Tech | February 10, 2012 | 75 comments

Opposition rising against U.S. Arctic drilling

Image
JanforGore
Drilling in the Arctic waters of the U.S. may become as contested an issue as the Keystone Pipeline XL in up-coming months. Scientists, congress members, and ordinary Americans have all come out in large numbers against the Obama Administration's leases for exploratory drilling in the Beaufort Sea and the Chuckchi Sea.

Last month 573 scientists signed a letter against opening the Arctic up to drilling until more research can be done in the sensitive area. In addition, a letter signed by 60 Congress members has been sent to Interior Secretary Ken Salazar noting that the Deepwater Horizon disaster occurred only two years ago. Finally, nearly half a million Americans (400,000) signed a petition against drilling in the Arctic. Critics of the Obama Administration's leases say there is no coherent plan to clean-up a spill in the icy, remote Arctic ecosystem, which already embattled by climate change.

"The Arctic is the last wild ocean on the planet. Its waters and the abundant life they support are simply too sensitive to be drilled—especially since neither the oil industry nor scientists have identified a proven way to contain or clean up a spill in the Arctic’s extreme conditions," Chuck Clusen, Alaska Project Director with the Natural Resources Defense Council, said in a press release. "At the very least, there should be no plan to lease these areas until key scientific studies have been done and until the oil and gas industry can demonstrate its ability to contain and clean up a spill."

The letter from scientists asked the administration to "to follow through on its commitment to science" by following recommendations made by the United States Geological Survey (USGS) and refrain from drilling until more research can be done.

Still, drilling in the Arctic could begin as early as this summer by Royal Dutch Shell. The oil company argues that it has a meticulous oil-response plan even given the intense conditions of drilling in the Arctic, including response vessels standing by. Shell Alaska Vice President Pete Slaiby told the Associated Press that the company would be ready with a capping stack, similar to what was used to stop the Gulf oil spill in 2010 after the well leaked for three months.

Critics of Arctic drilling argue that given the extreme weather conditions, icy waters, and the remoteness of any oil well, it would currently be impossible to clean-up an oil spill adequately. Furthermore, clean-up efforts would almost certainly have to stop during the long Arctic winter. Currently the federal government is asking Shell to stop operations 38 days before the seasonal sea ice would arrive to make certain an oil spill doesn't occur at the end of the season. Shell is trying to overturn this ruling.

"If the Obama administration were making its decision based on science rather than politics, drilling in the Arctic would be a nonstarter," Rebecca Noblin, the Alaska Director with Center for Biological Diversity (CBD). "The Arctic Ocean is America’s last best wilderness. Launching massive industrial drilling operations risks America’s Arctic legacy for oil company profits."

Read more: http://news.mongabay.com/2012/0209-hance_arctic_drilling_us.html#ixzz1m0w4myDx

http://photos.mongabay.com/j/oil.drilling.shell.arctic.568.jpg
  1. groups:
    News and Politics,   Tech,   Green,   Earth and Science,   7 more
  2. tags:
    Culture Climate Change Oil Pollution 10 more
  3.     
    |

75 comments // Opposition rising against U.S. Arctic drilling

  • Wetdog
    • +2
      Wetdog  
    • We do not need oil.

      We can drive our vehicles with biofuels.

      Biofuels are clean, safe, non-toxic, do not contribute to atmospheric warming, are inexpensive to use, allow the use of far more thermally efficient engines, and are renewable and sustainable. We can make as much as we need for as long as we need them.

      We do not need to import biofuels. Biofuels can be made by workers right here in the US, using raw materials and resources that are just going to waste right now. We can make biofuels out of any kind of waste biomass at all---including sewage and landfills. It is being done right now.

      We do not have to fight wars, destroy the air, waters, land and public health to make or use biofuels. We do not have to have the economic damage of over $600-$800 billion a year trade deficits from using petroleum.

      There are already vehicles in manufacture, on sale and in use by consumers on the road that can use petroleum, petroleum and biofuel mixtures, or no petroleum at all---ever.

      We need to mandate that all new vehicles sold in the US have multi-fuel engines that are biofuel capable.

      We need to stop ALL permits and sales of drilling leases on publicly owned lands and waters.

      We need to charge a $50/brl import tariff on crude oil and finished petroleum products.

      We do not need oil.

