By Agence France-Presse
Monday, October 19th, 2009 -- 3:00 pm
Share on Facebook Stumble This! Email This Post Email This Post
Nobel winner slams Bible as handbook of bad moralsLISBON — A row broke out in Portugal on Monday after a Nobel Prize-winning author denounced the Bible as a "handbook of bad morals".
Speaking at the launch of his new book "Cain", Jose Saramago, who won the 1998 Nobel Prize for Literature, said society would probably be better off without the Bible.
Roman Catholic Church leaders accused the 86-year-old of a publicity stunt.
The book is an ironic retelling of the Biblical story of Cain, Adam and Eve's son who killed his younger brother Abel.
At the launch event in the northern Portuguese town of Penafiel on Sunday, Saramago said he did not think the book would offend Catholics "because they do not read the Bible".
"The Bible is a manual of bad morals (which) has a powerful influence on our culture and even our way of life. Without the Bible, we would be different, and probably better people," he was quoted as saying by the news agency Lusa.
Saramago attacked "a cruel, jealous and unbearable God (who) exists only in our heads" and said he did not think his book would cause problems for the Catholic Church "because Catholics do not read the Bible.
"It might offend Jews, but that doesn't really matter to me," he added.
Father Manuel Marujao, the spokesman for the Portuguese conference of bishops, said he thought the remarks were a publicity stunt.
"A writer of Jose Saramago's standing can criticise, (but) insults do no-one any good, particularly a Nobel Prize winner," the priest said.
Rabbi Elieze Martino, spokesman for the Jewish community in Lisbon, said the Jewish world would not be shocked by the writings of Saramago or anyone else.
"Saramago does not know the Bible," the rabbi said, "he has only superficial understanding of it."
The author caused a scandal in Portugal in 1992 with "The Gospel According to Jesus Christ."
The book depicted Jesus losing his virginity to Mary Magdalene and being used by God to control the world.
Saramago quit Portugal at the time and moved to Lanzarote, in the Spanish Canary Islands.
-
- groups:
- News, Culture, Booked, Controversial
-
- tags:
- + add
-
- recommended by:
- eldamon,
- Vierotchka
-
-
- RFIDemocracy
- added this
-
And the Gideons make certain there is one of these handbooks in every hotel room.
-
Oh yeah! I'm glad to live in a time when non-believers aren't afraid to step out and say what they are thinking. Religious types have had the podium for way too long! Time to charge the stage, I say!
Cheers to Saramago on this quote alone... 'he did not think the book would offend Catholics "because they do not read the Bible".'
It's about time everyone takes a hard look at the book that supposedly has the answer to all our ethical questions. Read it and you know that is far from true. (Hell, Shakespeare's canon has better ethical advice and is a more powerful examination of the human condition.)
-
If anyone's going to take the bible away, they should also take away the Talmud, Midrash, New Testament, Qur'an, Sunnah Islam, Nahjul Balagha Islam, Avesta and Vedas.
I know there's more, but any book suggesting or telling people how to live, makes it hard on everyone else!!
-
I just love that warning label, where can I get one?
LOL!!!
-
1. He is a Nobel Prize winner: I think we can assume this credit is worthless now. Sorry Obama fans; even if I did like his policies, "wanting" world peace is different from achieving it.
2. He is a crazy 86 year old and is making assumptions based on things that are not true. (i.e. The Bible isn't just about Cain and Abel.)
3. How could a book that 99.9% of the world doesn't read have an overwhelming effect on society. If anything, the lack of reading this book is causing "bad morals."
4. I agree this is a publicity stunt, and, as much as I hate to spur his continuity, this man wants one last shine of fame in his life before he buys the farm. After all, he won't be living after this life... -
This is a very sad commentary of people so intent on believing in nothing that they feel like they have to slander those who do. The bible is not just a book it's a collection of books. Don't confuse the acts of a few intending on perverting it's meaning for self gain as a litmus test for it's overall validity. It is the word of God, deal with it now or later.
God bless!
-
-
- 4and3and2and1
- 1 month ago
-
-
Hey, i believe in a God and Jesus... but the bible is misinterpreted by the people that swear by it. I went to many different churches and religions and always left with more questions than answers. Why? because they gave me their interpretation of what the Bible is or was. So if people don't know how to follow it or use it, then why have it?
AGAIN, people should not have any of these books!!!
