A soldier in Iraq decided to write about his experiences. He never suspected he'd start a war
source: http://www.radaronline.com/from-the-magazine/2008/08/scott_beauchamp_the_new_republic_scanda...
-
-
- Pericles_Lewnes
- added this
Soldiers at war rarely write magazine stories. But on July 13, 2007, a 24-year-old army private named Scott Thomas Beauchamp who had been serving in Iraq for about 10 months published a short, pseudonymous essay in the New Republic magazine that created a media firestorm.
"Shock Troops" is a grim first-person account of the dehumanizing aspects of war. In a tone vacillating between shame and detachment, Beauchamp, under the byline "Scott Thomas," recounts with squirm-inducing detail how he and his buddies were becoming so callous they openly mocked a gruesomely disfigured woman—the apparent victim of a roadside bomb—when she sat down for a meal in a military mess hall.
"I love chicks that have been intimate—with IEDs. It really turns me on—melted skin, missing limbs, plastic noses...," Beauchamp quotes himself as saying, loud enough so the woman could hear. He continues: "My friend was practically falling out of his chair laughing. The disfigured woman slammed her cup down and ran out of the chow hall." Playfully referring to her as the Crypt Keeper, they made her a running gag.
In another passage Beauchamp describes a fellow soldier picking up a hair-clumped fragment of human skull while digging at a military base and donning it "like a crown." As the soldier "marched around with the skull on his head, people dropped shovels and sandbags, folding in half with laughter." And then there was the private "who really only enjoyed driving Bradley Fighting Vehicles because it gave him the opportunity to run things over"—dogs especially. His preferred method was to "suddenly swerve and catch a leg or tail in the vehicle's tracks."
At a time when the military and the war's defenders were working hard to play up the achievements of Bush's troop surge, the New Republic's searing account of soldiers acting like sadistic teenagers was bound to raise a lot of hackles. The blowback began almost immediately.
Read the rest of this article at the link. It is NOT anti Troops. It is pro-reality.
-
- groups:
- News and Politics
-
- tags:
- News and Politics, Current TV, Iraq, Current Radio News, 11 more
-
- recommended by:
- Vierotchka
-
-
Cynic2
-
Beam us out of there, Scotty.
- 3 years ago
-
Cynic2
-
-
Denica_Cassandra
-
My ex-boyfriend went into the military when I broke with him. He told me that the guys he was training with all listened to death metal and couldn't wait "to run over people in their fighting vehicles." They all thought it was one big joke, like a video game since they wouldn't have the blood on them. While I respect the military, there is something fundamentally wrong with taking a human being and making it their job not to be human. Beauchamp is very brave to have written such an open account of what he experienced.
- 3 years ago
-
Denica_Cassandra
-
-
satanskidney
-
i like how we only seem concerned with the body count... lets just neglect the soldiers who come home with PTSD, commit suicide and other various mental conditions due to the war. as ive said before, violence begets violence.
- 3 years ago
-
satanskidney
-
-
Robroy1
-
You have an illegal invasion and an illegal occupation so where are the laws if there are any at all. You have more mercenaries than regular army who are not answerable to anyone what do you expect. This invasion has turned into a sick free for all with no laws or boundries. It is definitely an insane situation. If it were a legal war where America was attacked and our Army was defending America and its borders it would be a totally different story. When you have Bush and Co's total disregard for the Geneva Convention, the U.N. the laws of the American Constitution, kidnapping, secret jails, torture and no one holding Bush and Co. responsible what do you expext from a Army under this type of command where no one is held responsible for thier actions. Thank you Nancy Pelosi and a few others. Don't stop trying Dennis Kucinich. America must hold Bush and Co. responsible under the laws of our Constitution.