    • 3 months ago
  • Truthitswhatsfordinner
  • Wetdog
    • +1
      Wetdog  
    • Image
    • Truthitswhatsfordinner:

      The very first engine that Rudolf Diesel built in 1893 ran on peanut oil.

      Synthetic oil.

      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synthetic_oil

      Diesel engines can be driven completely petroleum free by the use of B100 biodiesel, methane(CNG, compressed natural gas) or both can be used in the same engine.

      With the use of synthetic oils available on the market right now(they've been around since the 1940s)----diesel engines can run completely petroleum free.

    • 3 months ago
  • Truthitswhatsfordinner
    • +1
      Truthitswhatsfordinner  
    • Wetdog:

      I am in the alternative energy business and B100 is very promising but it is not yet there as far as being widely available. I have to fill up at work. B100 has also caused some engine damage depending on what feedstock is used. We have high hopes for it, but it's a bit off in the future. I could use synthetic oil in the car and we do in the vw. It has been run on nothing but bio and synthetic. Our older 1972 diesel is the one that I have to be careful with--very finicky. I ran synthetic in only once and it did not do well.

    • 3 months ago
  • Wetdog
    • 0
      Wetdog  
    • Truthitswhatsfordinner:

      During WW2, 70 years ago, Germany used synthetic diesel fuel made from wood and coal by the Fischer-Tropsch process to power everything from submarines, to panzer tanks, to jet aircraft.

      I have no doubt that we can make it work today.

    • 3 months ago
  • Truthitswhatsfordinner
    • +1
      Truthitswhatsfordinner  
    • Wetdog:

      I too think we could make many of the available technologies work today but we are not serious about it. Govt investment into these areas has not been coordinated with an agreed upon goal. In fact the industry is gasping for air as a result of some of the crony capitalism that has gone on.

      The F-T process is an interesting one. The Germans use of it, based on coal, is about as green as electric cars that get plugged into coal or nuclear fed grids. The US Navy has bio blends that reach high enough octane to be used as jet fuel, but there is still some real diesel in the blends. It's a step in the right direction.

    • 3 months ago
  • Wetdog
    • 0
      Wetdog  
    • Truthitswhatsfordinner:

      Actually, Sasol[South Africa] has been making aviation fuel from coal for the last approximately 40 years.
      The only requirement is a source of carbon, which can be anything, coal or organic matter of any sort.
      The Germans in WW2, preferred wood. Coal was needed for steel making. And there were ample supplies of scrap wood available due to Allied bombing. And coal contains sulphur. Sulphur poisons the catalyst reforming beds----which shuts down the whole process. Coal also requires the addition of hydrogen(to form hydrocarbons)----organic materials do not, they already contain the hydrogen----and no sulphur. Using wood or other cellulosic matterials----the process can run longer and more efficiently producing more final fuel. About 100 gallons per ton.

      Using a 50/50 blend of petroleum/biodiesel means that you have reduced petroleum use to 1/2 what it would have been otherwise.

    • 3 months ago
  • Truthitswhatsfordinner
  • JanforGore
    • +2
      JanforGore  
    • There is only NOTHING THERE if you have rose colored glasses on, or are a bald faced liar just here to disrupt the site.

      But it is interesting to see Republicans actually agreeing with Obama on this. And notice again those who support him here are not calling him out on this. It is a shame to see that the environment is only a political football even to the people of blind allegiance on both sides.

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
  • The_Wanderer_Kansas
  • R3zn8D
  • Mishima
  • The_Wanderer_Kansas
  • Mishima
    • -1
      Mishima  
    • The_Wanderer_Kansas:

      It is true. His tax reports showed it.

      Proof or more Left-winger hypocrisy? Yep. Let’s start with his LIES about getting guns from a bank easily.

      1. The distortions about guns. This YouTube is 9 minutes long, so start from 3:54:

      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sq-3cegKOMQ

      Other lies:

      2. Moore told one reporter that, before "Roger and Me," he never made more than $19,000 a year; he told a New Yorker magazine reporter that he never made more than $15,000, he told a Canadian newspaper it was $12,000 during that time period.

      On top of that, before that came out, he received $50,000 from a New York publisher, another $50,000 from Mother Jones, and a $20,000 grant from Ralphy Nader - $120,000.

