"Lockerbie Bomber" Dies
-
-
- MolliBlum
- added this
Having always insisted his innocence of this crime, he was granted compassionate release by the Scottish government in 2009, shortly before his case was due to go to appeal on grounds of a report drawn up over several years by the independent Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission.
The SCCRC really does its homework -- and most cases presented by them are successful.
Even some of the victims' families, most notably Dr Jim Swire, who has dedicated years of his life to finding out what really happened to his daughter Flora, question Megrahi's conviction.
Will we ever know the truth now?
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-18137896
-
- groups:
- News and Politics, Entertainment, WTF, Technology, 1 more
-
-
CounterPoint [removed]
- This comment was removed as a violation of community guidelines.
-
CounterPoint [removed]
-
-
MolliBlum
-
CounterPoint:
Successive UK governments have refused to hold a full inquiry. The UK government has also tried to prevent publication of the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission report.
But the Scottish government is conducting an investigation. Let's see how far they get. - 12 months ago
-
MolliBlum
-
-
OlBlue
-
I remember when he was released, many were speculating that he didn't have cancer.
- 12 months ago
-
OlBlue
-
-
MolliBlum
-
OlBlue:
I remember when he was convicted, many were speculating that he didn't do it.
- 12 months ago
-
MolliBlum
-
-
MolliBlum
-
I have to log off now on this side of the pond -- but I do hope that other members of the Current community will stumble across this article and continue the debate by having their say, irrespective of whether they believe Megrahi was guilty or innocent.
There's so much more to this story -- including questions about the death penalty, compassionate release, and whether Libya was scapegoated...
I'll look forward to seeing what everyone has to say (if there are any more comments) in the morning.
Thanks for all the responses so far -- keep them coming!
- 12 months ago
-
MolliBlum
-
-
Incredulous
-
It is hard enough for Americans to know if their leaders are telling the truth about anything that goes on in this country, let alone what goes on elsewhere. I don't doubt that Megrahi could have been innocent, it happens all the time here in the US, at least he wasn't extradited to Texas, where only the powerless are ever found guilty.....and then they are executed.
- 12 months ago
-
Incredulous
-
-
MolliBlum
-
Incredulous:
Yes -- I'm very glad that we don't have the death penalty in Europe. Not only because innocent people may die, but also because it serves absolutely no purpose whatsoever, (except, perhaps, vengeance).
There is plenty of evidence to suggest that this particular conviction was "unsafe".Before his release on compassionate grounds, Megrahi had been granted an appeal (in Scotland this is recommended by an independent commission). This appeal was never heard. The UK government prevented the Scottish parliament from publishing the grounds for appeal.
- 12 months ago
-
MolliBlum
-
-
Progresshiv [removed]
- This comment was removed by its owner.
-
Progresshiv [removed]
-
-
MolliBlum
-
Progresshiv:
True. But there is no need to add to the suffering of the victims' families by presenting them with a politically convenient scapegoat when they deserve nothing less than the truth.
- 12 months ago
-
MolliBlum
-
-
cztheday
-
Progresshiv:
I didn't follow the trial closely enough to express an opinion as to whether this man was guilty or not guilty (there is no such thing as a finding of "innocence"). I know for certain, however, that airline bombers are among the most cowardly scum on the planet.
- 12 months ago
-
cztheday
-
-
TanzaniteDiamonds
-
Thanks for posting this, Molli.
Your submission of this story prompted me to search for more info regarding the Compassionate Release Program. This was one of many:
- 12 months ago
-
TanzaniteDiamonds
-
-
MolliBlum
-
TanzaniteDiamonds:
Yes, as the article states:
"The Scottish legal system permits compassionate release for terminal illness. There are only a few applications per year, and most are granted."
So, as far as the "compassionate release" part of the story goes, this was entirely above board, and not even uncommon, due to his medical diagnosis. The Scottish government had already refused to go along with the UK government's request to include Megrahi in a "prisoner transfer" deal, which would have been based on the presumption of Megrahi's guilt.
So this was a relatively elegant and low-key solution to what might otherwise (had his appeal gone ahead) have proved a rather embarrassing scenario for both the US and the UK.
- 12 months ago
-
MolliBlum
-
-
TanzaniteDiamonds
-
MolliBlum:
Very interesting, Molli. I also found this link:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/scotland/7909248/US-preferred-compassiona...
- 12 months ago
-
TanzaniteDiamonds
-
-
MolliBlum
-
TanzaniteDiamonds:
Well, now -- thanks for that. That really IS an interesting link. I hadn't seen it.
The Telegraph (aka "Torygraph" in the UK) is a very conservative and predominantly pro-US publication, so to see even the Telegraph stating that "The US Government told Scottish officials that the Lockerbie bomber's release on compassionate grounds was ''far preferable'' to his transfer back to a Libyan jail" is quite astonishing, and telling. - 12 months ago
-
MolliBlum
-
-
KSirys
-
TanzaniteDiamonds:
Thank you for email Tanzanite! It's a great story to do some research on.
- 12 months ago
-
KSirys
-
-
TanzaniteDiamonds
-
KSirys:
You're welcome, KSirys.
- 12 months ago
-
TanzaniteDiamonds
-
-
MolliBlum
-
TanzaniteDiamonds:
Just thought I should add this link to a Scottish government website listing the "compassionate release" cases granted. As you can see, these include people serving life sentences for murder:
http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Topics/Justice/legal/lockerbie/CompassionateReleasePr...
- 12 months ago
-
MolliBlum
-
-
kennymotown
-
Sounds like he must have really had Cancer. Oh well, someone evil like this should have left the planet a while back!
- 12 months ago
-
kennymotown
-
-
MolliBlum
-
kennymotown:
It's not at all clear that he was ever guilty in the first place.
I'd hold back with the word "evil" there... - 12 months ago
-
MolliBlum
-
-
kennymotown
-
MolliBlum:
According to the legal system he was!
- 12 months ago
-
kennymotown
-
-
MolliBlum
-
kennymotown:
Well, yes... but have you never heard of a "miscarriage of justice"?
Scotland is rightly proud of its judicial system, but nobody is perfect -- and this case had more holes than a Swiss cheese - 12 months ago
-
MolliBlum
-
-
MolliBlum
-
kennymotown:
Is the legal system infallible?
- 12 months ago
-
MolliBlum
-
-
kennymotown
-
MolliBlum:
Nope, but the Military Industrial Complex sure is. :)
- 12 months ago
-
kennymotown
-
-
MolliBlum
-
kennymotown:
LOL... can't disagree on that, kenny!
- 12 months ago
-
MolliBlum
-
-
kennymotown
-
MolliBlum:
It's all tied together, add the Religious factor and you've got a huge war of soft minds. :(
- 12 months ago
-
kennymotown