- 3 years ago
-
Robroy1
-
-
fiat_lux088
-
Normally I would add my insight, but everything I wanted to say was already posted, so great post
- 3 years ago
-
fiat_lux088
-
-
L4YER_CAK3
-
I'm a nurse in an ICU and one of the most important things I do is make sure people die with respect and dignity, but at the same time I can totally understand why some of the soldiers act like this because to a certain degree you disconnect yourself from the reality of the situation. Being asked to kill some one or in my case withdrawing care is not a natural thing to do. Thankfully my career as a lot of positives to offset this one negative. You can't expect that what these men /women are asked to do and see won't change them, for the better or worse. Facing your own mortality is hard especially when you are young.
- 3 years ago
-
L4YER_CAK3
-
-
bluestranger
-
L4YER_CAK3:
The stress must be terrible. But hit the point exactly. People that don't make these life and choices can more easily disconnect.
- 3 years ago
-
bluestranger
-
-
HiImGuss
-
It's like once you kill somebody, you don't feel as bad when you do other things that are morally wrong. You lose sympathy.
- 3 years ago
-
HiImGuss
-
-
sueathome
-
What the Hell do they think will happen to these solders when they send them into a killing field?
- 3 years ago
-
sueathome
-
-
onechance
-
War is MURDER FOR PROFIT. That is all. If you don't believe me or if my comment pisses you off, you haven't been paying attention.
The past has been dissected and the reasons for almost all wars have been fought solely for greed and Imperialism.
The poor die, the rich thrive.War is death.
PEACE NOW.
- 3 years ago
-
onechance
-
-
dazzleemdead
-
love that phrase at the end there,
pro-reality.i'm going to start using that.
- 3 years ago
-
dazzleemdead
-
-
pakazak
-
sorry peeved guy, beauchamp didn't recant.
COL. GIBBS: "He's standing by the stories, but the investigation from his buddies that worked with him and other investigations proved the allegations were incorrect, unfounded."so everybody else says he's wrong.........
- 3 years ago
-
pakazak
-
-
bluestranger
-
Your right Pericles, the article isn't about pro or anti troop. It also covers the dehumanizing aspect that war, any war, creates. More than anything though it is about lies. As is usually the case, people who send younger generations to war don't want to hear the grizzly details.
- 3 years ago
-
bluestranger
-
-
abbo
-
well said pericles
- 3 years ago
-
abbo
-
-
kadugen
-
Apologies asherp, I took you seriously. Colbert is pretty damn good sometimes. http://www.dailykos.com/story/2006/4/30/1441/59811
- 3 years ago
-
kadugen
-
-
pakazak
-
which is why the man is unfit for command. the navy obviously recognized it......
- 3 years ago
-
pakazak
-
-
LarzNero
-
Those horrifying anecdotes above are apparently what McCain finds hilarious, and if you dare question him about it, he says "Get a life."
- 3 years ago
-
LarzNero
-
-
kadugen
-
"Reality has a well known liberal bias" by asherp, has to be one of the dumbest things I have read in a long time. Quit being stupid, do yourself (and the world) a favor and stop categorizing everything as either Liberal or Conservative...
- 3 years ago
-
kadugen
-
-
Pericles_Lewnes
-
kadugen:
Asherp was qouting Stephen Colbert and I didn't pick up on it.
It's both funny and fucked up.
The funny thing is that Colbert is so amazing at 'being' a Kool-Aid drinking Righty. He said this at the 2006 White House Correspondents Dinner and it was dead on perfect. Asherp was just repeating it, and it was a good reference, I just didn't pick up on it.
The fucked up thing is that people actually say shit like this to me. It's more in the vein of someone telling me that I am choosing to take a "liberal's view of reality."
Asherp is a good person and I just misunderstood him.
I am just so frustrated about who divided this country is.
- 3 years ago
-
Pericles_Lewnes
-
-
Pericles_Lewnes
-
-
kadugen:
Colbert
- 3 years ago
-
Pericles_Lewnes
-
-
Argon18
-
kadugen:
But that is where "truthiness" gets you since if you "feel it in your gut" instead of checking out the facts then you can come to all sorts of conclusions like "Reality has a well known liberal bias"
So jumping to conclusions using "truthiness" can cause all kinds of misunderstandings like the one with mistaking the intent of that quote.