      3. The Hezbollah worked with Front Row Entertainment of the United Arab Emirates to promote his film, "Fahrenheit 911."

      The British Guardian:

      http://www.guardian.co.uk/film/2004/jun/17/1

      4. Moore flew to London on the Concorde and stayed at the Ritz. However, he booked a room at a cheap hotel and did his interviews there to pose as a "man of humble circumstances" (fatso's words).

      http://www.bfi.org.uk/sightandsound/feature/37

      5. Moore screams and rants about racism in America. Take a look at the record:

      "Bowling for Columbine" 14 producers, 13 white. Cameramen, film editor, music composer - All white.

      "The Big One" All producers, music composers, production manager, editor - All white.

      Canadian Bacon - Same as above.

      Pets or Meat - 3 producers, all white.

      Roger and me - 2 producers, both white.

      TV Nation - 13 producers, all white. 4 film editors and 10 writers. Take a guess. Every one.

      Of 134 producers, editors, composers, etc., 3 were black.

      6. Moore's biggest and one of his most hypocritical lies was related to the stock market: "I don't own any stock." He stated this clearly. He owns "foundations." These had corporate stock. Among other stocks, Moore made a 15% profit when he sold a certain stock: Halliburton. He owns stock in McDonald's, GE (another defense contractor), Sunoco, etc.

      Jump to 50” on this:

      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j6bNoOECwqI

      Further documentation:

      http://archive.newsmax.com/archives/articles/2005/11/3/150518.shtml

      That’s all for now.

    • 3 months ago
  • R3zn8D
  • Mishima
  • The_Wanderer_Kansas
  • Truthitswhatsfordinner
  • Mishima
  • Mishima
    • 0
      Mishima  
    • Truthitswhatsfordinner:

      Yes, Moore is a hypocrite and a liar. Let’s start with his LIES about getting guns from a bank easily.

      1. The distortions about guns. This YouTube is 9 minutes long, so start from 3:54:

      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sq-3cegKOMQ

      Other lies:

      2. Moore told one reporter that, before "Roger and Me," he never made more than $19,000 a year; he told a New Yorker magazine reporter that he never made more than $15,000, he told a Canadian newspaper it was $12,000 during that time period.

      On top of that, before that came out, he received $50,000 from a New York publisher, another $50,000 from Mother Jones, and a $20,000 grant from Ralphy Nader - $120,000.

      3. The Hezbollah worked with Front Row Entertainment of the United Arab Emirates to promote his film, "Fahrenheit 911."

      The British Guardian:

      http://www.guardian.co.uk/film/2004/jun/17/1

      4. Moore flew to London on the Concorde and stayed at the Ritz. However, he booked a room at a cheap hotel and did his interviews there to pose as a "man of humble circumstances" (fatso's words).

      http://www.bfi.org.uk/sightandsound/feature/37

      5. Moore screams and rants about racism in America. Take a look at the record:

      "Bowling for Columbine" 14 producers, 13 white. Cameramen, film editor, music composer - All white.

      "The Big One" All producers, music composers, production manager, editor - All white.

      Canadian Bacon - Same as above.

      Pets or Meat - 3 producers, all white.

      Roger and me - 2 producers, both white.

      TV Nation - 13 producers, all white. 4 film editors and 10 writers. Take a guess. Every one.

      Of 134 producers, editors, composers, etc., 3 were black.

      6. Moore's biggest and one of his most hypocritical lies was related to the stock market: "I don't own any stock." He stated this clearly. He owns "foundations." These had corporate stock. Among other stocks, Moore made a 15% profit when he sold a certain stock: Halliburton. He owns stock in McDonald's, GE (another defense contractor), Sunoco, etc.

      Jump to 50” on this:

      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j6bNoOECwqI

      Further documentation:

      http://archive.newsmax.com/archives/articles/2005/11/3/150518.shtml

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
  • circlesquared
  • Mishima
  • The_Wanderer_Kansas
  • Mishima
  • Wetdog
  • Mishima
  • MSII
  • coolplanet
    • +4
      coolplanet  
    • "The Arctic is the last wild ocean on the planet. Its waters and the abundant life they support are simply too sensitive to be drilled—especially since neither the oil industry nor scientists have identified a proven way to contain or clean up a spill in the Arctic’s extreme conditions."

      All so we can continue to fight rush hour every day and shop till we drop.

