Why Teens Don't Use Twitter

// added July 13, 2009 // 28 comments //
Image...
shocksopping
Twitter seems to be the hottest thing in tech recently — if you look at TechCrunch, it averages at least 3 posts a week about Twitter. But the bigger question is, who is really using Twitter? Many of you might think that, as with most of the latest gadgets and technologies, teenagers are using Twitter, but you’re wrong, and here’s why. Matthew Robson, a 15 year old intern, over at Morgan Stanley, wrote a report on how teenagers are consuming media, and why Twitter isn’t the hot topic in high school halls.

If you look at technologies trending with teens right now, it’s Apple devices (iPhone, iPod), smart phones (Blackberry, Palm), and then social networks (Facebook and MySpace). At least that’s what I see from hanging out with 1,500 other teenagers in high school every day (I am 16 years old). But why not Twitter? Well, because Twitter is a different type of social network than Facebook. Facebook is about connecting people, and sharing information with each other. The way my friends and I see it, Facebook is a closed network. It’s a network of people and friends that you trust to be connected to, and to share information like your email address, AIM screen name, and phone number. You know who’s getting your status messages, because you either approved or added each person to your network.

With Twitter, it’s the exact opposite. Anyone can follow your status updates. It’s a completely open network that makes teenagers feel “unsafe” about posting their content there, because who knows who will read it. Sure, you get emails notifying you when you have new followers, but that doesn’t compare to the level of detail you get when someone on Facebook adds you, and you get their information.

According to June, 2009 comScore numbers, 11.3% of visitors to Twitter.com in the U.S. are ages 12-17. Internationally, in May, 2009, only 4.4% of visitors were younger then 18.

Twitter is also seen as more expensive to keep up with than Facebook. Most of my friends spend their time playing video games, watching TV, surfing online, and text messaging to actual friends who you know will reply back. In an economy like this, most parents don’t want to spend the extra money on unlimited texting to total strangers. So why spend money on sending SMS updates to Twitter, when you can send updates to someone you know will read it and reply?

Facebook has a more dedicated community than Twitter, which is why teenagers want to use it. Maybe the reason Twitter still isn’t considered mainstream quite yet is because Gen Y isn’t the early adopter this time around.
  1. groups:
    Tech,   Twitter,   Teens,   Twitterapps
  2. tags:
    Tech Twitter Teens Tech_Featured

28 comments // Why Teens Don't Use Twitter

  • happy3kmed
    • 0
      happy3kmed  
    • i like twitter, it makes me feel important. if im eating cornflakes at 2am on a thursday night, i want other people to know about it dammit!!

    • 7 months ago
  • cztheday
    • 0
      cztheday  
    • I agree with SG that Twitter, any other type of information medium, is useful to those with particular needs. If there are enough of those poeple, the medium will survive. If not, it won't. I don't use it and never have...but I don't see any reason to spend even 5 minutes of my life urging its demise. That issue will take care of itself -- unlike cleaning the garage, which is where I will be sleeping next week if I don't get out there as I promised I would...

    • 7 months ago
  • maurajriordan
  • TabulaRasa
    • 0
      TabulaRasa  
    • I think twitter is pretty much useless because Facebook can do pretty much the same thing. I have friends who update their status constantly like it's twitter. Good thing about facebook though is that you can comment on their status/links/videos and actually be able to connect/converse with them unlike twitter.

    • 7 months ago
  • jamieson
    • 0
      jamieson  
    • I'm usually too busy doing what im doing to tweet it on the internet.

      and i think if your living to tweet, then you're not paying attention, and you're not really living.

      but then again, in some parts of the world, a person having the chance to say something on the internet in 140 words or less can bring about the most significant changes.

      I guess it's is like any communication platform, its how you use it.

      I dont know why Current hasnt looked at developing their own take on status updates. Current is all about right now right? Nothing closer to now than status updates.

      but rather than "what are you doing right now?" the premise should be "what do you have to say?"

    • 7 months ago
  • astrollenium
    • 0
      astrollenium  
    • Forums and blogs like this site are much better. It's a two, three, fourway conversation etc. As far as I know you cannot reply to tweets directly on the page can you? I like how current is set up, anyways...

    • 7 months ago
  • KefKef
    • 0
      KefKef  
    • "and why Twitter isn’t the hot topic in high school halls."

      Because schools out (in the US anyway).

      I'll pass this to my facebook and see what their response is. The only reason I don't use it is because I don't have an iPhone and I didn't get the internet plan with my phone.

    • 7 months ago
  • Valence
    • 0
      Valence  
    • :/ Because its stupid,moronic,and annoying unless it has something of importance which is probably like 5% of the tweets.

    • 7 months ago
  • jessilee23
    • 0
      jessilee23  
    • I can't be limited to 140 word or characters....that's why I don't use it I have far too much to say. I would be constantly tweeting and I am pretty sure no one needs to hear me talk that much.

    • 7 months ago
  • sarahlane
    • 0
      sarahlane  
    • Agreed with @sgwhites... it all depends on how you use Twitter, and especially who you follow.

      Do I want to know what my Twitter friends are doing every second of the day? No. But the people I follow don't tweet that kind of info anyway. If they did, I'd unfollow them because they'd be ruining my experience (this has happened before, and unfollowing them solved everything).

      I follow people that I know and care about to keep up with them and get a chuckle here and there when they want to share an amusing anecdote, etc. They're my friends, so I'm into it. I follow a handful people that I don't know because they've proven to consistently post content I find useful in some way. I follow a handful of people who I just think are awesome (@trent_reznor, for example), and Twitter allows me a window into their lives I can't find anywhere else. Twitter is a tool that is at once amusing, helpful, and full of cool info, and can be constantly tweaked to filter out anything you don't like.

