and the middle east. The authors support their claims well and argue within the context of the American political system very well.
The recent upturn of anti-Iranian nuclear program rhetoric in Israel/U.S is a useful way of deflecting the world's decreasing tolerance of Israeli expansionism, with Israel even trying to play a power politic card by refusing to resolve the Palestinian issue until the Iranian issue is solved. Seems like American diplomacy/mediation will play a major role, coming to an agreement with both Iran and Israel through our ability to apply considerable international pressure. Hopefully we don't screw it up. :P
Thanks highroller for posting on this topic consistently, as this new round of mid-eastern diplomatic efforts will undoubtedly be filled with media propaghanda. Conventional wisdom in the U.S. needs to be closer to the real happenings.
-
Thank you
Of the more than 66 ,000 people who receive our newsletter each day and over one million people who visit our website each month, 287 people have provided assistance (Thank you)
We need another 59 people in order to be able to ensure the continuation of this service.
If Information Clearing House is important to you, please use the link below to make a contribution using your credit / debit card or check.
-
It has always seemed to me you need your opposite what would one do without the other .push and pull ,give and take, good and evil .Israel is the opposite to Iran .that is why there is no resolve .you can not even try to discuss one without the other.there are haters on all sides.where would the balance be if not.It may sound crazy but it is true .
-
Read history!! and listen to other world radio. Americans can get a whole new view. The 10 o'clock news is for couch potatos. They don't want to know anything any way.
-
-
- GreenThumb_Izzy
- 6 months ago
-
-
I think alot of peole in the US do read history and see it as clearly as it can be seen and what I said earlier still holds true.If the middle east did not have eachother to be at perpetual war with .who would they be trying to war with than .they are following a natural evolution of country and religion that almost every other country and religion already has.in some cases they are just a few thousand years behind every one else (except scientology oops sorry they do not have thier own country ) but you get the point .If you look real close you get to see all the little bloody squabbles that come from the forementioned problem and it is in this place that all the humanitarians run.these countries hate americans so much because we do not go out in whole village wars with rocks ,clubs , home made bombs , and any other cheap method of death every time we have a problem.and, in the event that one of us does go nuts we do not give it a holy name and call it OK .It's not that I do not have sympathy for those innocents who get caught in the middle .but thier is very little realistically that can be done about that as an individual any way .Here is where the complacency comes from americans (we know, what are you going to do about it)
-
I don't know who I like more. Iraqi or Iranian.
-
-
- Mikeysfake1
- 6 months ago
-
-
Response to last comment by Sue 4e3
please Sue, don't insult all the people in the Middle East...or me. The Middle East is populated by wonderful kind people, and the Palestinians are very cultured and educated.
Israel is the cancer there....like a wound seeping.
Watch what they do. Expansion by force. Ethnic cleansing. Killing babies, young children, women and men. Do you know how they were given Arab land by an Empire who occupied it by force? Did you see the Israeli war in Lebanon? Did you see the war this year in Gaza?
Read John Pilger.......FREEDOM NEXT TIME.
go to ChapterTwo.."the last taboo."..............and you'll be sick in your stomach reading the results of the killings.
In fact I will type it up and post it in a couple of weeks....everyone should know the details of what happened in Lebanon.Please........either your a Jew or badly misinformed.
Such a comment is very irratating,
-
Rethinking The Costs Of Peace
By Josh Ruebnerhttp://www.countercurrents.org/ruebner250509.htm
By asking earlier this month for $2.775 billion in military aid to Israel in his FY2010 budget request, it would seem that on this important policy issue President Obama’s commitment is more rhetorical than substantive. Since 1949, according to the Congressional Research Service, the United States has provided to Israel more than $100 billion in military and economic assistance
========
As President Obama has stated, “We can't sustain a system that bleeds billions of taxpayer dollars, on programs that have outlived their usefulness or exist solely because of the power of politicians, lobbyists or interest groups. We simply can't afford it.” In regard to U.S. aid to Israel, this is true as much from a budgetary standpoint as it is from a moral one.
Josh Ruebner is the National Advocacy Director of the US Campaign to End the Israeli Occupation. This article was first published in Detroit Free Press
-
Human Rights Situation In Occupied Palestine
By Stephen Lendmanhttp://www.countercurrents.org/lendman250509.htm
At its tenth session this year, UN Human Rights Council (HRC) prepared a report titled: "Human Rights Situation in Palestine and other Occupied Arab Territories" and delivered it on March 20. It deals mainly with grave human rights violations in Occupied Palestine, especially due to Operation Cast Lead against Gaza
============
Gaza's Deepening Crisis
Years of Israeli incursions and blockade devastated Gaza's infrastructure, environment, and lives of 1.5 million people. The World Bank estimates that 98% of industrial operations are inactive, and around 70,000 workers lost their jobs since 2007. In December 2008, the UN's Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) estimated that 18 months of siege caused a 50% rise in unemployment, especially for women with only 11.5% of them employed in 2007, one of the world's lowest rates.
Suspending financial aid and tax transfers and revenues interrupted regular salary payments. Also, restrictions on currency transport caused a liquidity crisis enough to disrupt basic social services deliveries, forcing people to survive by any means possible.