    • 4 months ago
  • JanforGore
  • Mishima
  • Mishima
  • JanforGore
    • +3
      JanforGore  
    • Mishima:

      It only doesn't matter to ignorant people. People who haven't a clue about anything unless it includes them. Selfish, closeminded, greedy, ignorant people who have no sense or knowledge of the processes and species of this planet and how they are all connected.

    • 4 months ago
  • MSII
  • circlesquared
  • The_Wanderer_Kansas
    • +2
      The_Wanderer_Kansas  
    • Mishima:

      Stick your head underwaves there and try telling us that again! You are soooooo sad sir, I really am ashamed for our failure as a race to allow you to reach such a state of innate bigotry and hatred. I hope you grow beyond your current shortcomings and find peace within yourself before your death.

    • 4 months ago
  • Mishima
  • Mishima
    • -3
      Mishima  
    • MSII:

      No. I worked on the Slope for three years. I do not care if you do not believe it. It is true and I know. That is all that matters. Perhaps you are envious?

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • -3
      Mishima  
    • circlesquared:

      No, unless you are referring to bacteria and microbes. Occasionally carbiou pass through, but more go through Anaktuvik Pass, of course. There is a bit of vegetation and really nothing at all. Barren, empty, nothing.

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • -3
      Mishima  
    • The_Wanderer_Kansas:

      I am at peace, of course. I accept reality. Left-wingers live in a fantasy world. When it does not come to fruition, they get frustrated and angry. They demonstrate in the streets and scream for "revolution" and look abroad to find ideals instead of in their own country and neighborhoods. In the past, it was the USSR and Mao's China. Then the Third World "Agrarian Reformers."

      Now, instead of appreciating their own, they want us to be like Europe - the Paradise that got it right.

      Left-wingers are a frustrated and angry lot. In fact, research has proved this. If Left-wingers would ever accept human nature and not try to set up their utopias, we would have real peace. The peace with appreciating what one has and accepting what humans are.

    • 3 months ago
  • JanforGore
  • JanforGore
  • Mishima
    • -3
      Mishima  
    • JanforGore:

      No, I LIVED on the North Slope, and it was not for the oil companies. It was for the Natives who lived there! That is part of the North Slope. From Kaktovik to Point Hope and down to Anaktuvik. I went to all of the villages many times every year while living in Barrow. That was my job.

      I worked there when one person was murdered in the village where that narrator lived - He was murdered over whaling. Each village had a limit, but it is part of the native traditions. One native told the FEDERAL authorities; they went over the limit, and he ratted them out, possibly for money, who knows. He was found dead in the water. Officially, he was listed as "drunk, fell in the water," but everyone knew what really happened. Nobody would talk.

      They do not live on "subsistence." That is pure bull. I saw my first beached whale in Kaktovik. It was a baloga whale. 60 tons approximately. The Natives took what they could - only about 200 people in the village - and left probably 80-90% on the beach to rot.

      I was there. Three years, lady. I was there.

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • -3
      Mishima  
    • JanforGore:

      Continued from the last post. Because of the oil money, the Native there were filthy rich. I remember a lady from Massachusetts married a local Eskimo. The wedding gift from the father was interesting - An airplane!

      Everyone had big bucks from the oil royalties. It was almost like a socialist state - medical and plenty of other stuff was free.

    • 3 months ago
  • JanforGore
    • +2
      JanforGore  
    • Mishima:

      I don't CARE where you were. This isn't about YOU. You obviously have no CLUE to what this is about nor the damage that will be done to ecosystems WHEN a spill happens which is the topic. Your insistence here is suspicious and your disrepect sickening.

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • -3
      Mishima  
    • JanforGore:

      No, the Left constantly stir up dissent and anger. Class warfare of some kind, taking the forms of the oppressed and oppressor, race, economic class, religion vs. non-religion. You people never leave it alone and appreciate the bounty we all have. How would you like to live up in the Artic where these Eskimos live? Maybe that is one reason I can appreciate the bounty. There is not a single tree within 300 miles of where I lived in Barrow. One Eskimo husband - the one who married the lady from Massachusetts - ordered pine Christmas trees and put them in the permafrost around the house. Had to drill it in. The freezing weather kept them reasonablely the same for a time. She missed the green.

