Bono's net policing idea draws fire
-
-
- spacemikey [removed]
- added this
He hinted that China's efforts prove that tracking net content is possible.
The editorial drew sharp criticism, both on its economic merits and for the suggestion of net content policing.
"The immutable laws of bandwidth tell us we're just a few years away from being able to download an entire season of '24' in 24 seconds," he wrote.
"A decade's worth of music file-sharing and swiping has made clear that the people it hurts are the creators...the people this reverse Robin Hooding benefits are rich service providers, whose swollen profits perfectly mirror the lost receipts of the music business."
In a move that drew significant criticism, Bono went on to suggest that the feasibility of tracking down file-sharers had already been proven.
"We know from America's noble effort to stop child pornography, not to mention China's ignoble effort to suppress online dissent, that it's perfectly possible to track content," he said.
Several commentators assailed both the logic of net monitoring and the economic arguments of the essay, pointing out that U2 topped 2009's list of top-grossing live acts.
"Bono has missed that even a totalitarian government...can't effectively control net-content," tweeted Cory Doctorow, a blogger and journalist noted for his study of file-sharing policy.
"If only greed and ignorance could sequester carbon, Bono could FINALLY save the planet," he added.
-
- groups:
- Community, Music, Tech, Technology, 2 more
-
- tags:
- File Sharing, Bono, bono saves the planet
-
-
Maitereya
-
Die bono!!!
- 2 years ago
-
Maitereya
-
-
clish1
-
Why do we allow him to be so relevant outside the entertainment field? He's a singer, for Chrissakes, not a statesman, pope or resident genius. Just make some good music, which I don't think he has for a while.
- 2 years ago
-
clish1
-
-
skyking3525
-
clish1:
Because the majority of the public LOVES him. They would kiss the ground he walks on.
- 2 years ago
-
skyking3525
-
-
smallgod
-
What a huge piece of shit that guy is. Oh, you can't buy the most upgraded new G5 this year? Poor deserving baby!
- 2 years ago
-
smallgod
-
-
Sam_the_Wizer
-
I think that file sharing and the proliferation of freely available music on the internet has done nothing but help artists and bleed off the bloated record company monopolies that had strangled the industry through the 90's. If Bono's so concerned, perhaps he should find a new profession.
- 2 years ago
-
Sam_the_Wizer
-
-
gringoninjo
-
Sam_the_Wizer:
He did. He's probably campaigning to have 'Professional Tosser' legitimised for his tax-returns.
- 2 years ago
-
gringoninjo
-
-
jac1992
-
Bono used to be allright, but since the floods in ireland, I have realised he really is a git.
He will campaign to send money over to Africa and the third world, but when his own country gets hit by floods he is nowhere to be seen
- 2 years ago
-
jac1992
-
-
skyking3525
-
jac1992:
Right on Jac1992. Did you ever see the footage of him in Africa? Walking through the poorest villages in the country, wearing Gucci glasses in slacks and loafers, commenting on how sad it was to see all of those poor Africans.
He's a butt-head...
- 2 years ago
-
skyking3525
-
-
thewarnerla
-
jac1992:
This point couldn't have been said better. No one helps out the home-front anymore, its always about helping those in Africa, where our money's return only comeback in terrorist fashion.
- 2 years ago
-
thewarnerla
-
-
revolutioninamerica
-
bono fuck off you piece of shit
- 2 years ago
-
revolutioninamerica
-
-
CarolineS
-
revolutioninamerica:
i'll second that!
- 2 years ago
-
CarolineS
-
-
cynker
-
if you compete with technology society will not progress.
what ever will we do without the music and film industires, the same which target teenagers by dictating what they should watch or listen to, in order to 'fit in'.
Music and film have only existed in their marketed form for around 100 years, whereas performance and music has been around since the dawn of man.
This man is not an artist he is the head of an company known as U2 - 2 years ago
-
cynker
-
-
RaceBannon
-
cynker:
[applauds]
correct the art in music is coming back, not the businessman.
- 2 years ago
-
RaceBannon
-
-
nursediesel
-
cynker:
Agreed, if you're any good as a musician downloaders will buy your product and frequent your shows.
Bono's a moaner!
At least now most great musicians actually see monetary benefit in their lifetimes. - 2 years ago
-
nursediesel
-
-
surrealconcepts
-
cynker:
very cool, I applaud your comment as well! I'm an artist and know the value of keeping the creativity separate from the business, because business can thwart the creativity. I've been saying that business's only purpose is to stay alive, whereas creativity is meant to keep your soul alive. Big difference.
- 2 years ago
-
surrealconcepts
-
-
lordsbassman
-
Not even worth downloading his shit..
- 2 years ago
-
lordsbassman
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
Bono is a wanker. His megalomania is tiresome.
- 2 years ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
SuperMatt
-
EdJoyProductions:
I agree! The only thing download hurts is the already fat wallets of rich egomaniacs like him. He doesn't need any more money!!
- 2 years ago
-
SuperMatt
-
-
IndigoAnonymous
-
EdJoyProductions:
I agree very much...he's always come across as a pretentious prick to me.
- 2 years ago
-
IndigoAnonymous
-
-
skyking3525
-
EdJoyProductions:
I just can't stand that man. His ego is about two sizes too big.