It is the insidious part of the concept that most people would rather rely on "gut instinct" and "emotional appeals" than take the extra steps to check out the facts to get at the "truth" and find out what the "reality" of the situation acutally is.
That is why Stephen Colbert uses it with examples to point out the dangers of going too far in accepting "truthiness" over getting at the "truth"
- 3 years ago
-
Argon18
-
-
phukna
-
i get to run dogs over!!
sht sign me up.it would give me the opportunity to realy
act out the line from silence of the lambsit puts the lotion on its skin (skull) !!!!
- 3 years ago
-
phukna
-
-
Vierotchka
-
I think there is a big difference in the way an aggressive and illegal war affects soldiers and a defensive and therefore justified war does. Those who fight to defend their country, their families, etc., from pillaging aggressors do not act the same way as do those who fight on the aggressor and pillaging side.
- 3 years ago
-
Vierotchka
-
-
WhiteNoise
-
VETERANS DEMAND CHENEY & BUSH CHARGED WITH WAR CRIMES
Now who will say these guys are unpatriotic...
The chicken hawks ?
* Iraq Veterans Against War seizes National Archives Building *
IVAW members seize National Archives Building in front of hundreds of surprised museum visitors. Response from visitors including teachers, students, vacationers was highly positive though there were a few horrified faces in the crowd. IVAW read the terms of our Citizens Arrest Warrant.
http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article19713.htm
Reminds me that...
VERMONT TOWNS BACK INDICTMENT OF BUSH & CHENEY
In Vermont, voters in the towns of Brattleboro and Marlboro approved measures Tuesday calling for the indictment of President Bush and Vice President Dick Cheney for crimes against the Constitution. The symbolic votes instruct the police department in each town to arrest Bush and Cheney or to extradite them for prosecution elsewhere if they ever step foot in the towns. http://www.commondreams.org/archive/2008/03/05/7476/
As if treason was not a reason enough anyway...
DYING REGIME 2
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZNuefnjwbJ0CHAOS = OPPORTUNITY = $$$$$
Greed & Fear Unlimited under the guise of Mindfuck Inc. rules…
"We must repudiate the structure of economic privilege and the tyranny of war makers" - George McGovern 1975
- 3 years ago
-
WhiteNoise
-
-
Bren589
-
found nothing funny about what happened.. these men of war need to be brought home. I would imagine some of them will need mental help to cope , this war needs to end.
- 3 years ago
-
Bren589
-
-
bansheewail
-
This behavior will be coming home at some point. If you think these men will be able to leave it all in the desert, keep dreaming. I think it's "trickle-down" morality. If the president can lie about the war, then.......anything goes.
- 3 years ago
-
bansheewail
-
-
Pericles_Lewnes
-
Not true Asherp. Reality is really politically agnostic.
Our soldiers are our warriors. They are trained to kill people and break things. There has to be a disconnect between the value of human life and ones own physical, mental, spiritual and emotional survival if they are to be effective in a warzone.
My uncle fought under Patton in World War 2. He enlisted right after Pearl Harbor with my dad and my other uncles. He saw a lot of action.
When I was a child, I would ask him to tell me stories. He never would.
Dont start this "reality has a liberal bias" bullshit with me.
What does that mean? I guess you are being sarcastic?
That quip makes me think you are a product of the insane media driven compulsion to be one sided. I piss off my liberal friends and I piss off my conservative friends, but I listen to what they have to say and I learn things. I even agree with YOU most of the time right here on Current.
Just vote the story down like the sock puppet you are or open your mind to endless possibilities of free and critical thinking.