      I is things like that. When I see the Green Mountains of Vermont in my summer trips, I am inspired by the lush vegetation. When I go into grocery stores and see the incredible variety of food from all over the world, I actually am in awe. When I see houses that are heated and air conditioned, I realize how luck people are. That is because I saw people living on the edge in Southeast Asia, people starving in rural Turkey, and people literally dying of tuberculosis in Afghanistan, coughing up blood.

      Appreciate what you have. Be thankful for the liberty and bounty.

    • 3 months ago
  • Wetdog
    • +2
      Wetdog  
    • Mishima:

      -------" You people never leave it alone and appreciate the bounty we all have."------

      Or, do you mean the bounty that YOU have and don't want anyone else to share?

    • 3 months ago
  • Wetdog
  • JanforGore
    • +2
      JanforGore  
    • Mishima:

      "The peace with appreciating what one has and accepting what humans are."

      Humans like you are what I will fight until the day I die. Your brand of "utopia" is intolerant, selfish and myopic. And this BS left wing/ right wing paradigm just used to foment division is old and boring.

    • 3 months ago
  • Wetdog
    • +2
      Wetdog  
    • Mishima:

      No, only you do. Eskimos are world master environmentalists. They have survived the harshest environment on earth by knowing their environment and taking care of what they need to survive, for thousands of years.

      The traditional Eskimos are far more intelligent than you even think you are.

      Just because you can't see something does not mean it isn't there. In order to see something, you have to open your eyes.

    • 3 months ago
  • MSII
  • Mishima
    • -3
      Mishima  
    • JanforGore:

      I know it is not about me, but you personalize it. You call me a liar in order to push your radical anti-capitalist and anti-human agenda.

      You read the Left-winger environmentalist whacko press and believe anything they publish. I was there. I saw it and flew over it. I talked with Eskimos and others when I stayed there over a three-year period.

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
  • Mishima
  • Mishima
    • -3
      Mishima  
    • JanforGore:

      I am anti-utopian. Left-wingers have been trying to create utopias at the national level for over a century. In the past, antebellum era, they stayed to themselves, building their own communities, like the Oneida and others. But later on, they wanted GOVERNMENT to FORCE their "plans" and "visions" on the entire nation. The 20th century saw the results of it, taken to its ultimate conclusions - in Germany, Italy, Russia, China and Cambodia.

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • -3
      Mishima  
    • Wetdog:

      Seems you are an expert on Eskimos. How nice. Do you know that many villages on the North Slope simply died out? Do you know why, pray tell? There have been found human bones and artifacts, and the people apparently simply died. Try to figure out why.

      And do you really believe that they want to live the "old way?" Apparently you do. Well, tell me about what you saw in some documentary. I lived there for three years, and worked directly with the Eskimos for that time, and in every single village on the entire North Slope, so I am eager to learn of your "insights" that I seem to have missed.

      Why are you telling ME that they are intelligent? I met with Kleinfeld who did research on the intelligence of Eskimos, by the way. Check it out. Google her name and Eskimo. Feel free to ask me any questions.

    • 3 months ago
  • Wetdog
    • +2
      Wetdog  
    • Mishima:

      --------" How nice. Do you know that many villages on the North Slope simply died out? Do you know why, pray tell? There have been found human bones and artifacts, and the people apparently simply died. Try to figure out why."-------

      It's called archaeology. It is the main way that we know about previous civilizations. What they did, how they lived, what happened to them.

      And your precious oil drilling is killing that off too.

      Your 19th Century ethnocentric thought process is telling us that the destruction of other people and civilizations is OK as long as you make a profit, No matter what happens to other people, the land, the oceans, the air or anything else.

      -------" Why are you telling ME that they are intelligent? I met with Kleinfeld who did research on the intelligence of Eskimos, by the way. Check it out. Google her name and Eskimo. Feel free to ask me any questions."-------

      Don't tell me----let me guess. She found that Eskimos are not intelligent, right?

      And you buy it----you LIKE people who tell you that YOU are the most intelligent thing out there----because it fits right in with your 19th Century thought process. I'll take whatever I want from anyone I want, anyway I want because I'm better than anyone else.

      You are a racist, pure and simple. A pure, 100% homogenized racist, right to the bone, whose only goal in life is to take whatever you can from anyone else, and what you can't take you'll simply destroy out of wanton pride, greed and willfully self imposed ignorance.