      Anyway, some people aren't going to like Twitter, and that's fine. But to say it's just a service for arrogant people who want to talk about what they are doing every second of the day is just not accurate. Just unfollow those people and you'll never have to think about them again!

      Ok, I feel better now.

    • 7 months ago
  • sgwhites
    • 0
      sgwhites  
    • I think, like anything else, whether you like Twitter or not depends a lot on your how you use it, if other people you know use it, and your daily routine.

      I wouldn't have used Twitter much as a teen; I wasn't online as much, cell phones didn't have internet, and I saw my friends every day.

      Now, I sit in front of a computer all day anyway, which makes checking Twitter easier, and I like to use it to keep up with my friends because we're spread out through different time zones which makes phone calls difficult.

      Plus--Twitter isn't really to be taken literally. Yes, sometimes it IS interesting to see what people are doing right then, but most people I know use it to have conversations, share links and pictures, and that sort of thing.

      If you're not a fan, that's fine, but why put in all the effort to bash something just because it's not your cup of tea? I don't get it.

    • 7 months ago
  • astrollenium
    • 0
      astrollenium  
    • sgwhites:

      You do make some good points. It's perfect for someone that is at a computer all day to see what people that are not at a computer are doing. It's almost as if you have all these personal reporters keeping you up to date on what's going on in their lives. It definitely can be useful, very useful. I think some people go overboard with it though.

    • 7 months ago
  • sgwhites
    • 0
      sgwhites  
    • sgwhites:

      I think it's largely a case of different tools for different situations. I, and most of my friends, are online quite a bit during the course of our day, so it's a good way to exchange random updates, send links, etc. My friends that work at jobs that keep them away from a desk, well, I usually keep in touch with them different ways! To me, Twitter is just one communication tool; it's not meant to replace or outstrip all others.

    • 7 months ago
  • TheDecemberists
    • 0
      TheDecemberists  
    • sgwhites:

      He isn't bashing twitter. He's just saying that teens don't use twitter... which they don't. It's a statistical fact.

      However, I AM bashing twitter. It's like facebook... but without all of the nice features! Twitter is lame lame lame!

    • 7 months ago
  • MirrorLake
    • 0
      MirrorLake  
    • Twitter is just too simple. I'd log in for a few minutes each day, usually less. Often times, I wouldn't log in for a whole week and none of the people I was following had updated. It was boring. Trending topics were semi-interesting, but usually just served as reminders that I wouldn't be seeing the new crappy comedy that was out and I wouldn't be watching the sports game that was on that night.

    • 7 months ago
  • shocksopping
    • 0
      shocksopping  
    • MirrorLake:

      I think this is another common problem with Twitter too; if you just follow people, or friends, you typically have a huge lack of reason to continue using it. If you follow news companies, blogs, or Techies (@KevinRose, @SarahLane, @NataliDelConte, @MorganWebb,etc), you can get lots of feed, full of useful and interesting information.

    • 7 months ago
  • MirrorLake
    • 0
      MirrorLake  
    • MirrorLake:

      Ultimately, the interesting 'feeds' I found were updated so regularly that they completely overshadowed my friends' updates. I would have to check each of their pages individually just to see if they had any new tweets. That was no fun. Not to mention that most strangers' profiles were in such cryptic shorthand that it was impossible to understand what they were talking about.

      The site just felt like one big inside joke.

    • 7 months ago
  • TentativeChaos
    • 0
      TentativeChaos  
    • The reason for me has nothing to do with security, or cost. For me, the reason I don't use twitter is that it seems like a stupid, and conceded thing to do. I don't know anybody that would give a rat's ass about what I'm doing every single moment of every day, and to be honest, if a such a person exists, I don't think I would like them.

    • 7 months ago
  • astrollenium
    • 0
      astrollenium  
    • TentativeChaos:

      I'm with you 100% man. It's too bad in this day and age people are so egocentric that they believe everyone wants to know what they are up to, as if they are some sort of celebrity. I know not all people use twitter for that reason and it can be used for real applications ie. the iran protests or something legit. I have only used myspace in the past, but not anymore. Not even facebook.

      My girlfriend's friend updates her twitter/facebook thing all the time. She even said that people "live their lives vicariously through her" and that's why she uses twitter. How can someone be so delusional?

    • 7 months ago
  • shocksopping
    • 0
      shocksopping  
    • TentativeChaos:

      There are of course people that believe that the world revolves around them who use Twitter. Those are people that I don't follow. But, you get the same type of things on Facebook, Myspace, or blogs. My streams for each one are almost always filled with people taking stupid quizzes, or posting about their newest photo shoot and how awesome they are. This is a problem you will get on every social network. Twitter, though it is not immune to this problem, makes it very easy to ignore those ego-posts, as I like to call them.

    • 7 months ago
  • astrollenium
  • bailey78
  • Panzer_Tanzler
  • dzn_daniel
    • 0
      dzn_daniel  
    • Image...
    • I completely agree with you,here is something on what your saying but a little bit more other stuff like that,just noticing thing on the web.

    • 7 months ago
  • nextweektuesday
  • metalcookiesxy70
  • mariahbarnum
    • 0
      mariahbarnum  
    • honestly, i don't use twitter because its basically the same thing as updating your status on myspace or facebook. why use another website to post what you are up to when you could use the same websites you usually do and just change your status?

    • 7 months ago
  • dzn_daniel
  • shocksopping
    • 0
      shocksopping  
    • mariahbarnum:

      For me, Twitter has more use than just letting people know what I'm up to. I'm able to stay ahead of the news, get the latest details on new games and software, etc, all by following the correct people. Yes, there are those that only update about the PB&J they just ate, but I intentionally don't follow those people.

    • 7 months ago

Add your comment

current videos