-
The bible, and it's professional bigots, are disgusting!
-
Bible-haters are so narrow-minded!
-
Eh, just a book. I don't think the world would be better without it; it would be better if people didn't take it literally and distort its messages.
-
i always thought that penguins were the works of the devil because they are not in the bible!!
-
"religion is pimped-out superstition, designed to drug children with fears that they will endlessly pay to have alleviated"
for all those belittling this wise 86 year old nobel winner, i feel sorry for you, as does the universe. also, please watch "Zeitgeist" online (free), at least part one. might open up your perspective on this man you call jesus.
-
thank GOD someone finally said it. bible=B.S. ... another in the long line of religious hypocrisy...
people have always tried to connect with something greater than us we don't want to think we're the top of the food chain so we invent a god (a lie) and tell people we have a direct line to him. we can secure your next life in a good position, but only if you pay us your money in this life, every week. -
Would, have been better if it had been Obama
-
Winning a 'Nobel' prize is the same as a 'Darwin Award'. What a wasted of server space.
-
-
- My_America
- 1 month ago
-
-
No, it's not the same, one has to DIE to win a Darwin Award. So far, the Nobel Prizes are not posthumously awarded. Usually.
LOL!!
-
It's interesting that one of the main arguments I hear against the bible is that it spreads intolerance of others (gays, smokers, "sinners") and yet when it comes down to it all of these people spouting about tolerance have a deep seeded hate for Christians, it seems like.
I'm a lifetime Christian and I believe that's what makes me so accepting of other people and their ways of life.-
-
- yellowlyric
- 1 month ago
-
-
It's so strange how so many people take this post and this new book as a lever to put down a spiritual belief that some people feel within themselves.
Do so to the church but do not confuse that or any other dogma with faith.-
-
- lookatmypix
- 1 month ago
-
-
This makes me really, really sad. Let me just put this is simply, people will hate, kill, slander with or without a reason. The Bible did not cause this issues. In parts of the world where there was no bible, people killed, stole..and many more barbaric acts.
While the Bible has been used to justify extremes acts it has also brought joy and wonder to countless number of people. It has worked to change lives and ways we can not comprehend.
For everyone attacking the Bible and trying to destroy the faith of millions, your just proving that it certainly does not take reading the bible to be a hater.
-
“Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live”
ask the "witches" in Nigeria if the bible is a force for good.
"5 And they called to Lot, and said to him, Where are the men which came in to you this night? bring them out to us, that we may know them. 6 And Lot went out at the door to them, and shut the door after him, 7 And said, I pray you, brothers, do not so wickedly. 8 Behold now, I have two daughters which have not known man; let me, I pray you, bring them out to you, and do you to them as is good in your eyes:"
Basically sodomy bad, hetero rape cool.
There's also the homophobia & genocide. All & all the old testament is a guide to how we should all live. The New testament starts out alright, Jesus is cool enough, but then St.Paul balls's it up.
-
-
- capetan_omalley
- 1 month ago
-
-
Books are good. This is the number one book in the world--whether we like it or not. As literate people, we should all know its contents.
-
-
- samthesixth
- 1 month ago
-
-
It's simply a book, read it if you really want to as long as you don't look too hard into the messages you'll be okay. Maybe.
-
-
- Timmyeatworld
- 1 month ago
-
-
Sounds like hes saying that the Bible contains bad content, not bad morals, media can contain, and sometimes needs to contain bad content (sex, murder etc.) If he reads the bible and gets bad morals from it, its not interpreting it right, in fact it suggests HE has bad morals. Not that he doesn't say that Catholics or Christians have bad morals.
-
-
- Ciaran_Welch
- 1 month ago
-
-
Anyone who says ''i can't believe how non- believers can bash us". Take advise from your own book "do as you would do unto others". Christianity is all about putting down non-believers and has heretics and sinners.
On a side note any one who try's to make this book into science is sadly mistaken. In fact it was written well before modern science and is straight pseudoscience. Thus, why evolution is taught in school and creationism is not. Base your arguments off facts and not emotion.
-
-
- Devon_Oliver
- 1 month ago
-
-
Hate of religion is misplaced. In a world of atheists we'd have just as many wars, murders, rapes, and genocides because the simple fact is that violence has historically been a great problem solver.
If it wasn't for religion, then constitutions, morals, or "science" would have been used to justify all manner of wrong (as they often already have).