      History is FULL of the stories of people just like you who destroyed thousands of civilzations, and killed and destroyed everything in sight, and all out of pride, greed and intolerance.

      We all know who you are. We've heard everything you say thousands of times before throughout history. No matter how often you say it though, it is still lies.

      You are not better than anyone else.

    • 3 months ago
  • MSII
  • Mishima
    • -2
      Mishima  
    • Wetdog:

      "Your 19th Century ethnocentric thought process is telling us that the destruction of other people and civilizations is OK as long as you make a profit, No matter what happens to other people, the land, the oceans, the air or anything else."

      Quite a puerile branding. No point, and it appears to be just a reflexive type of response of someone who does not want to be contradicted or questioned at all.

      Who said the destruction of other people is OK? The villages died out - which means that PEOPLE died, not some artifact of the past, but real PEOPLE - before the oil companies went to the North Slope. Don't you know how the proserity has benefitted the Eskimos?

      You sir, are quite the racist. You would have Eskimos live in the most primitive conditions with incredibly high rates of death and infant mortality - in order to "preserve" their way of life. Keep them in their "natural state" right? Never mind that the ESKIMOS THEMSELVES chose to have the companies come, were not coerced into it, and receive HUGE profits for simply being owners of the land. But YOU will claim that civilization has spoiled them or some such preposterous nonsense. Just keep 'em nice and primitive in case you want to go gawk at them, see the nice "primitive people" on a eco-tour, right?

      How condescending! YOU know what is best for THEM. Incredible!

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • -2
      Mishima  
    • Wetdog:

      {Don't tell me----let me guess. She found that Eskimos are not intelligent, right?}

      Why didn't you look it up? I suppose you want to keep believing what makes you feel good.

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • -2
      Mishima  
    • Wetdog:

      "History is FULL of the stories of people just like you who destroyed thousands of civilzations, and killed and destroyed everything in sight, and all out of pride, greed and intolerance"

      No, YOU are the racist because you set your self up in the position that YOU know what is best for THEM. You never once showed any interest in what THEY want and chose voluntarily. You only want to impose your values on another race, assuming you know better. That is the vile kind of racism.

    • 3 months ago
  • Wetdog
  • Mishima
    • -2
      Mishima  
    • Wetdog:

      "Under U.S. law, the 7.7 million hectare refuge is protected from oil exploration and development. But over the last decade, Alaskan Inuit have tirelessly lobbied the president and Congress to change the law."

      "The area’s Inuit birthright organization, the Arctic Slope Regional Corporation, owns the subsurface drilling rights in the refuge, which it could sell to the likes of E on and British Petroleum. The corporation also stands to benefit by providing oil companies with contracted services ranging from engineering to road-construction to catering."

      -Nunatsiaq News, 2001

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • -3
      Mishima  
    • Wetdog:

      {After 40 years of taking the wealth out of their homelands and waters there should be thousands of Eskimo millionaires. Show me the long list of Eskimos who have over $1 million net worth.}

      "Each year, the oil companies that operate those fields pay nearly $600 million in taxes to the regional government, called the North Slope Borough. That sum comes to around $65,000 per resident, and goes to an array of lavish facilities and services."

      -Nunatsiaq News

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
  • Mishima
  • The_Wanderer_Kansas
  • Wetdog
    • +1
      Wetdog  
    • Mishima:

      from the link------" Atqasuk's residents rely heavily on subsistence and enjoy berry picking, hunting caribou, ptarmigan, ducks and geese. They also fish for grayling, burbot, salmon and whitefish in the Meade River.

      Atqasuk Corporation is the Village Corporation established pursuant to the Alaska Native Claims Act of 1971. Atqasuk Corporation owns approximately 73,000 acres of surface lands in and around the community."----------

      Surface lands? And the oil companies own the mineral wealth and have free hand to exploit and destroy the surface lands the indigenous people's are left with?

      $600 million dollars in taxes?----completely meaningless number without knowing the gross amount the taxes were paid on.

      The TransAlaska pipeline has a capacity of 2.136 M/brls per day.

      2.136 M/brls X 365 = 780 M/brls/yr

      780 M/brl X $100/brl = $78 Billion/yr

      $600 million / $78000(1000 million in a billion) = 0.007692307692307693% taxes paid.