Look this up:
"The aide said that guys like me were 'in what we call the reality-based community,' which he defined as people who 'believe that solutions emerge from your judicious study of discernible reality.' I nodded and murmured something about enlightenment principles and empiricism. He cut me off. 'That's not the way the world really works anymore. We're an empire now, and when we act, we create our own reality. And while you're studying that reality — judiciously, as you will — we'll act again, creating other new realities, which you can study too, and that's how things will sort out. We're history's actors … and you, all of you, will be left to just study what we do.' "
- 3 years ago
-
Pericles_Lewnes
-
-
asherp
-
Pericles_Lewnes:
Dude. I was quoting Stephen Colbert's address at the press dinner with the President. Chill.
- 3 years ago
-
asherp
-
-
Pericles_Lewnes
-
Pericles_Lewnes:
Sorry. A little too much coffee this morning.
- 3 years ago
-
Pericles_Lewnes
-
-
pakazak
-
Pericles_Lewnes:
Pericles1978
you are the reason that i served my country, you are the reason there is hope, you are the reason that we will rise above the stupidity of the past 8, hell, of the past 40 years.
there is no black and white, there are only shades of gray that we are constantly required to filter and judge.
we will survive. we will prevail.
thank you. - 3 years ago
-
pakazak
-
-
crob80227
-
The article was interesting because it showed the disturbing (almost hysterical) disconnect Republicans and Conservatives have from reality.
War is hell and living with death and suffering everyday wears soliders down -- that's not a slanderous "attack" against troops but an indisputable reality that has been documented in every war from World War II to Vietnam.
Had the Conservatives simply read the accounts and said, "Yeah. War is hell and we wish we didn't have to do it." -- it would have been a resonable position. They could have even done themselves a favor and used the article to drum up more political support for offering MORE mental health services for soilders.
But instead of dealing with reality in a mature, adult manner they decided to plug their fingers in their ears and mutter itsnottrue! itsnottrue! liberalshateamerica! over and over again like mental patient that need to be medicated and strapped to a hospital bed.
War is hell.
When you hear bad things you deal with them and offer help, not go into hysterical denial mode.
- 3 years ago
-
crob80227
-
-
asherp
-
crob80227:
The Democrats who voted for the war, and vote to keep funding it are just as messed up as the Republicans.
- 3 years ago
-
asherp
-
-
Incredulous
-
crob80227:
and your point is asherp???????
- 3 years ago
-
Incredulous
-
-
Wetdog
-
crob80227:
--------"Had the Conservatives simply read the accounts and said, "Yeah. War is hell and we wish we didn't have to do it." -- it would have been a resonable position. They could have even done themselves a favor and used the article to drum up more political support for offering MORE mental health services for soilders"--------
Look at the voting record. McCain is NO friend of the combat veterans. He has a 20% record of support for bills that would provide care for veterans or benefit active duty personell. HOW in the hell did people come off calling him a war hero? He's just a piss poor pilot is all.
By veterans group counts Obama has voted for 80% of bills that support veterans..
- 3 years ago
-
Wetdog
-
-
WhiteNoise
-
Everything in war is barbaric... But the worst barbarity of war is that it forces men collectively to commit acts against which individually they would revolt with their whole being. - Ellen Key
- 3 years ago
-
WhiteNoise
-
-
asherp
-
Pro-Reality, eh? Well, reality has a well known liberal bias.
- 3 years ago
-
asherp
-
-
Incredulous
-
asherp:
---not to be confused with a well known BLIND bias
- 3 years ago
-
Incredulous
-
-
CarlosIsDown
-
asherp:
Lol, I steal from Colbert too.
- 3 years ago
-
CarlosIsDown
-
-
Greenpointer
-
asherp:
How does a psychological defense mechanism denote liberalism? I mean, are you reacting to this nugget of hard truth in the same way these troops reacted to atrocities?
- 3 years ago
-
Greenpointer
-
-
Vierotchka
-
This war dehumanizes not only the Iraqis but also the US, UK and coalition troops.
- 3 years ago
-
Vierotchka