During Operation Cast Lead, Israel inflicted destructive terror against a defenseless civilian population affecting vast numbers of non-military sites - hospitals and other health facilities, water and sanitation infrastructure, land and cellular communications networks, schools, universities, mosques, residential and government buildings, factories, commercial enterprises, farms, fishing boats, roads, bridges, transportation, power, UN buildings, and any living being that moved - all in gross violation of international laws.
Israel also willfully obstructed humanitarian personal leaving the poor, injured, and others without basic food, medical, and other essential services - crimes of war and against humanity under international .........
-
continued
Israel also willfully obstructed humanitarian personal leaving the poor, injured, and others without basic food, medical, and other essential services - crimes of war and against humanity under international law. Also, after hostilities ceased, the IDF continues obstructing humanitarian aid by maintaining its siege and restricting the work of civil society and human rights organizations.HRC states that for Gaza and its population to revive, "all of (its) entry points must be opened to ensure freedom of movement for all, the free inflow of industrial and agricultural inputs and cash and the export of products" to buyers outside the Territory. Also that urgently needed fuel, construction materials, spare parts, and other essential supplies and services be allowed to be received normally.
Further, recovery depends on Gazans having income-generating work, including inside Israel and the West Bank as available, and access to education at all levels at home and abroad. The many thousands of injured, homeless, and displaced require special attention and aid, so far not forthcoming because Israel won't allow it and international leaders are silently complicit.
Besides the above-listed needs, HRC stresses that "to improve the lives of (Gazans) living in poverty, psychosocial support....is urgently needed," especially for children who've been severely traumatized by months of deprivation and conflict. "The rights of the victims of human rights violations to have access to remedy and reparations must also be respected.
Adequate Housing As Part of An Acceptable Standard of Living........................
-
-
- Highr0ller
- 6 months ago
-
-
HRC Recommendations
Briefly they include:
-- Israel's cooperation with HRC investigators;
-- ending the siege;
-- allowing unimpeded access and safe passage for humanitarian aid, including food, medicines, fuel, agricultural inputs, construction materials, and whatever else is needed to sustain, rebuild, and revive the shattered Territory;
-- let sick and injured persons be treated abroad and in Israel;
-- let those wishing to do so travel and study abroad; and
-- end all violations of binding international laws and commit no breaches thereof - to include:
(1) abiding by the principles of distinction, proportionality, and precaution;
(2) ending the killing of civilians;
(3) no longer using human shields;
(4) ending extrajudicial assassinations;
(5) terminating the use of illegal weapons like white phosphorous; and
(6) prohibiting attacks on medical personnel, ambulances, hospitals, schools, civilian infrastructure, UN buildings, and other non-military sites.
HRC also calls on UN entities to assess Palestinian needs and contribute to the wide-scale reconstruction of Occupied Palestine, including the vast amount of damage done to Gaza. It also asks the international community for help through the Security Council, International Court of Justice, and UN human rights mechanisms - and for all states to abide by international humanitarian law and work to restore a battered Palestine. Holding Israel accountable for its war crimes is a good way to start.
Stephen Lendman is a Research Associate of the Centre for Research on Globalization. He lives in Chicago and can be reached at lendmanstephen@sbcglobal.net.
-
are there any liberals, agitators, activitists or homosexuals ???
-
-
- GodsnLiberals
- 6 months ago
-
-
I do not view the people of Iran, or their rulers, as threats to national security.
What little I know of Iran is that...the wealth of the nation lies in its people.
The people are progressive, well educated and intelligent. They are ready and able to enter into the new world that is unfolding before our eyes. -
Highr0ller I was not insulting you I am not saying that there is not educated people or victims in the middle east I am saying that the populous has resorted to violence to solve problems and spread religion not a wholley uncommon phenomanon around the world .That is why there is a lack of interest by the common person .If you look at life with a broader perspective you would not pick sides .It usually becomes an argument of land and beliefs .agian a lesson other countries learned quicker separation of religion and state.It only becomes complicated when you look at the individual problem and try to solve it.Does alot of horrific acts happen on both sides absolutely .I assure you that even without israel there would be wars
-
Based on my earlier post, you know where I stand on the issue, but I have a question regarding Hamas.
I' ve heard various hand-waving about the way in which Hamas conducts its fighting against Israel, namely within the occupied territories, in which schools, residential buildings and hospitals are often booby-trapped with controlled explosives while Palestinian civilians are still inside, so when IDF soldiers enter into building x containing non-combatants it is destroyed by Hamas detonating the explosives.
I know that the scenario in which circumstances have placed Hamas is desperate, but if this is true they can surely avoid their own human rights violations by using civilians as bait.
-
-
- Mattattack
- 6 months ago
-
-
the day i see AMERICAN STYLE liberal lifestyle being tolerated in Iran would I agree with Fareed Zakaria
If iran's nuclear program is not designed to built a weapon then why the secrecy??? why not bring in the brightest minds in this planet to help iran "build that power source"..
the proof is everywhere..where is your proof Fareed Zakaria
-
-
- GodsnLiberals
- 6 months ago
-
-
One more thing just because I mentioned crude tools of war does not mean I believe the general population is crude and uneducated.I was making a general point of their state of being right now.that also includes Israel.Just because a country is behind in the democracy time line does not mean their citizens are unintelligent. work in progress