      Less than 1% paid back as taxes.

      11,000 citizens---$65,000 per resident----obviously they aren't very good with numbers

      $65,000 X 11,000 = $715 million. But, what the heck, that's only $115 million off.

      So, the residents of Atqasuk have a subsistance living, and "own" the land while the oil companies do anything they want, anywhere they want, and pump $78 billion worth of oil off and destroy the land, the hunting and fishing that the people of Atqasuk depend on to live.

      And send less than 3/4 of 1% of the money they take out back as taxes?

      So, you insist you and the oil companies are the wonderful benefactors granting immense wealth where ever you go. Well, yes, I suppose that is true. But you are granting it to yourselves, not the people of Atqasuk.

      The numbers say that you lie. And the numbers came from the same link that you post.

    • 3 months ago
  • Wetdog
    • -1
      Wetdog  
    • Mishima:

      Yes, I am an ethnocentric racist.

      My posts are in favor and support of the Native American peoples and their rights---central of which is the right to be free of the subjugation and exploitation of people like you.

      They have the right to legal, and economic freedom. And they have the right not to be bullied, intimidated and robbed by people like you.

      I am an ethnocentric racist who is on the side of the victims.

      -------" There are no HUGE profits going to Eskimos or any other native people for the wealth being stolen from them."---------

      That part is certainly true.

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • -1
      Mishima  
    • Wetdog:

      I do not lie. I posted facts. The wealth that the Eskimos get is immense. And you, being the racist that you are (because you - in your supreriority - know what is best for these "natives"), would reduce them to subsidence. What for? So you can go on an eco-tour and take pictures some day?

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • -1
      Mishima  
    • Wetdog:

      {My posts are in favor and support of the Native American peoples and their rights---central of which is the right to be free of the subjugation and exploitation of people like you.}

      Nope. You demean these people by claiming YOU know what is best for them. That is as racist as it gets, all the while claiming one is not a racist.

    • 3 months ago
  • Mishima
    • -1
      Mishima  
    • Wetdog:

      You are simply trying to distort the truth. First of all, I would not expect you to know about the villages there where I worked and lived for three years. You referred to Atqasuk, and ANWR is far, far from there.

      Then, you presented that village's land ownership as though it were the subject under "discussion." You presented ONLY {Atqasuk Corporation owns approximately 73,000 acres}

      Try this:

      "Arctic Slope Regional Corporation owns nearly 5 MILLION acres of land on Alaska's North Slope." (Emphasis mine)

      "ASRC has now received the majority of the lands it is entitled to under the provisions of the settlement act. ASRC is now one of the state's largest private landowners, holding title to nearly 5 million acres of Alaska's North Slope."

    • 3 months ago
  • Wetdog
    • 0
      Wetdog  
    • Mishima:

      From the ASRC website--------------" Since inception, ASRC has distributed over $400 million in dividends to shareholders."-----------

      It was founded in 1971. 40 years ago. $400 million / 40 = $10 million per year.

      $10 million per year to control 5 million acres of property that produce over $78 BILLION worth of oil per year is a real bargain.

      $10 million / $78 billion = 0.000128205 = .0128205 of 1% ROI.

      Any bank that paid its investors .0128% of 1% of its return on $78 billion would be out of business tomorrow morning. No matter HOW much Fed Reserve bailout money it got.

      So, the oil companies are paying the Native Americans slightly over one penny for oil that they sell on the open market for $10,000 dollars.

      Pretty good deal for the oil companies. Low overhead, high profit business. No wonder they are reporting the highest profits in history. No wonder they want completely unrestricted drilling on the North Slope.

      Distort the truth? I take these numbers directly from the official websites of the references you give me. I just do the math.

      Math does not seem to be a subject you know much about.

    • 3 months ago
  • JanforGore
    • +4
      JanforGore  
    • Republicans are in the pockets of oil companies. And so is this current administration. Using the lame excuse that you would allow one of the last pristine places on Earth that is already currently melting due in great part to burning fossil fuels to be destroyed by oil drilling and spills because you want to "diversify" energy opitons is BS. And these policies will never change as long as people claim to be against them only when the other "side" does it. The Arctic could not survive a spill the size of the Gulf ecocide. It seems we really never do learn until it is too late.

    • 4 months ago
more from Tech:

top videos