vanguard blog | April 05, 2010 | 16 comments

What 60 Minutes Missed in Uganda AIDS Story

This past weekend, 60 Minutes aired a story about the $15 billion anti-AIDS initiative known as PEPFAR, the US President’s Emergency Plan for Aids Relief, which was launched by President Bush in 2003. For the story, correspondent Bob Simon traveled to Uganda, a country that has lost more than a million lives to AIDS and has since benefited greatly from PEPFAR.

But I noticed one glaring omission in the piece. When Simon interviewed Pastor Martin Ssempa, one of Uganda’s most well-known Christian ministers, he failed to mention Ssempa’s role in the country’s controversial anti-gay bill.

It’s true that Ssempa has been one of Uganda’s leading HIV activists and that over the years his preaching of an abstinence-only approach has made him a darling of many US evangelicals. But more recently, Ssempa has become the Pied Piper of Uganda’s anti-gay campaign, leading rallies and protests to push the legislation through.

We're in the process of editing the piece we shot on Uganda's anti-gay bill for the upcoming season of Vanguard. And where the two stories intersect is over the question of what effect anti-gay legislation might have on the fight against HIV/AIDS in Uganda.

Many health care professionals we spoke to worry that the bill could have a very negative impact on whatever strides the country has made to combat HIV/AIDS. We’ll be exploring this question and more in the upcoming documentary.

Follow the Vanguard team on Twitter.

Also on the Vanguard blog:

+ Tutu: In Africa, Human Rights Moving "Backwards"

+ Ugandans Rally In Support Of Anti-Gay Legislation

+ Wrapping Up in Uganda

+ Uganda in Pictures

  1. groups:
    Community,   vanguard blog,   Mariana van Zeller,   VG-blog-MVZ
  2. tags:
    News News and Politics Africa GLBT 12 more
  3.     
    |

16 comments // What 60 Minutes Missed in Uganda AIDS Story

  • zakthezomb13
    • 0
      zakthezomb13  
    • hopefully we will see an end soon..."jesus the white" will come back and he will be riding a horse and swinging a sword killing all the gays and free thinkers and orcs and trolls and saurons reign will end...so just sit back close your eyes close your mind and start to believe in something you dont know anything about because it comforts your fear...HAPPY EASTER GANGSTERZZZZZZZ!

    • 2 years ago
  • CaptB
    • 0
      CaptB  
    • I often wondered about the actual medications given to Africa. I saw two pills? Isn't it a cocktail that HIV/AIDS victims receive to benefit them the most? If only two medications are used is that the full regimen that the Worlds Aids Doctors recommends? Or are they just happy to be receiving any medications?

      Do the doctors receive any training at all on prescribing the medications? I am questioning the efficacy of these drugs if not given properly.

    • 2 years ago
  • ampersand
    • 0
      ampersand  
    • I've always wondered exactly who were the recipients of George Bush's biggest last minute giveaway (next to Halliburton, that is.)
      Next bit of free time (ha!) I'll have to immerse myself in US AID grant documents. Call me silly, but I have the strange unshakable suspicion that a lot of obscurely connected fundamentalist Christian groups got on this money teat.
      Anyone out there familiar with how this actually went down in Africa?

    • 2 years ago
  • booninvailable
  • Saladin
  • Darlink
  • common_sense_please
    • 0
      common_sense_please  
    • It seem that if the 60 Minutes correspondent took the time to interview Pastor Ssempa he should have asked him about the anti-gay bill. It would not have been any more of a "sidetrack" because he was already being interviewed about how his country and their government is dealing with the large number of people with AIDS and the proposal to jail and possibly kill people with HIV/AIDS who may or may not actually be gay is a part of the government's plans or discussions on how to deal with it.

      That and if Uganda does pass this legislation and decides to kill people for being gay--and also takes money from PEPFAR which I am guessing contains some tax payer money--then including a discussion about this proposed legislation is just as relevant as Mr. Stupak being interviewed about his position that tax payer money should not be allowed to fund abortions and covering how he essentially coerced President Obama into signing an executive order to that end in exchange for his vote was to the health care reform debate here in the United States.

    • 2 years ago
  • outtheinside
    • +1
      outtheinside  
    • the video is on a policy set in place to stop the spread of AIDS. it sidetracks to interview the well known pastor and his opinion on youngsters getting knowledge of AIDS. it would be another degree of sidetracking to mention the pastors involvement in anti-gay legislation. a video on U.S. policy helping Uganda AIDS prevention that includes information on a Ugandan Pastor's efforts for criminalizing homosexuality would seem to slant the plot. as interrelated as they may be, you can't cover everything. i'm not arguing based on importance. i'm arguing based on related material.

      Now, if the video were on "Battling AIDS in Uganda", then you'd have a point about missing information, but the video is about American taxpayers and PEPFAR's successes.

    • 2 years ago
  • BrokenTruth
  • ii386
  • JosephJinx
    • 0
      JosephJinx  
    • BrokenTruth:

      But he doesn't like oranges?

      "The African nation of Uganda proposed an Anti-Homosexuality Bill on 13 October 2009 that would, if enacted, broaden the criminalization of homosexuality by introducing the death penalty for people who have previous convictions,are HIV-positive, or engage in same sex acts with people under 18 years of age. The bill also includes provisions for Ugandans who engage in same-sex sexual relations outside of Uganda, asserting that they may be extradited for punishment back to Uganda, and includes penalties for individuals, companies, media organisations, or non-governmental organisations that support LGBT rights." - from WikiPedia

      You know, you're right. I guess we shouldn't be griping about his dislike of "oranges". What a crock of shit. He saves people, then supports a law that will put them to death if they're gay, even if he's helped them/saved them from their HIV condition. Real, true compassion, there.

    • 2 years ago
  • phoe1
    • 0
      phoe1  
    • yea but you have to realize that gay people are probably still the biggest group being made responsible for spreading AIDS not only in uganda but in most parts of the world. therefore asking him about his stand relating to the bill would have been valid. the church is using the aids issue to try and discriminate against gay people (again not just in uganda).

    • 2 years ago
  • violintastic
    • +2
      violintastic  
    • Maybe they didn't touch on it because this story was about AIDS and the benefit of PEPFAR in Ugandan communities. They only have about 15 minutes to get the full story in, sidetracking to different issues might not have been in the best interest of 60 Minutes.

    • 2 years ago
  • JosephJinx
    • 0
      JosephJinx  
    • violintastic:

      Agreed. Any extra input, as the role that the anti-gay legislation would have on the fight against HIV/AIDS, is more than appreciated, and I'm looking forward to hearing about it. However. as violin said, they simply may not have been able to cover all sides within the 15 minute TV spot.

    • 2 years ago
MarianaVanZeller

top videos