- 2 years ago
-
skyking3525
-
-
Darlink
-
EdJoyProductions:
Matt do your research sweetheart. Free downloading hearts everyone. If the musishons don't get payed then they can't hire people, for example a hare stillest. Well if (S)he can't get payed then (s)he can't buy cloths or food and that two more indastrys down
OK so that may not be the best example but my point is artest make more people money than thimselvs
Oh and if anybody bitches about my spelling I will find you..........and kill you
- 2 years ago
-
Darlink
-
-
Incredulous
-
EdJoyProductions:
I like the way Bono is willing to sacrifice everyone's net freedom so his profit margin will be safe...what a tool.
- 2 years ago
-
Incredulous
-
-
Ares
-
EdJoyProductions:
Darlink: Do your research, honey. Go take an English class. I can't even tell what the hell you're talking about.
- 2 years ago
-
Ares
-
-
Darlink
-
EdJoyProductions:
Your problem not mine A
- 2 years ago
-
Darlink
-
-
Ares
-
EdJoyProductions:
I mean, I guess so? Do you go to Icelandic web forums and post in English, then tell them it's their problem that they can't understand you? I'm just trying to clarify what exactly it is you're talking about, because your first comment was pure gibberish.
- 2 years ago
-
Ares
-
-
Tyler_Roberts
-
EdJoyProductions:
I didn't know there was such a large rabbit grooming Industry. lol
- 2 years ago
-
Tyler_Roberts
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
EdJoyProductions:
LOL Tyler.
Darlink, I am far more dangerous than you are so the threat of your killing me is not going to stop me from saying this: Not only is your spelling terrible (which there is really no excuse for because there is spell check) but your incoherence is not going to be helpful in your search for a job. I am not saying this to be mean. I am offering constructive criticism. Brush up on the English skills, kid. It makes you a more formitable candidate for employment. - 2 years ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
AmericanTerr0rist
-
EdJoyProductions:
formitable? hahaha
- 2 years ago
-
AmericanTerr0rist
-
-
EdJoyProductions
-
EdJoyProductions:
LOL. Okay mine was a typo and i will even leave it for the joke's sake, but at least my statement is coherent.
- 2 years ago
-
EdJoyProductions
-
-
wehat
-
Poor Bono, next time I see him at a stop light in his Maserati Quattroporte I'll be sure and toss the guy some change.
- 2 years ago
-
wehat
-
-
UWAZell
-
wehat:
Yes, when I read the statement, 'A decade's worth of music file-sharing and swiping has made clear that the people it hurts are the creators...' I thought to my self, yes, you're real 'hurt'.
- 2 years ago
-
UWAZell
-
-
jubal
-
Music is knowledge, and knowledge should be free to all thinkers.
- 2 years ago
-
jubal
-
-
Darlink
-
jubal:
Britney and the Jonas brothers are NOT knowledge
- 2 years ago
-
Darlink
-
-
lopinjop
-
jubal:
Darlink makes a great point :l
- 2 years ago
-
lopinjop
-
-
CalgarC
-
jubal:
i will believe this statement the day i see soulja boy answer a mathematical equation lol...
- 2 years ago
-
CalgarC
-
-
CarolineS
-
jubal:
Your all forgetting that the Jonas brothers, miley cyrus, britney, soulja boy and many many more alike should not be considered as music, i think that's what jubal meant, at least thats what i hope!
- 2 years ago
-
CarolineS
-
-
artemis6
-
jubal:
yeah , what is pushed on children in place of music these days , is just .... embarrassing .
- 2 years ago
-
artemis6
-
-
lifestudentno83
-
jubal:
Not only is that what's pushed on children, but they also want them to PAY for that sugar-coated, bubblegum pop, brain rotting excuse for so-called music.
- 2 years ago
-
lifestudentno83
-
-
smallgod
-
jubal:
and superman that hoooe!
- 2 years ago
-
smallgod
-
-
Damien_M
-
jubal:
There is music for music's sake (netlabels under Creative Commons) and music for business (Bono, Cyrus, Spears, etc...). People like Bono and James Hetfield are up in arms over file sharing because they have lost sight of why they got into music in the first place and can only see dollar bills.
It's all about the Benjamins. - 2 years ago
-
Damien_M
-
-
jubal
-
jubal:
I am a Musician, and I create music for arts sake. Sure when I was young I dreamed of being as famous as Bono, but I quickly realized what whores the music business has become and the crap that passes for art these days is truly questionable. Several of you have already named a few. They are formulas and gimmicks. I am talking about music that has a message, moves you to laughter or tears, music that lifts your soul to a higher place.
If any of you care to check out my music you can find it at http://www.myspace.com/jonjaramillo
- 2 years ago
-
jubal
-
-
artemis6
-
jubal:
You are good !
- 2 years ago
-
artemis6
-
-
xiola
-
jubal:
wow, jubal! Really cool sound! Thanks for sharing. You have a very good voice. Are you playing guitar too? :)
- 2 years ago
-
xiola
-
-
jubal
-
jubal:
Xiola, I play keyboards and synthesizers. So all the voices and instruments are me. But the guitar is my dear old friend and producer David Waterbury.....http://www.linkedin.com/in/davewaterburyproductions. His group is called the XOTX (exotics)
- 2 years ago
-
jubal
-
-
xiola
-
jubal:
Well, jubal, it's really good music! I'm a fan :)
- 2 years ago
-
xiola
