Is an apology ever enough?

Zachrisson
Since the white people came to Australia the Aboriginals have suffered. They have been treated like animals, been showed off at freak shows and been separated from their loved ones. For more than 100 years up until the 1960s the government of Australia took Aboriginal children from their parents to give them a "white" and christian upbringing. This trauma is still affecting the young generation. The 13th of February 2008 Prime Minister Kevin Rudd made a historical speach where he apologized to "The Stolen Generation" for what they hade been put through.

We went out to "The Block", an Aboriginal community in Redfern, Sydney, to hear what the people there had to say about the apology, or what is now called "Sorry Day".
  1. groups:
    News and Politics,   Politics,   VC2 Top Contenders US,   Collective Journalism,   1 more
  2. tags:
    News and Politics Politics VC2 Top Contenders US Collective Journalism 2 more
  3. credits:
    Lisa Olsson co-producer
  4.     
    |
    Embed video:
    |

9 comments // Is an apology ever enough? // Video

  • Zachrisson
    • 0
      Zachrisson  
    • Thanks to all of you for commenting. I've been travelling so it took me some time to read and reflect.

      I don't mind constructive criticism at all, that can really help you to get better. And in a way I agree with some of the stuff you say Ando_SB. There could be more information about what happened but I don't like to have too many black slates in the beginning, takes too long before the you get to the actual story. And remember, this is not a pod about what happened to the Aboriginies, I'm sure that has been told many times. If that's what I wanted to do I would have done it in a very different way. This time I thought it enough to just point out that they were taken from their parents. The pod then deals with the reaction to the apology.

      I am sure that the pod could get better with more time spent on editing. Maybe I will look at it later and redo some things, but with the time I had I'm happy with the result. I can't really comment on the lack of continuity and finesse as I would need more details to understand your points.

      For me really constructive criticism is not just saying what is wrong, but how it could be made better.

      Anyway, a big thanks to everyone who took the time to watch and comment!

    • 4 years ago
  • islek
    • 0
      islek  
    • I can't speak for anyone specifically, but there are times when damage that has been done cannot be reversed. At least this generation of government acknowledges such mistreatment and understands it was wrong. It's a small consolation to what these people have endured, but it's a start. Thanks for making this pod.

    • 4 years ago
  • Neghie
    • 0
      Neghie  
    • Don't apologize for saying what you think. If I didn't like it, I probably would've been harsh, as I've been told. I say what I mean and never apologize...unless I was one of those white people who screwed the Aborigionese.

    • 4 years ago
  • Ando_SB
    • 0
      Ando_SB  
    • Neghie --

      You're totally right. She does a great job of talking to people and getting the scoop firsthand. I hope my comment didn't sound negative- I meant it in a constructive way!

    • 4 years ago
  • Neghie
    • 0
      Neghie  
    • I thought the pov was whats important here and she went straight to the source. It may lack the finesse it needs to be engaging, but better editing can take care of that, pacing is an issue. A great and relevant subject matter non-the-less.

    • 4 years ago
  • Ando_SB
    • 0
      Ando_SB  
    • Image
    • This pod lacks continuity. I understand the point, but it needs two minutes cut out of it. And there needs to be more information about that happened to this "Lost Generation" other than one woman saying that her relative wouldn't even talk about it.

    • 4 years ago
  • ronlee
  • jjmaster
    • 0
      jjmaster  
    • This is great reporting... but painfully familliar..

      What seems to have
      happened GrammySparkles, in regard to the Black/White issues is that New White
      Americans for Peace and Harmony, have moved away from racial discrimination and
      reached out with the olive branch of color blindness... However, due to the
      legacy of institutionalized racism, Blacks recognize that they have not had the
      same privileges as whites, and that they are still coming from behind.
      Therefore, the church which was a mobilizing entity for Black Community and
      civil rights in the past, is still sometimes used for social issues/reform. For
      instance, as a result of all of the ripple effects that Blacks have endured,
      many believe that the US government needs to pay Black Americans reparations for
      the crimes against them since their families were stolen from their Motherland
      and forced to build the economy here that made our White ancestors very rich
      "Men" and hugely contributed to the lifestyle that all Americans have benefitted from in some way. (Even though today, we have not maintained that wealth
      as good stewards would have). Hence, when Blacks see their men imprisioned, many
      of their communities impoverished and overrun with drug pushers (for lack of
      employment/education)... They remember Jim Crow, and hangings, and hoses... They
      remember, and they see that they still don't have complete equality, and they
      mobilize and they teach Afrocentric (something of their own to have and to hold
      onto) unification... and to White people it comes out as hateful and
      racist...and sometimes it is meant to be. It is a perpetual circle... I
      understand what is being said, and why... I however, do not like the tone or
      methodology because many Americans today just do not know enough about Black's
      current issues and might otherwise rally too, if it did not sound so segregated
      and hateful to them. Also, if the government really looked at the reparations
      that Black Americans deserve, it could not be paid... Some Blacks
      would just like an apology from the nation... But some say, that if our
      government even publically apologized to our Black people, it would allow for
      legal action. Hence, the discontent, and stalemate. We the street people need to
      talk, and apologize, and listen, and try in any small way, to make up for the
      horrors that have happened on all sides now. That does not, however, necessarily
      mean that we should vote for a person because of his/her race... In that regard,
      again I say, follow the money... We can figure out how much change we can expect
      by who is backing up our candidates financially... Our young people need to vote
      based on facts, not idealism. In my opinion. But I will add this footnote, I
      believe that with the trillions of waisted monies on this and other wars, we
      could have invested in the lives of our own citizens and rid America of its
      ghettos and suffering people. Shame on us! But, I still have a dream of
      egalitarianism. I do not believe that I am alone.

    • 4 years ago
  • sarahbelle
    • 0
      sarahbelle  
    • Really great work- compelling and important.

      I would like to invite you to submit this to our call for content in support of Silverdocs, if your piece is in the top five it will go to Silverdocs as well as have the option to get acquired for TV. All you have to do is add the tag "Current rocks silverdocs" send me a message if you have any questions.

      Thanks for uploading!

    • 4 years ago
more from News and Politics:

top videos